4 ms·
> Comments have been moved to chat; please do not continue the discussion here. Before posting a comment below this one, please review the purposes of comments.
by bombcar 3y ago
> Comments have been moved to chat; please do not continue the discussion here. Before posting a comment below this one, please review the purposes of comments. Comments that do not request clarification or suggest improvements usually belong as an answer, on Retrocomputing Meta, or in Retrocomputing Chat. Comments continuing discussion may be removed.
And this is how useful sites die.
- myself248 3y agoStackexchange's karma policy has effectively kept this 39-year veteran of computing from contributing so much as a word. I'm okay jumping through a hoop or two to prove I'm not a bot, but I never figured out how to earn enough points to comment without being able to comment. This is how useful sites die.
- duskwuff 3y ago> I never figured out how to earn enough points to comment By posting questions or answers, especially ones which get upvoted. Comments are, intentionally, treated as lower value by the site. They're intended for discussing and correcting issues which may exist with a question or answer, not for revealing new information.
- cellularmitosis 3y agoI'll echo OP's frustration / lament. I have domain expertise in a specific platform, and it is pretty common that I'll see an answer which could use some clarification or additional detail about edge cases to consider. However, 1) I never ask questions on SO, and 2) I don't have time to wade through unanswered questions. As a result, though I would like to give them free labor by adding useful comments, I will never be able to. The point is that SO is missing out here.
- o11c 3y agoIf you feel you can improve an answer, you can always just add your own answer. That should quickly give you enough to comment.
- apaprocki 3y agoIt feels wrong and an anti-pattern to copy-paste a 98% subjectively correct answer as your own, just to sprinkle the 2% (again, subjectively) that it was missing to be the Answer. Why can’t we highlight specific content and create a discussion thread hinged off the highlighted part? Creating a properly written, end-to-end answer for a complex question is an heroic task if all you wanted to point out was that there was a demonstrably better way to do Item 15(a)(5)(iii) and the author missed it. It’s funny that we, collectively as programmers, use git all day long to solve this problem for modifying discrete blocks of programming language text with discussion and more, but can’t seem to ever apply the same tools and fascination to written English. Even more interesting now that we use the best answers to train models. You’d think there would be more discipline involved in making the best answer even bestier. (Like, say, Wikipedia)
- DANmode 3y agoThe unique offering of their platform, for better and for worse, is not having to "go through" the discussion of why the best answer is the best - you just get right to the best, complete answer.
- lewispollard 3y agoThat would be great if it worked like that, but for the same reasons that the parent comments lamented about, it rarely does. Often the answer marked "correct" isn't as correct as something in a comment or another answer.
- duskwuff 3y agoIIRC, you can also propose edits to existing answers, and having those edits accepted will give you a bit of reputation too.
- dspillett 3y agoIf you can improve an answer, you could always give a new answer? > The point is that SO is missing out here. Unfortunately, if comments were open to all initially the site would quickly fill with “me too” comments and other things that would fill the page with low quality content that would be effort to moderate. This already happens to an extent with answers. My point being that the potential gain from automatically open comments may be less than the potential hassle from less useful users. Balancing these matters is difficult, many places get it even more wrong than SO and related sites do, and there is probably no perfect answer that doesn't put off some useful contributions.
- o11c 3y agoOther things about comments: You don't need karma to comment on your own questions/answers (i.e. in reply to someone else's comment on what you posted). Basically anyone can flag comments obsolete and this can make them be deleted without review. My last comment was "this code breaks for obscure input X" but I can no longer locate it. The real main problem with StackOverflow is that all the easy questions have already been asked and answered, and all the hard questions get little attention, so it's hard to get karma honestly. Many people have luck operating in obscure language tags.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoThe Internet is shit now, swarmed by bots (even ones some people argue are sentient). Useful sites are less possible than before. You are too late.
- ClassyJacket 3y agoWe should call this Redditification
- Etheryte 3y agoEspecially so given that if you read through all the moved comments, you can see that they actually end up uncovering where the code originated from. So in short, the actual correct answer to the question was found in the comments and then the moderator decided to move those comments away.
- dpkirchner 3y agoAt least this chat page is live. Often, IME, the linked chat page is not found (as in, requests return a 404). What a mess.
- wruza 3y agoI’m using SO occasionally and was actively participating in 201x-ish. Even then people cried SO was over, but I never felt that. Comments were moved to the chat, well, then I click on a link and read them. It’s not any different from clicking on expand-comments link. Excuse me if I’m getting something wrong here, but to me it feels like a good thing to keep such drama from a site. That said, sometimes moderators could lock questions which were different from where they redirected to and insist that’s correct. This was one of the worst issues, imo.
- pwdisswordfishc 3y agoBy enforcing quality standards?