11 ms·
Via ferratas are finally catching on in the United States
- snowwrestler 3y ago> With both the National Park Service and Forest Service currently challenging the ban on fixed climbing anchors on public lands, they may become more common in the near future. This is completely backward; there is currently not a ban on fixed climbing anchors in wilderness areas, and the NPS and Forest Service are attempting to create bans through a backdoor by updating their climbing management guidelines. There is no way via ferratas are ever going to go into wilderness areas. People can argue whether the occasional fixed rappel anchor is an impermissible “installation” under the Wilderness Act. But everyone agrees that via ferratas are.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoI personally would rather not see these in the wilderness. One of the things that make the little remaining wilderness we have in the US "wild" is the friction to entry. I have some seasoned experience with mountaineering and wilderness stays and what makes it remarkable is the smaller footprint from humans. The more accessible it is the less wild it becomes.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoPeople used to complain about Yosemite having a road built to it, because it'd detract from the natural beauty of the valley and bring in too many "lazy" tourists. To some extent those critics were right, but it's pretty undeniable in hindsight that the cause of the parks system has been better served by having parks like these accessible to the public than it would have been by keeping them pristine and largely unvisited. We still have parks like that too. Gates of the Arctic and Isla royale come to mind as inaccessible, and both are tragically undervisited / unknown as a result. It's not like you can't escape the crowded masses in busy parks either. A half hour hike towards the backcountry will free you from the bustle of crowds at almost all of them.
- snowwrestler 3y agoYosemite already has a via ferrata: the cable route on Half Dome.
- stagger87 3y agoYes, and it's a huge attraction. For better or for worse?
- snowwrestler 3y agoI think it’s for worse, but NPS obviously disagrees. They seem to have essentially designated most of the Valley a sort of tourist sacrifice zone, what with all the hotels, roads, stores, paved hiking trails, etc. There was a similar cables route up Longs Peak in Rocky Mountain National Park for decades, but NPS took it out, leaving the Keyhole Route as the easiest (but not easy) remaining way to the summit.
- treprinum 3y agoThat's not a real via ferrata. Via ferratas in Europe require a helmet, a harness and a double hook lanyard, and being secured to a steel rope at all times.
- sandworm101 3y agoThe balance is that if the park doesn't let enough people in, the people stop supporting the park. America is democratic. Parks are not protected by royal proclamation. If the park is inaccessible then people don't visit. Then they don't care about it. Then one day someone wants to drill for oil in the park, and nobody cares enough to vote that down. I really don't mind the car-camping crowd. They stay inside their gravel circles and don't impact the real wilderness much. But come time to vote they will always far outnumber the dedicated rock climbers. I want the car campers on my side. If that means giving them their parking spots then so be it.
- justrealist 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hattar 3y agoLet them spend a weekend in the woods then. There’s no reason to spoil a very rare commodity so that someone with no experience or appreciation can make use of it. There are many, many “close enough” experiences, and very few that haven’t been tainted by improper use. We should preserve these priceless spots, not sacrifice them to the lowest common denominator.
- Retric 3y agoIt’s not a rare commodity. People complain because it’s the best/iconic spots that become accessible, but there’s a near endless supply of almost as good locations in the national park system that nobody visits.
- tekla 3y agoGatekeeping is good. It keeps people out who simply don't give a damn about these spaces.
- seattle_spring 3y agoHate to say it, but agreed. This easily turns into a "tragedy of the commons" situation, where a place that used to be special to some is now special to no one. The general public has proven time and time again that they are incapable of respecting natural areas and following rules and accepted etiquette. We should not be spending money increasing access so the worst of the worst can ruin even more of the country's special places.
- petsfed 3y agoThe problem with gatekeeping like this is that it also becomes an obstacle to preservation, once the initial gatekeeping has failed. Consider the scenario where climbers descend by rappelling from trees, or using an informal climbers' trail. If sufficient quantities of people use that place, the trees will die and the trails will become significant erosion channels (where the Glacier Trail ascends out of Bomber Basin in Wyoming's Fitzpatrick wilderness is basically a groove in a steep hillside because the traffic it receives far exceeds the maintenance). Its certainly the case that installing bolted rappel anchors can encourage more people to climb a route, but the presence/absence of bolted belay/rappel anchors is far less of a deterrent than the presence/absence of protection bolts (which is why few people are disputing the the long-standing ban on power drills in wilderness areas). Put another way, if you claim the only reason you've never attempt Rocky Mountain National Park's Casual Route is because you're not good at building anchors, then I would argue you'll have a dangerously hard time with the rest of the route too. The right balance between access and preservation is a difficult one to strike, but I would argue that land managers should err on the side of enabling more access because it allows them to proactively direct traffic into areas that are more durable to greater traffic, and stave-off potentially preventable accidents like this one: https://washingtonclimbers.org/index.php/2014/09/01/12534/ https://washingtonclimbers.org/index.php/2014/09/01/12534/ and this one: https://gripped.com/201304/rock-climber-dies-on-rappel-from-rockfall-accident/ https://gripped.com/201304/rock-climber-dies-on-rappel-from-... (I've rappelled from the anchor that killed Heung, and the fact that it must be somewhere where tat can be wrapped/tied is, I think, a major factor in why it was so exposed to rockfall. Its also a cautionary tale about backing up and testing tat anchors before fully committing to them, a lesson that people don't seem to learn even in the absence of "fixed" anchors. Consider this accident as well: https://americanalpineclub.org/news/2023/6/7/the-prescription-june-2023 https://americanalpineclub.org/news/2023/6/7/the-prescriptio...)
- unit_circle 3y agoThe one counterpoint I'd like to make here is tat. Imo it's better to leave minimal high quality, long lived gear than soft goods that deteriorate over time that can make for a dangerous descent and produce a fair bit of garbage.
- themaninthedark 3y agoThe stuff I saw pictured looks like rebar bent into rungs, so now you have steel left out that will deteriorate, possibly in an undetectable manner(remember, your anchor point is in the rock face). Also you are drilling into the rock. So much for leave no trace.
- willcipriano 3y ago> little remaining wilderness The US is mostly wilderness. Drive across it sometime staying off the highways.
- schaefer 3y agoWithin the context of land management and the BLM, "wilderness" is a technical designation. Here is a map[1] for land designated wilderness. [1]: https://gbp-blm-egis.hub.arcgis.com/datasets/BLM-EGIS::blm-natl-nlcs-wilderness-areas-polygons/explore https://gbp-blm-egis.hub.arcgis.com/datasets/BLM-EGIS::blm-n...
- willcipriano 3y agoAlternatively: As of 2016, roughly 36.21% (about one-third of the U.S.) is forested.[0] A reasonable person will come to my conclusion if they do as I suggest in my comment. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forests_of_the_United_States
- mrosett 3y agoForested is not wilderness. Most forests have lots of roads, power lines running through them, etc. You're just trying to redefine a defined term.
- willcipriano 3y agoPrior to 1946 there was no wilderness as the BLM didn't exist to define it as such. Or they don't own the definition.
- nullindividual 3y agoCongress owns the definition via the Wilderness Act, which are tracts of land with no human presence or impact. Perhaps that will give you context in this discussion.
- legohead 3y agoAs a rock climber, I hope it grows. Tired of seeing these debates and fights with authorities on putting up anchors, which are far less visible than these via ferratas. If these catch on and people like them, I think it will be good for climbers.
- mateo1 3y agoI wholeheartedly agree. I used to visit my grandpa's village every year (somewhere in europe) surrounded by beautiful mountains. The nature was accessible by everyone - warranted they'd do a 2 hour drive on rough road, get a hiking map and hike to the top. You'd also have to pack lunch and coffee. Now a new road is build, several hotels including a luxury resort with pools, coffee shops, tourist traps selling "traditional" "local" products etc. It's just terrible. Before, you'd "buy" your way there with effort, now you just pay, and you take your laziness with you all the way to the mountain top where you buy your $10 coffee and instagram snaps. If you want to sidestep the "nature" part of nature just go to a city park.
- treprinum 3y agoYou can still find traditional unspoiled places in Europe and Alps have plenty of closed off areas. However, more accessible routes are good for old and disabled (e.g. post-COVID effects destroying one's athletic abilities etc.)
- alistairSH 3y agoThe OP means Wilderness (capital W), not wilderness. The former is federally designated as protected from just about any development. The latter is just undeveloped backcountry without the restrictive regulation. And I tend to agree that the designation should not be loosened.
- namdnay 3y agoGood news, but if this is anything like other mountain activities in the USA, I bet it costs an arm and a leg And... yep, I just opened a random one (Estes Park?) - prices starting at 199USD a head! About 4x the price of a french one (30-50e per adult depending on how big it is and how expensive the location is) I imagine it's a combination of novelty + everything being managed privately (whereas in most of europe there are a lot of subsidies to keep mountain areas thriving)
- lm28469 3y agoThe ones I've done in Europe were free, you could even access them and climb without any gear if you want
- namdnay 3y agoindeed a lot of them are "free" but they clearly state the correct equipment must be worn (which is of course available for rent at various approved outlets) , or else any accident will get you into a world of financial trouble
- sebtron 3y agoWhat do you mean by "financial trouble"? You certainly risk getting hurt or killed without the right equipment, but I don't see how this is related to "financial trouble".
- DebtDeflation 3y agoI assume they mean that you will be billed for any rescue costs incurred.
- hgomersall 3y agoI always assume that's the case when I'm in the Alps. That's why it's important to have proper insurance.
- 3y ago
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoI expected that to be a euphemism for a railroad but it means ladders and cables for climbing.
- dkdbejwi383 3y agoThe literal translation from Italian is something like "iron way". Compare with the Italian word for a railway, which is "ferroviario"
- hk__2 3y ago> Compare with the Italian word for a railway, which is "ferroviario" No, it’s "ferrovia" and it’s in the wrong order because it’s based on English: rail+way -> ferro+via.
- dkdbejwi383 3y agohttps://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trasporto_ferroviario https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trasporto_ferroviario
- myrmidon 3y agoNo; ferroviario is an adjective, like "rail" in "rail transport". But it is ONLY an adjective, you can not use it as a noun (you would use "ferrovia" for railroad track, instead).
- hk__2 3y agoThe case of French is curious, because "ferroviario" (adjective) is "ferroviaire", but the noun is "voie ferrée" and not something like *ferrovoie.
- gpderetta 3y ago"strada ferrata" (iron road) is literally railroad in Italian, while "via ferrata" (iron way) are the ladders and cables for climbing.
- paulkrush 3y agoGreat video on a free one in Colorado: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bReTV2J7PIk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bReTV2J7PIk "Telluride Via Ferrata in Colorado has been on our bucket list for quite some time. So when our cousin Anh asked if we want to make a trip there, of course, we said yes. Telluride Via Ferrata has to be one of the most exciting and unforgettable adventures. It combines mountain hiking with the traditional Via Ferrata cable system and breathtaking scenery. There is nothing more thrilling than traversing across a sheer cliff, 600ft above ground, with only safety tethers, a steel cable, and metal rungs to support you. Besides the spectacular views, this amazing adventure also challenges your physical and mental fortitude while giving you an incomparable sense of accomplishment."
- hnrodey 3y agoI hiked Via Ferrata in Telluride, CO and it's an amazing experience. Search on YouTube for videos. In the past few years there's been another via ferrata opened in Ouray, CO (neighbors Telluride) that looks even more intense - sadly I haven't made it to this one quite yet. We went with a paid guide in a small group and I thought it was money well spent. However, in Telluride it's public access so anyone can hike it completely free if they want. Make sure you know what you're doing though - follow the rules and I think it's quite safe.
- darkwizard42 3y agoThe Ouray one now has two tracks. Both were excellent! We did the more advanced one this time around with just my climbing-experienced brother leading us.
- darkwizard42 3y agoSo we did the Via Ferrata in Ouray and it was AMAZING! They did offer guided runs but we just rented gear for pretty cheap and went on the course. I’m not understanding the costs here as we paid no money for course access. For those interested it would be beneficial to have some understanding of rock climbing mechanics - how to strategically prop yourself and rest, how to transfer weight, how to grip efficiently. You can definitely “muscle” your way through the courses but it will get tiring and then dangerous. Highly recommend for those who have some beginner rock climbing experience and want to give it a shot!
- jakub_g 3y agoIf you're ever in south-east France, there's a bunch of nice via ferratas of varying difficulty. A nice one to start is in Lantosque, it's very easy and low and beautiful with river a few feet below (except a vertical climb at the end followed by a zip line / bridge very high above, but you can quit before that point if you're scared).
- Georgelemental 3y agoOne thing that's confusing is that in French, "voie ferrée" and "chemin de fer" ("iron way"/"path of iron") mean "railroad".
- jlongman 3y agoIt’s still called a via ferrata in France so this isn’t confusing at all. Source: did some near Annecy as well as Grenoble 20 years ago. And Quebec fwiw but I only know of the one at Tremblant (which is paid).
- morkalork 3y agoThere's a few in Quebec: https://viaferrataquebec.com https://viaferrataquebec.com https://www.sepaq.com/quoi-faire/via-ferrata.dot?language_id=1 https://www.sepaq.com/quoi-faire/via-ferrata.dot?language_id...
- namdnay 3y agoLantosque very nice, and less than an hour's drive from Nice airport
- seattle_spring 3y agoLots in northern Italy and Austria too!
- 082349872349872 3y agothat's where they started...
- exabrial 3y agoAfter visiting Austria and Germany, I'm "hooked" on Via Ferattas. It's astounding the number and variety of them available... I'm going to make a vacation next year where that's all I do However, Colorado needs to do some soul searching. Currently Colorado has exactly TWO free-access Via Ferattas: Ouray and Telluride. Allowing commercial companies to build exclusive access theme parks on public lands is a gross misuse of public lands. Private land owners can charge if they want for all I care, but the most obnoxious thing about this model is even an experienced climber often must "hire a 'certified' guide" at absurd rates.
- someguydave 3y ago“Allowing commercial companies to build exclusive access theme parks on public lands is a gross misuse of public lands.” This describes nearly all ski areas in the US, good luck getting them to change how things are done on either the public or private side.
- czinck 3y agoBecause of that, all ski resorts on US public land aren't actually "exclusive". A lift ticket just buys you access to the lifts, you can hike up during the winter or summer, with restrictions during the winter mainly around everyone's safety (designated uphill routes, don't go where they're doing avalanche control).
- exabrial 3y agoThis is 100% correct. You can actually walk to the top of a mountain and ski down. Or in the summer time, you can bike up and mountain bike down...
- someguydave 3y agoSure, so if there is a via feratta on public land I imagine there will be similar access, although controlling access to a via feratta would be much easier than a ski run.
- jupp0r 3y agoMountaineer with a bunch of via Ferrata experience here, mainly in Europe. What's often forgot in discussions about these is that in spite of you being anchored to steel ropes, the consequences of a fall on these are pretty severe when compared to falling into a normal dynamic climbing rope (which is pretty normal and done all the time without problems in sports climbing). The physics of shock absorption by via ferrata equipment is not your friend here, a fall with a vertical slide to the next anchor 6ft below you is a ticket to the hospital, likely with permanent damage. Via ferratas can be fun, but you really don't want to fall, and if in doubt, do your research and get really good equipment.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoIs this still true if you use the appropriate shock links? Those are set up to limit the force up to a certain height, wouldn't they design those to limit the force to one less likely to cause permanent damage?
- lazide 3y agoIt all depends on how you fall, what you hit and when, and what position your body is in at various stages of this. If you spend any time on a via ferrata, it’s pretty easy to see where the answers to one or more of these will be ‘not great’, and sometimes ‘really bad’. For instance, hitting a rung on the way down. Or getting an appendage caught behind something. But unlikely you’ll die. And honestly, you shouldn’t fall unless you screwed something up pretty bad to begin with, which is your primary protection anyway. You’re literally climbing a ladder, this isn’t wilderness trad climbing or developing some new route on loose rock.
- krallistic 3y agoDeath at Via Ferratas are extremely rare (with proper gear ofc). But the falls are notoriously hard. Force can get really high and the chance of injury is high, even in cases where the fall zone is free of any metal etc..
- sandworm101 3y ago
- sandworm101 3y ago>> A via ferrata is essentially rock climbing. It provides all of the same sensations,” says Michele Van Hise, managing partner at Zion Adventures, a guiding service and outfitter based in Springdale, Utah. Between 2018 and 2022, the company built three via ferratas near Zion National Park, including Shorty Town, which snakes up and down across a cliff suspended over the flowing water of Oak Creek. I cannot express how strongly I am against this. The first rule of most every outdoor activity is "take only pictures, leave only footprints". That applies for everything from scuba diving to mountaineering. Hammering in rods and installing ladders on otherwise perfectly climbable rocks is just wrong. There is a time and place for fixed protection, and regular climbers have huge debates about this, but installing ladders so people can more easily "climb" in hiking boots doesn't meet anyone's standard. I've known many climbers who, if seeing any of this, would actively destroy such installations if anywhere close to existing routes. And in Zion? I guess it isn't halfdome or dawn wall but this is still a climbing mecca that that should be left unaltered. I was once at a very popular toproping area when an army unit of about eight people showed up. They were about to hammer pitons into the cracks to "practice". The word when quickly around the crag and they were basically run out of town by a hundred climbers. You don't damage rock casually, not established climbing routes.
- blakeburnette 3y agoPitons are something I think are already controversial enough. Necessary in some rock types to enable climbing...but that's a debate for another day. I would say I lean to, only if necessary. Via Ferratas make me cringe and am wholeheartedly opposed.
- digital-cygnet 3y agoI've come to believe that there's a place for the more accessible enjoyment of the outdoors that the via ferrata seems to represent. Every park represents a different place on the spectrum of accessibility vs true wilderness -- from Manhattan's Central Park (millions of visitors of all types, requiring hard paths, railings etc) to Denali National Park (other than the road, limited to very small dispersed groups, kept few enough that it can remain a "trackless wilderness"). I don't begrudge someone who is not a very skilled climber their use of a via ferrata, provided that impact to the area (e.g. sightlines) is kept to a minimum and other options for more purists remain. I'm not a climber per se but this is the same attitude I have towards hiking, skiing, mountain biking, etc. I'm careful not to gate-keep casual folks using the Mt Washington cog railway because they get a lot of enjoyment out of it and it's a small blip in my Prezzie Traverse -- if carefully managed, there's enough nature for everyone.
- mrg2k8 3y agoI started practicing last summer and went on a few via ferratas in Switzerland and Italy. The hardest one was in the Dolomites and required climbing knowledge and upper body strength because there were no easy anchors. The scariest one was in Switzerland, called Mürren where there's a 30m horizontal section with a 400m vertical drop with nothing to hold on to other than the steel cable and some metal inserts in the wall, see https://www.sac-cas.ch/processed/sa2020assetsprod/9/0/csm_1520674018_261154973master_a3e1a8d0f5.jpg https://www.sac-cas.ch/processed/sa2020assetsprod/9/0/csm_15... .
- snowwrestler 3y agoLooks scary but horizontal sections of via ferratas are usually the safest part, because you’ll come tight to your leashes right away if you slip. It’s the vertical sections, where you could free fall and pick up speed before your leash catches on the next anchor point, which can cause the worst injuries.
- twobitshifter 3y agoIf you think nature must be left unspoiled then do not go. If you think only those like you with your specialized equipment and your physical fitness should be able to go, you do still ‘spoil nature.’ There’s no need to point fingers at others for going an inch beyond your intrusion by leaving equipment in place. Popular routes are visited so often than the average condition for the area is climbers with equipment. Any peaceful absence of human presence is entirely imagined.
- unit_circle 3y agoWestern American wilderness is different than Europe--it has very few human improvements. Personally I'd love to see it retain that character and I think this is the wrong direction. Imo if you want a European experience you should go to Europe.
- j7ake 3y agoYeah the European via ferratas you can see villages and cities once you get to the top. Not so much for the American ones.
- roca 3y agoSurely it's "vias ferrata".
- exabrial 3y agoWhat is blowing my mind in this thread is the amount of comments giving advice NOT to use a via ferrata set. One commenter even said to use two prussic hitches… let me keep this short: you will die. Use a via ferrata set. Any ‘climbing bro’ that gives you any other advice is a dangerous person and you probably shouldn’t have them belaying you, as they value their ego more than your life. USE THE CORRECT EQUIPMENT: Only via certified via ferrata set with a rip shock absorber. https://youtu.be/A5w9Kkd-f2w https://youtu.be/A5w9Kkd-f2w