3 ms·
Category error. Populism isn't an issue portfolio; there is left-populism and right-populism. Populism is a vector for influencing politics (specifically: it's
by tptacek 3y ago
Category error. Populism isn't an issue portfolio; there is left-populism and right-populism. Populism is a vector for influencing politics (specifically: it's the vector that rejects pluralism, divides the polity into "the people" and "the elites", and declares that a particular political agenda, in its entirety, represents the true will of the people).
If "traditional mindsets" are pursued by means of populism, it's a populist campaign. If not, it isn't. There is nothing intrinsically populist about anti-globalism, but, like many political agendas, it's easy to create a populist lozenge for it to get it down the polity's throat easily.
- jjjjj55555 3y agoWhat are the other possible vectors for influencing politics in a republic/democracy like the US. Now that I think of it, it seems like both sides are populist.
- importantbrian 3y ago> (specifically: it's the vector that rejects pluralism, divides the polity into "the people" and "the elites", and declares that a particular political agenda, in its entirety, represents the true will of the people) The elites vs the people distinction is usually the key characteristic of populism in most definitions. Populist movements also tend to be very anti-establishment. Many vectors for influencing politics don't involve viewing society as this battle between the people and the elites. For example, while it's true that left-wing populists exist in the US I wouldn't describe the current Democratic party as a populist party. It is more of an institutionalist party and they don't tend to attack elites, because most groups traditionally considered part of the elite support the party. This is in contrast to the current Republican party which very much casts itself as being opposed to the elite. All the rhetoric about battling the deep state and draining the swamp is very much populist.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoIt depends on your definition of elites. "Deep state" and "drain the swamp" is about attacking government elites but the same movement promotes less regulation and lower taxes for business elites.
- tptacek 3y agoIt doesn't matter who the elites are; it only matters that some notion of them exists. The key to populism is the claim that some political platform (left, right, religious or secular) represents the manifest will of the people in its entirety, and that any opposition to that platform is corrupt or elite-driven. If you're looking to understand the term by its opposition, the antonym of "populism" is "pluralism".
- jjjjj55555 3y ago> represents the manifest will of the people in its entirety, and that any opposition to that platform is corrupt or elite-driven It's funny how this starts to sound more and more like just Marxism.
- tptacek 3y agoNo, Marxism is an political platform. Populism obviously isn't Marxism; there is right-populism (which is currently the most popular form).
- jjk166 3y ago"Hey all the experts who have studied this phenomenon in depth suggest we should do this" "According to this religious text, this is how we should be living" "This will be good for the economy and put more money in your pockets" "If we don't do this, the terrorists win" "Think of the children" While it is easy to get people to support doing what they already want to do, people's opinions can also be swayed. Further, while populist movements try to present their positions as widely held by the majority, oftentimes that's a bluff. It's usually the case that populists are really just a vocal minority.
- jjjjj55555 3y agoThe condescension in your post is a good example of why someone might turn to "populism." A lot of people have lost trust in those experts and people who claim to know what's good for other people. They also don't appreciate being talked down to.
- jjk166 3y agoAny condescension you read in my post is imagined.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's entirely possible for two opposing sides in a polarized polity to both employ a populist strategy. How you'd see that happening is that the two sides would deliberately exclude moderates and centrists.
- leereeves 3y ago> the two sides would deliberately exclude moderates and centrists Which is exactly what's happening lately.
- tptacek 3y agoIf you say so. I'm a moderate (non-progressive) Democrat and feel perfectly at home in the party, but we don't have to agree. The "Democrat vs. Republican" thing is boring, and we won't get anywhere with it. But popularism vs. pluralism is a discussion we can have; there are left-populists to dunk on!
- leereeves 3y agoYou're not a politician so there's no need to for the party to exclude you. Moderates with actual power, like Kyrsten Sinema and Joe Manchin, have been excluded from the modern Democratic party. As Manchin said: "The bottom line is — will the middle speak up? Does the middle have a voice?"
- tptacek 3y agoI don't love the way Twitter treats Sinema or Manchin (Sinema I could take or leave though!) but they are objectively two of the most powerful people in the party. I don't think this is a winnable argument. Look at the 2020 candidate field, and look who won. Look at the track record for Justice Dems over the past 3 cycles. We have a strategy, and it's "win the suburbs". I'm fine with it.
- leereeves 3y ago
- rayiner 3y agoMy point is that people are incorrectly using the term “populist” to describe people who simply oppose immigration and free trade. In that respect, I agree it’s a category error. I disagree that populism is merely a “vector for influencing politics.” That makes it sound like a choice or tactic. But oftentimes, particular issues just happen to break down along lines where people who can be described as “elite” converge on a view, while non-elites tend to adopt a different view. For example in India, secularism is an idea championed mainly by elites, and largely opposed by the masses. Thats what makes opposition to secularism a populist viewpoint, not Modi’s choice to point that out.
- tptacek 3y agoSecularism is a policy platform. You can be a secular populist or a sectarian populist. It's important to understand that populism claims the support of "the masses", sometimes even in good faith, but the actual support of the "masses" isn't core to the strategy. A key part of popularism is acceptance of an agenda in its entirety. If you could just scope platforms down to the bits that everyone agreed with, you wouldn't need a term for it (though David Shor proposed one, "popularism".)
- leereeves 3y agoClearly, when there is real disagreement between elites and the masses, you can't "scope platforms down to the bits that everyone agreed with". In such a case, what would you call a political movement that embraced the position of the non-elites, not as a political tactic, but because actual support of the "masses" is core to the movement? Whatever word you would use for that, I think you'd understand Rayiner's post better if you replace populist with the word you prefer. If (and I'm not sure this is true) the "masses" do oppose globalism (worldwide) and secularism (in India), then there is something inherently ______ about those positions. This side discussion about the true meaning of the word "populist" only distracts from the more important question of whether the people's desires are actually being suppressed by an elite who control the levers of power and the channels of communication.
- 3y ago