8 ms·
Nokia is replacing Huawei at Deutsche Telekom sites in Germany
- unmole 3y agoI wonder what they're going to do with their cloud offering: https://www.open-telekom-cloud.com/en https://www.open-telekom-cloud.com/en Sure it's based on OpenStack so, they could switch to a different distribution. But there are plenty of Huawei proprietary bits that aren't straightforward to replace. Full disclosure: Former Huawei employee who worked on one of the aforementioned proprietary bits.
- godzillabrennus 3y agoMakes me miss nephoscale.
- mike_d 3y agoThe German government has given providers until 2026 to reduce their exposure to high risk vendors (Huawei and ZTE) to less than 25% of equipment, with a complete ban in places like the capitol and near military bases. Basically the same problem played out in the US as well, where smaller operators looking to offset massive hardware costs for 5G upgrades selected high risk vendors who came in well below cost to establish a spying foothold in our telecom networks. The FCC handed out almost $2 billion last year to help these networks rip and replace.
- culopatin 3y agoWhat a deal would be to buy second hand Chinese equipment at a discount to then ask the FCC to help you change it…
- huggingmouth 3y agoWith (deserved) increased scrutiny in Huawei and friends, I'm half tempted to get the discarded gear to actually put in production use. China/Huawei is no longer in a position to pull something stupid. Current gen functioning gear at a discount price will be very tempting.
- The_Colonel 3y agoWhat do you mean? China has economic problems, but international escalation is often a great way to distract from donestic problems.
- unmole 3y agoHuawei was always subject to a much higher level of scrutiny for obvious reasons. In the UK, for example since around 2010, Huawei turned over code to an independent oversight board: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/huawei-cyber-security-evaluation-centre-hcsec-oversight-board-annual-report-2021 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/huawei-cyber-secu...
- rfoo 3y ago> came in well below cost Could you please suggest some read on why equipments are considered coming in well below cost? Haven't heard this before.
- crotchfire 3y agohttps://www.seattleix.net/infrastructure-history https://www.seattleix.net/infrastructure-history Note the dates the Huawei CE12808 was put into and taken out of service. Less than one year.
- roenxi 3y agoIt is terribly revealing about what the US has been up to that the minute they realise Huawei is more cost competitive they develop a rip and replace program to get Chinese gear out of the system. They understand what is possible; and likely because someone in the intelligence apparatus wrote a report saying "the Chinese could [do this thing we are doing]".
- kortilla 3y agoThere isn’t anything magic here. It’s not that China would have particularly special capabilities over this equipment. It’s that it’s so full of vulnerabilities that any nation state (or really any determined good hacker) can get into these systems.
- jajko 3y agoWas there any comparison actually done between various providers that didn't stay within some 3-letter agency like NSA? Generally a lot of equipment is full of holes and its nigh impossible to keep track if every year there is new version, scales of this matter of course but this move specifically nicely aligns into general start of US trade war with China. Also, to most of the world whether US is spying or China is makes 0 practical difference, both can and will be used against given country when decided (ie secret services helping 'their' big companies win big contracts due to leaking some related secrets, many cases like this in the past).
- roenxi 3y ago> whether US is spying or China is makes 0 practical difference It does make a practical difference. It is better to be spied on by the weakest power. That is probably still China if we blindly guess that their GDP is overstated and note that their military is less adventurous than the US. In the Middle East, Eastern Europe and maybe Africa there is actually a good chance that the US spying will be used to overthrow your government or literally build an invasion plan. I have no idea how active they are in South America but I assume the sausage making process is ugly there too. I don't think China has been accused of doing either yet although I assume it is going to get started on government-toppling sooner or later. India would be in a tough spot though. They should probably figure out how to produce telecoms gear through native companies if they haven't already.
- kragen 3y ago[flagged]
- chaostheory 3y agoIn case you didn’t know, the US materially supported Ukraine while China provided aid to Russia in more ways than one.
- lemper 3y agoand in case you didn't know US carpet bombed Vietnam and many other countries. so, what's your point?
- computerfriend 3y agoThe point, presumably, is that Germany and the US are politically and militarily aligned and that Russia and China are adversaries.
- curiousgal 3y ago⠀
- phantomathkg 3y agoAre you seriously trying to argue that the China/Russia is better than US when it comes to...foreign policy?
- graphe 3y agoIn regards to Africa, China is indisputably better than the US at foreign policy as a fact. Check out the passport rankings to see who objectivity has the best foreign relations. https://www.passportindex.org/byRank.php https://www.passportindex.org/byRank.php surprised to see Syria and Pakistan lower than "Palestinian territories".
- 3y ago
- ein0p 3y agoIsn’t Nokia also Chinese though?
- resolutebat 3y agoUh, no, it's Finnish through and through.
- ein0p 3y agoMy bad, I thought HMD was Chinese just based on abysmally bad quality of the phones they manufacture. Surprised to see this from a former leader. My first cell phone was made by Nokia, it was absolutely rock solid.
- Hamuko 3y agoHMD is also Finnish, and a completely different company than Nokia.
- abenga 3y agoAre their phones that bad? I have never bought any of their flagships (typing this on an X30), but I've found that the phones are excellent for their price point, plus they put pure Android on them, which is quite rare these days for non-Pixel phones.
- aitchnyu 3y agoI've happily switched from Nokia to Samsung and so many niggles were gone. I couldn't imagine a Samsung PM seeing Android alarm and go "lets just allow alarms to blare till the speakers breaks loose, Google's snooze settings belongs on a spaceship"
- abenga 3y agoI guess it depends on the person. I have a Samsung tablet, and would rather it was running the stock Android launcher. I also detest that there are (Samsung or otherwise) apps on there I do not want to use and cannot uninstall.
- Leary 3y ago[flagged]
- FredPret 3y agoCCP penetration of comms in China: 100% CCP penetration of comms in Germany: less than that
- yogorenapan 3y agoThis is pure bullshit. 164.58 Mbps looks great until you realize that’s only true for sites within China or sites whitelisted by the CCP. It’s obviously 0 Mbps for Google or BBC. For sites that haven’t been reviewed, they throttle the connection. All sites on Cloudflare become unreliable. GitHub is sporadically banned. Any sane person would much rather live in Germany.
- lithiumii 3y agoSites being blocked is different from internet being slow. Theoretically it's possible for GFW to disappear (very unlikely) or malfunction (more likely) and access to Google or BBC is suddenly much faster. Practically you can use a proper VPN. I don't disagree with your opinion on which country is better to live in.
- est 3y ago> It’s obviously 0 Mbps for Google or BBC Google's ads business works fine in China. BBC is mostly English so Chinese people don't visit it anyway. > All sites on Cloudflare become unreliable This is completely false. Many people rely CF for domain-fronting. Also: https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-partners-with-jd-cloud/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-partners-with-jd-clou... The "164.58 Mbps average speed" is mostly spent on Tencent/Wechat, and the infamous Douyin(tiktok)
- yogorenapan 3y agoI ran a pretty popular site that at its peak got a terabyte a day back a few years ago. One of the most common complaints I got was that cloudflare is unstable in China. The link you gave says serving Chinese traffic is at request, not for all sites.
- womitt 3y agoCurious what happens to the Chinese equipment. Where could one buy it?
- kmarc 3y agoAnecdote time. I worked on a Deutsche Telekom cloud project, which was somewhat internally competing with the Huawei-built Open Telekom Cloud. At the same time, a business partner and I also consulted other telco companies. What I have seen, down to the data center from Huawei was insane. From a technical perspective (hardware and software) was great, but the pace they ate up people was something I am not familiar with in European culture. This one day, checking the servers in the DC, a manager-like dude was shouting at his subordinate engineer to fix things. I found it weird (and a bit unprofessional). Next day, a new engineer joined the team, the previous one was not there anymore. When I asked how did they replace him so quickly, they told me that they literally flew someone in from China overnight. They delivered. Their things worked. Tech was great. I wouldn't want to work in such environment.
- dilyevsky 3y agoI also worked on the telco side and we did dd for huawei equipment in 2010 (it was early days of IMS). They actually flew us to their hq in shenzhen and i spent weeks there. I haven’t seen anything like what you’re describing but one thing I remember is how paranoid about security (including physical security) they were always talking shit about “those thieves from zte”. I found this pretty hilarious and still do
- pototo666 3y agoIn China, Huawei is known for offering competitive salaries but also demands a lot from its employees. Many people tolerate the toxic work environment in exchange for financial benefits, particularly as they gradually improve their family's lifestyle with their rising income. As a successful company, Huawei has also popularized the so-called "Wolf-like Spirit" among other Chinese firms. The "Wolf-like Spirit" implies an expectation to work extremely hard and do whatever is necessary to achieve the company's goals. One anecdote involves some Japanese customers who visited ZTE, a competitor of Huawei. To break the deals, Huawei allegedly sent individuals who pretended to be ZTE employees and entertained the customers with drinking and whoring for a week. No one should trust a company like Huawei. Or any companies with deep CCP connection from China.
- 3y ago
- andrewstuart 3y agoHuawei was beginning of the souring of the west's relationship with China, starting with Australia, which had major security concerns about Huawei being allowed our build our 5G networks. "China envoy says Australia fired first shot with Huawei ban" https://apnews.com/article/technology-china-sydney-australia-037521cd9d6e09854c98b4acf1acbf20 https://apnews.com/article/technology-china-sydney-australia... "Huawei? No way! Why Australia banned the world’s biggest telecoms firm" https://www.smh.com.au/national/huawei-no-way-why-australia-banned-the-world-s-biggest-telecoms-firm-20210503-p57oc9.html https://www.smh.com.au/national/huawei-no-way-why-australia-... "Huawei ban is just the start of the great decoupling" https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/huawei-ban-is-just-the-start-of-the-great-decoupling-20200728-p55g2u https://www.afr.com/policy/economy/huawei-ban-is-just-the-st... "A Chinese official openly declared on Wednesday that Beijing has singled out Australia for economic punishment, saying the federal government cannot profit from China while "smearing" it" https://www.business-standard.com/article/international/china-hits-australian-industries-with-economic-sanctions-amid-souring-ties-121070900082_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/international/chin...
- bwilli123 3y agoAt a meeting of the 'Five Eyes' months before on Vancouver Island, Australia was nominated/volunteered to start the Western anti-Huawei campaign.
- Goodroo 3y agoHuawei would probably have 90 % of the 5G equipment market if this smear campaign had not started. They were even beating Nokia and Ericsson in their respective home markets
- throwaway4good 3y agoIt took some time but now Germany is finally free from foreign powers surveilling its citizens and forcing it to do things it doesn't want to do.
- mihular 3y agoAll that remains now is domestic and allies surveillance forcing it to do things it doesn't want to.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agolol, what? Either my sarcasm detector is way off or…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hcfman 3y agoIf they haven't already, likely Germany will also introduce a new law like the Dutch did such that a court order or judge is no longer necessary to hack someone and you don't have to be a criminal either. Additionally, it goes without saying of course, you don't never any form of evidence of anything.
- fransje26 3y agoLuckily for now, the Germans, for all their flaws, still have a much better understanding of the concept of privacy than the Dutch, and are pushing back as they can. Being a bit more historically conscious will do that to you, I guess. And it's not like there haven't been repeated offenses of privacy abuse in the Netherlands the past few years.. (With little to no repercussion whatsoever..) The general response of the average (uninformed) citizen is that they have nothing to hide, so they don't care. And it is well know that abuses only happen in other, less developed countries, with said countries starting at the southern, eastern, and "western" boarders. So, as long as they inconvenience someone else's life, all is well. As the poem goes: First they came...
- pjmlp 3y agoSweet revenge I guess, Huawei was one of the reasons Nokia Networks reduced head count in Germany during the 2005 - 2010.
- severino 3y agoBut that only happened because Huawei became the most competitive offer back then. Now Nokia is back in business due to a political decision that eliminates its competitors.
- pjmlp 3y agoThere are many ways how competitive offer was achieved.
- SSLy 3y agoand AT&T was reason Nokia reduced headcount last month.
- guidedlight 3y agoChina has moved onto EV’s for its surveillance apparatus. They are everywhere and are eating Tesla’s lunch.
- paganel 3y agoThe digitisation and GPS-localisation of everything has been a mistake. For West's sake I hope that they end up becoming aware of all that, sooner rather than later, because there's no way that they can make better and cheaper electronic/electric things on a grand scale compared to China. Now it's EVs, next it will be China-produced fridges that home in on what the Western population is eating, then China-produced TV sets and so on and so forth.
- DeathArrow 3y agoIf the US manufacturers can't compete with Chinese manufacturers on price / performance, then there are laws enacted to protect them. And laws are always "for the greater good." And we always have justifications ready: war on terror, war on drugs, war on child pornography, war on fake news with more wars coming.
- grantla 3y agoWish them good luck. They will find out how incompetent Nokia became.
- hcfman 3y agoI expect the German government are less able to spy on German citizens with Huawei equipment. So it turned out that the buyer of Nokia might have done a good deal after all. With a little help from their friends they have new business.
- Alifatisk 3y agoWas there actual proof of Huawei (or any other foreign company) used as backdoor for the CCP or was the actions taken as a safety measure?
- guappa 3y agoI see it as the usual USA saying "russia/china/iran/nk bad!" I'm not aware of any evidence ever being shown about this specific issue.
- Intermernet 3y agoLess than the equivalent proof of US equipment having similar back doors. Have we learnt nothing from the snowden leaks? Are we now living in innocent rainbow land?
- blackoil 3y agoIn near future world will have these factions. US and its allies and vassals. China+Russia,Iran,NK. India is hostile to China but close to Russia. It won't let go Russia as needs the resources and has been burnt few times to become solely dependent on US. Africa will be interesting and SEA while not friendly with China likes the cheap stuff and for them China spying vs US spying is not very different. For US/Europe politicians one challenge would be to convince voters to be deadictted to cheap stuff they are used to buying. Particularly if replacement isn't local. Like Tesla vs BYD.