4 ms·
NASA satellite, Russian spacecraft crossed within 65 ft (20 m) of each other
- Ringz 3y agoAs it gets increasingly crowded up there, it’s time for one of the imaginative ideas for capturing space debris to be implemented.
- Gys 3y agoOne of the challenges might also be distinguishing between debris and a concealed spy satellite.
- looofooo0 3y agoThats a feature not a bug.
- throwup238 3y agoThat’s how we can pay for the whole operation! Orbital racketeering. ”That’s a nice piece of stealthy debris you have there. It would be a shame if someone were to just… scoop it up.” It’s like international waters. Anything goes. In three dimensions!
- bluish29 3y agoImplement a method to deal with debris and don't worry about concealed spy satellite. The entity behind it can of course complain but then have to explain why.
- SunlitCat 3y agoThough it seems many actors are reluctant on implementing something to capture space debris as this could open the doors for capturing more then just debris (as in foreign spy satellites and the like).
- euroderf 3y agoWell, HN had that story a week or so ago about US satellites that cruise around near-geosync orbit (IIRC) checking out the competition. Try to convince me that there's no funny stuff going on.
- jccooper 3y agoThat requires imaginative ideas for paying for such missions.
- yetihehe 3y agoWe could link that with another comment "Though it seems many actors are reluctant on implementing something to capture space debris as this could open the doors for capturing more then just debris (as in foreign spy satellites and the like)." and sell this as "Remove debris AND foreign spy satellites. If you pay for this, we will leave your satellites intact."
- thfuran 3y agoI think that trying to secure funding by extorting your government with threats to intelligence assets is not just a bad business plan but a poor life choice.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoHow about a nice directed energy tool to zap it out of orbit? You could simply vaporise the smaller bits.
- wkat4242 3y agoIt's not that simple to vaporise smaller bits because you'll have to track them after breakup. At orbital velocities even a fleck of paint hits like a bullet so it's better to just keep it in one big piece.
- nicktelford 3y agoIt always irks me that discussion of space debris invariably talks about their high velocity relative to the ground, which is completely meaningless. What really matters is their velocity relative to each other, which of course will vary, especially for objects on different orbits that happen to intersect. The closing velocities involved can still be very high, and the "bullet" metaphor still applies in most cases, but it's misleading to label them as travelling at "17,500 mph (28,160 kph)". The other thing that always bothers me is the graphical depictions that show a "point cloud" of debris in orbit around Earth. These always underplay the size of the earth and overplay the size of the orbital objects. When discussing space debris, it's always worth remembering that there's approximately 10,000 planes in the air at a given time, and yet if you look up, how many can you see in the sky above you? Since orbits are much higher, they're consequently much larger, providing even more available space than there is to commercial aviation. Not only that, but there's a far greater altitude range available for satellites than for planes, making the available space out there even more massive. I don't doubt that space debris is an (emerging) problem, but the current severity of it often seems overplayed by the mainstream media.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoAt those kinds of speeds, the orbital paths have to be really improbably similar to not have "bullet" like destructive effects. The relative velocity will almost aways be in the same order of magnitude as the ground speed and definitely more than bullet speed which is super slow compared to the ground speed. And calculating the collision speed is pretty complex while the ground speed is static so I can imagine the press just take that. After all pretty much any speed will be destructive to a satellite that's not designed to be bumped around.
- HPsquared 3y agoOrbital inclination is the big one. A polar orbit intersecting an equatorial orbit would have a very high relative velocity. On the other hand two orbits in the same inclination, with one being slightly eccentric, their relative velocity is much lower.
- ahmedfromtunis 3y agoI get how tiny that is compared to space, even that in Earth's orbit. But since these satellites are super precise, could we make a plan where two of them zoom past each other with just a 5-meter gap without fearing them colliding? I mean, if robocars can do it driving centimeters apart, why not satellites?
- HPsquared 3y agoTheir movements are also very smooth and predictable. Probably more a "what if there's a slight disturbance" thing, or "this is within our measurement / prediction error range and they could collide"
- orbital-decay 3y agoTwo problems are orbit determination accuracy (bottlenecked by the amount of ground stations and the low quality of public NORAD data) and prediction of perturbations (dominated by the atmosphere and space weather at low orbits). Both areas progressed greatly in the last decade, but still not enough.
- araes 3y agoOther than purely technical issues, there's also social issues. Lot of folks won't have the ability to meet those specs anyway. Many countries simply will not care that much, and launch whatever to wherever, because "tragedy of the commons." And, many are openly antagonistic, and will simply test anti-satellite missiles, because the USA already has em, and tested em, so we can too.
- aaronmdjones 3y agoCars can maneuver much more readily, travel at much lower velocities, have road traction so aren't affected by their gravitational attraction to each other, and don't have a third axis of separation (altitude) to deal with, including changes in that axis due to micro-gravity and atmospheric fluctuations. This makes long-term modelling of orbits/intersections very difficult, and the error bounds are much too large to give any reliable projections on the order of 5 metres. We would know that they came within 5 metres of each other when they come within 5 metres of each other; not long before.
- throw0101a 3y agoVox recently released a video on space lasers to deal with smaller debris: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQKpMmBDtZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQKpMmBDtZo * https://www.vox.com/science/2024/2/29/24086652/space-trash-lasers-explained https://www.vox.com/science/2024/2/29/24086652/space-trash-l... The idea is to sweep LEO: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_broom
- FoeNyx 3y agosmall nitpicking: it ought to be written as "20 m" instead of "20M" or else why bother including the equivalent in meters? (in the International System of Units, M is the prefix for mega: 10^6)
- belter 3y agoNot a nitpick and yes should be :-) I can't edit but Dang is always around...