4 ms·
> Our power grid is very reliable. Looking at availability information from “uptimed“, my home file server has been powered on for 99.97% of the time in the las
by bell-cot 3y ago
> Our power grid is very reliable. Looking at availability information from “uptimed“, my home file server has been powered on for 99.97% of the time in the last 14 years. That includes time spent moving house and a day when the house power was off for several hours while the kitchen was refitted!
> However, in December 2023 a fault with our electric oven popped the breaker for the sockets causing everything to be harshly powered off. My fileserver took it badly and one drive died. That wasn’t a huge issue as it has a redundant filesystem, but I didn’t like it.
> I decided I could afford to treat myself to a relatively cheap UPS.
Just from that, I'd say he for-sure should have avoided UPS's, and gotten a "real" surge protector. The "shockwave" from that high-amperage short is far more likely to have done the damage than the mere loss of power. And the output of cheap UPS's is often far worse than the input.
[Edit: And good surge protection is never a feature of cheap UPS's.]
- jeffbee 3y agoThe quoted material sounds like a poor analysis. It doesn't take into account all the times the UPS would have failed while the grid was fine. UPSs are not pure goods with no downsides that merely add to availability. Commercial UPS are very unreliable, bordering on a scam.
- Symbiote 3y agoIt also doesn't account for the fire risk — a cheap UPS is much more likely to catch fire than a PC / NAS.
- WWLink 3y agoYea, a disturbing amount of reviews on amazon for the lower end (still 1350/1500VA though!) UPSes contain words like "smoke" and "fire". My own experience with UPSes didn't involve smoke or fires, but it did involve remote equipment going offline for months until I had time to make a trip out to replace the UPS with a surge protector.
- gnuser 3y agoSine-Wave UPSs are the only thing I allow in my DCs for a reason! (don’t forget the generators either!!!)
- Night_Thastus 3y agoPure Sine-wave UPSs are massive overkill and offer no advantage for any normal consumer. If you have incredibly power-sensitive $100k equipment that needs protecting, maybe. But not for normal consumer electronics. None of them are that picky about the power.
- kcb 3y agoThat's not my experience. Modern power supplies in desktop PCs either don't work or trip up non Pure Sine wave UPSs. I don't know the technical specifics but it has to do with Active PFC on power supplies.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI've used square wave UPSs on my PCs for as long as I can remember with power supplies from varying manufacturers, I have never had a problem. I have heard this before but I suspect it's either a myth or it only was ever a problem with very rare combinations of poorly-made UPSs and poorly-made power supplies.
- wzdd 3y agoI was forced to change UPS relatively recently (a few years ago) because the cheap but not bargain-basement PSU on my computer didn't work with the non-sine-wave output of my UPS. Call them poorly-made if you like, but either I got unlucky or they're fairly common. Power supplies tend not to advertise their compatibility with non-sinewave power, but UPSes will certainly make it clear if they produce sinewave output. So the safe option is to get the UPS which gives the PSU what it's expecting.
- J_Shelby_J 3y ago
- criley2 3y agoWe recently upgraded to a whole house surge protector installed at the panel. They're not that expensive ($100-$200 around me, depending) and with the reduced quality of power we're seeing lately here and the damage it has done to our circuit breakers, it's become a necessity.
- da768 3y agoAnd after the UPS will inevitably fail to power on, he'll probably want to add an automatic transfer switch to the mix.
- ssl-3 3y agoCan you be more precise about how a high-amperage short circuit can produce a "shockwave" of a form that would be ameliorated by a "real" surge protector?
- bell-cot 3y ago> Can you be more precise... Apologies - I know enough to do long-winded hand-waving on the subject...but if you want precise and concise (and really accurate), you'll need to ask a real electrical engineer.
- javawizard 3y agoThis Wikipedia article may point you in the right direction: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltage_spike https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltage_spike I'm not an electrician by any means so take everything I saw with a grain of salt, but: in general, electricity flowing through a system has some amount of "inertia" (the technical term for this is inductance), and shutting off a circuit breaker will cause a brief voltage spike upstream of the breaker due to the flow of electrical current suddenly being forced to stop. Have you ever unplugged a running appliance from the wall and noticed a brief spark at the plug? That's the same effect: motors in general have high inductance and try quite hard to fight changes in current. It's bad enough that when designing circuits that switch power to inductive loads like motors, you have to include a flyback diode (read: one way valve) to allow a path for electricity to continue to flow internal to the load when the power is switched off, otherwise it will generate a voltage spike high enough to damage the switching circuit. Put another way: it's not the "high amperage short circuit" that causes the voltage spike; it's the rapid stop to said high current that happens when the circuit breaker realizes what's going on and trips.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThe inductance of your house's power lines shouldn't be very big, though, and computer power supplies have fat capacitors.
- ssl-3 3y ago
- Saris 3y agoI'm curious how a voltage spike would have gotten through the computer PSU conversion to DC, and then only damaged 1 drive somehow?
- dijit 3y agoit hit all the drives, but it’ll affect things unevenly
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoI assume the drive failed due to the power cycle, not due to electrical damage. Especially if it was 14 years old.