6 ms·
US judge halts government effort to monitor crypto mining energy use
- ThisIsMyAltAcct 3y agoThis is the form that miners allege will cause them irreparable injury and has cost them 40 hours to fill out: https://www.eia.gov/survey/form/eia_862/form.pdf https://www.eia.gov/survey/form/eia_862/form.pdf
- Canada 3y agoIt's big and extremely invasive, and asks questions that are none of the government's business, and definitely none of that agency's business. The form claims it should only take 30 minutes to complete. Laughable. It's 26 pages, and it's not simple, and it begins with a threat that being incorrect is a criminal offense.
- bitfilped 3y agoThe stability and security of energy generation in the US is in fact the DOE's business.
- roamerz 3y agoIf I opened a laundromat I doubt I’d need to fill out something for the DOE. I think this is nothing more than another agency using the DOE for a conduit to get that information for them.
- pasc1878 3y agoA laundromat does not affect how much generation you need - crypto facilities can and have.
- singleshot_ 3y agoIf thousands of people cooperate to create a global money laundering operation that directly affects the power grid it makes sense to request some information from them.
- alchemist1e9 3y agoBugger off. Bitcoin is coming no matter what you think and eventually it will smack some responsibility into the irresponsible governments that are actually the biggest polluters and encouraging waste and consumption though endless fiat money printing and civilization scale money laundering.
- singleshot_ 3y agoLovely language. Bitcoin isn’t “coming,” it’s here and it’s a nightmare. People lose money down this drain every day and there’s next to no way to get it back. A serious transnational criminal problem that must be addressed and if the government wants to keep tabs on who profits from this, that’s be great.
- alchemist1e9 3y agoYour assumptions couldn’t be more misguided. It’s glaringly obvious you’re part of the collectivist, statist, authoritarian crowd, like so many out there. But here’s the kicker: Bitcoin, with its Proof of Work (PoW) marvel, is cutting through the tyranny of your majority like a hot knife through butter. Bitcoin is already outperforming the sluggish efforts of the IMF and World Bank, breathing life into renewable energy projects in the most forgotten corners of the world. This is revolutionizing local economies and lifting standards of living, far from your narrow, outdated critiques. Now, let’s dissect the energy “problem.” Yes Bitcoin will eventually devour 1-2% of the planet’s energy, but calling it a problem is missing the point. This consumption is a beacon, signaling the dire need for more energy production. Bitcoin isn’t just sitting there; it’s actively pushing for energy innovation and sustainability, something your limited perspective fails to grasp. And who made you the arbiter of good versus bad energy use? Do cloud services, AI, gaming, and your mundane household activities get a free pass? The real issue is your lack of vision, stuck in a defeatist echo chamber. Bitcoin is addressing the massive demand for a currency that’s private, uncensored, and deflationary. You might not like it, but it’s because you’re too caught up playing traffic cop, basking in telling others what to do. You also overlook the ingenious utilization of Bitcoin’s ‘waste’ heat, a byproduct turned asset. This isn’t merely about keeping some servers running; it’s about a visionary leap towards using every joule of energy to its fullest. Bitcoin mining operations are pioneering the capture and repurposing of waste heat for practical, everyday uses - from water heaters in homes to boosting agricultural yields. Imagine a world where the excess heat from securing a decentralized financial network warms homes, powers greenhouses, and promotes sustainability. This isn’t a hypothetical future; it’s happening now. And as for the global energy supply, your argument falls short by ignoring the pressing necessity for a dramatic increase in energy production. To genuinely elevate the living standards of every human being on this planet out of poverty, we require energy solutions that are orders of magnitude greater than what’s currently available. Bitcoin’s energy consumption, far from being a wasteful curse, is a catalyst for this much-needed energy revolution, driving innovation and investment in renewable sources at a scale previously unimaginable. As for the financial drain, let’s get real. Over any 5-year span, Bitcoin has been a golden ticket compared to the sinking ship of fiat currency, plagued by inflation and collapse. Bitcoin is on track to eclipse Silver and even challenge Gold as a store of value. And all the supposed “problems”? Solved. Layer 2 solutions, altcoins, and stablecoins are gearing up to handle global transaction volumes, with Bitcoin as the unshakeable foundation. Your darling governments and their policies? More often than not, they’re the real hurdles to progress, wielding violence and spreading misery under the guise of collectivist and socialist dreams. And let’s not even start on the education system, brainwashing generations with fairytales instead of truth. Money laundering? Look in the mirror. The biggest laundromats are your central banks and government policies, sanctifying grand-scale financial crimes under the guise of legality. Bitcoin is the least of your worries if you’re genuinely concerned about corruption and illicit finance. You’re right, Bitcoin isn’t just coming; it’s already here, tearing down the facades of the leeches, parasites, and warmongers. With leaders who get it inching closer to power, we’re on the brink of a financial renaissance. Picture it: a Swiss bank account in every pocket, the ultimate nightmare for the likes of Obama and his collectivist cronies. And guess what? There’s nothing you can do to stop it.
- bitfilped 3y agoNo you wouldn't, because your laundromat wouldn't be consuming MW-GW ranges of power.
- Canada 3y agoThen why is the first question fishing for info about what proof of stake validators are present? Why would they need to know the ages of the equipment? This is very obviously not about what they claim it is about.
- Johnny555 3y agoIt's so long because it has a space for up to 10 crypto facilities, with 2 pages per facility. So basically 10 questions that need to be answered for a company that has a single crypto facility. And since power is such a large part of costs, I'd be surprised if most don't already know the answers to the power questions.
- justrealist 3y agoFilling out any form for the federal government is actually a big deal, because you incur huge legal liability by being wrong (criminal, if they decide you were lying). Submitting regulatory documents goes through a lot of legal review for a reason, you can't just "spitball" the numbers.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoBaloney. Any government form I've filled out gives that vibe, sure. And then when you're wrong, you don't get a fucking prison sentence, you get a phone call where someone explains why they think you're wrong and asks you to take a stab at it. Also, every form from the Government I've ever filled out that is binding in terms of accuracy goes out of it's way, where you sign (which this one, to my looking, I don't even see where you sign!) to say that "you certify that this information is accurate and correct to the best of your knowledge which like, the deniability there is a mile fucking wide. I, personally, as a citizen of both the United States and the larger world would very much like to know how much energy is being pissed away on crypto nonsense. I don't care if that's hard for you, if you can't be arsed to fill out a form, then shut down your stupid mining rigs. Edit: For an example of this: I straight up forgot to include a large gift from a family member in my taxes one year. I never once saw a cop, was threatened, or anything else: I got two letters, one from the IRS, and one from the state, detailing that they found I had forgotten it during an audit, and I owed them.... IIRC it was a G and a half, thereabouts. If I disagreed and wanted to question their findings, I had to reply with the requisite documentation and a signed statement explaining why I felt what I did. If not, I could accept the judgement, and they included the paperwork to setup a payment plan if I couldn't afford it right away. This "big government so scary" shit just is not reality. Every government institution I've dealt with (apart from the police, of course) approaches everyone in good faith, arguably even when they shouldn't. The ONLY way you can really get the G-men on your ass is if you're purposely going out of your way and doing fraudulent or illegal shit. Like the IRS doesn't even give a damn if you sell drugs, they just demand Uncle Sam gets his cut.
- yownie 3y agosure just as long as you shut down your dumb video games and movie distribution network.
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoTrust me, if that form came into the place where I work, 40 hours would be the tip of the iceberg. No novel regulatory request would get a response without compliance and legal review and interpretation. In any case, this isn't a decision on the merits. It's just saying that the plaintiff has a reasonable chance of succeeding at trial; the "irreparable harm" occurs when the government forces you to incur unrecoverable compliance costs for something that isn't legally required - that's just the law. The government could've avoided this by going through the actual hoops necessitated by the Paperwork Reduction Act, notice and comment etc. rather than creating the requirement as an "emergency".
- reaperman 3y agoIt's also a terrible form. It boils down to just 2 important questions: * Mining Electric Load: (in MW) * Mining Hash Rate: (in TH/s) But it doesn't have a place to specify which cryptocurrency is being mined. Each have a very different hash rate on the same hardware. So this "emergency" data will be useless even if they do collect it.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoThis is also the fundamental unit of business performance that everyone would hate to leak. I'm sure it'll be in great hands with USG regulators!
- anoncow 3y ago[flagged]
- gwbas1c 3y agoBecause that's the point of government: To govern. Edit: We don't always let people pay "market price" for whatever they want. There's plenty of precedent for rationing: IE, In CA, it doesn't matter how rich you are, you can't water your lawn in a drought. During the 1970s oil embargo, it didn't matter how rich you were, you still had to ration gasoline. In this case, cryptocurrency is both increasing the cost of electricity for other important needs, like home heating / cooling, and increasing pollution. It's perfectly within the definition of what government does to set reasonable limits for the cryptocurrency industry.
- office_drone 3y agoGood governance doesn't always mean doing something instead of nothing.
- polski-g 3y ago> In CA, it doesn't matter how rich you are, you can't water your lawn in a drought Yes, this policy is stupid. If the cost of water rose in response to scarcity, then it would incentivize institutions to build things to alleviate said scarcity and consumers would shift usage habits. Some people would move, some people would build desalination plants. Price fixes are the worst possible choice to a resource scarcity.
- pton_xd 3y agoIs there something exceptional about paying market price for a commodity?
- kibwen 3y agoIs there something exceptional about a major industry being asked to be transparent about its energy usage?
- bequanna 3y agoFair enough, but why isn’t every business/industry subject to this? Maybe all data centers, farmers, etc should have to provide detailed reporting on the energy they use.
- shagie 3y agohttps://eta.lbl.gov/publications/united-states-data-center-energy https://eta.lbl.gov/publications/united-states-data-center-e... ( 3.5 MB pdf for the full report https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/sites/default/files/lbnl-1005775_v2.pdf https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/sites/default/files/lbnl-10... ) https://www.energy.gov/eere/buildings/data-centers-and-servers https://www.energy.gov/eere/buildings/data-centers-and-serve... https://www.wired.com/story/amazon-google-microsoft-green-clouds-and-hyperscale-data-centers/ https://www.wired.com/story/amazon-google-microsoft-green-cl... They do / have.
- ComputerGuru 3y agoI imagine in general the data is already provided by the power company. The issue here is overlap between general data center power usage or residential power usage and crypto mining power usage, which isn’t as easy for the power company to discern.
- unethical_ban 3y agoFarmers should be subject to monitoring on disproportionate use of vital resources. Such as alfalfa farms that are a backdoor to export US groundwater to China.
- charonn0 3y agoAs I read it[1], the plaintiffs allege that the government has overstepped its authority by using emergency powers to make new demands for information under threat of prosecution. There is a plausible argument for that position, and so a TRO is appropriate while the questions are resolved. [1]: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24440902-cryptoenergytro https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24440902-cryptoenerg...
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoThat is exactly right.
- babypuncher 3y agoAnother case of something being done for the right reason, but in the wrong way because our legislative branch refuses to lift a finger.
- mywittyname 3y agoThis is really it. A dysfunctional Congress serves to empower the Executive. And the Judicial branch only serves as a check so long as the Executive cares to follow their rulings. This isn't just a problem if we get a malicious Executive either. If judges keep saying the Executive doesn't have some power unless Congress acts, and Congress continues to not act, then the Executive might be put in a position where they have to ignore judicial rulings in order to govern. Technically Congress can impeach, but a dysfunctional Congress isn't likely to get that one done.
- SllX 3y agoGovern isn’t a verb in American Federal law severable from Acts of Congress. If Congress doesn’t act, then the President and his subordinates are not lawfully empowered to act the way they think Congress should allow them to act. That’s why they spend a lot of time trying to stretch their interpretation of previous Acts of Congress still in effect to try to justify what they want to do under the law. Sometimes they get away with it, sometimes the courts tell them “Nah, dawg.” Also willingness to impeach is demonstrably not the problem. The resulting trials is where Congress stuffs it all up.
- tchock23 3y agoSo the impact is likely higher than the 2.3% estimated.
- justin66 3y agoIt's bad when you can read a headline like this and guess where the judge is.
- infecto 3y agoIt's disappointing when instead of reading the supporting documentation that we collectively jump into politics so quickly.
- sackfield 3y agoIt's weird that people are acting like commodities are under some sort of license when they are purchased. As far as I know they aren't. A world that tries to regulate this scares me more than one where people participate in futile hashing.
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI think it's a perfectly reasonable thing to begin considering. It's clear that the markets by themselves are not capable of addressing various concerns about our planet's limited resources. If we want our society to remain viable long term, we need to start being smart with how much of any given commodity is committed to how much of any given effort. A new one, to be sure, and worth scrutinizing as we begin. But the market has demonstrated quite clearly it can't be trusted to manage finite resources.
- sackfield 3y agoI think the market has shown that growth is the solution rather than rationing. Lots of the humanitarian improvements of the 20th century (such as number of people starving) are improved due to market forces innovating on doing more with less. The same will no doubt happen to energy. Consumption is the catalyst.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI think anyone mining crypto currency would carefully track their expenses including their electricity consumption. So reporting that would be a few lines of scripting, not irreparable harm. I love screwing environmentalists as much as any muscle car fan, but the headline implies that shenanigans are happening.
- ImJamal 3y agoWhat exactly does monitoring energy use mean? Does this apply to people mining at their house?