6 ms·
> Financial systems are inseparably computer systems. Most similarly important computer systems don’t take holidays. Google doesn’t take holidays… or doesn’t se
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Financial systems are inseparably computer systems. Most similarly important computer systems don’t take holidays. Google doesn’t take holidays… or doesn’t seem to, from the perspective of a typical user, at any rate.
Wouldn't it be better for users if our financial systems worked like the Google example? Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday? Why can't I move money from one bank account to another on Sunday? Imagine not being able to send E-mail on Easter because nobody at your ISP was there to push bits around or whatever these banks' excuse is?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBecause there is a lot more plumbing involved in buying and selling equities or moving money than there is to send and receive email. Specifically, a lot of measures to prevent something going wrong, because the the damages are far greater when moving things of great value than an email. You technically can trade stock on a Saturday, just not using all the aforementioned plumbing of a popular stock exchange and brokerage. And you can move money on the weekends, just maybe not with the help of banks because they consider it not worth their while to offer the service on weekends.
- ryandrake 3y agoBut why? What makes the plumbing stop on weekends and holidays? Is this some kind of law of nature, or can it be fixed? It seems silly that bank transactions, stock trades, purchases of insurance or anything like that requires human intervention. It's like an HTTP request requiring a human to put it through. Bonkers.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI don’t know all the reasons, it could involve regulators not wanting to be on call, or more likely, the businesses not wanting to be on call. I know that for lots of accounting related things, there used to be a need for downtime time to tally things up, and maybe that schedule carried over. But overall, I would bet it’s just a low demand thing that isn’t worth it. Suppose you opened an exchange that was 24/7. Would the cost to trade on your exchange be sufficiently low to compete with the current exchanges with limited hours? Technically, if you had a paper stock certificate, you could sell it or buy it, and if you had a bag of money, you could move it. But whether or not other people will help you is probably dependent on how much you can pay, which for 99.99% of people, is probably not worth it to just wait a couple days. Think about real estate. It’s possible that you have a paper deed and draw up some documents and buy or sell it in 30 minutes, but the cost of something going wrong is so high that it makes sense to take a little time and use lawyers to double and triple check things.
- nottorp 3y agoIf 0.01% of the transactions a bank processes daily need some form of human intervention, that's already a full day for a lot of bank employees. Said bank employees would rather have the same number of days off we the rest do.
- theideaofcoffee 3y agoThen I guess we have to question why those .01% of transactions need human intervention at all. It seem like .01% of requests to Google Search don't need human interaction, why does money, now that it's mostly just an entry in a database somewhere (or on its way to be)? If it's a matter of approvals, then those should be codified in rules that can be expressed in code. That may be difficult for laws, the general refrain being 'laws aren't code', but money transfer is just a list of rules, transactions, settlement dates and so on.
- nottorp 3y ago> but money transfer is just a list of rules, transactions, settlement dates and so on. Never worked with financial transactions but I have a feeling what you said qualifies as 'famous last words'.
- clarada 3y agoBecause with transactions things have to match and sometimes data errors happen. Take something really simple like a bank cash transfer. Do you really think that no one ever accidentally puts in a typo in an account number or an amount? If that happens then the transaction either fails or doesn't do as desired. Either way someone has to manually resolve it. Take that and put it on steroids for securities transactions.
- Jevon23 3y ago>money transfer is just a list of rules, transactions, settlement dates and so on. Surely you must appreciate how obnoxious it is when people assume that software development is just “translating the requirements into code”, right?
- theideaofcoffee 3y agoIn a lower reply of mine, I still have to ask why this is the case. If it's that big of a thing, then there should be rules defined to catch things. We have exception handlers for code and steps that go awry, why not the same for money, so the rest of the money flow can keep going, and only the weird things need to be checked out (and further rules then be refined).
- clarada 3y agoThat's what happens. Almost all transactions are Straight Through Processed. It's only when things go wrong (or very exceptional cases) that a human gets involved. The banks can't afford for humans to be involved in too many transactions.
- mason55 3y ago> Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday? Markets have chosen to concentrate trading to specific hours so as to concentrate liquidity and to help out the professional traders. If everyone's trading 24/7 then it means you need to be prepared to trade 24/7. Having defined market hours means defined hours in which important things can happen. And since the people who work in the market can also define the hours, they've chosen to give themselves reasonable working hours. In a world where the major markets are trading 24/7, traders need to be at their desk 24/7. > Why can't I move money from one bank account to another on Sunday? Instant money transfer means instantly draining someone's bank account with no recourse. Checks have plenty of opportunities to stop the money, so you can write a check on a Sunday as easily as a Wednesday. Wires are more irreversible and so you can only send those when the bank is open and there's someone to double check any suspicious behavior.
- richardw 3y agoI can do an instant payment at the bank I work at, on a Sunday. We just warn clients that there’s no recourse but we give them the option. This is a choice, not an act of god. Our clients (including me) love it.
- jimmydorry 3y agoExcept sophisticated traders are allowed to trade outside of market hours (after hours markets are a thing). When news drops, price is absolutely affected in the after-hours market. It's only the regular Joe's that are not allowed the priviledge to trade at all hours.
- jmb99 3y agoI'm a regular Joe (in Canada no less) and my discount brokerage lets me trade after hours with no extra verification or fees.
- dmurray 3y agoIn the US, retail investors have been allowed trade after hours since (Googles...) mid-1999. [0] https://seekingalpha.com/article/4453440-after-hours-trading https://seekingalpha.com/article/4453440-after-hours-trading
- pavlov 3y ago> “Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday?” Stock trading on exchanges traditionally has delayed settlement. You don’t need to have the money and stock at hand when you make the trade, but you’re expected to provide them on the settlement date. For a long time this was two days later, but is now being changed to only one day in the U.S. Trading on Saturdays would either mean complications for settlement, or that settlement must happen on Saturday too. Surely not impossible, but these things have ripple effects that are not immediately obvious. > “Why can't I move money from one bank account to another on Sunday?” This exists in Europe with 24/7 SEPA instant credit across banks and Eurozone countries. It doesn’t cost anything extra. But getting to that point needed a serious mandate from the European Union, years of planning, and cooperation by the various governments. The effort was worth it because it’s a far better solution for consumers than e.g. cryptocurrencies or the American proprietary payment solutions like Venmo.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> ... But getting to that point needed a serious mandate from the European Union, years of planning, and cooperation by the various governments. The effort was worth it I'd take my EU strong from an economic point of view and without "yay sunday SEPA transfer" any day over the EU we have today. The EU is a massive failure and it's going to fall into oblivion versus the US and China: especially now that the EU voted to kill its main economy, Germany, by destroying german automakers (with the mandatory shift to EVs). The EU produces metric shittons of rules and legislation which brings absolutely nothing of value to its citizens. If anything I don't think the EU is something to strive for: on the contrary, it should serve as an example of what not to do. Even if this means no "yay, instant sunday payments".
- Tijdreiziger 3y agoSure, they gave us 100 years of peace on the European continent, and hassle-free commerce, travel and communication across borders, and the freedom for any of its citizens to study and work anywhere within its borders, and modern mobile phone networks [1], and universal phone chargers, and strong protections of our personal data, etc., etc., etc. …but other than that, what has the EU ever done for us? https://genius.com/Monty-python-what-have-the-romans-ever-done-for-us-annotated https://genius.com/Monty-python-what-have-the-romans-ever-do... [1] GSM was created as a European standard by the EU
- lmm 3y ago> Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday? Having worked in the industry for some years: because it's always been that way, and because the people who make financial systems are lazy and bad at their jobs and don't want to admit they were wrong. It's happening, very slowly, just yesterday I was reading about "the first 24/7 stock exchange" making another filing or something. But the financial industry is conservative and most users are happy for it to be - sure they'll talk about how they want their bank to have a better online service, but they'll keep banking at the big four names they recognise rather than the upstarts that offer better service. > Imagine not being able to send E-mail on Easter because nobody at your ISP was there to push bits around or whatever these banks' excuse is? Here in Japan a lot of government systems work like that.
- lxgr 3y agoSorry to hear you've worked in such a depressing part of the industry. I've worked with some incredibly motivated and talented people and this is not my impression at all. Still, it's an old, large and hugely complex interconnected system made up of literally thousands of banks employing millions of people and several regulatory bodies run by different federal and state administrations. Such interconnected systems/networks are notoriously hard to evolve, especially given that, as you also noted, people are often extremely conservative when it comes to their life savings. I don't think it's fair to blame the people working in the industry for all of that or even call them lazy.
- lmm 3y ago> I've worked with some incredibly motivated and talented people and this is not my impression at all. I worked with some incredibly motivated and talented people too - and saw many of them ground down as basic improvements took literally years to make it through in watered-down form, if they even saw the light of day at all. I was actually amazed by how few people in the financial industry are incompetent in the "couldn't write fizzbuzz" sense, but there seems to be a big-picture insularity where stuff that would be basic and common sense in every other industry (e.g. automated CI) is just not done.
- 3y ago
- rodgerd 3y ago> Wouldn't it be better for users if our financial systems worked like the Google example? Yes, I guess there are a few precious hours of our lives that aren't crushed under the perversity of the Protestant work cult, we should seek them out and grind them under the heel.
- theideaofcoffee 3y agoIf anything I think it would go in the opposite direction, freeing people to do things on their own time, and not the banks'. Available when when people need them to be, not when the institutions want to be, but that would require effort on their part and maybe cost them a few basis points in profit.
- blibble 3y agonothing's stopping you swapping your share certificates with some random guy in a dark alley for cash/candy/... at 3am on a Saturday if you want to do it on NASDAQ/NYSE/... then those businesses have decided they only want to operate certain hours > Imagine not being able to send E-mail on Easter because nobody at your ISP was there to push bits around emails stuck in a transfer queue somewhere is not exactly a rare occurrence
- resolutebat 3y agoFor all its faults, this is the one thing crypto gets right: you can trade 24/7.
- ForHackernews 3y agoWouldn't it be better if Google worked like financial systems? Perhaps people would learn to read maps if they weren't misled into unrealistic assumptions that Google Maps will always be available, always responsive, always correct. What is the cost, in money time, attention, engineering effort of trying to build for five 9s of reliability?
- wbl 3y agoYou can put in orders any time and they execute at the open.
- dopylitty 3y agoI would take it the other way. The stock market should only be open one day a year. That would have several benefits: - Remove the perverse incentives encouraging the use of the stock market for gambling - Free up intelligent people who are currently wasting their lives on said gambling to do things that actually benefit society - Encourage creation of some other way for people to save for retirement that isn't a casino where their life savings could disappear at any moment
- Cheer2171 3y agoI can't tell if this is a bad attempt at a joke or if you actually think this would work.
- lmm 3y agoSome people have seriously suggested shortening trading hours, on the grounds that all the interesting trading happens at the open and especially at the close, closing prices are the ones that are reported and used for risk analysis etc.. If everyone wants to trade at the close, why not just have one "opening" auction every day, and the price from that auction is the "closing" price for the day? That also eliminates the opportunity for trying to "pick off" or "front-run" other people's orders, or "quote fade" on the other side.
- mlrtime 3y agoThese suggestions come up all the time and they are hilariously naive. You can tell these people haven't set foot near the finance market. That saying there are some markets where auctions do take place, as well as RFQs, etc. They work well in illiquid markets.
- FabHK 3y agoYou're going a bit extreme, but 5 auctions per week strike me as reasonable. If the markets are trading continuously, benefits of parsing new information go to those who parse it the fastest. If the markets trade in occasional auctions, everyone shares the burden (or gift) of new information equally, and no resources are wasted in, say, building a somewhat more straight glass fibre connection between Chicago and NY, then building a sequence of microwave towers, because light moves faster in air than in fibre.
- lxgr 3y ago> Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday? Because stock exchanges don't run themselves. There's all kinds of services with humans in the loop, and without these, you'd have a market with much less guardrails than the current public stock exchanges. You can make a case for such a market being good or bad for society, but it currently simply wouldn't be legal in most countries. > Why can't I move money from one bank account to another on Sunday? You can in many countries! In the EU, SEPA Instant is going to be mandatory soon. In the US, I can already do this between two of my bank accounts; most banks unfortunately don't participate yet. The larger problem seems to be that the US simply does not have customer-initiated account transfers (to third parties) in the first place. In a way, the reason why you can't do bank transfers on the weekends is that you can't even do them on weekdays either.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Because stock exchanges don't run themselves. Nor does Google, yet somehow they are able to handle running 24/7.
- affyboi 3y agoI think NYSE has higher uptime and tighter latency requirements. Google doesn’t get in as much trouble if there’s some downtime, especially for consumer facing products
- reisse 3y ago> Why can't I as a regular retail investor trade a stock on Saturday? Because for you it means spending few minutes to open your app and send and order, for other market participants it means organizing holiday shifts, night shifts, and working long hours. You just cannot keep the strategies running without a human eye, the lack of oversight could be too expensive. Exchanges and banks and big players can afford that (though still, you're making some people more miserable for unclear reason), but can the small prop shop with tens of people trading on multiple exchanges do the same?
- andrewjl 3y agoWouldn't exchanges and market makers (i.e. the big players) be all that's needed to clear orders at reasonable spreads? Others can always choose to what scope they'd participate.