4 ms·
I really like stories of individual folks out there making the world a better place. A motivated individual with some level of exposure to the problem / solut
by duxup 3y ago
I really like stories of individual folks out there making the world a better place. A motivated individual with some level of exposure to the problem / solution often seems so much more efficient than other solutions.
There's a local group that helps folks find stolen bikes:
https://www.wsj.com/us-news/your-bike-just-got-stolen-these-vigilantes-will-get-it-back-af45a9d0?st=36dqme79yig8m3z&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/us-news/your-bike-just-got-stolen-these-...
- mtmail 3y agoOnline I saw a guy with a power washer cleaning hate-speech graffiti for free (e.g. swastikas in the US). I don't think he does it for fame or clicks but even if it's a net positive.
- chrisBob 3y agoI don't understand the "even if" comment. This is the one benefit of these social platforms. If the attention really motivates people to do something good, then have at it!
- neocritter 3y agoOne of my favorite YouTube channels uses the fame and funding to take on dog grooming jobs no one else is able to, or is able to devote enough time and detail to. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OkGk2YRSnw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OkGk2YRSnw There's also an explosion of channels where professional landscapers and pressure washers do the occasional free job on a house in desperate need while recording it for YouTube. It's great background TV and likely more effective than any kind of paid advertising.
- onemoresoop 3y agoBe careful with the attention seeking as an incentive. People could stage all kind of things just to get the attention they crave or monetize.
- thefaux 3y agoyes, see the cobra effect.
- RinTohsaka 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive
- therealdrag0 3y agoThere’s a YouTuber called “scumbagdad” I think that parodies the feel good cliches.
- fennecbutt 3y agoWell, we're living in an era of electronic crack, being a social species has its disadvantages as well; people can become addicted to clout. Think of all of the "I rescued this kitten from a well!!!" videos, only to find that that's the only type of video that channel makes, ie they're throwing kittens down wells.
- bluGill 3y agoIs it? I know of one case where someone cleaned some graffiti - but they didn't realize that there was priceless art under that graffiti and their cleaning also destroyed the priceless art. If experts had been called in they could found and used the proper solvent and saved the art. (often this means work a couple square cm at a time)
- ssklash 3y agoI don't think we need to call in experts to decide if we need to save swastika graffiti and other hate speech.
- JohnMakin 3y agoThey were saying there could be art under the hate speech.. not that the hate speech was art..
- dmd 3y agoThat's going to be my kids' new excuse whenever I ask them to do any cleaning whatsoever. WHAT IF THERE'S PRICELESS ART UNDER THIS PILE OF LAUNDRY!? BETTER CALL IN THE EXPERTS!
- crtasm 3y agoWho knew the art was there? If it's priceless maybe they could have put a notice up?
- ornornor 3y agoHow often is that the case though? I don’t think it should be an excuse to do nothing about it on the one in a million chance there is priceless artwork under. I’m also skeptical about how priceless it was if it was on a street wall just like that. Unique, beloved, commissioned etc I totally see it but priceless?
- koliber 3y agoYou mean like someone trying to clean graffiti off a famous painting in the Louvre? Fully agree with you - don’t do it yourself. As far as other run-of-the-mill graffiti, I’d say take your chances.
- FireBeyond 3y ago"WIIFM". I volunteered at an animal shelter that was not no-kill, because of sheer demand, sadly. Of new volunteers, they ask "What's in it for you?" Inevitably, "I get to help animals find new homes, etc." However they'd say "No - that's what you'll do here. But what do you get out of it?" And they wanted selfish answers. "I feel better about myself", whatever. Because what they'd found is when things were a struggle, it was the "what's in it for me" that often pushed people to keep helping and volunteering, rather than (solely) "the mission".
- toomuchtodo 3y ago> “I like to randomly do things to help when nobody’s looking,” Benigno said. “I’ll do just random stuff to help improve things that will benefit random people that I’ve never met before … it’s just so that I can do a little thing to fix something so somebody doesn’t suffer down the road.” We need all of this we can get.
- munificent 3y agoWe also need all of this we can give. So many people are unhappy these days because they feel they aren't doing anything that meaningfully helps their community. We're a social species. We thrive when we feel we are helping our tribe thrive.
- jajko 3y agoAny parent knows darn well that giving is so much better for the giver than just receiving
- jstarfish 3y agoA huge part of this is that people who are willing to do so don't know how/where to offer it. Not everyone has an entrepreneurial spirit or the ambition of a trailblazer. Today, I jump-started a car for a sketchy couple in rough shape at the end of a dirt road in the middle of nowhere that I encountered after making a wrong turn. Forensic Files episodes often start this way, but I still stopped to help. To be happy, I recommend looking at what the media pushes and doing the exact opposite. No matter what it is. Even when you're wrong, you'll be right often enough to negate the losses. Sob story about ___? The subjects are always going to prove to be criminals or assholes. Avoid them. Be afraid of these people! They're probably being put upon and desperately need your help. Don't be afraid of these people! They just want to scam you. #believewomen! Don't.
- dfxm12 3y agoIt frustrates me to see people in my neighborhood complain about minor things on local social media, but do nothing about it or even go out of their way to make things worse (like complaining about trash on the sidewalk on an especially windy day, or walking their dog on the high school football field instead of the dog park, which is two blocks (!!) further, for example). It feels like it is hard to get people to to extend common courtesy towards their neighbors, let alone do something good for someone they think they'll never run into.
- smm11 3y agoI spent a summer 'rescuing' stolen bikes from (mostly homeless) chopshops and under-bridge/in desert settlements, and only found one or two of more than 50 former bike owners who wanted their property back. The risk to me was too great, and I had dozens of high-dollar, spraypainted, butchered former nice bikes stuffed into my garage. Never again.
- duxup 3y agoThe more vigilante side of things, gotta be careful too. I have no problem telling / hoping someone would pickup the trash they saw and helped out even if a little. But not so much retrieving stolen bikes, those folks, their call.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> The risk to me was too great, and I had dozens of high-dollar, spraypainted, butchered former nice bikes stuffed into my garage. Possession of stolen property is still a serious crime. There is generally no exemption for vigilante people returning stolen goods. I honestly would not advise amassing stolen property in your garage no matter your good intentions. Batman wears a mask for a reason.
- crooked-v 3y agoI feel like that giant penny has to be over the line of felony possession of stolen goods just by itself, right?
- wolverine876 3y ago> only found one or two of more than 50 former bike owners who wanted their property back Why didn't they want their bicycles?
- smm11 3y agoInsurance settlements and the hassle of fixing what were basically trashed bikes. Yes, I realized I was in possession of stolen property after a time. I also went through a few baseball bats.
- ericmcer 3y agoHow much do you think it would cost the city to implement something like this themselves? It would probably involve hiring 2-3 bike riders, a manager, some people to oversee/analyze the efficacy of the program, an approved supply chain using approved vendors. They could probably get a couple bikes with magnets on them riding around the city for < 3m year.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoIf your point is that it costs less to have someone do something for free than to hire and supervise workers to do the same task, I don't think that's particularly insightful!
- munificent 3y agoWell, the better approach at city scale is to use actual street sweepers. Magnets don't pick up broken glass.
- cameron_b 3y agoI’m the article he pivoted from the magnets and used the publicity he got from the story to overfund a bike-attached sweeper of a type previously shared on HN
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scrose 3y agoThe city would extend a no-bid contract to run a 6-month pilot in a 3 block radius. It’d go to a random company that never did anything related to trash pick up, but one of the board members would be loosely related to the mayor. The mayor will then do a victory lap in front of journalists talking about this revolutionary project. The winner would then sub-contract a series of shell companies to handle ‘planning the design and implementation’ of the vehicle used to pick up the debris. 3 months will pass and the first community board meeting about the pilot in the neighborhood will happen, where the project will hit vicious opposition from people citing gentrification, how this pilot will rip apart the fabric of the neighborhood, cause gridlock, be dangerous for kids (What if a kid runs infront of the magnet bike??), etc… 6 months and $5M later, the pilot gets extended and another $50M worth of funding having never picked up an ounce of trash. Hello from NYC
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoThis guy on youtube goes around cleaning blocked drains and has inspired some copycats https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MV9dOHRDb3c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MV9dOHRDb3c
- NotSammyHagar 3y agothanks for posting, that was strangely a great and positive example of what we can all do.
- bsder 3y agoIt's nice that individuals can do things like clean the streets ... But how about we actually fund street sweeping at a level that this isn't necessary?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]