8 ms·
Say I own a house, and want to rent it out. I'm naturally going to go onto rental search sites and look at what similar houses in the area are renting for, and
by SoftTalker 3y ago
Say I own a house, and want to rent it out. I'm naturally going to go onto rental search sites and look at what similar houses in the area are renting for, and probably ask something pretty close to that.
I would assume this is not illegal because it's using public information and not colluding with any competitors on price.
But subscribing to a service that uses an algorithm that does basically the same thing is (might be) illegal? Does it cross the line when I explicitly agree with competitors that we'll all use the same algorithm? Or if we're all just independently using the popular pricing service could that become illegal? Or if the service agreement requires me to not rent for less than their algorithm calculates?
- 10000truths 3y agoWhat makes it collusion is the fact that others are using it as well, so the answer to your questions is yes. My understanding is that there's nothing wrong with building your own software that crawls public information and computes a price for you - the key thing is that it has to be your own, you can't distribute that software to others.
- jkic47 3y agoate you sure it is that? after all, we all independently use the Kelley Blue book value of a car before we sell. I think there has to be some intentional and provable link that you and I agreed (colluded) to use a particular value and set a floor below which we wouldn't sell.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago> ate you sure it is that? after all, we all independently use the Kelley Blue book value of a car before we sell. That book doesn't price individual cars, only types and the price of the actual car is open to interpretation and usually negotiation.
- slrainka 3y agoThe key distinction lies in how YieldStar approaches setting rental prices compared to other systems. YieldStar not only recommends rental prices by analyzing the entire inventory it oversees but also incorporates a strategy that effectively eliminates the possibility of rent negotiation with potential tenants. This approach mirrors the dynamics of the prisoner’s dilemma, a situation in game theory where individuals may not cooperate, even if it’s in their best interest to do so. However, YieldStar transcends the Nash equilibrium—the point at which no participant can benefit by changing strategies if the others remain unchanged—by stripping tenants of any bargaining power. This ensures that the rent pricing strategy is firmly controlled, without the usual back-and-forth negotiation process.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoThe only way you can productively refuse negotiation is by knowing the price is fixed (or you have the only supply), otherwise others will take your business.
- jprete 3y agoIf it's widely believed that other landlords use the same pricing system as you, then that's exactly how landlords can refuse to negotiate.
- samatman 3y agoThis is a strange claim. How is it that software can eliminate the possibility of rent negotiation? A tenant can negotiate, or try to. How does software eliminate the possibility that this will succeed?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoBecause the software has set the price and the landlords are using the software's price exclusively. That is why it's price fixing.
- vineyardmike 3y agoWhat’s missing here is that landlords agree to use the algorithm or leave the unit empty. It’s part of the TOS. So when many marker participants do this, it’s colluding.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWow, that's brazen if true. I don't know why anybody is even talking about algorithms. That's a contract to fix prices. It also implies that all of the landlords using it are idiots. Not only is price fixing illegal, joining the cartel is optional and costs you money for no personal advantage because you'd have to leave your units vacant instead of immediately renting them out at the higher price induced by the "selfless" idiots in the cartel.
- jprete 3y agoIf holding back 20% of the units in every building drives up prices by 30% - this is completely possible in something like real estate where supply is so inflexible - then each individual landlord might have a motivation to defect, but the group as a whole has a reason to cooperate. The purpose of the software is to give the coordinators visibility into who's cooperating. Note that the TOS requires a landlord to always use the algorithm's pricing decision, including leaving units empty, and requires reporting back on every lease transaction so the company can measure compliance. This really is collusion as a service.
- mlrtime 3y agoI agree, but one missing component is how many housing units are represented by this software in a given market. If everything here is true [price fixing] but the number of units is small 20%, it still won't work. Consumers will go to the 80% where the actual market lives. Now maybe someone better at economics can tell me how many units does it take to shift the market? 50%?
- nerdponx 3y agoIt's an interesting area because the line might be fuzzy. It's not reasonable to expect every landlord to become a data analyst or statistician! So naturally there's a market for a product that helps landlords make data-driven pricing decisions. I'm sure the big landlords know exactly what they're doing, but I suspect that the smaller landlords don't even realize they are participating in a price-fixing cartel. As an interesting point of comparison, consider that the Zillow "zestimate" is also an algorithmic price recommendation, shared by all market participants. What's the difference there? Is it that buyers and sellers can both use the same algorithm freely? I want to make very clear that I think price-fixing is bad and that I believe extremely high real estate prices are at the root of a large and growing amount of misery in Western economies and societies. But I'm also cautious of pursuing thoughtless regulation that hurts small businesses, to the advantage of the big businesses that are causing all the problems in the first place.
- kllrnohj 3y ago> It's not reasonable to expect every landlord to become a data analyst or statistician! Why not? It's what they did just fine for thousands of years. What fundamentally changed in the last 20 years that makes it impossible for landlords to determine their own price?
- damontal 3y agoSounds like they’re determining their own price with the technology that’s available.
- kllrnohj 3y agoThey aren't, they're outsourcing pricing to a 3rd party knowing that the same 3rd party is doing everyone else's pricing decisions as well.
- Geisterde 3y agoSpecialization, how much time out of my day do I have to worry about the price, if I am dealing with the city trying to get the water fixed, or repaving the driveway, or handling customer complaints? It can be more efficient to pay a modest sum to arrive at the right result, or, more profitable to actively watch the market and adjust pricing, but that costs time/money, so itd better be worth it.
- casualscience 3y agoMy understanding is that further than just using software, the software is optimizing to increase maximum profits for the industry by causing a cartel block of people who won't lower prices. Any individual can go out there and build a model for the rent price, the issue comes in when that model is able to coordinate everyone to keep the prices high and discourage competition/undercutting.
- koliber 3y agoYou seem to hit the crux. There is a blurry line here and I had a hard time seeing where it really divides legal and illegal until your comment. Showing that the average rent is this, the min and max are that, and the percentiles look like this is probably legal. Showing historical trends is also legal. Recommending a certain rent based on a single shared algorithm used by all the players begins to cross that line.
- avarun 3y agoEspecially when it uses material non-public information in order to do so.
- trogdor 3y agoUsing material non-public information to set prices is not illegal. Colluding with other sellers to fix prices is illegal. That is the issue here.
- casualscience 3y agoYes exactly. I think it's an interesting case. Where/how do you legislate this? Is it based on intent (you literally are training your model to be cooperative), or is it based on effect (your company is having this effect regardless of their intent -- e.g. Zillow might also be offending). Both of these will be hard to show in practice.
- Geisterde 3y agoExcept, setting higher prices doesnt discouage competition, it encourages it. It makes it far more profitable to undercut anyone foolish enough to buy into this strategy.
- jkoudys 3y agoWhich makes this a great example of the shittiest side of "AI": not as software techniques to detect patterns and relationships, but as a method for obfuscating your sources. This software really is just saying "don't price fix by talking to eachother, price fix by having it done on our platform for you."
- soerxpso 3y agoI see how this is illegal when it's using a single centralized platform that everyone implicitly agrees on. However, I have a hypothetical that I'm curious about: Individually, without speaking, every landlord decides that it's in their best interest to charge the highest (per square foot) price that a nearby property is charging. They also all individually understand that if they leave units vacant instead of undercutting eachother, the market impact in favor of their interests will be sufficiently positive to justify the lost immediate revenue, and they trust (blindly) that no landlords will defect from this prisoner's dilemma. There's no communication at all; they all just understand game theory and have blind trust in their fellow landlords. This would have the exact same material impact on renters. The only difference is that it's slightly harder to pull off. Is it illegal, and should it be illegal?
- jprete 3y agoLandlords will undercut left and right because the benefits are local while the drawbacks are mostly distributed to competitors.
- mlrtime 3y agoThese examples are covered in high school level economics classes. All it takes is one landlord to have a slightly different concern to change their strategy. They need money fast, so they drop the price to get a tenant, boom competition.
- aaomidi 3y agoThe issue is, you're one person doing this manually. That means there's also a ton of people who don't. This algorithm, unlike a single person, ends up taking over entire cities, which means now there is no supply & demand. There is supply, and all that supply is effectively the same number. Demand has no other choice other than meet the supply where they are. It's either that or being without a house.
- theragra 3y agoWhat if there are multiple vendors selling algorithms? Open source bots doing this? How many bots is a collusion?
- polygamous_bat 3y agoEven if you’re talking to your next door landlord and coming up with a joint price, it’s collusion.
- theragra 3y agoBut it is not talking and agreeing. It is algorithm that determines some abstract price that makes sense in the current market. If me and my neighbor use the same formula from Wikipedia, is this also collusion?
- dragonwriter 3y ago> What if there are multiple vendors selling algorithms? Then each vendor’s customers may constitute a small price fixing conspiracy, which is still illegal (price fixing doesn’t have a market threshold before it is illegal) but also a lot less effective, so it probably would be a transitory condition even if it didn’t get punished.
- theragra 3y agoWhat about open source apps? Formulas from blog articles or Wikipedia?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago1. I'm going to use this pricing service. 2. I'm not going to deviate from what it tells me. 3. I know everyone else (who matters) is using this service in the same way.
- hnburnsy 3y agoWhat amazed me was that sometimes the recommendation from the software was to not lease a unit to anyone.
- bluGill 3y agoyou should always have a unit not leased so that you can lease it to someone who needs it now and is willing to pay. If you only have a few units though you will never hit that point where the theory is worth the risk the desperite person comes along.
- lupire 3y agoWhy would that desperate person be willing to pay the xN premium needed to cover the idle time? Why would there be exactly one desperate person in the market? You need a curve, charging more as the space fills up. Desperate renters don't have infinite money. People with money are the people who are not desperate, because they have flexible options.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- letmeinhere 3y agoThe algorithm is not operating on public info, it is soliciting proprietary pricing and vacancy data that is not available to renters or regulators. That secretive information sharing is the basis of the whole scheme. And the collusion doesn't stop with this information hoarding; the pricing recommendations are as profitable as they are precisely because many property owners in a market are enacting them with the knowledge that a known quantity of their peers have no intent to undercut. Sure, someone can renege on that, but collusion doesn't require that you have an airtight legal contract to bind all parties; after all, such contracts are inherently illegal!
- jessriedel 3y ago> That secretive information sharing is the basis of the whole scheme. can you recommend a link that this describes this in detail?
- karmajunkie 3y agothe link at the top of this thread does so.
- jessriedel 3y agoIt does not
- colechristensen 3y agohttps://www.propublica.org/article/doj-backs-tenants-price-fixing-case-big-landlords-real-estate-tech https://www.propublica.org/article/doj-backs-tenants-price-f... Contains links to an investigation and lawsuits where you can read DOJ complaints
- jessriedel 3y agoRight, but I'm asking a more specific question: what is the secret info that they are sharing? Is it just the rents?
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- turquoisevar 3y agoThis is why nuance and details are key in legal matters and where the sum is greater than the parts. Where the line gets drawn is often unclear and is often a matter of “I know it when I see it”. Just individually comparing prices isn’t an issue. What does become an issue is if (at least) all of the following are met. - You use an algorithm service does automates all of this - This algorithm uses both public and private data - The algorithm is ubiquitous and widely used by almost every relevant market player - The algorithm tells all users to not negotiate and the users abide by this recommendation - All of the above has a noticeable effect on the market to the detriment of a big demographic of market participants
- tsimionescu 3y agoPer the FTC filing, many of these are not relevant for deciding if illegal price fixing has occurred. It doesn't matter how the algorithm operates. If all landlords in an area publically agree that they will set rent prices at 400xx the price of a coke can, they are only using public information, but still engaged in price fixing. It doesn't matter how many people actually use the algorithm. If you try to start a cartel to do price fixing and only succeed in convincing two of your 50 competitors to participate, you've still engaged in illegal price fixing. It doesn't matter if individual price negotiation happens or not. If a bunch of companies agree to set the same list price, but also agree that they can offer deals to their customers, they are still engaging in illegal price fixing. It doesn't matter if the scheme actually succeeds in changing the prices. If two companies meet and agree to set prices at a certain value, but then they backstabber each other and undercut the agreed price, or simply other companies in the space who were not part of the scheme have too much market power to allow prices to change, the original companies still agreed to an illegal price fixing scheme and are guilty. All of the above will probably have a massive impact on the amount of damages and so on. But they have no bearing on the verdict, as the FTC lays out at length in the filing they link from the article. And this is not speculation, it is established case law.
- chii 3y ago> meet and agree to set prices at a certain value so the question becomes what it means to "meet and agree". If these companies never communicated, and all came to the same conclusion of a price floor (that happens to all be the same), then how can it be price fixing? To me, price fixing require that the parties agree (explicitly, or implicitly with punishment) to _not_ lower the price regardless of the lack of sales. It is not enough to have the same price (however that price comes about is irrelevant).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> I'm naturally going to go onto rental search sites and look at what similar houses in the area are renting for, and probably ask something pretty close to that. Or, Say I own and house, and I want to rent it out. I would calculate how much I would have to charge for rent for it to be worthwhile to me. Why would I care what anyone else is charging?
- pylua 3y agoBecause you want to maximize your profit and get the most from your investment. You also want to see, generally speaking, if it is even reasonable that anyone would to rent out your house at that price
- zymhan 3y ago> Why would I care what anyone else is charging? Then you probably shouldn't be participating in this discussion.
- bikezen 3y agoYou have a duty to your family/pets/shareholders to extract maximum value clearly. /s I added /s because dear lord this thread is full of people who think its true. Housing shouldnt be an investment venue when we have millions unhoused.
- codexb 3y agoThat's like saying people shouldn't invest in farms, or pharmacies, or water pumps because there are poor or mentally disabled people who have trouble securing and affording those products.
- lupire 3y agoThe difference is whether the good in question is being produced by investment, or monopolized by investment. This has been enshrined in law for over a century. You want to make more money in housing? Build more housing.
- 3y ago
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoIf you own a house and it sits empty for a year because an algorithm told you you could get more for it, you’re an idiot. If you use an algorithm to effectively collude with others and you fail to rent your house but keep rents artificially high, then you an idiot and a criminal.
- bluGill 3y agoIf you own 100 houses to rent it is already known you should have a few empty at all times.
- lozenge 3y agoI don't think it suggested leaving places empty for a year. Rather they wanted to spread out lease renewals. If everybody's lease ends in September then your property is competing with a lot of others. Whereas if you keep it empty until February then offer a 12 month lease, your renter will have much fewer choices and is more likely to stay (despite your demand of a high rent increase).
- FireBeyond 3y agoThis generally isn't targeted at single property homeowners/landlords. RealPage says if you have a portfolio of apartments, that following their recommendations will generate you more overall, regardless of occupancy. Their algorithm literally is "it is better to rent out 19 units at $X, when the demand will drop to 0.94X if there's 20 available". And it can do so because it happens to know that the other 80 units on the market with other landlords will be following the same rule.
- ThrustVectoring 3y agoYou're over-emphasizing the methods by which these people are price-fixing, rather than the result. The result is a price higher than the market-clearing price that is low enough to find tenancy for all housing. Any scheme to generate excess profit by raising rent above this price is (or ought to be) illegal, whether it's colluding to do price fixing, using some algorithm to price-fix, or monopolizing the market.
- closeparen 3y agoAll store owners should be jailed, then, since the presence of inventory on their shelves is proof of a scheme to generate excess profit by charging higher than market-clearing prices - or it would have sold already.
- bluGill 3y agoWe only know current inventory. As I write this in early March stores are starting to order their halloween candy (the orders need to be in by somethime in april). You do not know what candy your competitor will order, but this is relavant to sales since you will price match their ads and in turn lower priced candy will sell in greater quantities.
- tsimionescu 3y agoThe FTC is claiming the exact opposite, basically. Colluding to fix prices, by any means, is illegal. It is still illegal even if the scheme is only followed by a handful of those who "agreed" to it. It is still illegal if it utterly fails to control the price and thus has no material impact. It's like trying to scam people. You're not allowed to try to defraud people. It doesn't matter if your scam is so bad that it would cost you more money to execute than you would get out of it, and it doesn't matter if no one engages with your scam at all: what you were doing is still illegal.
- lupire 3y agoFTC would not be interested if the scheme hypothetically somehow had no effect. They said that it is still be illegal even if it is imperfect. Empirical reality still gets a vote, for pragmatic reasons.
- nkrisc 3y agoI won’t belabor the point others have made, but if the end result is price fixing, it’s price fixing. The law isn’t code and it is open to interpretation and intent and outcomes matter, sometimes more than the methods.
- lupire 3y agoSo the law is an AI model :-)
- hnburnsy 3y agoPrices on rental search sites are wishes not actually leased costs and would be missing things like the term, pets, and incentives.
- FireBeyond 3y agoThe service also requires you to go with their recommendation 95% of the time, and at a certain point requires you to go with their recommendation, and you can only "request an override" that RP can allow or deny at their discretion (of course, they can't enforce it, other than to kick you off their service, with no refund).
- bostik 3y agoSubscribing to a pricing data service: legal. Using data feed to guide pricing and set initial figures: legal. Agreeing, either implicitly or explicitly, to let the pricing data feed set the price floor: collusion. Leaving units unsold and refusing to lower the price despite insufficient demand: usually a bad business decision, possibly indicator of a market failure. Leaving units unsold to maintain agreed-upon price floor despite insufficient demand: collusion, market manipulation. Congratulations, you are a cartel.
- ethbr1 3y agoI guess the other way of looking at it is: What is the value of subscribing to a pricing service where you have no idea how your competitors are using the numbers (over-, match-, under-price)? Versus what is the value of same, if you know your competitors never under-price? That value difference is the value of running a cartel.
- hinkley 3y agoBut we are disrupting markets! Doesn’t that make us trendy and forward thinking??
- mu53 3y agoPulled from the Sherman Act, Section 1. Available on wikipedia > Every contract, combination in the form of trust or otherwise, or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, is declared to be illegal It is written in a general way to catch all problems going into the future. The problem is translating this to case law. Often judges ask the question "Is this bad for the consumer?" If rents are rising faster than inflation with more consumers becoming homeless citing cost of rent while vacancy rates are increasing, the market is bad for the consumer and the country.
- cyanydeez 3y agoit was illegal. making a mechanical turk to kill people doesn't free the turk from a crime.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoYour acting on independent research doesn't distort the market. If you directly or indirectly control pricing in 30% of housing stock you can drive prices up incrementally because you have influence on every lease offer in that population.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoImagine you are Microsoft and you want to collude with Amazon to rig compute prices. You both agree to follow the recommendations of an unbiased Amasoft Price Calculator tool. This tool uses an advanced algorithm looking at thousands of data points and always returns the same price, $10000 per month. You both follow this independent tool and end up pricing it the same. Is this a fair system? You’re both subscribing to an algorithm.
- ametrau 3y agoYou can’t be part of a price fixing cartel no.
- unethical_ban 3y agoYou're missing a critical point, which is that using this software requires agreeing to follow its recommendation (else penalty) and to give them access to your pricing.