6 ms·
> Abstract > The literature on populism is divided on whether economic factors are significant and robust causes of populism. To clarify this, we performed the
by bell-cot 3y ago
> Abstract
> The literature on populism is divided on whether economic factors are significant and robust causes of populism. To clarify this, we performed the first systematic review and meta-analysis of the evidence of a causal association between economic insecurity and populism. We combined database searches with searching the citations of eligible studies and recently published reviews. We identified and reviewed thirty-six studies and presented a concise narrative summary and numerical synthesis of the key findings. Although we found significant heterogeneity in several dimensions, all studies reported a significant causal association. A recurrent magnitude was that economic insecurity explained around one-third of recent surges in populism. We tested for publication bias by conducting a funnel-plot asymmetry test and a density discontinuity test of the distribution of t-statistics. We found significant evidence of publication bias; however, the causal association between economic insecurity and populism remains significant after controlling for it.
At the risk of dating myself...my memory* is that the #1 lesson of WWII in Europe was that grim economic insecurity ==>> really nasty governments ==>> lots of war and other evil-at-scale.
True?
*not direct memory, admittedly
- 082349872349872 3y ago> grim economic insecurity ==>> really nasty governments ==>> lots of war and other evil-at-scale. my personal view (pinko commie in my birth country but centre-right in my adoptive) is that "societies without grim economic insecurity" are public goods and hence governments should provide them.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoHope is the public good to be provided and defended. Without hope, there is no purpose nor future.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> "societies without grim economic insecurity" are public goods and hence governments should provide them. The question is how to do that. Some people argue that it's by providing competitive free markets. And that's often true, when the markets are actually competitive and free, but you can also have concentrated markets where the incumbents have captured the regulators, and that doesn't work. Some argue that transfer payments can reduce inequality, and that can also be true (e.g. UBI), but then many of the implementations try to provide specific services or limit what you can buy with them instead of providing fungible currency. Especially when those services are provided by a captured industry, and then they just end up as a subsidy for that industry, which can absorb the subsidies by raising prices. The problem is, when you have one of the degenerate situations as the status quo, people know that something is wrong and start clamoring for change without inherently understanding what change is necessary. And then it's easy for the exact forces that create problems and increase concentration of wealth to propose solutions that enrich themselves rather than addressing the issues. Which often makes it worse as those "solutions" accumulate, increasing overhead, inefficiency and the complexity that allows it to remain opaque and intractable.
- 082349872349872 3y ago> try to provide specific services or limit what you can buy with them instead of providing fungible currency I like our local safety net: it works by subsidising those who need it at tax time, but they acquire all their goods and services on the open market (avoiding distortion).
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt's kind of amusing the extent to which nominally opposing factions actually agree. Q: How do you help poor people? A: Make them less poor. The right says lower their taxes, the left says transfer payments, mathematically these are the exact same thing. The only real dispute is whether negative tax rates should be used, and de facto negative rates are the status quo and only a real dispute because attempts to make it explicit get muddied by the factions who don't want the problem solved. If housing is overpriced, instead of policies that would reduce the market price of housing (and so lower rents for landlords), they propose rent subsidies (so they get the money), or income-gated housing projects (so they can point to something nominally being done while the market price stays high). Which eats up the money that could have been used for transfer payments/tax cuts while it continues to flow to landlords. And likewise for healthcare costs -- instead of addressing the regulatory causes of high prices, the incumbents keep pushing government subsidies, so that the prices (i.e. their profits) can stay high at the expense of the customer/taxpayer. The fight isn't a question of tax cuts vs. a safety net. The fight is against industry incumbents who want to keep collecting high rents through regulatory capture.
- 082349872349872 3y agoA local advantage of not having a first-past-the-post system is that centre-right and centre-left parties not only exist but taken together are broadly representative, and hence do spend much of their time working together to find solutions which have been crafted less to be sound-bitey and more to be acceptable to wide swaths of the populace.
- jjjjj55555 3y agoI didn't see any clear definition of populism anywhere here. At present moment it seems to just be a pejorative against lower class people with right-wing leanings. It's also odd to me that they only look at the post-WWII period. Populism was widespread in Europe during the 1800s
- rayiner 3y agoUsing “populism” to describe traditional mindsets is a clever rhetorical trick. You don’t need a label to describe the desire of people to protect local industries and not have foreigners come live in their country. That’s just how most people in the world have felt historically, and how most people in the world still feel. If you look at China, most of the rest of Asia, Africa, the Middle East, etc., those things are no-brainers. What requires a label is the new thing. The new idea that embraces freedom of movement of capital, goods, and labor, across national borders. “Populism” is nothing more than the opposition to this new, unlabeled thing.
- bawolff 3y agoPopulism is not neccesarily protectionism. Its less about the specific policies as how they are made. Also its not like populism is a new term or idea. It goes back to Roman times at least.
- rayiner 3y agoPopulism isn’t new. But the ideas being called “populist” today wouldn’t have warranted that label even a few decades ago. It’s turned into a label for everyone who opposes globalized industries and mass immigration.
- jjjjj55555 3y agoAnti-globalist seems like a more precise term for what you're describing. It also avoids clashing with populist movements of the past, which dealt with issues other than those that you're describing.
- 3y ago
- huijzer 3y ago> grim economic insecurity ==>> really nasty governments ==>> lots of war and other evil-at-scale. I sort of agree, but it’s also a bit more nuanced than that (and of course more nuanced than what I write here. The world is incredibly complex and we simply never know in history where some event must inevitably have been followed by another or that something else could have happened under slightly different circumstances.) Hitler at the peak received only about 40% of the votes, but he got in because the autocracy thought he would not become much anyway and still hamper the autocrats opposition. Also not the whole of Europe was having nasty governments. Most were trying to appease the Nazi regime in the hope to avoid further escalation. Churchill, for example, was considered a war monger at that time since he didn’t trust Hitler and wanted to stop the appeasement politics. Also, in Eastern Europe the first causality arrow should be reversed. Really nasty governments caused economic problems in the Soviet. Not necessarily the other way around. Since there is currently a lot of capitalism hate going around, I’ll defend why the Soviet was nasty regime. The idea of Karl Marx for example was that capitalism is wage slavery and Marxism-Leninism was the only solution. So what they did in their fight against capitalism is to round up everyone who had too much capital. And to still get money into the goverment, farmers were enslaved. Next, factories received weird metrics and incentives, all centrally managed, which caused factories to often produce low quality products. In some cases the sum of the value of the products going into the factory was higher than the products coming out of the factory.
- karmakurtisaani 3y ago> Since there is currently a lot of capitalism hate going around, I’ll defend why the Soviet was nasty regime. Soviet regime is a terrible straw man to attack if you want to go against capitalism hate. Try Northern European social democracies instead.
- huijzer 3y agoI don’t know what you see around you, but I see a lot of complaints about the big capitalists, companies, and the poor labourers who are enslaved by wages; also in Europe (I live in Europe). That’s why I mentioned an earlier ideology which also hammered on the wage slavery and similar points.