6 ms·
CDC ditches 5-day Covid isolation, argues Covid is becoming flu-like
- generalizations 3y ago[flagged]
- ajross 3y agoThis seems like a cheap shot, but such is the polarization of the debate that I can't tell from which direction or with what aim. The simpler, rational and boring truth is that the CDC is basically right. Most people have had covid several times, existing variants are much less dangerous than the original ones, vaccines work very well. There are and will remain (and have always been, vs. all disease) populations that are susceptible anyway and will need to continue to be vigilant. There remain open questions of science as to exactly what the long term effect will be or how recovery from "long covid" works (though to be fair, the dire predictions of an epidemiological time bomb haven't come true -- covid does not seem like a major source of long term disability in aggregate). But... it's safe enough. People get sick and always will, and that sucks. But there's little more we can gain by treating this disease as special.
- catlifeonmars 3y agoThis actually made me think of it in this opposite way: wouldn’t a better posture be to elevate other contagious diseases to the level at which we treated COVID? My takeaway from the pandemic is that this is likely a recurring event. Reverting to a more relaxed posture doesn’t line up with normalizing everyday practices to reduce spread of disease overall.
- jeromegv 3y agoDepends what you mean by long Covid not being « major ». Seems like a lot of data out there that shows there’s quite a high amount of disabled people. Considering infection rate is close to 100%, doesn’t take a huge percentage for it to reach millions of people.
- ajross 3y agoI'm looking for the study now and can't find it, but it was shown somewhere a few months back that in fact total/all-cause disability rates are not increasing. They dropped over the pandemic itself (because when you're not working you tend not to seek treatment for low-impact conditions like long covid), bounced back, and have now leveled off roughly where they were. That is, "long covid" ended up displacing a bunch of other, routine long term disability diagnoses by giving them a name and a focus. But I can't find it right now, so it's possible I'm misremembering the spin. Maybe someone else can help.
- CubsFan1060 3y agoI still don't want to get the flu :( I wish we could have a culture of "wear a (good) mask when you're sick". I don't think I'm going to die from the Flu or Covid, but it is going to make life miserable for awhile.
- mcronce 3y agoExactly this. I had COVID two years ago, the flu last year, and COVID again a couple months ago. Last year's flu was absolutely miserable; just as bad as COVID was the first time around. I really don't want either one. Putting a piece of cloth on your face when you are/recently were sick really isn't much of a burden. I did.
- basil-rash 3y agoFunny, you two purport to agree, but the parent specifically requested a “good” mask (which can be effective, with the right training and protocols, which are almost never followed), and you advocate a “piece of cloth”, which is almost never effective. Two people agreeing in their advocacy for highly visible, yet ineffective, remedies.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoThere is a difference between wearing a mask to prevent spread to others and wearing one to protect yourself. The parent was concerned with reducing spread to others. Interestingly, one meta study [1] concludes that cloth masks are actually better than "good" masks if they are not worn and used correctly. [1] https://academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/article/46/1/e84/7337687?login=false https://academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/article/46/1/e84/7337687...
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- ipqk 3y agoCloth masks may be still be useful for RSV/cold/flu.
- superkuh 3y agoThe CDC is saying it's okay to infect other people because pretty much everyone on earth has already been infected with the novel sars-cov-2 virus and taken their risk already with the first infection. Anyone that would have bad outcomes has died or been taken out of productive life so they don't matter. And the rare few of us that have still avoided any exposure to sars-cov-2 virus in our upper respiratory mucosal immune compartment don't matter because we are so few and the humoral immune compartment is protected by intramuscular vaccination. A very pragmatic position but not one that has much to do with the science of sars-cov-2 shed duration or infective window.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>And the rare few of us that have still avoided any exposure to sars-cov-2 virus in our upper respiratory mucosal immune compartment don't matter because we are so few and the humoral immune compartment is protected by intramuscular vaccination. As one of the rare few, I'd rather not take risks, especially since there's still so much developing science behind the long term effects of COVID. Good to know the CDC does not in fact care about disease control for those who heeded their advice up until now.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y ago> Anyone that would have bad outcomes has died or been taken out of productive life so they don't matter. That's just not how it works though. Each subsequent infection increases the risk of bad outcomes (1) The CDC must know this 1) https://www.unmc.edu/healthsecurity/transmission/2023/12/27/every-covid-infection-increases-your-risk-of-long-covid-study-warns https://www.unmc.edu/healthsecurity/transmission/2023/12/27/... https://time.com/6553340/covid-19-reinfection-risk/ https://time.com/6553340/covid-19-reinfection-risk/ https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/23/repeat-covid-infections-health-risks https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/23/repeat-covid-i...
- superkuh 3y agoTrue enough. I didn't want to complicate my message. I only meant the risk of the first exposure is much, much greater than subsequent ones. It is unarguable that the risk of the first exposure to a novel virus is much greater than subsequent exposures. I say this because T-cells generalize across mutations. And T-cells stay tissue resident for years to decades (unfortunately sars-cov-2 IgG and IgA antibodies are gone by 6 months). Your T-cells from the first sars-cov-2 exposure will start killing infected cells much faster once you've been exposed. This limits the replication earlier and reduces the viral load. This reduces damage done. Weird side effects like the collection of things called long-covid have been shown in study after study not to be related to viral load. So whatever risk is associated with reinfection does not decrease in that sense. But in the dying sense? It decreases a lot.
- tomp 3y ago[flagged]
- basil-rash 3y ago[flagged]
- netsharc 3y agoSigh, when scientists do a good job that [uncharitable word deleted] like you end up saying "see, it wasn't a big deal!". A bit like Y2K...
- marcosdumay 3y agoExcept that it was a huge deal. There was nothing scientists could do for an year, it became one of the largest human killers, and crippled an unknown number of people. And yet some people still deny it was dangerous. It's not the same situation of Y2K at all.
- SirensOfTitan 3y agoI’m not a zero COVID person and just got on to living my life as normal after the acute pandemic, but about a year in I started developing autoimmune symptoms I’m still struggling to figure out. There’s a chance I was always going to develop it, but I definitely wonder about long term COVID dysfunction. First I had muscle spasms and twitches, then intermittent joint pain, trouble sleeping, hives on occasion while running, now exocrine pancreatic insufficiency that seems like it’s idiopathic (MRI is confirming today). I’m scared as hell and any attempt at diagnosis or treatment is a dead end or makes things worse.
- downrightmike 3y agoWe have barely any idea what happens long term. Chicken pox becomes shingles later in life. One infection of covid can disable you, and it happens more often than people think. Basically for every dead person, there is now a disabled one. 2021: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/covid-19-likely-resulted-in-1-2-million-more-disabled-people-by-the-end-of-2021-workplaces-and-policy-will-need-to-adapt/ https://www.americanprogress.org/article/covid-19-likely-res... NHS study from 2022: "Results Of 206 299 participants (mean age 45 years, 54% female, 92% white), 15% were ever labour market inactive and 10% were ever long-term absent during follow-up. Compared with pre-infection, inactivity was higher in participants reporting Long Covid 30 to <40 weeks [adjusted odds ratio (aOR): 1.45; 95% CI: 1.17–1.81] or 40 to <52 weeks (aOR: 1.34; 95% CI: 1.05–1.72) post-infection. Combining with official statistics on Long Covid prevalence, and assuming a correct statistical model, our estimates translate to 27 000 (95% CI: 6000–47 000) working-age adults in the UK being inactive because of Long Covid in July 2022." https://academic.oup.com/eurpub/advance-article/doi/10.1093/eurpub/ckae034/7616634?rss=1 https://academic.oup.com/eurpub/advance-article/doi/10.1093/...
- RoyTyrell 3y agoExactly, it's a nasty virus. * I know someone that contracted Covid late fall of 2020 and is still disabled from Long Covid/PASC with daily fevers and fatigue. If they don't get a good night's sleep and eat enough, they're wiped out for 1-2 days afterward. * Have another friend that is still dealing with smell and taste changes a bit over a year out. Luckily the "rotting garlic" smell and most everything tasting "bitter" (their words) has significantly improved. Now most things have a little bit of normal smell and some taste has returned. * Another friend's step dad, in his mid 60s, had a heart attack and died a couple months after a week long hospital stay due to Covid. Hard to say exactly if Covid damaged something that lead to it, but his doctor thinks it's probably likely but can't prove it. He was maybe 25-30lbs overweight, which of course does raise the chances of bad outcomes from Covid, but no other chronic conditions like diabetes or COPD. He walked a few miles nearly every day before getting sick.
- matznerd 3y agoThis is insane again as it was just found that an infection lowers your IQ by 3 points (2 big recent studies)*. The average person now has over 3 infections to date. We aren't even far enough in the research to understand the compound effects on the brain (and body). And basically, everyone in society, even the smartest people are losing IQ points at a time when we need people to become more intelligent and aware and able to adapt to an accelerating future... "Extrapolation to Loss of IQ points, compared to uninfected controls: Mild Covid, Resolved Symptoms: 3 points Unresolved Symptoms: 6 points Covid requiring Intensive Care Unit admission: 9 point Reinfection: Additional 2 points " https://erictopol.substack.com/p/long-covid-and-cognitive-deficits https://erictopol.substack.com/p/long-covid-and-cognitive-de... https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2311330 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2311330 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2311200 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2311200 The virus is a massive vascular infection attacking every cell on the lining of the body (blood vessels, endothelial cells) and even organ organs, heart damage etc... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8771611/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8771611/
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- gnicholas 3y agoDo IQ tests have a resolution that is good enough to notice a difference of 3 points?
- ender341341 3y agoI think when measuring a big enough populations they likely would show that small of a shift, though would be interested in the range of it, like is it a smaller group highly effected vs being pretty consistent.
- _2d30 3y agoI wonder if they account for the noise of the test itself though in their CIs
- nothercastle 3y ago[flagged]
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoI'll get down voted for this but when COVID was a thing I wasn't wearing those cloth masks. I was wearing a 3m respirator with p100 cartridges. One because the paper masks were hard to find, two they reduce but do not eliminate the risk of infection, and three those cartridges last way longer. Never caught it either.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoAt this point, unless you've been living in a cabin in the woods, it's almost guaranteed you've had at least an asymptomatic infection.
- gnicholas 3y agoSlight exaggeration here. I have several older family members who have not had COVID yet. They wear masks in grocery stores and don't go to movie theaters anymore, but they live in the suburbs are several notches from living in a cabin in the woods.
- ejb999 3y agoThe things is - you can't actually know for sure - it is entirely possible to get covid and have nothing more than a sniffle or nothing at all - so I think what the OP you are responding to is saying is that just because someone thinks they never had covid, it might not be true. I know people who never had symptoms, but tested because a household member had tested positive (with symptoms) and found out they were positive too - it happens. In my opinion, that is the best case scenario - you got it, didn't know it and your body fought it off like a champ.
- gnicholas 3y ago> just because someone thinks they never had covid, it might not be true. Definitely true. But there are some people who have been very careful and/or tested multiple times with every illness in the last 4 years, and who are fairly certain they have not had COVID.
- ck2 3y agocounterpoint (well one of many) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-26/covid-made-heart-disease-deadlier-puzzling-scientists https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-02-26/covid-mad...
- geor9e 3y agoIn reality, most people have never even had the flu. They often mistake a severe common cold for the flu. The true influenza hits you hard, like a brick wall, and has a significant fatality rate among the elderly. The primary contrast between COVID-19 and the flu has always been the R-factor, which indicates how many people an infected person will spread the virus to. The flu typically has an R-factor of around 1, just enough to sustain itself. On the other hand, COVID-19 has an R-factor closer to 2, meaning that one person can infect 2, then 4, 8, 16, and so on. This is why many countries implemented drastic measures initially. Now that vulnerable populations are vaccinated and the general population has some level of herd immunity, the situation is not as alarming. The CDC implemented severe measures, but the new guidance does not imply that "COVID-19 was not a big deal" as some individuals are suggesting. It falls somewhere in between - there were valid reasons for the initial actions taken, some measures may have been missteps, but overall the situation has improved.
- calibas 3y agoThis didn't sound correct, so I Googled it. "Researchers analysed blood samples from volunteers in Southern China, looking at antibody levels against nine different influenza strains that circulated from 1968 to 2009. They found that while children get flu on average every other year, flu infections become less frequent as people progress through childhood and early adulthood. From the age of 30 onwards, flu infections tend to occur at a steady rate of about two per decade." https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/164239/adults-only-really-catch-about-twice/ https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/164239/adults-only-really-ca...
- Jabbles 3y agoIs it possible to pay for a private Covid vaccine? In which country? Or are all countries still only allowing the most vulnerable to be vaccinated?
- Terretta 3y agoIn greater NYC area you can just make an appointment and walk into any CVS or Walgreens and add a booster of your choice, every 2+ months (which is the frequency CDC mentions, though research graphs suggest moderate booster effect doesn't disappear for 6 - 9 months), and supposedly your insurance will cover it if you're in a window the federal government isn't covering it, but so far they still seem to be covering it. Visitors from outside the US are still being able to walk in and get it as well. YMMV etc. etc., but this is accurate in greater NYC area as of January/February 2024.
- nikolay 3y agoThe lockdowns were irresponsible (people didn't obey them anyway), and now this is stupid and irresponsible again. Don't judge a disease by it symptoms - most cancers don't have any until it's too late! The piling evidence of the damage every COVID-19 reinfection does is overwhelming! This is NOT flu-like! Many other diseases, some very serious, share similar symptoms, but they don't call them "flu-like", because it would be crazy! On top, this is now the most contagious virus!
- RoyTyrell 3y agoI suppose that depends on your physical location to say if they weren't obeyed. It's true they weren't followed 100% in spirit or in practice, but they were to enough degree. At least in my area, from when lockdowns started until probably mid 2022 traffic wasn't something I had to worry about anymore. Now it seems to be back to normal. Stores seem even busier now than they were before Covid, etc. In our lockdown capacity, it demonstrate how fast the virus spread and how much damage it did with a population largely immunologically naive to Covid). I can only imagine what would have happened in the US had it just been business as usual.
- nikolay 3y agoThere was enough science to avoid lockdowns. Face masks (not the surgical kinds though) work, but they needed to educate people to wear them consistently and that there's no point in wearing a mask and then taking it out to eat or drink water for 1 minute. They also changed it to "face covering," allowing people to wear germ-infested cloths and surgical masks.
- nikolay 3y agoMy family of 4 traveled internationally during COVID-19 and wore N95 and FFP3 face masks, didn't eat at the airplane, we only ate briefly at airports in secluded areas, and never got COVID-19. In fact, we only got COVID-19... at the pool, i.e., outside. My daughter was without a face mask and her friend, who was later tested positive, was 10-15 minutes away. We know for sure it was him infecting her outside in a larger than the standard "social distance", because she was home for 2-3 weeks and didn't see anybody else. Only she was positive and had symptoms.
- Terretta 3y agoThey didn't argue the disease Covid is becoming like the disease flu. They argued the prevalence and common impact is. That's an important distinction. Hospitalization and death is different, long covid is different, and they mention both, specifically. Even WSJ coverage of this emphasized that point, and it's hardly a liberal rag, phrasing as "Treat it more like flu" not that the disease itself is flu-like. On the contrary, WSJ point out: However, public health officials cautioned that Covid still isn’t the same as the flu or other respiratory viruses. “Let’s be clear. Covid-19 is not the flu,” said Jackson at the CDC. “It still causes more serious illness and leads to more lasting effects,” he said. Public-health experts and physicians note that Covid is still a disease that is cited as a cause of death in more than 1,000 people a week, according to CDC data. And long Covid, with symptoms that can linger months and even years, hasn’t gone away. https://www.wsj.com/health/wellness/covid-guidelines-2024-cdc-symptoms-contagious-cdefb6b8 https://www.wsj.com/health/wellness/covid-guidelines-2024-cd... Finally, CDC didn't ditch 5 day precautions. The part most coverage isn't headlining, CDC say if you're not isolating, wear a well-fitting mask, keep your distance from people, for five days. They also say during that 5 days have clean air, which they define as outside air, higher fresh air mix, and purification. An office demanding people come in should ask their building if they've adopted the post-pandemic ASHRAE directional guidance (not yet formalized). With recent research attributing long covid brain-fog to leaking blood in the brain, and research is still finding other unexplained effects, it may be worthwhile to weigh that we have a pretty good handle on the flu, but ... TL;DR: We are still learning about this thing.
- projektfu 3y agoComments suggesting the CDC is telling sick people to go to work or airports are not consistent with the recommendations. The CDC is recommending people stay home/isolate during fever and symptoms, and consider returning to work after the fever breaks and symptoms start to improve. FTA: "The CDC acknowledged that the eased isolation guidance will create 'residual risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission,' and that most people are no longer infectious only after 8 to 10 days. As such, the agency urged people to follow additional interventions—including masking, testing, distancing, hygiene, and improving air quality—for five additional days after their isolation period." Given that many people were ignoring the prior advice before this advice came out, I doubt it will effect little change. The same recommendations should have been applied to all influenza-like-illness even before Covid, but people mostly just try to work until they can't, then stay home until they can, and come back to work anyway.
- PaulKeeble 3y agoThe problem is people are infectious for up to 16 days and almost all are still infectious on day 12. Its not a policy based on the reality of the virus or the disease it causes.
- projektfu 3y agoI will agree with those numbers if you're including the incubation (presymptomatic) period which is quite long with COVID-19, estimated at 7 days on average.[1] Unfortunately that just stresses how little we can accomplish in preventing spread after someone has symptoms. They were already contagious (perhaps 1-4 days) before the onset of symptoms. 10-day isolation periods after infection don't reflect the reality of the virus either, and permanent isolation forever even less so. Like I said, I don't expect anything to change from this new guidance. They have different guidance for healthcare settings and very few people were following the previous general guidance anyway. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9396366/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9396366/
- leotravis10 3y agoSadly, this is what Corporate America ultimately lobbied hard for this and the CDC has caved to them. I'm sure this is a move to exploit workers even more, causing more preventable permanant sickness (Long COVID) and deaths as a result. [1] [2] [1] https://skepchick.org/2024/02/the-cdc-gives-up-on-covid-19/ https://skepchick.org/2024/02/the-cdc-gives-up-on-covid-19/ [2] https://med-mastodon.com/@luckytran/112021781878554992 https://med-mastodon.com/@luckytran/112021781878554992