5 ms·
A close friend of mine went down the ChatGPT medical rabbit hole last year. He was disagreeing with his doctors and getting deep into supplements and unproven m
by Aurornis 3y ago
A close friend of mine went down the ChatGPT medical rabbit hole last year. He was disagreeing with his doctors and getting deep into supplements and unproven medical theories.
ChatGPT was instrumental in convincing him that he was correct and his doctors were wrong. He would post his ChatGPT conversations as proof, but we could see that his prompts were becoming obvious leading questions.
He would phrase things like “Is it possible for {symptoms} to be caused by {condition} and could it be treated by {herbal product}?” Then ChatGPT would give him a wall of text saying that it’s possible, which he took as confirmation of being correct.
It was scary to see how much ChatGPT turned into a mirror for what he wanted to be told. He got very good at getting the answers he wanted. He could dismiss answers that disagreed as being hallucinations or being artifacts of an overly protective system. With enough repeat questioning and adjusting his prompts he could get it to say almost whatever he wanted to hear.
ChatGPT is rocket fuel for hypochondriacs. Makes WebMD look tame.
- ageek123 3y agoYou can do the same thing with regular web search.
- dartos 3y agoNot as quickly, easily, or convincingly.
- __loam 3y agoWeb search also wasn’t trained to be convincing to humans.
- visarga 3y agoWeb content was created to be enticing to humans. Most of it is just like flowers waiting for bees to come over.
- tsimionescu 3y agoMuch of it is also paying good money to make sure their pollen is in all the places that bees congregate.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoYou can probably even in worse ways find likeminded communities, which are likely much more unhinged than ChatGPT and lead you down a much darker path.
- npalli 3y agoNo, regular web search will just give you links. You have to click and go read the text. Putting together a comprehensive page of (seemingly) cogent arguments will need GenAI.
- mewpmewp2 3y agoPeople like this will go and click those pages, and seek out communities that will agree with their preconceived notions. ChatGPT results are just one mild manifestation of it. If and actually not if as an alternative they will find unhinged forums with echo chambers far worse than ChatGPT. At least ChatGPT isn't actively trying to rip you off to sell those supplements, and it usually adds disclaimers.
- neaden 3y agoI think the big difference is that with web search there will be a couple of reputable sources that will be at/near the top, like web MD and Mayo clinic. I can search and click one of those and be fairly sure it'll be accurate. There is no immediate way with chat gpt for me to know if it is reliable or crank mode.
- aurareturn 3y agoFYI, this is the same as people doing web searches. You’ll always find a place that agrees with you or says it’s possible.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoWith web searches the reputation of sources can at least be discriminated. (Which seems to even help GPT-4 ?)
- zarathustreal 3y agoTo be fair, this is also illogical, at least in a literal sense. It’s the Appeal to Authority fallacy. The reputation of the speaker doesn’t necessarily confirm or deny an assertion they make. Granted, most people tend to use some combination of both logic and heuristics in practice to determine their own understanding of the truth, perceived reputation being a fairly common one.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoSure, but so is listening to doctors(' websites). That's why there's a LOT of checks and balances around who gets to claim to be a doctor !
- tsimionescu 3y ago> To be fair, this is also illogical, at least in a literal sense Mostly in the same sense as arguments from induction are "illogical". Appeal to authority is essentially an inductive argument, and those are just as logical. Of course, they deal in probabilities rather than certainty, unlike deduction, but that doesn't make them illogical.
- zarathustreal 3y agoIt does make it illogical, in the same way that “dealing in probabilities” makes many other things illogical. Like, for example, crime statistics.
- rickysahu 3y agoIt it’s too bad that this type of data beyond the medical record is not tracked along side it. Although many anecdotal associations are probably not correct for the broad population, there are likely nuances in the patients history and lifestyle which do make some more basic interventions helpful. ChatGPT surely picks up on some trends but doesn’t have enough data about the people where those trends are effective. And of course its responses are highly subject to the prompts used
- photochemsyn 3y agoOne of the most basic prompts everyone should be using with questions like this is something like "provide detailed arguments both for and against the presented hypothesis."
- Williams565 3y ago[dead]
- kromem 3y agoThis works when the person evaluating can distinguish between the subject matter being correct or not. But the models can generate compelling devil's advocate positions, particularly when they confabulate supporting facts, which might appear convincing to non-experts.
- kromem 3y agoOne of the most interesting things for me over the past 18 months was seeing the difference between this behavior in GPT-3.5 and 4 (especially the early versions of it). You jumped from being extremely context sensitive to leading questions to almost ornery in its stubbornness and disagreement. Was one of the big early indicators to me significant differences were occurring between the two. I really do wonder just how harmful the disconnect has been between people hearing accurate praise about GPT-4 powered agents and then interacting with GPT-3 level agents and assuming the same competencies. GPT-3 was a very convincing text generator with lackluster reasoning capabilities, but 4 has significant reasoning capabilities and is less prone to parroting. But the majority of users are likely interacting with 3 because it's free. It's been very hard to explain to lay audiences the vast difference between two similarly branded products.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 3y agoWhile I agree the difference is vast, GPT4 still goes down the garden path a lot. If you're critical you can usually spot it's reason errors and challenge them, but it still also has enough issues that conversely I think in some areas there's a risk it'll be better at convincing people about the wrong things.
- kenjackson 3y agoI tried using your template for a few items and none gave misleading results. Here’s one example: Prompt: Can loss of vision be caused by a meniscus tear and treated with rose hips? Response: A meniscus tear is a knee injury affecting the cartilage that acts as a cushion between the thigh bone (femur) and shin bone (tibia). This type of injury typically affects mobility and stability of the knee, causing pain, swelling, and difficulty in moving the knee joint. There is no direct physiological pathway through which a meniscus tear could cause loss of vision. Vision problems are generally related to issues within the eye or neurological conditions affecting the optic nerves or brain, not injuries to the knee or other joints. Regarding the treatment with rose hips for a meniscus tear, while rose hips are known for their high vitamin C content and anti-inflammatory properties, they are not a recognized treatment for repairing a meniscus tear. They may potentially contribute to overall joint health and reduce inflammation, which could be beneficial in managing symptoms associated with joint injuries or conditions like arthritis. However, the primary treatments for a meniscus tear usually involve rest, ice, compression, elevation (RICE protocol), physical therapy, and in some cases, surgery, depending on the severity of the tear. If you are considering using rose hips or any other supplements for joint health or recovery from an injury, it's important to discuss this with your healthcare provider to ensure it's safe and appropriate for your specific situation. They can offer guidance on effective treatments for your condition and whether any supplements could support your recovery.
- sigmoid10 3y agoIs this GPT4? There's a good chance that the other person used the free 3.5 which is significantly worse in these aspects.
- kenjackson 3y agoYes. It’s GPT-4.
- melagonster 3y agohere is chatGPT 3.5: >A meniscus tear typically affects the knee and wouldn't directly cause loss of vision. However, there could be indirect factors such as reduced mobility or associated health issues that might impact eye health. Rose hips are not a typical treatment for meniscus tears or vision loss. It's important to consult with a healthcare professional for appropriate diagnosis and treatment options for both conditions.
- exitb 3y agoYou could make a religion out of this.
- staunton 3y agoPeople definitely will. There's also already a political party "lead" by an AI.
- harvey9 3y agoIf only Philip K Dick had lived to see so many of his stories play out in real life.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoNo don't
- renewiltord 3y ago[flagged]
- squigz 3y agoYou should give the HN guidelines a read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- renewiltord 3y ago[flagged]
- harvey9 3y agoThe friend was already consulting with doctors (plural). It is quite common for people with ambiguous presentations to take a long time to get a definitive diagnosis. Not surprising that some of them will be receptive to Cranks and GenAIs along the way. Some years ago I was on a neurology ward (for something straightforward) and my neighbour had been trying to get a diagnosis for his problems for about a year. He finally got one but it took a panel of senior medics in a top hospital in a big city to crack it.
- taneq 3y agoPlaying with the smaller free models, I’ve definitely found that they like to play along and mirror whatever you say. They’re great as a sounding board and active listener when you need to work through something, and they’re good for recalling facts that they know. They can be really useful when they glue together something you’re talking about and something relevant that they know. They’re terrible for anything that requires interoception or any kind of confidence estimation. They have no idea whether they’re recalling or confabulating.
- mateo1 3y agoWebMD lists facts. ChatGPT will output things that sound plausible. It's like comparing a medical textbook with the town lunatic. Not the same.
- seydor 3y agoChatgpt is a continuator, of course it will mirror input . But i m sure that someone is training the adversarial persuasion machine that will fund the next internet with ads
- hackerlight 3y agoIt's the examples curated for RLHF. Not its autoregressive nature.
- koliber 3y agoThe same thing happens with web searching. If you provide a leading question in the query you are more likely to get results that confirm the thesis. It’s surprisingly hard to ask open ended questions.
- JPLeRouzic 3y ago> He would phrase things like “Is it possible for {symptoms} to be caused by {condition} and could it be treated by {herbal product}?” Then ChatGPT would give him a wall of text saying that it’s possible, which he took as confirmation of being correct. If you mine Pubmed, you sometimes find literature with opposite claims. So if a LLM is trained on Pubmed/PMC, it will repeat that kind of garbage. You don't have to dig into "herbal products" it happens also in more conventional domains. I once even found that kind of contradiction in articles where the "main author" was the same in both publications. It was about ALS and the "main author" was a prominent scientist from the USA who probably never wrote nor even read any of these articles.