3 ms·
"They're dying, as they should be." I think looking at it only in terms of economic efficiency is a little bit callous. I'm fine with bad corporations "dying.
by jimbokun 18y ago
"They're dying, as they should be."
I think looking at it only in terms of economic efficiency is a little bit callous.
I'm fine with bad corporations "dying." However, what about the actual human beings that will not have jobs, and their children? Detroit is already starting to look like a third world country. What will it be like by the time all three auto makers get through the bankruptcy procedure?
I think the argument for a "bailout" for the people who still support it is that it is simply cheaper to keep the auto companies alive a little while longer than what the government would pay out in benefits for all of the resulting unemployed workers. And that it is a more efficient "stimulus" than the government just spending money on other projects directly. Maybe we will have to pay those benefits eventually in any case. But as bad as things are now it might actually make sense to keep the auto companies alive, even for just another year or so, while the rest of the economy maybe starts to improve.
You can argue that we should be more libertarian about these things, and the government should not be involved in "social safety nets" or whatever. But that is not the government we have, and it is not going to be the government we have any time soon. Given that, the question of whether a bail out is cost effective from the federal government's standpoint is not as clear cut.
- cstejerean 18y agoI'm perfectly fine with the government bailing out the people. They probably need help. So give them a nice severance package, relocation assistance, job training, actual jobs, whatever. But don't pump billions into keeping a failed company on life support for another year.
- lliiffee 18y agoI would love to see this calculated quantitatively. I've heard that the bailout amounts to $50,000 per worker. That sounds pretty good... However, if the bailout is able to keep everyone in $70,000 other jobs for a year, that might be a better deal, even if it just means postponing the inevitable. I recognize that this is very complex, one should account for e.g. if the economy will be recovered in a year, and more able to take the hit of these industries going under, how much more value the workers might produce in new jobs, etc. It's beyond me to calculate, but I would love to see an analysis that presupposes that this is straightforward charity for those workers, and how to get the best bang for our redistributive buck.
- cstejerean 18y agoI'd take $50k up-front over $70k for a year, since in the former I immediately get a ton of free time to think of something better to do, learn a skill, move to a better area, etc. In the latter I'll be no better off a year from now than I am right now.