6 ms·
Majority of workers at Mercedes plant in Alabama sign UAW authorization cards
- toomuchtodo 3y agoPrevious: https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/foreign/2024/01/10/tuscaloosa-alabama-mercedes-benz-uaw-authorization-union/72176259007/ https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/foreign/202... ("Alabama Mercedes-Benz plant hits 30% UAW authorization support")
- beanjuiceII 3y ago[flagged]
- changoplatanero 3y agoThe main thing I want from the UAW is a refund for all the money they took from me when I was a grad student. In the US, the UAW is the union for graduate student employees at several universities.
- EricDeb 3y agoI'm sure it was an immense amount compared to your current paycheck
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoHow is it a trap? Seems pretty obvious for a worker to why this makes sense.
- mc32 3y agoIt’s good in the medium term, but in the longer term production will be moved to Mexico. No reason not to and a union of a reason to move.
- EricDeb 3y agoHopefully politicians can punish the move to mexico. Voters should support that.
- mc32 3y agoVoters? That’s proven not to be true. Ask all the SC garment workers or the New England shoe factory workers… No, people want cheap even if that means their neighbors Steve and Diane lose their jobs, go on welfare and they end up paying more in taxes as a result offsetting their savings in cheaper textiles and shoes! So… yeah, no. They want less expensive cars from Mexique. And the pols want those nice Corp contributions… they do not represent their voting constituency.
- mdasen 3y agoUSMCA (the NAFTA replacement; a free trade agreement between the US, Canada, and Mexico) does have some restrictions on the automotive industry in Canada and Mexico, but Mexico has been an automotive powerhouse for years now. Mexico is already the 6th largest auto producing nation - basically the same size as Germany and South Korea. Mercedes already produces vehicles in Mexico (as does Audi, Baic Group, BMW, Stellantis, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Mazda, Nissan, Toyota and Volkswagen). About 70% of Mexico's vehicle production heads for the US and employs over 1M people. Mexico accounts for 23% of North American auto assembly. Mexico also imports about 50% of its auto parts from the US. Before NAFTA, Mexico had restrictions requiring vehicles to be made domestically from domestic parts. NAFTA opened Mexico to US vehicles. Over time, Mexico's automotive industry took off assembling many US and foreign vehicles and creating lots of parts. As of 2021, US/Canadian auto workers earned an average of around $20-21/hour. USMCA requires that 40-45% of auto workers earn a minimum of $16/hour, including all the parts manufacturing, etc. (NAFTA didn't have this wage requirement) When you create free trade agreements, it can cut both ways. It opens Mexico to lots of US goods and services and it also means that Mexico can export to the US. At the same time, we've only seen moderate movement toward Mexican manufacturing with US/Canadian manufacturing accounting for 77% of North American manufacturing. Companies haven't just up and moved their American manufacturing to Mexico. Companies are still opening new US plants. Rivian is opening a $5B plant in Georgia (and before you say "because of the tax credits if you make EVs in the US" those also apply to countries we have a free trade agreement with like Mexico). Hyundai/Kia is opening a new plant in Georgia. Ford broke ground on a new plant in Tennessee in 2022, one of 4 new US factories. VinFast (a Vietnamese auto company) is opening a $4B plant in North Carolina. GM is spending billions on new US facilities. So when someone says that automotive production will all be moving to Mexico because of this, it seems unlikely. Yes, Mexico will become an increasingly important part of the North American automotive industry, but we're seeing companies continue to invest in US factories - including unionized US factories. That's not to say that unions have zero impact on the planning decisions of automotive companies, but the view of the comment that you're responding to (that automotive production will simply be moved to Mexico) probably isn't going to come to pass in a clear-cut way. The US and Mexico have had a free trade agreement for 30 years now and we simply haven't seen companies run away from unions to Mexico. That's not to say that companies haven't used Mexican plants. They have. But we haven't even seen this type of thing come up in union negotiations. Mexico is producing around 30% more vehicles today than when free trade started. US production is flat, German production is down 20%, Canadian production is down 50%, Japanese production is down 25%, French down 60%, British down 40%. The US automotive industry isn't without issues, but it's doing pretty well compared to a lot of peer nations - even while Mexican imports are there. Again, I'm not saying that it has no impact, but there's no evidence that the sky is falling. It's a political boogeyman more than a reality. It's also important to note that US vehicle production basically hasn't moved much since 1950. In fact, from 1950-1980, US production was around 8M vehicles per year. US automotive manufacturing is higher now than it was when we had more protections against cheap Mexican cars - while other high-income countries have seen declines and despite the fact that US automotive manufacturing saw no growth for 30 years when there were plenty of protections. It's not like US cars were a growth industry and then that stopped when Mexican imports happened. US auto manufacturing was a stagnating industry for decades then free trade with Mexico happened and US auto manufacturing has done better. The sky isn't falling, companies are still investing tens of billions (probably hundreds of billions combined) in new US auto manufacturing, and I don't think this vote is going to make much of a difference.
- grecy 3y agoBecause unionized workers consistently have higher pay, better benefits and more rights. Next time you see the headline about some company laying off thousands of people while simultaneously making record profits and paying their CEO some number of hundreds of millions of dollars per year, ask yourself why that never seems to happen to unionized workers. Next time you see the headline about the "working poor" that have multiple jobs and still can't make ends meet, ask yourself why that never seems to happen to unionized workers. Next time you see the headline about people going years without so much of a cost of living increase to their wages, ask yourself why that never seems to happen to unionized workers. (I could go on)
- chatmasta 3y agoAdding a union might net workers who join it higher pay in the short term, but who's to say that they aren't missing out on significant wage increases in the long term? You'll never see that counterfactual, and as a union gains momentum, it becomes increasingly unlikely we'll ever know how the workers might have performed without the union.
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoInteresting apprach, This makes sense and I wonder why people aren't talking more about it. I have a suspiction that companies would be paying people way more money if it wasn't for the pesky unions. This is also the reason why companies fight tooth-and-nail against unions. They do it out of kindness for the workers, so they are able to pay the workers more in the long run. People need to talk more about this, it's called corporate kindheartedness.
- tomrod 3y ago> but who's to say Economic theory, strategic behavior, and repeated observations through history (leading to the genesis if unions).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaysleep 3y agoThey don't care if they kill the cow, as long as they can extract a bit more milk from it. I don't have a problem with unions in general except for the rule against being able to fire and replace them all as a block. Let them negotiate jointly, fine, but employers should have the right to find alternatives.
- senectus1 3y agoI'm skeptical of unions as well, but the auto workers in the US are getting absolutely shafted. I see no other way to deal with this corporate greed.
- missedthecue 3y agoWhat is the difference between corporate greed and regular greed?
- reso 3y agoConcentrated vs. diffuse greed.
- xyst 3y agoGood for them. Got to keep unions alive for that collective bargaining. Given the recent state court rulings in AL, I am honestly surprised Mercedes is even keeping the plant open.
- daniel-s 3y agoI always saw unions as a bureaucratic/political layer that sits on top of workers, collecting money without contributing. I also don't think that people should all get the same pay or collectively bargain. Some people work harder, invest more in their skills, bring a better attitude, etc. They should get paid more.
- rickydroll 3y agowho is likely to be more successful in negotiating with a very large corporation like Mercedes? A union representing thousands of workers or, an individual that is replaceable no matter what skills they have?
- StudyAnimal 3y agoFrom my experience, it’s the individual. I always get paid more than the union members. I also notice that the non union members seem to have a bit more motivation and spirit and their own idea about their goals and where they want to go compared to the union members who seem to delegate the progress of their careers to their employers. Clearly it’s not a case of one being better than the other. It’s great we have the choice. Unions are good for some types of people and job but terrible for others.
- nielsbot 3y agoThis is a terrible take, and unions absolutely contribute. Just look at the concessions the UAW won from the "big 3" recently. Unless workers band together they have no bargaining power. Without bargaining power the owners horde the profits.
- throwaway0665 3y agoYou pay to be a part of a union so it must have some kind of value to the customers (the workers) otherwise no one would pay and there wouldn't be high union membership. If workers felt that a good attitude and honing their skills would get them paid more than being a part of a union they wouldn't join.
- nycdatasci 3y agoIt seems like the bulk of the comments here are in response to a dead comment. @dang: Can we either revive the dead comment or suppress the entire story?
- refulgentis 3y agoI'm curious, why the dichotomy?
- komali2 3y agoIMO the comment is flamebait and the bait was effective, I'm strongly resisting the urge to chuck my hat in the ring.
- pierat 3y agoClick on the time next to a post's name. Opens up their comment in a new page, with a 'vouch' button. That can un-dead. I just did that, not because I agree, but because a lot of people in IT have the similar view. Discussing and refuting that view is essential.
- rcbdev 3y agoThe cognitive dissonance needed to believe countries with high unionization (Austria, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, etc.) and collective agreements are bad for their citizens while the US is touted as a gold standard is unbelievable.