5 ms·
I just got back from vacation in Japan. It’s completely unsurprising that American mid-skill workers are worse at cooperating on delicate large scale manufactur
by rayiner 3y ago
I just got back from vacation in Japan. It’s completely unsurprising that American mid-skill workers are worse at cooperating on delicate large scale manufacturing than Japanese ones. The culture and habits of a country’s population makes a difference, and the coarsening of Americans has been quite apparent to me over the last 30 years. I bet this delta between US and Japanese workers wouldn’t have existed in 1960.
- kranke155 3y agoWhat? Really? You think the gap between 1960s American workers and Japanese workers was smaller?
- electriclove 3y agoIt was still wide then but even wider now.
- appleiigs 3y agoEspecially with the US social media trend of anti-work and quiet-quitting
- dingnuts 3y ago> the coarsening of Americans has been quite apparent to me over the last 30 years sorry, the what of Americans?
- pfisherman 3y agoI know! Who has ever thought of Americans as a particularly refined bunch? I know that we don’t think of ourselves that way.
- rayiner 3y agoHow old are you? When my family came to northern Virginia in 1989, it was quite polished, conformist, and orderly. The George H.W. Bush East-coast WASP culture still dominated. The current generation of “think for yourself” “don’t let anyone tell you what to do” kids was percolating through the education system, but they were not yet running anything. You can still see pockets of this. I was in Salt Lake City a couple of years ago and it was amazing. I was also in Iowa, and the older folks were pretty orderly, but you can see among the younger folks that southern redneck culture has been spreading.
- bart_spoon 3y agoSalt Lake City/Utah is rapidly losing that culture as well.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago> It’s completely unsurprising that American mid-skill workers are worse at cooperating on delicate large scale manufacturing than Japanese ones. Watch the 1986 movie "Gung Ho" starring Michael Keaton, about a Japanese car company opening a fab in the US. It's amazingly witty and funny. The gist is that Japanese workers (and Asians in general) are expected to sacrifice their personal life for the good of the company with all the downsides that incurs for them, while American workers want to do the bare minimum at work and also expect to be paid significantly more than workers in Asia (duh!). In the globalized world of today (let alone the 1980's), manufacturing is a race to the bottom in terms of cost where you need to squeeze your labor as much as you can to keep costs down, and high income countries like the US, can't compete, nor do they want to because they have better options to pump up their GDP, like printing USD. So why do we keep discussing this over and over again? Working in factories competing with Asia kinda sucks for the 21 century wealthy westerner so they don't want to do it like in Asia, which is what it takes to keep prices low and consumers happy. So opening factories under these conditions seems like you're setting yourself for failure form the start.
- rayiner 3y ago> So why do we keep discussing this over and over again? Working in factories competing with Asia kinda sucks for the 21 century wealthy westerner so they don't want to do it like in Asia, which is what it takes to keep prices low and consumers happy What’s the alternative for your average American? They don’t want to work like Asians in a factory, but they also don’t want the dead-end service jobs that are the alternative in an economy where the real productive work is done overseas.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoGoing into finance/tech or blue collar jobs if you don't want to go into debt. Have you seen how much plumbers/electricians/handymen earn? You don't need a university degree to earn good money.
- bemmu 3y agoYou would also enjoy "American Factory" (2019). It's a documentary about a Chinese company taking over an old General Motors factory and hiring Americans to work there.
- Nokinside 3y agoMaybe it's not just the wage cap. There is plenty of semiconductor industry in the US but it's differently specialized and they compete for the same pool of engineers. Nvidia, AMD or Broadcom don't have fabs, but they hire engineers from the same pipeline as fab companies. It's few years since I was hiring EE majors in the US, but it felt that skilled people with EE master's are harder and harder to find every year. I think USC and CMU are the only ones that produce quantity and quality. MIT, Stanford, and Berkley produce quality but not quantity.
- selimthegrim 3y agoCaltech?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Nokinside 3y agoIf I remember correctly Caltech is in the quality over quantity group as well. Something like 100 - 150 graduates per year. Here is some data: CHIPPING AWAY ASSESSING AND ADDRESSING THE LABOR MARKET GAP FACING THE U.S. SEMICONDUCTOR INDUSTRY https://www.semiconductors.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/SIA_July2023_ExecSummary.pdf https://www.semiconductors.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/SI... >67,000, or 58%, of new jobs across manufacturing and design will risk going unfilled by 2030. Another nugget from Fig 6: More than half of the MS graduates in semiconductor-related engineering fields are foreign and 80% of foreign Master’s leave the U.S. People in the US keep asking "Should I go to college?" and "Who needs calculus?"
- bsder 3y ago> It's few years since I was hiring EE majors in the US, but it felt that skilled people with EE master's are harder and harder to find every year. Semiconductor pay is dogshit compared to software. And everything is going to be in the office at whatever crap city has the fab--no remote work for you. Any EE smart enough to be good at stuff for a fab is smart enough to GTFO to software. The solution: cough up some damn cash. I have to use my microscope to go hunt for the world's tiniest violin when I hear companies complaining about hiring EEs.
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y ago>I bet this delta between US and Japanese workers wouldn’t have existed in 1960. There was a larger delta then because US workers were much more skilled than Japanese ones in 1960
- ReflectedImage 3y agoBut Japan has a collapsing population due to said work ethic, which is a far more serious problem in the long run.
- ohnoitsahuman 3y agoSo does America. We've disguised it with massive immigration.
- radiator 3y agoI agreen that also in America the population is collapsing, but I don't believe it is because of the work ethic.
- rayiner 3y agoHas the Japanese work ethic gotten more intense since 1950, when their birth rate was well over three children per woman? I suspect the proximate cause of the drop is the hysteria about overpopulation that gripped all Asian countries in the 1960-1990s. The governments there raised two generations of people socialized to believe that having too many kids was bad for the country. Japan and Korea never had anything as barbaric as China’s one-child policy, but the government heavily propagandized population control during the second half of the 20th century. They imposed taxes on families with more than two kids, heavily promoted abortion and sterilization, etc.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoJapan has the highest fertility rate in asia
- reducesuffering 3y agoNot even close. One, Asia is a big place and includes countries like Pakistan with 3.56 fertility rate, and two, if you meant East Asia, North Korea has 1.8 tfr to Japan's 1.3.
- triceratops 3y ago
- userbinator 3y agoIn 1960, the perception of consumer goods quality was entirely the opposite between US and Japan than it is today. "Made in Japan" was considered the same as "Made in China" today.
- spywaregorilla 3y agoYeah. On the broader level, look at the transit system of Tokyo. So many different companies cooperating so closely and making investments for the public benefit. Unfathomable in the US.