21 ms·
Children need risk, fear, and excitement in play
- psunavy03 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chomp 3y agoI don’t disagree that children need to engage in risky behavior, but the claim that it needs to be unsupervised and then viewing it through the lens of yesteryear is a combination of survivor bias and nostalgia. Children pre-1990s were also a lot more likely to have less present parents across the board, and there’s a lot of strings attached to the unsupervised play those children got. I agree unsupervised play is important, I let our kids play by themselves all the time, it’s very important for learning conflict resolution. But make room in your argument also for having a strong and engaged presence in their lives.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> viewing it through the lens of yesteryear Given that those critical adult-free hours were the norm ~throughout human history, I think the year part of yesteryear sells it short. How about Yesterever?
- 15457345234 3y ago> survivor bias Using that phrase is... 80s childhoods weren't some sort of trial by fire threshing machine, dude. By and large everybody survived. Children being lost to quicksand or stumbling across gangs of counterfeiters holed up in abandoned mills who black-bagged them is a thing that happened in Scooby Doo and The Hardy Boys, not real life. This elides the main issue; children need to be left to play unsupervised as the machiavellian instigator types only reveal themselves when nobody's watching. It isn't so much about letting the children take risks as it is about figuring out who's always present when something odd and painful happens to somebody else.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoStrings? You over there pretending the latchkey generation didn't happen or something? Waking up to an empty house with $5 and a note on the kitchen table was hardly remarkable bitd. The entire point of the exercise is for there to be -no- presence, forcing kids to work through stuff on their own.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bcrosby95 3y agoLatchkey is a historical anomaly due to atomic families transitioning into dual income households leaving no adults at home and not knowing what to do with their kids. When my mother grew up there was always an adult at home - her mom. Same with her parents. Same with my mother-in-law. You also don't have to go too far back, just 150 years, to when children were largely used for labor. Childhood itself is a relatively new invention. The idea that kids sat around doing nothing but getting in trouble with other kids all day is just wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoDepends on what you mean. If you are within earshot of your children, you are not "letting them play by themselves." You are supervising their play from a distance. They are not the same. Know why bullies have it so easy nowadays? Because once upon a time, a bully was usually a kid who came from an abusive household and they were just demonstrating what they learned at home. Eventually, they'd end up getting their asses kicked by a kid who had the means and background to defend himself, and they'd learn something from it. Today, the world is full of little Eric Cartman wannabes: little asshole kids whose parents hover around them and will defend them to the ends of the Earth. It's screwed up child socialization and it's ruined childhood education because teachers with three degrees would rather do anything than take abuse from those bad kids and their pathetic, enabling parents.
- rightbyte 3y agoEric Cartman's mother does not defend just him though. She defends all sides and is forgiving. Kyle's mother do though. But Kyle is not an asshole.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rightbyte 3y agoYe I agree. I think "safe playgrounds" is just a scapegoat and a straw man. You don't learn much from accidents. Anything that is climbable is dangerous enought. You don't need to add rocks on the ground, to use another strawman.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoAs linked in this piece, Related from a month ago: Balancing Outdoor Risky Play and Injury Prevention in Childhood Development https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39139540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39139540
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoAs much as I contributed to my kids growing up under a ceaseless adult presence, I was a bad father. In doing this I deprived them of irreplaceable opportunities to learn self-actuation, learn social problem-solving and earn confidence. As far as I acted on a baseless fear that they were at meaningful risk of stranger kidnapping, I was a stupid father. That's mostly a different kind of bad father but whatever.
- oschvr 3y agoFirst time father here and curious about your comment. Can you elaborate on what was are your grounds for labeling yourself as a bad father?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Can you elaborate on what was are your grounds for labeling yourself as a bad father? I mostly label myself a father. There would always have been bad parts but these stand out. They're bad fathering. As far as grounds for my complaint, my children needed a steady diet of adult free hours. I mostly failed to recognize it, prioritize it and act accordingly.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoLearn social problem solving with who? There are -no- unsupervised children anymore, anywhere. No sense in kicking yourself, there are no opportunities for the kind of play older generations engaged in available to kids these days.
- bowsamic 3y agoThat’s just plainly false. In my city (Hamburg) I see 8 year olds taking the public transport alone and playing in the streets (no ones with cars) without supervision. I think you extrapolated too far
- twojobsoneboss 3y ago
- stephc_int13 3y agoIt turns out this is a tradeoff, the cost of this extra safety is mental health issues later in life.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> the cost of this extra safety is mental health issues later in life. This is so true it could be physics.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoI'm happy with admitting that it's something that would take an RCT to prove to me and that it's also unethical to perform one. it's essentially unknowable. Some people are uncomfortable with that. We dismiss nutrition studies with more evidence. The standard of evidence doesn't chabge just because we want it to be true.
- achenet 3y agodisagree. Many other factors. For example, I believe the current rise in mental health issues is due to smartphone use. But I admit that's only a theory.
- simonbarker87 3y agoCould increased smart phone use be because the outside world has been sanitised so much for these kids that they have literally nothing else to do?
- demondemidi 3y agoOr you’re just repeating the latest Oprah-like trope that’s plastered all over the tabloids.
- Animats 3y agoAnd a pony. I've been around horse barns for many years. Rode today. It's not a kids thing any more. Most of the riders are not only adults, but older adults. Few kids take riding lessons. The old ponies are under-used. Fifteen years ago, the ponies were usually being ridden or groomed by girls in their early teens. We used to see groups of kids go out on the trails unsupervised. That was normal. The kids would go out for an hour or so. Nobody does that any more. Now, if there's a kid around, it's usually because the parent is a horse person. Barns that teach kids are very organized. Kids are never out of sight of an adult. Usually the parents sit there and watch. It's sad. Kids that grow up around horses tend not to have trouble with bullies. After you're used to dealing with half-ton, somewhat pushy animals with huge teeth and steel-shod hooves, big guys just don't look that big.
- cultofmetatron 3y ago> Kids that grow up around horses tend not to have trouble with bullies. adding this to my list of thing to look into if I ever have a daiughter.
- CraigJPerry 3y agoI wouldn’t bother. It’s rose tinted specs at work. Girls on the horse yard bully each other just like they do in every other arena. Source: I had a horse when I was a teenager.
- whatshisface 3y agoThe OP was painting an incomplete picture, the complete horse based solution to bullying involves plate mail and polearms.
- aaron695 3y ago> What kids are dying from today are mainly car crashes and suicides, not playing outside unsupervised with friends > Injury-related deaths are at an all-time low in most Western nations. To a normal person this is proof helicopter parenting is working. Two practical choices 1. Have more kids again so they are more disposable. This is a big part of the change. This will happen with UBI. If UBI is a while away, weak kids are here to stay. 2. They don't normally talk about pretense of risk and independence. They mention heights. This can be done safely. I'm really scared to climb the trees I used to as a kid, part is fear of heights growing with age the other is common sense. But why not have 'safe' climbing frame that go to 50+ meters? This is really hard for most things... How do you blow up gas cylinders with a thrill and be safe? Mixing explosive material that's a thrill, again hard to do safely. The fun is not being supervised and in a lab. Blowing off fingers.... not the end of the world. Maybe when eyesight and hearing is restorable it'd be fine again. Killing animals is another one no one openly talks about but is important, it's why biology is failing they are all imposers who want to cuddle a lion, not cut a frog open to see how it works.
- ativzzz 3y ago>This will happen with UBI Dunno why you think more prosperity leads to more children when it's almost always the other way around. Poorer, less educated people have more kids. Once a society develops economically, they have less kids. This is a worldwide phenomenon. UBI will free you from having to work shitty jobs. You think people will spend their newfound time raising kids instead? Doubt
- matrix87 3y ago> Dunno why you think more prosperity leads to more children when it's almost always the other way around Because capitalism incorporates more and more of their lives in the production of economic value. That isn't the same thing as prosperity. If economic value isn't distributed to the working classes, there's more work without prosperity. Look at South Korea, where people work hard in order to cover basic essentials like housing. Maybe according to the WEF or Economist that's "prosperity" and a "higher standard of living", but it's an obvious scam to anyone who isn't thoroughly brainwashed by capitalism
- ip26 3y agoIt’s not ok to let your five year old play with a soccer ball on a busy neighborhood street unsupervised. It’s good to let your thirteen year old play in the neighborhood with their friends. But what about everything in between? At what age should you let your kid play in the pool without you even watching? When can they be trusted to use a band saw unsupervised? How young is too young to have unrestricted access to razor sharp eight inch kitchen knives? This is mostly rhetorical; the point is the constant (necessary) risk calculus is draining, and parents are rational to err on the side of caution. It has been observed that most public spaces in America are default adult spaces where children are only tolerated. It follows most public spaces will tend to have adult levels of hazard and risk.
- ChiMan 3y agoSounds like sports are good for kids, and contact sports are good for boys. Who knew?
- scraplab 3y agoDid you read the article? It specially argues for unstructured play and freedom, and against structured play, such as organised sports.
- AlbertCory 3y ago"sports" does not imply "organization, with adults." I never played any organized football, but I played a ton of informal touch football, and very occasionally tackle. Same with most baseball: a bunch of us kids got together and played. In most of the world, it's football ("soccer" as Americans call it).
- Loughla 3y agoYes, it does. In the US, in today's middle class society, sports means structured, competitive play organized by adults. Pick up games are dead for vast, vast portions of the country.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI'm sorry, you're totally wrong. I walk past some basketball courts every day, and there are always games going on. At the middle school, the kids play volleyball, and also spike ball: https://www.wikihow.com/Play-Spikeball https://www.wikihow.com/Play-Spikeball I also occasionally see pickup touch football games, and of course soccer. Baseball: maybe you're right, only adults play that anymore. And let's not forget pickleball. Contrary to the stereotype of its being an elderly sport, go look at a court sometime: people of all ages play it.
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoWell, I'm glad I didn't read it, because a child should have both unstructured play, fully free of adult supervision AND structured play to learn the ins and outs of working in structured rule-based groups while pursuing something they enjoy.
- dclowd9901 3y ago> Think back to your favorite childhood play memory. Where were you? What were you doing? Was there an adult supervising you? I have two memories 1) I was playing in my grandfather’s pipe yard with my cousins. Lots of heavy equipment and stuff that was precariously stacked. Very easily could have ended up in a situation were something fell on me and killed me. Instead, I just ran headlong into a rusty pipe and nearly broke my nose. 2) I was in my early teens riding a 3 wheeled ATV. I was going too fast and went into a wash and flipped the machine over me. I didn’t kill myself. Didn’t even get seriously hurt, but easily could have. I was incredibly lucky to come out of both of those experiences relatively unscathed. It’s not really a tough calculus thinking “well, my daughter doesn’t have an eye anymore, but at least she was having fun!” I instead encourage my kids to have fun in activities that _feel_ risky but where the chance of life altering injury is low. Like walking on a high brick fence or jumping from a high point into a big deep body of water. Anyway, as a parent I’m so fucking tired of people trying to tell me how to raise a kid.
- calvinmorrison 3y agoClimbing at the top of very tall trees. At age 5 or 6. Looks like the tree is still there on Google maps 60 S Church St https://maps.app.goo.gl/niB4443VK65M8LPB6 https://maps.app.goo.gl/niB4443VK65M8LPB6
- GeoAtreides 3y agoTo my European eye that is a very pretty town; it feels so uniquely american. Is it safe? is it nice living there?
- calvinmorrison 3y agoDoylestown, PA is a quintessential Bucks County town
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- watwut 3y agoMy big problem with these articles is that they invariably list activities that are NOT risky or dangerous. And what they end up doing is just ramping up sense of danger about non dangerous behavior. If you frame reasonable and safe activities as risk taking, then well, people will conclude those activities are risky. And second issue is that they do NOT engage with other host of issues that limit outside play. For example, unsupervised playing kids are annoying to many unrelated adults - and adults who strongly dislike kids and want to exclude them from everywhere are very common. Or, simple fact that just meeting friends often requires in advance agreed upon play date and a drive by car. Or, simple fact that before you was bored in your room and outside had things to do, nowdays you have fun stuff at home (computer, tablet, phone) and outside has not much to do above the age of 7. Half of this feels like fighting fear by adding new dangers and threats to the equation. Hey, not only you need to add risk, if you dont your kid will have serious mental health issues. Hey, lets worry simultaneously about risk taking while doing safe activities while also worrying they dont take enough risk.
- LispSporks22 3y agoAt my old school we had glorious two story high steel monkey bars apparatus. At some point they put rubber shavings under it as a safety thing. Several years later, they cut it down to one story. Later they removed the whole thing. I know exactly what they mean by fear, excitement and risk. It was fun while it was dangerous yet it was extremely rare for a kid to fall off and be hurt. I fondly remember those steel bars polished by countless human hands like it was yesterday. I don’t know what’s there now. Probably a big sign that says “Your parents made you a pussy”
- reddalo 3y agoI completely agree. When I was a child, there was a super fun steel monkey bars in a park near my home. I used to play a lot on it. Fear was surely one of the fun factors. Then they removed it, because the local council was afraid some kid might get hurt. It's sad.
- bombcar 3y agoThey still make and install quite a bit of things that used to be considered "unsafe" (mainly because they make it plastic and brightly colored) See https://www.americanparkscompany.com/playground-equipment/commercial.html https://www.americanparkscompany.com/playground-equipment/co... or https://www.gametime.com/playground-equipment/gt-wave https://www.gametime.com/playground-equipment/gt-wave for examples.
- vasco 3y agoIt's funny because my grandpa called us pussies for playing in man made safe playgrounds instead of in the woods. Every generation will think the next one is coddled.
- jansan 3y agoAfter my 15yo son when hiking with friends to sleep in caves without a tent I do not call him a pussy anymore. It actually made me feel that I forgot to live properly when I way young.
- circlefavshape 3y agoI still need excitement, and I'm 52
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bjackman 3y agoIt's not exactly what the article is talking about but: I have a 2 year old niece. Her family have an attitude of "let her learn for herself" that I've found pretty interesting. They keep a very close eye on her and try to warn her verbally and with demonstrations but don't really stop her from doing anything. So instead of physically separating her from a hot kettle they just go "it's very hot!" and demonstrate by touching it carefully and then pulling their hand away. They let her play with matches. She could pick up on these cues long before she could understand words. But it does look exhausting. And there have been some moments (once she was trotting around holding scissors pointing up in the air) where I've thought "no that's too risky and no amount of careful supervision can prevent injury here". She has also burned herself, but only once. So overall I am pretty impressed, at least in principle, and if I have kids I'll definitely endeavour to try and curb my overprotective instincts.
- cpursley 3y agoThis is exactly what we do with our toddler (tell her it’s hot, sharp, etc - mimic a painful reaction). It’s worked really well. She’s only two and will even tell us to “be careful papa, it’s hot” etc). Kids are smart, if you treat them like little adults instead of little helpless goo goo ga ga babies - they will generally pick up on things. Which actually makes it easier on the parents.
- lm2s 3y agoAnother way to teach them about hot things is to have something that is uncomfortably hot but won't burn if you touch it for a few seconds*, warn them that it's hot and remove the fingers quickly but let them touch it anyway. They won't burn themselves but will understand what is hot and will understand when you tell them that it's hot. The side effect of this, is that then they might be scared of things that are only slightly hot. But that's something easier and less risky to deal with IMO and they'll eventually understand that there's different levels. *babies/toddlers have a skin that is a lot more sensitive, so this should be taken into consideration.
- wumms 3y agoReminded me of: The dangerous playgrounds of 1900s through vintage photographs https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31855163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31855163
- lp4vn 3y agoI arrived to the conclusion that this "risk-aversion" in child rearing is basically the result of smaller families. This may sound callous but I think parents are much more OK with their oldest son/dqughter taking bigger risks if there are other 4 ones at home than if that's your only child and losing him/her is the end of your lineage. Not saying that more kids work as a genetic backup, but I think that for sure that creates a subconscious effect in the parents' risk assessment. I read somewhere that propensity to war is proportional to the average age of a society. I think the same phenomenon applies to acceptance of risk in child behaviour but now related to fertility rate.
- aylmao 3y agoAdding two notes onto this hypothesis: - I can only assume that if a kid doesn't have an older sibling "to keep an eye on them" the parents take this role, and parents tend to be more risk-adverse and responsible caretakers than siblings. - I've never lived in the American suburbs, but they don't seem very dense. I know that, growing up in Mexico, the kid density was great. Some of it probably has to do with the fact everyone had siblings. Matching ages with nearby neighbors is more likely when there's more kids too. We were outside all the time, older siblings introduced younger ones to the crowd. Friendships were made, broken and fixed. Adventures were had. More than once we got into situations that I knew my mom wouldn't be happy about too.
- lapcat 3y ago> I can only assume that if a kid doesn't have an older sibling "to keep an eye on them" the parents take this role, and parents tend to be more risk-adverse and responsible caretakers than siblings. This hypothesis doesn't make sense, because all children were treated differently many decades ago, and by pure math the most common type of child is the first born. Every family no matter the size has a firstborn child, who by definition has no older sibling to keep an eye on them. The fact is that parents were just less hovering helicopters in the past. I can attest to this as firstborn myself.
- imp0cat 3y ago
- drchiu 3y agoLet’s not forget the role of lawyers and the general increasing litigious nature of society. Things are made “safe” because there is now always a risk of getting sued when stuff happens.
- euroderf 3y agoThis is the four hundred pound gorilla in the room.
- Loughla 3y agoThis is the root cause. 150%. At least for the US.
- mlrtime 3y agoFor some areas in the US yeah. To say this happens in every city in the US is 100% wrong. It would never happen in my neighborhood.
- jerf 3y agoThis is the core problem. It doesn't matter if you convince Mom & Dad & the kids to play risky if the primary "risk" is getting picked up by the police and having your family fed into the bureaucratic grinder of Child Protective Services. Society isn't just encouraging the removal of risky play, it is enforcing it. Until the police are trained to get a call to a child riding their bike down the road by themselves and berate the person who called them and not issue even a token warning to the kid or parents, there will be no change.
- Apocryphon 3y agoNot to deny that this is an increasingly litigious society, but if the bureaucracy is so sprawling, surely it gets to a level where it's too stuffed with requests to be able to respond to every triviality, no?
- dagw 3y ago
- hyperman1 3y agoI'm much more worried about the road to the playground than the risks on the playground themselves. Below 18, about 3/8 of the deaths are from traffic. I grew up in 80's the time where almost everybody played in parks and fields. But I can't give that to my own son of 7. He has to cross 3 streets to reach a playground 200m from here,the worst of the crossings a street with 50km/h limitsand 1 car every 10 seconds. Not much, except just enough people drive like idiots, 90km/h or more on a road not even 500m long. We've been teaching him good pedestrian behaviour since he could walk. We've done a few tests where he walked to the baker, thinking he was unsupervised. He probably can do it most of the time. Except, 1 distraction while an idiot drives by will kill him. So I bring him to the playground and let him play as unsupervised as possible for an adult on the side of a playground. Of course, he knows I am there. I start working with him with more dangerous tools like a soldering iron. He can deal well enough with these risks. But not the streets.
- MomoXenosaga 3y agoI won't ride a bicycle in the UK because the British despise anything that isn't a car. People will literally cheer if a cyclist is mowed down.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoThat sounds horrific. When I biked a lot recently the worst I got was a water bottle thrown at me and shouts intended to startle me to fall down
- bowsamic 3y agoYou're being downvoted but I've observed this behaviour. I had a colleague who had multiple dash cams because truck drivers kept trying to drive him over when passing. They thought it was hilarious, they don't seem to care about whether or not the person will be killed. I was shocked coming to Germany and seeing cyclists not constantly being attacked by the general public. In the UK it's seen as totally illegitimate.
- spacebacon 3y agoMeanwhile the Yanomami tribes children are climbing 100 foot trees on their own.
- cyco130 3y agoWhen I was a kid (~10 yo), mothers of younger (~4 yo) kids would send them to the grocery store a few blocks away and ask us to follow them in secret to make sure they didn't get lost or run under a car or anything. This way they could build confidence in relative safety. I believe it's now illegal in some jurisdictions.
- xandrius 3y agoI'm sad this is the current state of affairs but I'm glad they (and you) had the chance to grow up like that.
- lqet 3y agoAs a parent, I have found that raising a child without risk, fear and the occasional smaller painful accident is not possible. My daughter is 4, and we can not convince her that something she does is dangerous until she has empirically proven it. Exceptions are obvious things where it is clear that you will die or you "will become a skeleton" (crossing the road without looking, playing around train tracks, playing with electricity). Examples: "Don't sit on the backrest of that chair, it will topple over". "No, that's not true at all, you're wrong!!!" 5 minutes later: Crash. Quiet. Cry. Never done again. "You cannot build bridges out of sofa cushions between the sofa and the coffee table, it won't support you". "No! I am small! It will hold!" 5 minutes later: Crash. Quiet. Cry. Never done again. On bicycle: "Drive slower, you have to break!". "No, I like it fast! I cannot fall, my tires are big!" Seconds later: Crash against fence. Quiet. Cry. Now she drives carefully. In winter: "Be careful on that ice!". "But my new shoes have rubber, dad, they won't slip, don't you know that?!?" Seconds later: Slip. Bamm. Quiet. Cry. Now she knows rubber soles slip on ice. As long as there is no risk of a serious, life-threatening accident, I have become pretty relaxed. I remember that I constantly had scraped knees and bruises as a child. When I was 7, my grandparents regularly send me to a gas station nearby to buy the paper, and my mother would send me to the supermarket with my 4 year old brother to get groceries. I walked to kindergarten by myself when I was 5.
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y agoI grew up in the 70s and we spent most of our time outside because we weren’t allowed inside or our parents were at work. Everything was unsupervised and bit like Lord of the Flies, but we survived. I have a lot of memories of riding my bike, alone, pretty much anywhere I wanted in the city. Seems great, and I think most of us enjoyed it, but the kids who really got ahead in life stayed inside studying. Fast forward several decades, I raised some kids of my own and by and large we let them have a lot of a fun. That said, the stakes are so much higher these days that it is impractical to give kids total freedom. The long-term costs and lost opportunity is just way too high.
- Loughla 3y ago>and lost opportunity is just way too high. I think this is the reason for the childhood/teen mental health epidemic. If you're not optimizing your child's life, they won't be competitive for jobs or college or whatever in the future. It's exhausting.
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y agoPretty much. We sought out a balance and by and large our kids are happier than their peers. However, they also paid the price when it came to school choice, scholarships, and the downstream opportunities that flow from the relentless pursuit of top honors. It is insane.
- Apocryphon 3y agoAny details on how that went? It’s certainly that secondary education is very competitive these days.
- dhfbshfbu4u3 3y agoSure. The typical path I see is that kids fail to lock in with a high level state school and either need to go private (assuming they get in) or out of state (which will welcome you because you’re paying 50% more). This happened with one of my kids and it has cost me upwards of $60-70K at a minimum to go out of state. Another path I see are kids who just opt out entirely. They go to that 5th or 6th tier school and are totally unmotivated. This doesn’t hit them early but it will have a long term impact on job prospects and their career arc. This one is actually becoming more common from what I hear. To me, the real disconnect is happening in high school here in the US where we are still educating kids like it is 1950 (or 1850). Teachers are overworked and underpaid, and the administration is apathetic. All of that can easily combine for a couple of poor grades or missed expectations in extracurricular activities which in turn cut your opportunities when you apply for college. Sounds extreme but that is how it is today and it is why so many parents are overprotective to the point of being manic.
- gampleman 3y agoI am very sympathetic to this (to the extent that my wife thinks I am borderline irresponsible). That said, I think the argument about how fears are misplaced since now is the most safe time to be a kid is bad. > And it is widely believed that the world is no longer a safe place for children to play in. Yet statistics show that it has never been a safer time to be a child. Injury-related deaths are at an all-time low in most Western nations. In the US, deaths from unintentional injuries fell by 73% for boys and 85% for girls between 1973 and 2010. This misperception of risk creates the parental paradox. This doesn't make much sense. Parents have mass migrated to a different style of parenting. In the same period life has gotten much safer for children. Therefore we should revert to the older style of parenting and not be afraid that the risks will return? I think this cause is really hurting itself with this kind of weak argument.
- mlrtime 3y agoThis jumped at me as well. The author did not do a great job of combating this argument.
- strix_varius 3y agoAgreed. As a new parent myself, I also don't think any proposal to have children running free in the neighborhood / playing together unsupervised can be taken seriously with addressing that: > This is the most dangerous time to be a pedestrian in over 40 years. https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/04/us/dangerous-time-pedestrian-trucks-suv-dg/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/04/us/dangerous-time-pedestrian-... I would love for my daughter to get to roam the neighborhood like I roamed mine. But despite choosing one of the safest, lowest-traffic neighborhoods in our city - with 25 mph speed limits - I still regularly see drivers flying by at twice that, in a lifted truck, with a phone in front of their face.
- geraldhh 3y agogives a whole new meaning to the "smartphones and social media are a threat to children" trope
- lucasRW 3y agoQuite a risky position in a society where the dominant view is the one for "safe-spaces" and "not being offended"...
- ineedasername 3y agoI think the author’s points here are only their strongest when mentioning the lack of unstructured play and overall reduction in play time & leisure as a whole. It’s weakest when it speaks about “risky” play, where the author seems to focus on the excitement & fear etc. that comes from physically risky play. I don’t think physical risk should be a requirement for a robustly healthy childhood play experience. From the article, bemoaning the lack of play in abandoned locations seems fairly absurd, though again some other points are well taken. I will note one interesting trend that may partially be a product of this desire &/or need for risky play, which is the recent popularity of much more elaborate & diverse videogames in the “sandbox survival crafting” genre. These for me actually do seem to evoke a similar feel to the childhood sense of exploration and creative play. I’m not necessarily proposing these as a solution to what we had decades ago but it may be that just as the “safety” movement didn’t happen overnight, perhaps cultural solutions to fill these same needs will take a bit more time as well.
- gilbetron 3y agoHaving grown up in the 70s and 80s, and who is just finishing up raising a kid in the 2010s/2020s (he's 15), I think I have some nuance on this view. While I worry about the lower amount of unstructured play my son had, he did have tons of structured/semi-structured play that I would have loved. Sure, I ran around the woods, but he was able to go on all sorts of adventures through various camps that I never got to do. I mean, I guess being bored out of my fucking mind most of the summer and doing stupid shit was helpful, but it wasn't some pinnacle of education. My son at age 11 took at digital media camp thing and walked around interviewing people at different locations and making little videos. That was pretty cool and seems kind of educational. Plus, I know at least 3 people that were kids when I was a kid, within several years, that are now disabled adults because of that unstructured play. Two broke their necks, one broke so many bones they were in a wheelchair for several years. I know probably half a dozen kids that were hit by cars in some form. Several kids dead by drunk driving. So that unstructured play isn't without cost. There are other tradeoffs, too. I know several kids that are raised more unstructured because of their specific situation, and they have a lot of social and physical confidence, but they are also kinda dumb. Like they lack intellectual curiosity. Anecdotal, I know, but I just don't think things are as clear as they make it out to be. My son's playgrounds were still fairly dangerous, so I think the pendulum has started swinging back. When he was 6-9 or so, his favorite two playground stuctures were a 15' tall climbing tower, and the old school metal merri-go-round thing. Oh, and one elementary school had two huge play structures made of wood with all kinds of tunnels and nooks and crannies, he had tons of fun with that with his friends. What I mostly missed with him is his ability to just go outside and play with a bunch of kids - there is a negative feedback loop where even if you want your kid to do that, there are no other kids out there in many places. Plus there are just not many interesting "third spaces" anymore that are fun for kids but also ok for them to be kids.
- playingonline 3y agoI wonder if the 3rd spaces are moving online. This thread notes the decline of horse girls and car guys - (it's gender roles too, but) maybe everything is just online now. Idk if toontown or minecraft or whatever perfectly replaces playing on a playground, but maybe? There is a sort of exploration, maybe not the same. There is a perception of in game risk without the risk of physical injury, but also without physical fitness benefits.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoI'll go out on a limb and say SAE Level 5 (full self-driving) is going to solve this problem. Imagine a world where a group of children has regained all the safety of traveling anywhere their parents will let them. It will reset our current understanding of parenting to where it was 30 years ago.
- tokai 3y ago30 years ago is full Satanic Panic and general hysteria over please-think-of-the-children. Not at all a time we want parenting to return to.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoThat was very much a news media thing. Many parents rightfully ignored it as such.
- hoseja 3y agoCivilizational schoolmarmism must be stopped.
- jp42 3y agoI lived in small village in India. When I was a kid (6+ yo) the only time I was at home is to eat & sleep. Parents were not watching us at all. Me and my friends used to go wherever we want to go miles away from village & somehow used to come back by lunch time or dinner time. I miss those days.
- m3kw9 3y agoi think before 10, you limit their risk such as walking out by themselves because they are either too short for cars to see in some blind spots or not have developed enough awareness of the world yet. Other than that let them fall a few times and stuff in controlled manner and they get better at risk assessment. Otherwise they default to being risk adverse because you’ve been always telling them everything is risky
- elevatedastalt 3y agoA lot of this also seems a result of litigious culture and liability releases and waivers in everything? Also it's hard not being risk-averse when you have only one child you can barely afford to raise since it costs 50-100K a year.
- 99_00 3y ago>Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play I don't see research or data to back this up in the article. It seems that the conclusion that "Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play" is based on the authors personal interpretation of her research around play and development, rather than actual data and experimentation on risk, fear, excitement in play. It would also be helpful to define 'need'. Overall, the ideas in the article seems bypass the reader's critical thinking by appealing to "back in my day", and "kids these days" attitudes and feelings.
- hackburg 3y ago[dead]
- jcarrano 3y agoIn primary school they banned marbles because they would cause conflict. They also banned other things (cards? I forget) for the same reason. How on earth will children learn to deal with and solve conflicts if conflict is banned??
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- gwbas1c 3y agoGrowing up, my neighborhood had wide streets and sidewalks. Around the time I turned 6 I could wander unsupervised with my friends. My neighborhood has narrow streets and no sidewalks, and I'm paranoid about letting my children walk around freely. I don't really see kids unsupervised until they are about 10-12 years old.
- Xeyz0r 3y agoWithout learning to fall, you won't learn to stand up
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- timtas 3y agoWe just spent three years telling kids to view the breath of other humans as poison. If this is reactionary, bring it on. I’m starting to see a lot more free ranging kids in my neighborhood. White pill.