7 ms·
Heat Pumps Take on Cold Climates
- sokoloff 3y ago> But heat pump manufacturers say they now have the technology to heat homes just as efficiently in bitter cold as they do in milder winter temperatures. This claim defies thermodynamics (and I expect better from IEEE). Heat pumps are bound to be less efficient as the spread between inside and outside temperature grows. (They might be just as effective or they might be just as efficient as current heat pump tech, but they will not be as efficient at -20°C outside air temp as they are at +10°C.)
- fullstop 3y agoAre they perhaps referring to geothermal heat pumps?
- swechsler 3y agoNo, they specifically say "air source" heat pumps. And geothermal isn't new.
- solardev 3y agoNo, they're talking about air source ones (which is what's popular these days): > At about 4 °C, most air-source heat pumps currently on the market start operating at less than their full capacity, and at some point (usually around -15 °C), they can no longer do the job at all. At that point, an auxiliary heat source kicks on, which is less efficient. > But advancements in compressor technology over the last five years have addressed that issue. By controlling the compressor motor’s speed, and improving the timing of when vapor is injected into the compressor, engineers have made heat pumps efficient in colder temperatures.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago" just as efficiently " as what? The way I read it was "just as efficiently as a conventional furnace". IOW, a COP of 1 at bitter cold temperatures.
- sokoloff 3y agothe next words are "[as] they do", so I naturally read it as 'those same heat pumps'.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoYes on rereading it definitely appears phrased the way you interpreted. But as you said that's nonsensical so my brain must have dumped the nonsensical interpretation. :)
- unbalancedevh 3y agoI've found that marketing material takes significant liberties with their claims, with the understanding that the audience isn't actually interested in the gory details, just the general question of "should I buy option A or option B?" I've been asked to critique statements that were flat-out wrong, only to be told yeah, thanks, nobody cares about that.
- ajross 3y agoIf you want to get nitpicky: Cycle losses aren't the only source of inefficiency and in fact the end-to-end efficiency curves of most domestic heat pumps tend to be pretty flat through their useful range. Basic thermodynamics, provided a refrigerant that is well matched to the cycle (which is what the article is actually about), isn't really the core design point.
- sokoloff 3y agoI've never seen a CoP curve that was not downward sloping with decreasing outside temperature. Do a google image search for "heat pump cop curve" and glance at the results. All of them are significantly downward sloping because the underlying thermodynamic cycle effect is very strong (agree not the only) limit.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atoav 3y agoMy father has a heat pump that works fine in alpine climate (half of the winter snow outside) for more than a decade now. Not sure about the precise english terminology here, but his hear pump works using the deep ground water next to our house. The temperature of that water slightly dips in winter, but it is no more than a degree. It is a very old house that before had a oil heating system and I think the replacement worked quite well.
- sgerenser 3y agoThat’s a ground-source heat pump (often called geothermal heat pump). These have been around for decades in the U.S. but haven’t been very popular due to the 2-3x installed cost vs. an air source heat pump.
- solardev 3y agoThis is common in some parts of the world (which is great!), but not in the US. They're quite a bit more expensive, especially compared to modern mini-split air-source heat pumps that can cost just a couple thousand dollars and don't require any digging or duct installations, just a small hole in the wall.
- atoav 3y agoI guess my father was just lucky, because 1m through the wall from our oil cellar we had an old well that could be used, so there was no need for much more digging (except 1m sidways). He added a ton of solar as well, which is a nice combination.
- DannyBee 3y agothis feels pedantic. They are clearly not talking about the theoretical bounds, but instead in practice. The claim can be literally true. It may be they are at x% efficiency in both cases, where x is optimal for bitter cold but not for mild winter.
- sokoloff 3y ago> The claim can be literally true. It can be. Would you take an even-money wager that the CoP curve will be flat [or increasing] with decreasing outside temp vs my wager that it will be downward sloping with decreasing outside temp?
- DannyBee 3y agoThe claim is true. You've transformed their claim into something else. What they wrote is " But heat pump manufacturers say they now have the technology to heat homes just as efficiently in bitter cold as they do in milder winter temperatures." That is about whether they gained the technology to make the finished units as efficient in bitter cold as they are currently efficient in mild winter. Given they were inoperative in bitter cold, and fairly inefficient in mild winter, this is almost certainly trivially true. Here is a real curve: https://hvac-talk.com/vbb/attachment.php?s=f7eb5f83efc8804403081f85ab72d79d&attachmentid=822851&stc=1&d=1615838362 https://hvac-talk.com/vbb/attachment.php?s=f7eb5f83efc880440... If we all mild winter 32F, and bitter cold -10F, they would only have to improve efficiency by 2x at bitter cold to make it as efficient as current heat pumps as mild winter. That is easily possible. As for whether they are strictly flat/decreasing, they are not. Here is more data: https://connect.fujitsugeneral.com/3cfb13a7-a386-4697-aa3e-58187dfd578f https://connect.fujitsugeneral.com/3cfb13a7-a386-4697-aa3e-5... You can see capacity, input power, and efficiency do not have a strictly linear (flat or decreasing) relationship with outdoor temperature. This is an artifact of it being impossible to good at all things at once. It is also obvious to every reader you can not make a "maximally efficient in all" cases heat pump as efficient in bitter cold as in mild winter. So rather than assume that is what they are claiming by adding a lot of implicit things to it, i would just read it in a straightforward manner and when I do, it seems pretty easily true.
- cma 3y agoIn Kelvin the percentage difference looks a lot smaller than -20°C to +10°C, more towards a rounding error for an ideal heat pump. So if they can operate at the same percentage efficiency away from ideal, the extra difference from the actual source/sink temperature could be very minimal right?
- lcvw 3y agoIs there a way to get your house (currently with hydronic gas heat) retrofitted for heat pumps that doesn’t result in either a ton of demo or ugly lines all over the exterior? I tried to switch over last year only to find the savings were not that great in my climate, and that it would have an unacceptable aesthetic cost.
- fullstop 3y agoMine has one pipe going into the basement, and the mains power connection. What sorts of ugly lines are you referring to?
- sokoloff 3y agoI think probably the ugly lineset covers characteristic of lowest possible budget (and therefore overwhelmingly most common) installation of air-to-air heat pumps.
- free_bip 3y agoI have my doubts about heat pumps ever being viable for Canadian and other high-latitude countries -40 degree winters. Everywhere else though, they probably should be the standard.
- epistasis 3y agoWhat fraction of the population lives with -40 degree winters? That's the only reason they might not be viable, in that they require customization that is only useful to a tiny tiny tiny fraction of the population.
- goalieca 3y agoA huge chunk of canadas population in Quebec, Ontario, prairies, and BC see -20 for weeks on end. -40 is more rare but happens every year. Huge chunks of the mid-western USA see those as well. At -30 my furnace is basically on continuously.
- timbit42 3y agoHow many days/nights do they see -40C? Even if it's 30 days straight, a heat pump would work the other 335 days of the year.
- goalieca 3y agoOne night at -40 when the heat pump is shut off is enough to freeze pipes and cause serious damage.
- emmanuel_1234 3y agoA bit late, but maybe someone will read this. I live in Toronto and installed a heat pump this year. We've been through the worst of Winter, I believe, and although the cost ramps up on the coldest days, the heat pump worked perfectly at -15C (it claims a COP of 2 at that temperature). I watch the auxiliary circuit, that is triggered if the heat pump fails to heat to the required temperature, and it never ran for the whole season. Yes, Winter can still get a lot worse and a lot cooler, but my house also has insulation and there is no scenario where I will freeze to death. In terms of cost, it's a lot cheaper than gas + electricity (it evens-out on the coolest days, and is cheaper otherwise). It will not amortize the cost of the heat pump itself for a while, but that's a cost I'm happy to eat right now.
- circusfly 3y ago[flagged]
- deprecative 3y agoThis would be nice. It's not the end of the world to convert them myself but given the large readership base that uses Freedom I'd like to see these with both. It's much easier for them to add our units than it is for us to adopt metric here anytime soon.
- cwoolfe 3y agoAs someone who switched to a heat pump recently, you should know "your mileage may vary." Don't confuse physical efficiency for cost efficiency. In many places, natural gas is still more cost efficient, even if it isn't as efficient in terms of physics.
- sgerenser 3y agoNatural gas is dirt cheap in most of the U.S., so it does make it hard for heat pumps to compete, especially if electricity is expensive. Just checked my most recent gas bill and I only paid $1.09/therm (plus 7% sales tax and $10 fixed fee). OTOH if you’re heating with propane or fuel oil, heat pumps are probably a good alternative.
- grumpyinfosec 3y agoThats kind of high. I only pay $0.78 a therm here in Wisconsin. 1 therm is around 30kwh so im paying like 2.5c a kwh vs 17c for electricity. So unless I can get a CoP of 700% from a air source heatpump im literally lighting money on fire. That really is the main issue, as much as I care about emissions I don't care enough to spend money on a heat pump to then spend more money on utilities. And the calculus gets worse and worse when your poorer.
- sgerenser 3y agoLooks like Wisconsin has lower than average natgas prices vs. rest of U.S.: https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_a_EPG0_PRS_DMcf_m.htm https://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/ng_pri_sum_a_EPG0_PRS_DMcf_m.htm
- grumpyinfosec 3y agoseems pretty comparable to the other colder parts of the country. (besides the east coast) The warmer parts of the US i'd imagine are less sensitive to residential gas prices.
- kevstev 3y ago
- throwawayheatp 3y agoWe decided to install a cold climate central ducted heat pump system, operating down to -20 F and swapped from wood to pellet stoves in our fireplaces. We didn't have AC previously, and got too old to haul wood around. We can run the heat pump on the coldest days but burning biomass is cheaper and has a nice ambiance. Does wonders for humidity in the summer time too!
- devsatish 3y agoI just got one installed last month in middle of winter at my home in New England. The air from heat pump feels more comfortable than the dry air from the furnace. I got installed with a the furnace back-up option, that way if the heat-pump can't generate the heat, it switches to propane (it becomes very cold here in New England in Winters). From my experience, the heat pump is working well in 30F and above weather (-1.C) Heat pumps burn a lot of electricity, luckily I have solar to off-set that cost, although Solar generation is low in Winter, it adds up well over the year. Heat Pumps + Solar is the way to go.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sircastor 3y agoI was poking through my Thermostat's App a couple of weeks ago, and found a setting that said "Use Gas", "Use Heat Pump", and "Let system decide". I had thought our furnance was running the heat pump automatically... for the last 5 years. I switched, and now the display says "Heating with Heat Pump" and I'm a little upset that it wasn't more obvious before now.
- data_ders 3y agoI feel you! There’s a lot of specifics that are hard to know without digging in and making mistakes! I just found out my heat pump was configured incorrectly in the Nest Thermostat bc I have a Rheem and their heat cool valves are reversed from typical. TLDR my January heating bill was $500 bc heat pump never came on!
- doctoboggan 3y agoI recently had a Mitsubishi hyper heat installed to replace my natural gas furnace. The air handler is connected to the ducts so it was an easy transition. I live in Chicago so I also had 10kW resistive heat strips installed as a backup. This winter they never needed to come on, and I was able to keep the house at 70 degrees F even when we hit around 0 degrees F outside. I haven't crunched all the numbers but so far my electricity bill has gone up by about as much as my gas bill has gone down, so there really isn't much savings there which is too bad. I mainly did this though for the environmental benefits, as I want to slowly phase out all natural gas in my home. Next step will be to replace my gas range with an induction cooker, and the last will be a heat pump water heater.
- solardev 3y agoIf you're considering a heat pump, be sure to check the minimum operating temperature before you buy, and/or make sure you have a backup heat source. I live in a rented apartment with a mini-split, and it worked great for 363 of the last 365 days. Those two days, we had a sudden cold spell and temperatures went down to -6 F (which isn't that cold), but we found out the hard way that our unit was only rated to -4 F. Once it went down to -5, the heat pump didn't just work less efficiently, it stopped working altogether. It was the only real heat source in the house. We tried turning on the kitchen oven for a while, but it couldn't keep up. We had to leave the apt for those days and crash with a friend. Other than that, though, it's been wonderful! SO much nicer than other heat sources (furnaces, space heaters, etc.) It's comfortable, cheap, quiet, and has its own thermostat. We just leave it on and it does its thing and it's magical.
- sgerenser 3y agoI don’t think it’s normal for a heat pump to just stop working completely like that vs. just getting more and more inefficient. Wonder if perhaps it iced up and the defrost wasn’t working.
- NDizzle 3y agoIt's my experience that they do stop working completely at some temp. The defrost cycle creeps up to 100% and there goes the heat.
- simonblack 3y agoThat's because the heat-exchanger is not efficient enough to prevent too much frost from building up. The answer there is a better (probably bigger) heat-exchanger.
- NDizzle 3y agoYep, correct. As many have pointed out in this thread though, HVAC is full of trade offs. I COULD get a bigger heat exchanger.. Although my furnace is already a 5 ton unit. The question is, in the Ozarks, where I am, are the 1-4 days a year where it's too cold to run the heat pump worth paying the extra money for the larger system? I added an efficient wood stove instead. There's a good tax rebate that covers installation as well - I took advantage of that last year.
- rswskg 3y agoWhy does these articles always leave out how electricity the pump needs and how that varys with temperature? It's not magic or free.
- timbit42 3y agoAs someone who lives where natural gas isn't available, virtually everyone here had either EBBs or an oil furnace. A heat pump uses as little as 1/4 the electricity but uses more as you get into lower temps. A heat pump remains more efficient than EBBs down to around -25C. Heating oil is more expensive than EBBs, so very expensive compared to the electricity needed for a heat pump, and switching is a 'no brainer'. So far, 35% of households in my province have installed heat pumps, most keeping their EBBs or oil furnace as a backup. Every home that switches from EBBS is cutting their heating electricity usage by 50% (annually), freeing up electricity for the homes switching from oil furnaces to use for their heat pumps so our grid isn't being overloaded.
- rssoconnor 3y agoI very recently replace my forced air gas furnace with a forced air heat pump (with 10 KW of auxiliary restive heater as well) in southern Ontario. Over the last 11 days or so (February with a combination of cold and unseasonably warm days) I've used 1047.15 kWh of electricity, of which I estimate half to two-thirds is used on the heat pump. Taking the new ultra-low overnight pricing into account I'm paying an average of 9¢ (CAD) per kWh. I've been trying to pre-heat my home at the tail end of the ultra-low overnight rates (2.8 ¢/kWh) leading up to the 7 a.m. cutoff time. My gas furnace was my only gas appliance, so I can remove now remove it and save on the month connection charge which is about $30 a month, even in the summer when I don't use gas. Canada also, at least for now, has a pigouvian carbon tax, so I'll be saving on that as well.
- simonblack 3y agoDepending on the ambient temperatures in your local climate, you may need a more efficient heat-exchanger on one side or other of the heat pump. The cost of a heat-exchanger is a compromise between cost and efficiency.