3 ms·
Auto industry jobs will only be lost due to lowering demand, which won't change with or without the bailout. For one, American car companies won't disappear. Re
by mattmaroon 18y ago
Auto industry jobs will only be lost due to lowering demand, which won't change with or without the bailout. For one, American car companies won't disappear. Read up on Chapter 11. They'll be restructured. Some layoffs may occur, but they need to anyway, otherwise this bailout would only forestall the inevitable. The only way American car companies can compete long term is to get down to similar cost basis to foreign ones, which means their cars have to take a similar amount of man hours to build.
And if they did fold, people won't just stop buying cars. They'll just buy different cars that were made mostly here in America, which employee the same number of people to build that a viable American car company would.
It's easy to say bailout = jobs, but that's sadly just not true. In the long run it won't save any, and it will cost a fortune. If it's done right, it will ensure viability, which means loss of jobs. If it's not done at all, it will mean restructuring and/or a shift to Japanese cars which means the same loss of jobs.
- programnature 18y agoYou can't just juggle the variables like that because there are discontinuities and nonlinear effects. Industries interact with each other. What is happening to auto is mostly caused by 1) the financial crisis making credit scarce and 2) a huge drop in demand (30-40%) that no industry could sustain For a "elderly and weak" patient such as auto, this is too much. Fine. But what happens if auto goes down, which the OP is celibrating? What other weak or newly weakened sectors does it take down with it? Btw, chapter 11 is the best case, it could go chapter 7. We don't know.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWell, it wasn't caused by those factors, only accelerated. They've been struggling for a very long time. Toyota is sustaining the drop just fine. If GM had Toyota's good will, brand image, and cost basis, they would be too. They need that to compete in the long run. And they've done a good job of working on lowering their cost basis over the last 5 years, along with the Unions, but they've still got a long way to go and are progressing slowly. Without serious oversight in the bailout it's just throwing money down a well. Or so goes the theory. You can choose to believe it's wrong (and you may be correct, it's a complex issue) but it's disingenuous and mean-spirited to say that the people against it are happy about job losses. They're happy that a bill that they believe is throwing money down a well and only delaying job losses didn't pass.
- programnature 18y agohaha. Well, I think its mean-spirited to celebrate the demise of an industry that employs 3 million people, with no mention of the human toll involved in these transitions. And I think its disingenuous to claim that I said others are "happy" about job losses, when I said no such thing. My two points were 1) this is bad for the economy short term, potentially leading to further trickle down effects, and 2) the response of "meh, its just optimization" to the human suffering is not indicative of a society I am proud to live in.
- jamiequint 18y agoYou can't artificially prevent "human suffering" through economic ignorance. I appreciate the point, but don't see the bailout and human suffering as the only two choices. One other possible option is for the government to spend a fraction of this money to help people suffering by the collapse of the US auto industry as a buffer until (likely foreign) competition moves in and takes its place. If you see this as simply the acceleration of the inevitable (as I do) the argument you are making for a bailout is akin to saying we should support any industry that is no longer economically viable just to keep the people from having to suffer job loss. This is not a sustainable long term strategy. At some point people must move on. If this means acquisition of new skills in order to most efficiently re-integrate into the economy than society should help people who unfortunately lost their jobs in attaining these skills, but it is the wrong decision to prop up failing companies in order to help their employees, because at some point this ceases to work. There are more efficient uses for capital that help more people in the long term.
- jimbokun 18y ago"One other possible option is for the government to spend a fraction of this money to help people suffering by the collapse of the US auto industry as a buffer until (likely foreign) competition moves in and takes its place." I think this is the relevant question. Is government money more efficiently spent propping up the auto companies a little bit longer, or giving it directly to all of the people laid off after the auto companies go under? As others have described in this discussion there is a real possibility of damage quickly spreading to other parts of the economy in a downward spiral if the automakers go down. So there might be a lot of people in need of that "fraction" of the money needed to keep the auto companies going a little bit longer. The decision rests on how we weigh the specific costs and risks involved for each option.
- lacker 18y agoWhat is happening to auto is mostly caused by 1) the financial crisis making credit scarce and 2) a huge drop in demand (30-40%) that no industry could sustain If this were true, all auto makers would be going bankrupt. But, it's only GM and Chrysler. The well-run auto makers need to expand, the badly-run ones need to contract, and we need new entrants into the market. I don't want the industry to be destroyed, but change is inevitable.
- mattobrien 18y agoIt's not necessarily the same loss of jobs. The issue here isn't just the Big 3, but all of the secondary industries and suppliers that depend on the Big 3 as clients. If the Big 3 go bankrupt now, there is a not insignificant chance that this could cascade through the supply chains, and actually hurt the Japanese companies with American plants as well. The issue here isn't whether the Big 3 should fail - they have and they should - but whether they should fail right now. Even accepting the hard argument that this bailout would merely forestall restructuring and eventual job loss, if that restructuring can be pushed to a time when the economy isn't in such dire straits, then the bailout could easily be worth it. The timing is clearly the most important factor. Consider Lehman. Lehman (and all of Wall St for that matter) was in a very similar position to the one the hedge fund LTCM was in 1998 - i.e., highly levered and insolvent, thus constituting a systemic risk. In 1998 because the rest of Wall St was healthy, the Fed was able to organize a private bailout of LTCM that prevented a, in hindsight, minor credit crisis from escalating. In 2008, since all of Wall St is essentially insolvent, the Treasury was unable to broker a bailout/merger and unwilling to bail out Lehman with public funds, leading to a catastrophic bankruptcy. The cost of being wrong about Lehman far outweighed what bailing it out would have cost, just as the cost of being wrong about letting the Big 3 fail at this moment could far outweight the proposed $14 billion (admittedly just a first offering).
- mattmaroon 18y agoI never understand this argument about the suppliers either. Lets say Americans would have bought 1 million American cars per year. But all of the manufacturers vanish in a puff of smoke. Now what do they do? They buy 1 million Japanese cars (made right here in America) per year. Those cars are built with parts from the same suppliers, or other suppliers still largely based in America. Profits may shift from one supplier to another, but they don't decrease.
- mattobrien 18y agoCheck the front page of the NYT right now. Suppliers are near bankruptcy as well. Just like the Big 3, or anyone else for that matter, these suppliers can't get credit now. They need business (and payment for past business) from the Big 3 to remain solvent. Your mistake is assuming that demand, in this case for cars, remains constant even if the Big 3 go bankrupt. If the Big 3 disappear, it's an enormous downward force on demand. Japanese companies can't immediately start producing more cars to make up for the slack from a Big 3 failure, so the suppliers would likely disappear. So we're talking about potentially millions of lost jobs. And that's a lot of people no longer in the market for cars, or really any other goods or services. We're potentially facing a deflationary spiral, where the credit markets freezing up leads to companies failing/laying people off, which lowers demand, which causes businesses and investors to cut back on development and lay even more people off, and so forth. And as drop in aggregate demand creates deflation, individual's debt burdens increase. So we can expect continued foreclosures and increasing defaults on credit card debt and student loans, etc., leading to even more writedowns for banks, and even less credit available for business or consumers. It's a vicious feedback loop. We need the government to stop this downward spiral.