3 ms·
My point is that people are incorrectly using the term “populist” to describe people who simply oppose immigration and free trade. In that respect, I agree it’s
by rayiner 3y ago
My point is that people are incorrectly using the term “populist” to describe people who simply oppose immigration and free trade. In that respect, I agree it’s a category error.
I disagree that populism is merely a “vector for influencing politics.” That makes it sound like a choice or tactic. But oftentimes, particular issues just happen to break down along lines where people who can be described as “elite” converge on a view, while non-elites tend to adopt a different view.
For example in India, secularism is an idea championed mainly by elites, and largely opposed by the masses. Thats what makes opposition to secularism a populist viewpoint, not Modi’s choice to point that out.
- tptacek 3y agoSecularism is a policy platform. You can be a secular populist or a sectarian populist. It's important to understand that populism claims the support of "the masses", sometimes even in good faith, but the actual support of the "masses" isn't core to the strategy. A key part of popularism is acceptance of an agenda in its entirety. If you could just scope platforms down to the bits that everyone agreed with, you wouldn't need a term for it (though David Shor proposed one, "popularism".)
- leereeves 3y agoClearly, when there is real disagreement between elites and the masses, you can't "scope platforms down to the bits that everyone agreed with". In such a case, what would you call a political movement that embraced the position of the non-elites, not as a political tactic, but because actual support of the "masses" is core to the movement? Whatever word you would use for that, I think you'd understand Rayiner's post better if you replace populist with the word you prefer. If (and I'm not sure this is true) the "masses" do oppose globalism (worldwide) and secularism (in India), then there is something inherently ______ about those positions. This side discussion about the true meaning of the word "populist" only distracts from the more important question of whether the people's desires are actually being suppressed by an elite who control the levers of power and the channels of communication.
- tptacek 3y agoThe problem with populism is there's no one platform that captures the masses. It's very much like Spolsky's observation about how the 80% solution in software, and the fact that everybody has a different 20% of dealbreakers on top of that. To capture the core "popularist" stuff we all agree about, you have to be willing to compromise on that 20%. Populism is defined by not doing that.
- idlewords 3y agoI think you two have earned a special section of this tech forum where you can slug it out about politics in peace.
- leereeves 3y agoLike the comments on a post about a "Populist backlash against globalization"? That seems like an appropriate place to discuss politics.
- idlewords 3y agoI follow HN by user threads so I don't necessarily notice where the rayiner/tptacek walls of text are rooted.
- tptacek 3y agoFollow 'jcranmer. He's great.
- kasey_junk 3y agoIt’s the better way to follow comments. I wish the gui made it easier
- tptacek 3y agoAlso follow kasey!
- rayiner 3y ago> Secularism is a policy platform. You can be a secular populist or a sectarian populist. Except, in practice, secularism is a policy originating with and being championed mainly by western-educated elites like Nehru.
- tptacek 3y agoYou're fixated on bringing your own definition of "elite" into this conversation. Sometimes, a populist argument about who the elites are is plausible. Sometimes it isn't. But it's besides the point. There argument against populism isn't that there isn't some real "elite". It's that there's no singular "populace" aligned perfectly in opposition to that elite. Half the population is, say, 80% aligned with the "elite"; the other, 15%.
- rayiner 3y agoThe people pushing secularism in India (and Bangladesh) are undeniably an “elite.” They’re part of the 1-2% with college degrees, they’re often exposed to the west or even western educated, they work in industries where they have contact with the west, etc. my dad, who got a college education and then left the country, is a secularist. The other people from his village aren’t. The fact that some of the proles might agree or disagree with the elites for various reasons (e.g. Indian Muslims) is irrelevant. Indian Muslims don’t believe in secularism either, the elite view on secularism just happens to be beneficial to their situation as a religious minority in the country. That doesn’t change the fact that secularism originates in and is advanced by the elite. But remember, my point is that “populist” isn’t a good description of this. It’s common in politics to assign lower moral weight to the views of various groups—in India or Bangladesh, ideas of western origin are viewed as suspect. In America, anything supported by “Wall Street” or “the Harvard faculty lounge” is automatically questionable. Playing to that was a staple of ordinary liberal and conservative rhetoric throughout the 20th century. Thats not “populist.”
- tptacek 3y agoYou haven't established that populism isn't a good description of it. All you've said is that there's a definable elite that occupies a policy position in India. That's orthogonal. Occupy Wall Street was certainly a populist movement! Its slogan was a capsule summary of the whole concept of populism. They were the 99%! That they didn't in reality speak for all or even a majority of the 99% was just a detail.