4 ms·
This appears in the biggest way in the financial sector. The US financial sector is now about 12% of employment. The US used to have a much simpler financial s
by Animats 3y ago
This appears in the biggest way in the financial sector. The US financial sector is now about 12% of employment.
The US used to have a much simpler financial sector, due to strict regulation.
* Banks could not do brokerage, and brokers could not do banking. (Glass-Stegall)
* Banks could only do boring stuff - transactions and loans.
* Utilities were mostly rate of return regulated, paid dividends, and had stable stock prices.
* Utility ownership was simple - there was a limit of 3 on ownership tree depth. (Utility Holding Company Act)
* Stocks traded much more slowly. There were no hedge funds, leveraged buyouts, private equity (which is leveraged buyouts under another name), or high frequency trading.
* Major companies could have only one class of voting stock, a NYSE rule. (Ford Motor was grandfathered in, being older than the NYSE).
* Home loans came mostly from savings and loan companies, which could pay higher interest rates than banks.
All that held from 1940-1980, arguably one of the greatest periods for the US. Then came financial deregulation.
The big effect was that if you wanted to make money, you didn't go into finance. You went into manufacturing.
- logicchains 3y agoYou missed a key thing: before the 70s there was a limit on the amount of cash in the system, but after the US jettisoned all ties to gold there was no limit on how much money the financial system can create. That's why the US dollar has seen more inflation in the past 50 years than in the 150 years before that.
- pama 3y agoWhy has the US seen so little inflation in the last 30 years?
- Spivak 3y agoLike ~100% inflation since 1994 sounds bad until you look at the 30 years prior to that which was ~380% inflation.
- pama 3y agoIt also doesn’t sound bad if one calculates that 2.4% annual inflation would exceed 100% over 30 years, and one considers that below about 2% is often harmful to the economy.
- geraldhh 3y ago'exponential doubling time' is the effect that devalues money by 3/4th's within a average 'work life' effectively putting a lower limit on profit in order to actually grow wealth
- BirAdam 3y agoIt saw tremendous inflation, just less than the 70s and 80s, and this due to two different things. First, companies just began making shitty products. Use glued and compressed pulp instead of wood, use fructose instead of glucose, use bleached and desiccated wheat, use chips instead of anything mechanical, use cheaper less pure and thinner metals, etc. in the realm of food there was also shrinkflation. Second, the USA exported much of its inflation as dollar imperialism. Today, making products of less quality is nearly impossible without sacrificing sales, and the USA has run out of countries to add to its empire while simultaneously having sanctioned enough countries that they’ve now formed their own trading bloque. All of this means that dollars are staying at home after printing and that dollars are starting to come home from the rest of the world. This follows after the government shutdown parts of the economy and concomitantly printed trillions. So, there’s now rather high inflation once again. Deregulation actually played less important a part of all of the financialization of the economy than did the transition to debt-based economics. The inversion of time in money is a dance with the devil, and the devil usually wins that dance.
- ted_bunny 3y agoWonder if anyone's written anything about the inevitability of the decline of profit.
- smallmancontrov 3y agoThey have, extensively, but it's not a story the Jedi would tell you.
- NhanH 3y agoCan you please share some authors or sources from the Empire that I can read?
- smallmancontrov 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_saving_glut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_saving_glut I may have exaggerated slightly, but it's a touchy subject because investment is the legitimate way by which rich people get paid for being rich, which is how class works in capitalist societies. The long term sustainability of investment supply / demand dynamics have deep implications for the legitimacy of this enterprise, its winners and losers, and the policies that prop them up (or don't).
- smallmancontrov 3y agoBecause everyone wants to bank/invest with the US. The money is being pushed in, not pulled in. If it were being pulled in, rates would have to be relatively high to pull it in, but they are not, so it is being pushed in. Why is money being pushed in? Put yourself in the shoes of a wealth-weighted non-US citizen. Wealth weighting is critical for understanding many aspects of economics yet systematically under-discussed to make the economy seem more altruistic than it is, but that's another story. So you have a bunch of money and you're outside the US. You want to preserve or grow your wealth, but your local government keeps devaluing the currency to pump the real economy, or hiking taxes, or there's a labor party that you think might get in power and do those things, or your government is literally called the Chinese Communist Party and is ideologically predisposed to confiscating your wealth tomorrow. Where do you put your savings? Some of it you still keep locally, for practical reasons, but the rest you invest abroad. Where? A peer country with the same issues? A developing country where investment never comes back? A small banking haven that will fold at the first sign of hard power? Or do you send it to the rabidly capitalist country with a 50 year track record of delivering investor returns and dozens of aircraft carriers and nuclear submarines to put between your bank account and the New Workers Collective of Yourlandia? That's right. You send it to the USA. What happens when the money lands in the USA? It pumps assets, because that's what the money buys, and it dumps exports, which now must compete with a literal money printer for access to talent and resources. Asset holders do great. People who sell services to the asset holders do OK. People who build shit for export, though, oof. Software, chip designs, and movies might be lucrative enough that they don't have to care (thus far) but in general, oof. "We used to make shit in this country, build shit. Now all we do is put our hand in the next guy's pocket." - The Wire That's exactly right, but it's extremely important to understand the macro that drives this so that you can understand how the macro affects you and make informed guesses about where it is headed. For example, I wouldn't bet on this dynamic collapsing tomorrow.
- devnullbrain 3y agoAnd all we have to show for it is a 1600% increase in GDP.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoAnd vastly exceeded the carrying capacity of the planet, leading to ecological and likely societal collapse. Thanks, capitalism!
- platformdecay 3y agoGDP ... denominated in fiat currency
- CSMastermind 3y agoInflation adjusted the US GDP grew from $5.30 trillion in 1970 to $22.67 trillion in 2023. Which is about a 4x increase in real terms. https://www.multpl.com/us-gdp-inflation-adjusted/table/by-year#:~:text=Dec%2031%2C%201972%205.91%20trillion%20Dec%2031%2C,1971%205.53%20trillion%20Dec%2031%2C%201970%205.30%20trillion https://www.multpl.com/us-gdp-inflation-adjusted/table/by-ye...
- VirusNewbie 3y agowhy would you adjust for inflation, what we are talking about would mean adjusting for M2.
- Dylan16807 3y agoWhy would you adjust for M2? Inflation exaggerates GDP growth. M2 doesn't. If you measure a country and M2 and GDP go up together, that's important to know, but you don't "adjust for M2" and pretend that GDP didn't actually go up.
- VirusNewbie 3y agoHmm, let me ask you this. It we double the money supply because say, banks are allowed to loan more to each other, but that money doesn’t make it to the average consumer, does CPI go up and does GDP go up?
- lr4444lr 3y agoThat's right. Because the productivity of the capitalist system has absolutely zero reason to be tethered to one or 2 elements on the periodic table that is mostly for jewelry.
- arp242 3y agoNot just US, seems to have happened fairly broadly across many countries. It's what I like to call "the financialisation of everything". "Everything" is perhaps a bit exaggerated, but it sounds nice. On a lot of these issues I feel we're all stuck on some rollercoaster ride that almost no one really likes, but also no one really has the courage to stop. Stopping would mean large changes, and our political systems have become so risk-averse and voters have become so unforgiving that nothing ever gets done.
- hackernewds 3y agoRight. Because it's exuberant margins. Starbucks and Delta both operate with their core businesses as adjacent to their financial business in accruing customer deposits now. Multiple corporations are now bundled loyalty programs - Amazon Prime, Uber One, Lyft Pink
- financypants 3y agoI want to recommend two books on this subject, of contrasting if not tangential subject matter. “Debt: the first 5000 years” by David Graeber and “This time is different” by Reinhart and Rogoff. They differ drastically in perspective, but both discuss capitalism with a very long- term view. To respond to the posts above, I want to say that it almost always feels like a rollercoaster ride when up close, and that financial “innovation” and liberalization usually leads to corrections of varying degrees.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoSpecific to the 1940-1980 period [and Debt: first 5k], I also really enjoyed Generation of Sociopaths. Lots of charts/graphs, which will leave you in doubt [regardless of your age]. The math checks out...
- crotchfire 3y ago> On a lot of these issues I feel we're all stuck on some rollercoaster ride that almost no one really likes, but also no one really has the courage to stop. As Will Emerson says in Margin Call: "Jesus, Seth. Listen, if you really wanna do this with your life you have to believe you're necessary and you are. People wanna live like this in their cars and big fuckin' houses they can't even pay for, then you're necessary. The only reason that they all get to continue living like kings is cause we got our fingers on the scales in their favor. I take my hand off and then the whole world gets really fuckin' fair really fuckin' quickly and nobody actually wants that. They say they do but they don't." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31300922 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31300922 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2f2kGHcdJYU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2f2kGHcdJYU https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1615147/characters/nm0079273 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1615147/characters/nm0079273
- pyuser583 3y ago1979 was a terrible year. My parents moan about it every Christmas, There was a widespread belief that things needed to change, and economic growth had to be a part of that. In the US, Reagan pushed deregulation. in the UK, Thatcher went to war with state owned industries. The USSR began experimenting with open policies. China embraced capitalist style economics. This was a world wide change.
- bumblebeedoo 3y agoThats because the GOP in tandem with OPEC inflated oil prices to cause a recession intentionally. They did it to sell deregulation.
- raffraffraff 3y ago1974 was pretty shitty in the UK too. The IRA was bombing pubs and shops several times a week, the coal miners union took advantage of the oil crisis to demand a massive pay hike, and went on strike, crippling the economy. The government couldn't give the miners union what they wanted because the other unions were watching and waiting, so instead the whole country switched to a 3 day working week and rationed street lighting (creating a kurfew). Personally, I think the 3 day working week is a great idea though.
- pyuser583 3y agoIn 1976, the UK had to be bailed out by the IMF.
- roenxi 3y agoThat isn't addressing the most obvious causes. * Since 1970 the US has been printing money and dumping it into asset markets. This makes it easier to make money in finance * US industrial policy has been to squeeze manufacturing talent, especially with environmental policy, which means it moves to foreign industrial hubs. Those 2 factors alone mean that manufacturing can't compete as a cash cow. It is rather obvious at this point that the big winners in the US are not going to be manufacturers. What is necessary to achieve success is to have a good-enough story for why the Fed should give you money, be that access to the bond market and the Fed's belief that pumping money into the bond market generates wealth or a good reason why the Fed should bail you out when you go bankrupt (Silicon Valley bank, the '08 crisis, etc). How is a manufacturer supposed to get in on that in the same way the banks do? This has surely been clear enough to the people involved since the mid 90s. You're also looking at a period (1940-1980) when every other industrial power had just had their factories demolished in WWII, so the US was in an unusually advantaged position to make money from manufacturing.
- throwaway345353 3y agoWho demolished the factories?
- jeffdn 3y agoThe United States is certainly not solely responsible for the demolition of all of the factories of Europe. Sure, they played a majority role in the bombing of Germany, Czechoslovakia, occupied France, and Italy, but that is not the full picture and you know it. The British bombed, the Germans bombed, the Soviets bombed, and massive ground campaigns carried on by all of the above with the profligate use of artillery didn’t help either.
- geraldhh 3y agothou 'strategic bombing' was more or less invented in ww2 and the circumstances do not change because others were involved. the us bombed their competition into submission and this continues to be a viable model to day, which maybe, could be disturbed by cyber.
- lr4444lr 3y agoMost of the rest of the developed world had to rebuild from the ashes of WW2 during that period as well, giving us a massive advantage in exports. We also didn't have those pesky environmental regulations weighing everything down.
- dnissley 3y agoNot sure I understand how this relates to the article? Which problems are banks attempting to preserve that they are the solutions for?
- geraldhh 3y agodistrust between individuals
- nmca 3y agoCowen has a counterpoint that whilst finance has grown as a proportion of GDP it has remained very close to 2% as a proportion of wealth, which honestly seems pretty reasonable.
- Animats 3y ago"Proportion of wealth" - What does that even mean for finance?
- abigail95 3y agothis is a bunch of spooky correlations and conspiracy style "just pointing out facts" thinking. show me a causal relationship between the depth of utility ownership, the percentage of employment being in the financial sector, and the problem described in the article. please.
- crotchfire 3y ago> All that held from 1940-1980 ...right up until the Nixon Shock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- noobermin 3y agoYou're getting downvoted by the fintech crowd I'd assume. May be an argument for them is they see themselves as more manufacturing than finance, perhaps.