5 ms·
I’m really fascinated with the way journalists are trying to turn the most basic supply and demand situation into “fighting back”. > In grocery stores, they’re
by Aurornis 3y ago
I’m really fascinated with the way journalists are trying to turn the most basic supply and demand situation into “fighting back”.
> In grocery stores, they’re shifting away from name brands to store-brand items, switching to discount stores or simply buying fewer items like snacks or gourmet foods.
Like everything must be a war between two sides. It can’t simply be the most basic economic concept at work.
On the other hand, I’m equally surprised at how few people seem to understand supply and demand has influence on prices. I watched as some family members complained loudly about how concert prices were outrageous and unaffordable for the average person like them, then went right on ahead and then bought the tickets they wanted anyway. They didn’t understand that people’s willingness to pay uncomfortably high prices was the entire reason tickets were so expensive.
I watched the same thing happen at the grocery store earlier where a couple picked up a package of steaks, lamented that it was going to cost them X hours of work, and then threw them in the basket anyway. It’s like large parts of the population are on purchasing autopilot and the price barely matters.
I think it speaks volumes to how high our standard of living has been if we think that it’s newsworthy that some people are switching to store-brand foods or buying fewer gourmet food items (quoted from the article above). Of course, the people suffering the most are the ones who have had to buy store brand foods and avoid gourmet luxuries long before inflation kicked in.
- duxup 3y agoI generally agree with your statement, but I'll add that "Like everything must be a war between two sides." people seem to love that concept too. If they're not identifying with what they buy, it's with what they don't buy and so on. It's a bummer because I want to know about what people enjoy, like, not what they hate or dislike. So often it is the latter. I somewhat blame social media as outrage and anger gets more engagement than anything else it seems and folks seem conditioned to express that more often than something ... nicer.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 3y agoA lot of people probably don't even realize they're doing it. This stuff is drilled into our heads from the time of our very earliest memories. Red versus blue, the farthest two things can be apart from each other while still being the same sense to us (visible light). When you're a kid it's blue toy aisle versus pink toy aisle. SEGA (blue logo / mascot) — or I guess Playstation these days — versus Nintendo (red logo / mascot). Coke versus Pepsi. As we reach adulthood we're primed for duality in a way that makes us think we must choose one way or the other when presented some choice we didn't even ask for. Do I shop at Walmart, or Target? Do I vote Democrat, or Republican? Do I watch CNN, or Fox? Do I use iPhone, or Android? Do I take the Blue Pill, or the Red Pill? By the time one has been coerced into the decision they've already lost. The only winning move is not to play :)
- ttt11199907 3y agoWell said, thank you.
- rokkitmensch 3y ago"Binary crisis".
- nebula8804 3y agoThe numbers vary between elections and polling organizations (why I dont know) but it seems like ~40-50% of people do not vote so that means that people following your line of thinking are more numerous than you may think. ;) [1]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_turnout_in_United_States_presidential_elections#Turnout_statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_turnout_in_United_States... The reason I say numbers vary is because the chart at the top of this article paints a different story (that more than 50% do not vote)
- selcuka 3y ago> I watched the same thing happen at the grocery store earlier where a couple picked up a package of steaks, lamented that it was going to cost them X hours of work, and then threw them in the basket anyway. What are they supposed to do? Meat is generally considered an inelastic good [1] unlike your concert example. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_elasticity_of_demand
- allturtles 3y agoEat chicken. Or ground beef. Or pork chops. Or any of the other meats that are cheaper than steak.
- bombcar 3y agoAnd lots of people do substitute; but the reality is that even steak is a small portion of most people’s expenses.
- mertd 3y agoMeat is maybe non negotiable for some folks but surely steak can be subbed with a cheaper cut, different animal etc... Also let's not judge the shoppers in the original comment. Maybe they wanted it for a special occasion which made it less optional.
- knightofmars 3y agoPreface, I'm not a vegan or vegetarian. I also hunt and have killed and butchered animals for meat. That people consider meat an inelastic good shows a cultural and commercial brainwashing. The idea that an individual or family could go without meat is practically heresy in the United States. Frankly, it's ridiculous and shows a fundamental lack of imagination and willingness to accept that reality doesn't guarantee anyone's ability to acquire cheap hamburger, chicken breasts, bacon, or any other meat.
- kelipso 3y agoReality has done exactly that for decades in the US. What's so weird about people complaining that this is not continuing.
- Simulacra 3y agoSometimes you have to get really creative to generate those clicks. That's what it's all about. Journalism is a faint echo of what it once was.
- briHass 3y agoSee also many of the discussions about housing costs, on HN and elsewhere. Yes, housing is expensive, but somebody keeps paying those prices. Boogymen like private equity and landlords are often blamed, but looking at the data shows most houses are still bought by owner-occupiers.
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s quite rare to meet someone who wishes they paid more for their current house, or that it was now worth less. People do notice changes, however, even if they don’t contextualize them correctly all the time.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoThe percentage of owners is trending downward. Homelessness and renting are tending upwards.
- briHass 3y agoThe homeownership rate has been remarkably stable at around 65% for the last 50 years. It generally stays within 2-3% of that number, even though it does have periodic, temporary upward and downward trends. I wouldn't call it an actual trend unless it falls outside the typical range and stays there for more than a few years.
- nebula8804 3y agoCan we measure % of homes transferred from parents to children? I know several millennials who inherited their houses from their parents when they passed away. There is no way they would be home owners otherwise.
- andersa 3y ago> On the other hand, I’m equally surprised at how few people seem to understand supply and demand has influence on prices. I watched as some family members complained loudly about how concert prices were outrageous and unaffordable for the average person like them, then went right on ahead and then bought the tickets they wanted anyway. They didn’t understand that people’s willingness to pay uncomfortably high prices was the entire reason tickets were so expensive. It sounds like the alternative you propose would involve... not having a ticket? That is clearly not an acceptable outcome if I want to go to the concert.
- sahila 3y agoWhy isn’t it acceptable? It’s the same way I want to own a yacht and a private jet but it’s too expensive so I accept that I can’t afford it.
- ryandrake 3y agoLOL@ the visual. “Ugh, these private jets are so expensive these days!” as he buys a King Air. A lot of people just don't get it: Tickets for major sporting events and concerts are luxuries for the rich, exactly like private jets. They are supposed to be unaffordable. I don’t know where this idea came from that a middle class family is supposed to just be able to afford live Taylor Swift tickets. This isn’t 1970. If artists price them below what they are worth, they are going to sell out to (mostly) scalpers in 200 milliseconds. If they price them at what they're worth, people grumble and complain about how expensive they have gotten, but that doesn't stop people from buying them, so there is no downward pressure on the price.
- fuzzfactor 3y ago>If they price them at what they're worth, people grumble and complain about how expensive they have gotten, but that doesn't stop people from buying them, So by now they're pricing them way more than they are worth, and people are buying it regardless, so there's still further upside :\
- HumblyTossed 3y agoThis is why we are so divided as a nation. Politicians corporations have been attacking consumers and citizens since the Powell Memo. We have no true fourth estate.
- nebula8804 3y agoWe technically do, but its behind a Substack/Youtube premium paywall. Its individual reporters going out and reporting on stories but needing people to cover their costs. Only people who can afford to support them do so and in a way they are paying for that journalism so they can have it. I suspect this is coming for many thing that AI will automate. In the future rich people will have human performers performing for them only while everyone else has to make do with AI generated slop.
- FireBeyond 3y agoSo true. Disclaimer, I haven't lived there full time since 2006, but back then one of my points of pride about living in Australia was the idea that you could go to the pub with people of opposite political/social persuasions and have a positive/light/good natured talk, debate, argument about them with such things over some beers. Here in the US, now though? There are huge swathes of people who will say, with all seriousness, "I'd rather be dead than be friends with a liberal/etc." It's so polarized. Not just teasing/smart ass as outright abusive labeling.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> They didn’t understand that people’s willingness to pay uncomfortably high prices was the entire reason tickets were so expensive. this is something I found weird about how inflation was politicized. One group said “its corporations being greedy, exclusively!” another group said “its the stimulus money in everyone’s hands, exclusively!”, centrists would say “supply chain disruptions!” but…. capital misallocations are expected in any economic school of thinking? this means all of those politicized scapegoats are expected factors? the part nobody wants to hear is that if you still begrudgingly bought overpriced necessities instead of starving to death in the street, then yes, you contributed to inflation. congratulations. if corporations raised their prices and profits stayed the same, that would be the most equalized outcome. if profits went down then there would be a case for attempting greed and failing, and if it was for withholding a necessity that would be a real case worth scrutiny! but since they raised prices and profits went up, despite that combination being what really pissed people off the most, it means that the buyers … had more money… from… somewhere. hmmm….
- ttt11199907 3y agoOr used money they had saved. Or would otherwise save...
- yieldcrv 3y agoYes that, or traded up in their brokerage account, or didnt pay rent with, or didnt pay their student loans for 3 years with, or collected unemployment + amped up state benefit for a year plus while not paying those other things But about those savings: nothing about our economy is about rewarding savers, every single aspect of monetary and fiscal policy is to promote transactions in the economy If not to another person for consumptive reasons, they want savings to go into assets If you want to save in its currency the governments will tax you the most, up to 55% if you’re self employed anywhere Americans have a 1/3rd chance of living If you do what the government is pointing at with big blaring neon signs, you’ll often get taxed 0% and be paid a tax rebate for doing do.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
- novok 3y agoHumans love drama. The news is mostly an entertainment medium. When your on the other side, talk about something with nuance and suck the drama out of it, you see that nobody really cares to read it compared to the dramatically colored version. Which means less ad revenue and thus less money. It's the same supply & demand you are talking about here. I've seen it when I've written tweets, write it dramatically, engagement everywhere, write it with nuance, nobody engages.
- AviationAtom 3y agoLife hack: go to the box office to buy your tickets. Now suddenly they're half off.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIf only. Climate pledge arena (Seattle), for example, will only sell tickets with all the Ticketmaster fees at their own in person box office, which has to be collusion, but basically the add on fees (many of which are kicked back to event organizers as simply a stealth ticket price increase) can’t be avoided.
- brayhite 3y ago> I’m equally surprised at how few people seem to understand supply and demand has influence on prices. Whenever this comes up about athletes and musicians, I say the same thing. I’ve watched friends lament how much money quarterbacks get compared to “heroes” aka police officers, military, firefighters, etc… yet vote against tax increases and buy sports jerseys.
- bonton89 3y ago> I watched the same thing happen at the grocery store earlier where a couple picked up a package of steaks, lamented that it was going to cost them X hours of work, and then threw them in the basket anyway. It’s like large parts of the population are on purchasing autopilot and the price barely matters. I used to think the shopping mall full of zombies in Dawn of the Dead was just a hamfisted critique of consumerism. But after all the complaining and not much doing I see Americans doing I think if you reanimated our corpses they would mostly go right back to shopping in a literal sense.