4 ms·
Dealing with surprising human emotions: desk moves (2017)
- JohnClark1337 3y ago[dead]
- lebean 3y agoI once had a severe emotional reaction to someone taking my stapler. Let's just say I caused a bit of desk shuffling in retaliation. I have no regrets, the place was toxic.
- ftth_finland 3y agoWas it red?
- morkalork 3y agoReason #6479 of why WFH is a godsend. Never again will I have to suffer a useless VP rearranging the floor for the nth time in their quest to optimize inter-team collaboration.
- dgfitz 3y agoActively in the market for a WFH job because, among other things, I’m tired of changing desks every year.
- plasticchris 3y agoI used to sit and stare at the walls in offices daydreaming about a better way. I would stare down at the green space around the office building and imagine small single room office cabins, where everyone had light, privacy, control over the local environment. I thought if it could be made to work this would be the ideal layout for engineering/design/whatever creative work. Funny thing, over a decade later I found out I just described working from home.
- tharkun__ 3y agoWhen possible, tie it back to company strategy or objectives (“it’s important for us to sit closer to our stakeholders”, or “this layout will improve our carbon footprint”). These feel exactly like the kind of BS VP rearrangement you're mentioning. Moving desks improves our carbon footprint? What kind of coolaid do they drink and how am I supposed to control my urge to just burst out in loud laughter if my boss tells me that as a reason?
- 486sx33 3y agoHow dare you question the impact on carbon footprint? Are you some kind of fossil fuel drinking cowboy?
- Talanes 3y agoI honestly believe the primary driver of organizational dysfunction is management's tendency to find justifications for things rather than actually understanding what they're doing and if it's necessary.
- floydnoel 3y agoi imagine they think it's necessary in order for them to maintain power dynamic, but they aren't willing to convey that message. so they contrive creative "cover stories."
- lmm 3y ago> Moving desks improves our carbon footprint? If it's "we're moving everyone downstairs so we can turn off the heating on the 6th floor" then it does. But yeah, even in that case it's better to skip the bullshit; if you've laid off a bunch of people and you're packing the people who are left into a smaller space to save money, if you tell them that, they'll understand.
- tharkun__ 3y agoThe trick would we to move everyone from the first floor to the 6th, rent out the first floor and let them pay for "their" heating bill, knowing warm air goes up ;) That would be a great explanation. Doesn't do squat for the carbon footprint either way tho.
- slillibri 3y agoIs that ever really the reason? More likely, a larger or more important team covets your location, so your dinky cost-center team will have to move to the dark center of the 'open' layout.
- morkalork 3y agoHysterically enough, the IT and sysadmin team got put in what became known as "the cave" and never got moved out. At least they had a door they could close. The real short end of the stick in the 'open' floor was being beside sales and customer support.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- db48x 3y agoYes! The one time I had a Real job I had to suffer through a desk shuffle. I happened to go into the office early one day the next week to get some actual work done. Around 6:30–7am some guy walks up to me while I am programming and asks me a question. It took me 30 or 40 seconds to finish my thoughts and start to think about the question. By that time, he had walked off. His question turned out to be something like “How much has moving the desks around improved the working conditions around here?” Even after he was gone, I couldn’t figure out how to answer that question; to me moving desks around was mostly irrelevant, and I wasn’t even sure if it was possible for a shuffle to make any difference at all. At least not for engineering, where all of our communications can be done through email, bug trackers, version control, etc, etc. Later I learned that he was the CEO (oops!). On the other hand, they at least had a good reason for the shuffle. They had been subleasing half of the floor to another company. As we were growing, they ended that lease and let every one expand into their place. This left plenty of open space for the new people who were hired that year.
- tzs 3y agoI now kind of want to figure out where you work and try to get a job there that would put me in a management position above you, just to show that even WFH is not enough to save you from stupid management rearrangement of things. It might go something like this: > Morkalork, I've noticed in our team Zoom meetings when you look at something on your second monitor you look to the left. Everyone else has their second monitor on the right and its really distracting to see you go left when everyone else goes right. > I'm going to need you to move that second monitor over to the right.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- EstanislaoStan 3y agoJust flip the video?
- function_seven 3y agoI’m disappointed that after our last talk, you decided to try and fake a “solution” rather than swapping your screens as we had agreed. I’m getting complaints that the “NY JETS” pennant in the background is flipped now.
- qup 3y agoFlip the pennant
- rukuu001 3y agoThe BICEPS thing is cute. Handy as a checklist.
- legel 3y agoI once quit a big tech company triggered by a desk move. All of the social disruption described here is true. I also felt an environmental gentrification: my “secret” window spot, where the data engineers were stuffed into, being hijacked by “more important” salespeople… I still remember the feeling when they walked over and surveyed my land, smiling in delight of their new gains. All of this is to say: people belong to spaces, too.
- mdekkers 3y agoOne of the many reasons why I will never work in an office again.
- the_jeremy 3y ago> Additionally, coach them to figure out how to find other avenues for their autonomy and choice. (In the desk move case: how will they decorate it? What day of the week could they start the move? How will they celebrate as a team once the move is checked off the list?) These should be realistic and doable, and will hopefully help address this core need. Having extreme difficulty taking this as a serious suggestion.
- johnny_canuck 3y agoIt would work for a toddler, not sure it would work as well for a grown up. But then again, IME there is quite an overlap between the two...
- sibit 3y ago> IME there is quite an overlap between the two... Do you think there is an equation where the larger the company the more they treat the employees like toddlers? I've primarily worked for small companies where management treated the employees like adults. They expected us to be professionals so they treated us as such. Sometimes that meant they provided just enough rope for someone to hang themselves but for the most part, it worked pretty well. As I've moved to bigger companies it seems as though management treats the employees more and more like children. The HR department is especially notorious for treating people like toddlers. I find it odd and a bit frustrating. I don't think I could be easily convinced that anyone within my team, department, or adjacent departments could be equated to children yet the actions and tone of management makes me think otherwise.
- lmm 3y agoIME no, there's no correlation. There are companies of all sizes with all kinds of cultures.
- dudul 3y agoI have observed the same thing. I dont know if there is an equation, but it think it just comes from bloated HT department. There is only so much Facebook and Instagram browsing that HR folks can do in one day, eventually they have to do some form of work. This translates into policies, forced trainings, migration from an HR system to another, etc etc. HR is usually the team most disconnected from the rest of the company. They don't know what the company sells/produces. They don't know what are the important projects/deadlines in flight. They just do their thing.
- novia 3y ago> For those of you who have never dealt with an emotional reaction to a desk move, you’re probably confused. This article makes me angry. Anyone who would be confused by this does not belong in management because they do not understand people, full stop.
- Accujack 3y agoSee also "Open Plan Workspace".
- ferfumarma 3y agoYour amygdala's been hijacked.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- steveBK123 3y agoI worked at a bank that moved us on average twice per year, and in some years more. You kind of get over it. I think hotdesking/hoteling is worse than any desk move because you get to have the feeling of uneasiness and disruption daily.
- 15457345234 3y ago> I think hotdesking/hoteling is worse than any desk move because you get to have the feeling of uneasiness and disruption daily. It's interesting to observe how many companies deliberately adopt policies which they _know_ cause employees to be less effective workers. It really does make you think, although... I don't know _what_ it makes me think. Like, to me, this is trivial. I know what people want from a working space. They want a little nook they can customise and personalise, a little space that they can both retreat into when they need to concentrate and invite people into when they need to discuss. A cubicle isn't perfect - an office with a closed door would be best - but a cubicle works. Yet cubicles have been utterly abandoned in favour of open-plan offices, which I've literally never seen anyone say anything positive about. Ever. It's just... how does this occur? And the smug reddit answer 'all CEOS are dark triad' isn't it because CEOs are not making these decisions.
- wodenokoto 3y agoLots of people LOVE hot desking. I’ve seen work place advertise it as a benefit.
- 15457345234 3y agoWhat do they love about it? If you genuinely know people that like it, please ask them. Although I do notice that lots of people like to work from coffee shops so... I guess it might be pushing the same buttons...
- steveBK123 3y agoSome people crave distraction
- aunty_helen 3y agoSo the secret to BICEP is to gaslight your employees into agreeing to be pushed around. On a serious note though, the closing paragraphs mention looking for the root cause of what’s causing someone to come to you asking for a raise or unhappy etc. This is a powerful strategy, whenever someone comes to me in a 1-1 with an issue, I take some time to ask myself “what are they really saying?” It’s a simple yet strong technique for driving the conversation toward them opening up. Don’t just assume and not verify however.
- _el1s7 3y ago[flagged]
- floodfx 3y agoBack when I was in an office, we switched desks once a quarter. We randomized the selection order each time and the only rules were you couldn't sit at the same desk or next to the same people. The value was that sitting next to new people created more social connections and created more trust and a change in scenery was refreshing.
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoAlso forces you to artificially build social connections which for some introverts might be challenging and upsetting.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoMany necessary and/or good things are challenging and upsetting. It's a thing, but it's not automatically the most important thing. That depends on other factors.
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoThe premise here is that most desk changes are neither necessary nor good.