4 ms·
Quality is expensive. Even a fairly minor improvement in basic Quality can double the cost of implementation. But, in my opinion, it’s absolutely required for
by ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago
Quality is expensive. Even a fairly minor improvement in basic Quality can double the cost of implementation.
But, in my opinion, it’s absolutely required for complex systems, and complex problems often need complex answers, despite the wish for simplicity (which can sometimes happen, but less frequently than people might think).
I had an online back-and-forth, the other day, with someone that didn’t seem to be able to grasp the fundamental concept (actually thousands of years old) that big things tend to be aggregates of lots of small things, so it’s a good idea to make the small things high Quality, as you go. It was interesting. One of those things that seems obvious, to me, but I guess isn’t, to a lot of folks.
It reminded me of that “Eat Less, Move More” SNL skit, where people can’t understand that eating less, and moving more, is a great way to lose weight. There must be some shiny tech, or popular book. You can’t simply take care in every little job, so the big ones work out.
I do think that the current lack of personal investment, by engineers, in their vocation, doesn’t help. When someone only stays at a company for a couple of years, or less, that’s enough time to do a half-assed job, but not enough time to be responsible for maintaining it. It incentivizes churning out a lot of shoddy work, quickly.
That’s not really the fault of the IC. The executives are the ones that establish the corporate culture, and retaining talent doesn’t seem to be high on anyone’s list, these days.
- bayindirh 3y agoQuality needs appreciation and an eye for it. It's abstract yet infinitely enhancing. I'll happily pay more for higher quality software and higher quality goods. At the end, I have my peace of mind, things work the way they should, in a predictable manner. This also means that quality is boring (and boring is good). As you said quality is expensive, and is hard. Because needs iteration, blood, sweat and tears. And masses of engineers (of any kind) is in this for money, not for their passions. To be able to build quality $SOMETHING, you need to go slow, pour yourself in the thing you're building. You need to think like a craftsman, and be one with the thing you're building. Companies want "MVP in 48 hours, product in 4 months, exit in 12 months". So, people glue what they can find together to build, without any regard for quality (or anything really). This kind of environment is not conductive to quality, but only littering.
- nothercastle 3y agoHigh quality is orthogonal to high feature count. I think in most industries you need to balance it at least somewhat to keep up with the feature leader
- bayindirh 3y agoBBEdit, Sublime Text, OmniGraffle, Pixelmator, Darktable, Forklift (file manager), KDE (as a whole), yt-dlp, curl, wget, freemind, mindnode (and I can add many more) are strong counter examples to this. They are high quality, packed with tons of features and are leaders or give leaders a decent run for their money. The most important thing is all of them go slow. Without rushing. They don’t race. They release when they are done. And it shows. Ah, also there’s CameraBag, which spent their last year optimizing first, adding more features second.
- nothercastle 3y agoThe tools you listed don’t have to make a profit they are open source and can go slow.
- bayindirh 3y agoI carefully selected the set. Half of them are closed source. A couple of them is pretty pricey.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> BBEdit, Sublime Text, OmniGraffle, Pixelmator... ForkLift Those are all for-profit. I have paid for BBEdit for over 30 years. Also, OmniGraffle is a standard tool, and I have been paying for that, since 1.0. Same with ForkLift. I don't think that any of these are actually open-source.
- graemep 3y agoAs far as I can see all are either open source or developed by small companies. The problem is the incentives large public companies have are to do well short term, keep investors happy and get the management their bonuses this year, or maybe next.
- ozim 3y agoI would hook on quality is expensive take. Lots of people write lengthy posts nagging about quality and usually these people work in qa or software dev where they get paid for it and mor quality is more work safety for them. But no one wants really put their own money. Where fixing even trivial bug is 1h of work because someone has to write requirements, someone has to code it, someone has to check if it works and did not break something else. 1 hour on b2b market is $70 or $100 - no one is going to pay that to fix small issue. I drive 10 year old car it has some issues and if I would go to car mechanic it would be $50 an hour - even if it would take 1 hour to fix all I am not willing to pay for that. No one wants to pay for 100% quality.
- pylua 3y agoWorse is that no one wants to pay to keep the domain knowledge alive. The project finishes, the team disbands which makes maintenance cost more.
- MyFedora 3y agoYeah sure, really expensive until the accumulated tech debt prevents any productive work from being done. Correct a typo? Sorry boss, takes at least 1 year, shit hits the fan when you change labels like that (the truth). How much is your salary? Oh ok... let's not do that then. Managers throw more people at the problem to improve productivity, only for the new people to need training. Okay, let's have the new people develop everything from scratch. Wow, that's fast... initially, but they throw code quality out of the window to reach feature parity asap, crippling productivity in the process again. Rinse and repeat. Or, or... give people the time to improve things. Nobody wants to pay for quality in software until they realize how much it costs them to neglect quality. Unfortunately, some people never realize, cut their losses after a dozen rewrites, and launch the current half-assed iteration. No, it didn't work out for them.
- ozim 3y agoThen they drop project and start new one. Software is not endangered species to protect it by all means. When I am done with my car I just get a new one. Yes there are software projects that need high quality but it is not 90% of cases.
- Terr_ 3y ago> It reminded me of that “Eat Less, Move More” SNL skit Or another skit "Don't buy stuff you cannot afford." https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=R3ZJKN_5M44 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=R3ZJKN_5M44
- Anotheroneagain 3y ago[flagged]
- dolni 3y ago> Quality is expensive. Even a fairly minor improvement in basic Quality can double the cost of implementation. Quality is expensive, but lack of quality is also expensive. Low-quality software causes customer churn, increases implementation time for new features, causes more incidents, negatively affects your reputation, etc. Moving fast is the right thing sometimes. But overall, quality is the way.
- mmcnl 3y agoYou're absolutely right. But if you don't measure churn, time-to-market, incidents, brand reputation, etc., then you will never see the benefits of investing in quality. So it becomes easy not to do it.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Moving fast is the right thing sometimes. But overall, quality is the way. There must be some sweet spot between poor and perfect where (a) the quality is good enough to prevent greater than expected churn and (b) increasing quality anymore is so expensive that the additional profit isn't worth it. When NASA sends a rover to mars, the launch/space travel costs are so high that they can justify investing heavily in quality. That balloons the price of course, and that limits the number of projects they can do. The goal then is to make higher quality cheaper, or to make higher quality unnecessary (e.g. through cheaper launch/space travel costs). I can't imagine it is much different for the software industry (where quality requirements are not as high as aerospace).
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI always think of BMW, as an example of that level. Mercedes is better, but a fair bit more expensive. Bentley, Lamborghini, etc., are inasnely more expensive. Toyota, Honda, etc. are decent quality, though not at the same level, but are a lot cheaper. Of all the companies I mentioned, Toyota probably makes the most money (I have not bothered to check the financials, so I could be wrong). I guess it depends on corporate mission.
- 3y ago
- mixmastamyk 3y agoYes, though I’d say high quality is expensive at first. Low quality is more expensive in the long term.