4 ms·
Zero-rupee note
- bigyikes 3y agoHere in the U.S. we have our own zero-value currency called the “penny”. Strangely, our own government mints these things - no NGO required.
- Teknomancer 3y agoNot quite, they're actually a NEGATIVE value currency. U.S. currency production is funded by the federal budget, supported by taxpayer dollars, and offset by seigniorage revenue. The cost of producing the U.S. penny, exceeds its face value. The GOVT. explain that this loss is recovered through the concept of seigniorage. Seigniorage is the difference between the face value of money and the cost to produce it. For the U.S. Mint, which produces the penny, the overall profit comes from the entire spectrum of coin production, not just the penny. Since our penny results in a loss, other denominations like dimes, and quarters, are produced at a cost lower than their face value, generating profit. So this profit helps offset the losses from penny production. So the overall seigniorage generated from the other denominations theoretically covers the cost of producing a negative value coin.
- gedy 3y agoMaybe they should mint them in China
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aristus 3y agoThe US stopped minting pennies last year.
- jezzamon 3y agoThat's not true. As someone who is slightly invested just because I hope to see governments make logical decisions, I would like that to be the case but no the US is still making pennies
- aristus 3y agoAh, you're right. They announced they would but Congress didn't act. https://catalog.usmint.gov/proof-set-2024-24RG.html?cgid=annual-sets#full-description https://catalog.usmint.gov/proof-set-2024-24RG.html?cgid=ann...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- omoikane 3y agoMaybe you are thinking of Canada, which stopped in 2012. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_(Canadian_coin) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penny_(Canadian_coin)
- ipython 3y agoEven 30+ years ago when I lived overseas on military bases, change was not given in pennies on the base exchange as it was too expensive to ship them (as I was told). Instead your change was rounded to the nearest nickel.
- sneak 3y agoIf only we could use these here in the US to pay speeding tickets issued on the 29th of the month.
- op00to 3y agoExplain how committing an offense and having to pay the legally established fine is similar to the corruption mentioned in the article. Slow down and you won’t get fined.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ticket_quota https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ticket_quota
- jrockway 3y agoI mean, the ticket quota doesn't involve giving speeding tickets to people driving under the speed limit. If the sign says 35, drive 35, and you're good.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoI'm sure they could then fine you for obstructing traffic for driving too slowly. Or for indicating too early, or too late. Or for not keeping enough distance from the vehicle in front of you. Or because you used your horn. Or for not using your horn perhaps. If they just kept following you, sooner or later you'd make a mistake. Ticket quotas have been discontinued or made illegal in many places.
- op00to 3y agoDo you believe you are somehow above the law, and immune from punishment later in the month? I’m confused by your response.
- Kim_Bruning 3y ago
- opaquej 3y agoWe cleverly just ensured any amount of our currency is worthless here in South Africa
- hilux 3y agoCoincidentally some Indian brothers were responsible for that as well!
- pietro72ohboy 3y agoCare to share more details?
- layer8 3y agoIt enables using the reduce function to accumulate Rupees.
- durag 3y agoI read the article twice but I'm having a hard time imagining how these are supposed to work. How does showing the note to the person that is trying to get bribed differ from just telling them it's wrong and that you won't do it? Usually in those situation you don't really have a choice, like when a cop stops you in the middle of the night. Is it meant to be given in a discrete way, so that the false note is discovered after the supposed bribe?
- MontagFTB 3y agoAs a giver of one of these notes, I would imagine you have decided to stand against bribery no matter the outcome of the scenario where it is given. Hopefully reason wins out and the situation ends amicably. To address the bribery problem, though, there’s a sense where you have to be okay with things getting worse before they get better. It seems to me the note is a socially well known form of protest, which may go down better than a direct interaction.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sonofhans 3y agoThis is describing a different culture, so your expectations are being confounded. In places bribery is truly pervasive, paying bribes is a habit. You see your parents do it, you see how everyone around you accepts it. Indian (very broadly — this is a stereotype) culture can be less individualistic than the USA, and this makes it even harder to say no to things like this. It’s like tipping, in the USA — so pervasive that it’s invisible. And these days with digital point-of-sale systems, you have to take affirmative action _not_ to tip, and people in line around you can see, so the social pressure is enormous. So the note is proof that the person not paying the bribe is not alone, that they are part of a movement, that their actions are acceptable to at least some portion of their society. This makes is feel safer, and puts the onus on the briber to either escalate or to back down. It also relies on the sense of shame of the briber. Since bribes are commonplace, some civil servants depend on them for their livelihood, or at least their lifestyle. Confronted with the evidence of a social movement saying that their actions are not ok, they’re more likely to feel some shame, versus just feeling anger at a random citizen confronting them.
- op00to 3y agoWhy not simply bash the person over the head when they give you one of these notes?
- StockHuman 3y agoBecause they're presently employed, and a missed bribe is not worth their career.
- selimthegrim 3y agoA District Magistrate used to basically have the power of life and death.
- einpoklum 3y ago"One does not simply..." bash public officials over the head.
- SushiHippie 3y agoThere is also the zero euro note https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/0-Euro-Schein https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/0-Euro-Schein
- przemub 3y agoThough it's not anticorruption but for souvenir purposes. I have quite a few of them from various tourist attractions.
- alwa 3y agoSo have I! I’m puzzled but delighted by how widespread they are-and in fact I’m personally aware of vending locations in several places not reflected on the official map [0]. [0] http://www.euro-souvenirscheine.de/map.php http://www.euro-souvenirscheine.de/map.php
- amelius 3y agoNow we only need an infinite euro note. It will be fun paying with it and getting change back.
- hcs 3y agoThere's also the Greater Japan Zero Yen Note https://www.moma.org/collection/works/136620 https://www.moma.org/collection/works/136620 (The background to these is a complex of art projects and a court case, but it came to mind)
- captn3m0 3y agoHaving lived in India all my life, I’ve never seen one of these notes, or known anyone who used these. They are not part of the cultural zeitgeist - no films or shows that have them for eg. The only time I’ve seen them mentioned is in news reports about their existence as a campaign, never actual usage. Another interesting campaign around corruption is ipaidabribe.com to gain some data around this. Unfortunately, both giving and taking bribes is illegal, thus you need anonymity for reports resulting in a lower data quality. To fix that, there’s proposals to make it legal to pay “harassment bribes” (the ones where the bribe giver does not gain undue advantage). > Giving complete immunity to the bribe-giver would ensure higher reporting and co-operation of the giver in bringing to justice the bribe taker. The present law acts as a deterrent to reporting of bribery. https://prsindia.org/theprsblog/should-bribe-giving-be-legalized https://prsindia.org/theprsblog/should-bribe-giving-be-legal...
- darkflame91 3y agoIn a nutshell, the government does not differentiate between bribery and blackmail. "Harassment bribes" is blackmail, plain and simple.
- paulddraper 3y ago> “harassment bribes” (the ones where the bribe giver does not gain undue advantage) Isn't that the point of the bribe? Why else would they pay it?
- dotnet00 3y agoHarassment bribe sounds more like if an official were running some sort of unofficial protection racket. But feels like it'd be absurd to punish the bribe giver for that already, considering that the protection racket itself would be illegal. This paper [1] seems to use the term to describe bribes given to obtain things you're already legally entitled to, which makes a bit more sense. There's an old Indian meme about pensioners having to pay a bribe to get their monthly payment for instance. [1] https://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/50335.html https://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/50335.html
- 3y ago
- vinay_ys 3y agoLooks like a bogus PR propaganda wikipedia link.
- amai 3y agoIndia should use these notes to pay for Russian oil and gas nowadays.
- teitoklien 3y agoThey use the same notes that the united states[2] and europe[1] uses right now to pay for russian gas instead. [1](https://youtu.be/bJusZyN-yn8?si=Yq3jPFo7Pq2xF_Yd https://youtu.be/bJusZyN-yn8?si=Yq3jPFo7Pq2xF_Yd.) [2](https://youtu.be/bMTEBoapjbY?si=fo5ZrtETxLociDES https://youtu.be/bMTEBoapjbY?si=fo5ZrtETxLociDES)
- viewtransform 3y agoOr they could just use dollars like the U.S. is doing. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/climate/enriched-uranium-nuclear-russia-ohio.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/climate/enriched-uranium-...
- instagraham 3y agoThis is quite old and outdated but just to engage with it : It defeats the whole purpose of a bribe, doesn't it? If officials were gonna be intimidated by a note, there are probably other recourses that would've done the job. Except none of them have. Officials are obviously aware that bribery is illegal. It's the idea that they "can get away with it" that needs challenging. If it's true, then the agency of the citizen is minimal; it's the agency of the relevant watchdog that needs strengthening. > Satindar Mohan Bhagat, an Indian expatriate who is a physics professor at the University of Maryland and the director of Association for India's Development, Inc. US, is credited with originating the concept of the zero-rupee note in 2001 I appreciate the sentiment, but it really reflects the disconnect between people who don't live in India and people who do. There is hardly a single bribery situation where this would be useful. The only cure to bribery is knowing more powerful people than the corrupt official - ie, bribery won't work on the elite and well-connected, unless the official is a fairly significant fellow. In an era where arbitrary income tax raids, "anti-national" accusations or just plain old Kafkaesque "punish them with more process" recourse are what meets people who challenge the regime...hard to see a valueless note gaining traction. If anything, it's a free pass for the official to get you accused of counterfeiting notes. Will it pass it court? no. but you'll be in jail for months before you see a judge. perhaps forever.
- hilux 3y ago> it really reflects the disconnect between people who don't live in India and people who do As well as the disconnect between academics and the real world.
- darkest_ruby 3y agoI wonder if '5th pillar' is an allusion to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_column https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_column
- anandchowdhary 3y agoGrowing up in India, we learned that the four pillars of democracy are the Legislature, the Executive, the Judiciary and the Media. The nonprofit presumably is saying that they/nonprofits are the fifth pillar.
- uptownfunk 3y ago[flagged]
- pimlottc 3y agoThis was introduced in 2007 under a previous administration. It has nothing to do with any specific leader.
- Iwan-Zotow 3y agoIndian Zero-rupee note vs mine א-null coin
- guru4consulting 3y agoI volunteered for 5th Pillar many years ago and yes, the zero rupee note worked on many occasions. When any corrupted government official sees this note, they don't want the potential trouble of fighting with an activist organization like 5th pillar. They would just process the request without getting bribe and simply move on to prey on other innocent, helpless victims waiting in the queue. Of course, this worked only in the lower level of government offices like getting certificates, driving licenses, etc.