8 ms·
Yale will again require standardized test scores for admission
- pseudolus 3y agohttp://archive.today/9Q6Z1 http://archive.today/9Q6Z1
- yeknoda 3y agohow would you describe the 21, 22, and 23 vintages?
- chestertn 3y agoLucky
- pxmpxm 3y agoif they recenter the GPA distribution for every class year, one should be more discerning when hiring 21-23 yale kids, since the distribution won't be comparable to the pre/post cohort. It's a bit ironic they've managed to dampen the one signal that's embedded in a yale degree. It's almost as if reality doesn't want to cooperate with these ___ Justice efforts.
- barryrandall 3y agoMore likely to leave college/university with debt, but no degree.
- sebg 3y agoSee also Dartmouth: https://www.npr.org/2024/02/06/1229405722/after-a-pause-for-the-pandemic-dartmouth-will-again-require-sat-and-act-scores https://www.npr.org/2024/02/06/1229405722/after-a-pause-for-...
- sokoloff 3y agoAnd MIT: https://news.mit.edu/2022/stuart-schmill-sat-act-requirement-0328 https://news.mit.edu/2022/stuart-schmill-sat-act-requirement...
- jdefr89 3y agoIronic I am researcher at MIT and a college dropout lol.
- lapcat 3y agoA crucial proviso, though, is that they're comparing the applicant's test scores to their high school peers rather than to other applicants. > They don't know that their 1400 might be a great score given the challenges of their neighborhood and educational environment. "standardized testing—when assessed using the local norms at a student's high school—is a valuable element of Dartmouth's undergraduate application" https://admissions.dartmouth.edu/apply/update-testing-policy https://admissions.dartmouth.edu/apply/update-testing-policy
- sokoloff 3y ago> The decision comes after officials found that the scores were the single best predictor of students’ academic performance and that not considering them could be a disadvantage for those who have already faced daunting challenges. Neither half of this sentence is surprising. Some people love to hate on standardized testing, despite it having been repeatedly shown to have high predictive capability.
- anon291 3y agoIt's almost as if those of us who used critical reasoning before the decision was made to scrap these tests were right. A lot of introspection needs to be done to determine why these decisions were made. At the time of the decision, the admissions committees claimed the exact opposite was true, that the tests are poor predictors and disadvantaged already-disadvantaged students. Now they're claiming the opposite. Based on what data? Why did we allow the admissions committees of so-called 'elite' institutions to be so easily swayed? Are these institutions really worthy of their 'elite' status? It would seem to be called into question if they can't answer a question as straightforwards as this. Especially institutions like MIT... one would expect that they have a solid understanding of data analysis.
- megaman821 3y agoI think the groups championing stuff like this had a lot of clout a few years ago. Unfortunately for them, concrete positive results never materialized. In the meantime, the Supreme Court ruled negatively on race-based admissions and DEI offices are facing public backlash. If there really were any ideas with pursuing, those groups squandered their chance.
- lapcat 3y ago> I think the groups championing stuff like this had a lot of clout a few years ago. Alternative explanation: the pandemic happened. "When the coronavirus pandemic scrambled testing, Yale and many other colleges dropped requirements that applicants submit standardized tests such as the SAT or ACT."
- JCM9 3y agoGrade inflation and bonus points for honors or AP classes has long made GPA a useless metric. One persons 4.0 is another school’s 4.27 (on a 4 point scale). Standardized testing isn’t perfect but it is one datapoint on how everyone did against the same task. Yes there can be differences in prep and training, but that’s life. Some folks will have more advantages than you. Those that work past that will succeed in life. That’s that don’t won’t.
- Scubabear68 3y agoYep. Universities tried to track relative strength of GPA to school districts, but ultimately that is a hopeless task. Our own district has been guilty of severe grade inflation and teaching 2-3 grades behind grade level to the point where a “B” here would be a D or F in a college prep private school. Standardized tests are imperfect, but they are not entirely flawed the way high school grades are. This will also re level the playing field for poor families with smart kids who can’t afford all the extra-curricular wealthy families lean heavily into.
- bumby 3y agoThis will also re level the playing field for poor families with smart kids who can’t afford all the extra-curricular wealthy families lean heavily into. Is this really leveling the playing field? If a wealthy, average student can get prep work to score as well as a gifted, poor student, that doesn’t seem like it’s leveling the playing field of socioeconomic disadvantage.
- jhanschoo 3y agoIme tuition is far more accessible than many extracurriculars, and has better feedback (assuming that standardized testing is the only metric).
- Scubabear68 3y agoMaybe not perfectly level, but more so when colleges did not look at standardized test scores.
- xbar 3y agoI know I am operating as a bad scientist when I am happy that the data supports my bias.
- BadHumans 3y agoMy only hang up with standardized testing is that it isn't accessible but not in the ways people might think. When I was in high school, I saw a good number of people who could not travel to a testing center. The closest testing center to my high school was the next city and with no public transport and a variety of family circumstances they couldn't take the test. Test also cost money and you could find yourself in the middle class trap where you are too rich to get a waiver but too broke to afford the test.
- hef19898 3y agoIdeally, said tests are part of the normal tests done in the last year of highschool, right? Shit, having to travel and pay for another test before you can go to college is borderline dystopian...
- lapcat 3y agoWay back in the day, I remember having to travel to take the SAT. In fact, I got a speeding ticket on the way to the test! Naturally, that didn't help my score.
- btilly 3y agoNo. They are done in specific locations, administered by the testing organization. They do a lot to try to avoid cheating, limit memorizing answers, and so on. There is a conflict of interest with actually trusting the school whose reputation depends on how well their students do. Over the years, I've run into quite a few cheating scandals with other tests where teachers tried to improve scores. Because of that, I think that their precautions are very reasonable.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoMany high schools do force every junior to take the SAT in school. Mine did. We all got to skip class for the day and took it in the gym.
- 3y ago
- legitster 3y agoI admire that they actually stuck with it and tried it, but it's still crazy to me that anyone thought this was a good idea. I don't know how anyone who spent decades within school and then academia could convince themselves and others "let's get rid of the one part of the Kabuki theatre application process that isn't a massive performative time suck". In the name of equality!
- lapcat 3y ago> In the name of equality! No, that's not why. From the article: "When the coronavirus pandemic scrambled testing, Yale and many other colleges dropped requirements that applicants submit standardized tests such as the SAT or ACT."
- legitster 3y agoThat's a bit revisionist. Covid was justification at the time, but the idea clearly didn't happen in a vacuum, and the policy was reinstated several times even after testing resumed.
- lapcat 3y ago> That's a bit revisionist. Covid was justification at the time Many colleges suspended the requirement simultaneously in 2020, citing the pandemic, and you're claiming that it's revisionist? Occam's razor suggests the cited justification was the reason, and with the pandemic over, this explains why many colleges are now going back to requiring test scores.
- ejb999 3y agothe movement was well underway before covid hit - you are trying to rewrite history.
- lapcat 3y ago> you are trying to rewrite history. No, I'm not. Yale (along with a number of college colleges) suspended the testing policy in 2020 due to the pandemic. That's an indisputable historical fact. "For nearly four years Yale’s undergraduate admissions process has been test-optional. The experience, originally necessitated by the pandemic, has been an invaluable opportunity to think deeply about testing policy and to generate new data and analyses. With testing availability now fully restored for prospective applicants around the world, we have reevaluated our policy with the benefit of fresh insights." https://admissions.yale.edu/test-flexible https://admissions.yale.edu/test-flexible Let me put it this way: before the pandemic there was already a work-from-home movement. But when countless companies suddenly decided to do WFH in 2020, it wasn't because of the movement! It was because of the pandemic. And a lot of those companies are now calling for return-to-office. It's the exact same thing with standardized testing. There's literally no difference between the two cases. We don't need a political conspiracy theory when there's a very obvious and logical explanation for what happened. The pandemic was a forced experiment for WFH and a forced experiment for many other things, such as the omission of standardized testing. We had students taking classes from home too!
- imgabe 3y agoIt’s too late. Ivy League schools are a joke. They’ve been coasting on the accomplishments of alumni from 50 years ago. Serious kids of the current generation should not worry about trying to get into Ivies. Why would you go to an Ivy? Do you think you’re going to learn calculus better than you would at flagship state U? You aren’t. Do you think you’re going to work with famous professor there? You aren’t. They wouldn’t touch an undergrad with a 10 ft pole. They will hand off all your classes to adjuncts and grad students. Don’t waste your money on a fancy brand.
- kyawzazaw 3y agofinancial aid
- Upvoter33 3y agolook, I'm a public school guy through and through, but to say people who go to Harvard don't get any benefit from going there is pretty silly.
- addicted 3y agoThe results of people going to Ivies is significantly better. You make better contacts and you have access to better resources. This would be better described as Ivy+ which is the usual Ivies and colleges that are considered at that tier such as Stanford. Putting it another way, if you are going to college and you had an Ivy+ college as an option, why would you not choose that?
- bumby 3y ago>The results of people going to Ivies is significantly better. The studies I’ve seen contradict this. Students who are accepted to elite colleges but instead go to “lesser” schools do just as well as their Ivy counterparts. The exception is extremely poor students who do better by going to elite schools; researchers speculate that is due to networking effects. But that effect doesn’t generalize well like your comment implies.
- antasvara 3y ago
- ubj 3y agoRelated: MIT's detailed blog post about why they reinstated the SAT/ACT requirement (2 years ago): https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/we-are-reinstating-our-sat-act-requirement-for-future-admissions-cycles/ https://mitadmissions.org/blogs/entry/we-are-reinstating-our... Some quotes from the MIT blog post: > [S]tandardized tests also help us identify academically prepared, socioeconomically disadvantaged students who could not otherwise demonstrate readiness because they do not attend schools that offer advanced coursework, cannot afford expensive enrichment opportunities, cannot expect lengthy letters of recommendation from their overburdened teachers, or are otherwise hampered by educational inequalities. > [O]ur findings directionally align with a major study conducted by the University of California’s Standardized Testing Task Force, which found that including SAT/ACT scores predicted undergraduate performance better than grades alone, and also helped admissions officers identify well-prepared students from less-advantaged backgrounds.
- 15457345234 3y agoSanity and normality is returning, slowly. It's normal to test children at the end of the educational process. No, it isn't racist/bigoted/discriminatory. No, minorities aren't too stupid to recognise the test is important. Implying that _is_ racist. No, it isn't any of the other things it was claimed to be. No, it isn't perfect. Yes, it's necessary to ensure that schools are actually teaching and that schools which aren't actually teaching can be fixed. Really the entire US educational system appears to have come under the influence recently of some people with very strange ideas.
- otoburb 3y agoAs a (to me, puzzling) counterpoint, Caltech ran a similar internal analysis in 2020 and again in 2022 and extended their moratorium on standardized test scores for first-year admissions out to 2025.[1] [1] https://www.admissions.caltech.edu/apply/first-year-applicants/standardized-tests https://www.admissions.caltech.edu/apply/first-year-applican...
- swatcoder 3y agoCaltech is a much smaller and more narrowly focused school with a smaller applicant pool that self-selects even more than MIT's. The needs and workflows of their admission process are different and peculiar and shouldn't be taken as a strong signal of what makes sense elsewhere.
- Upvoter33 3y agoSeems like an important thing to do: it gives smart people, no matter the background, and chance to show their stuff. That said, we should be putting work in to level the "prep" playing field. Some people have the resources to do a lot of prep, some not so much. The more the prep situation is addressed, the better these tests are.
- curiousllama 3y agoIt's important to remember that the legal context around admissions has changed over the past few years. 2-3 years ago, it seemed clear that (1) the courts were likely to strike down policies that support diversity via admissions and (2) they were going to use test scores as a way to measure the inequity. [A] It appeared then that schools were no longer requiring test scores as a defensive move - if they don't require tests, it's harder to use them in court. Today, the court appears to be signaling that they won't continue cracking down. [B] [C]. Accordingly, we should not be surprised that that admissions offices are reacting by reinstating the requirements - they've always been useful; they were just briefly dangerous. [A] https://www.harvard.edu/admissionscase/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2022/05/FINAL_Key-Facts_FINAL.pdf https://www.harvard.edu/admissionscase/wp-content/uploads/si... [B] https://www.reuters.com/legal/us-supreme-court-rejects-virginia-case-over-race-high-school-admissions-2024-02-20/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/us-supreme-court-rejects-virgi... [C] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/02/05/supreme-court-declines-west-point-affirmative-action-case https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/02/05/s...
- lapcat 3y ago> It appeared then that schools were no longer requiring test scores as a defensive move - if they don't require tests, it's harder to use them in court. From the article: "When the coronavirus pandemic scrambled testing, Yale and many other colleges dropped requirements that applicants submit standardized tests such as the SAT or ACT." Why is everyone looking for a convoluted theory when there's a very obvious explanation?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bombcar 3y agoRemote computer proctoring is a solved problem, way before Covid, so the pandemic may be part of the reason, but it's unlikely to be the whole reason. Universities bandwagon just as much as anyone else does, and the reasons they give afterwards may not be the reasons they went into it.
- polski-g 3y agoFDB predicted this: https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/why-the-fuck-do-you-trust-harvard https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/why-the-fuck-do-you-tru... > You can’t make college admissions fair by getting rid of the SAT because colleges admissions can’t be “fair.” College admissions exist to serve the schools. Period. End of story. They always have, they always will. Elite colleges exist to get donations from graduates. If said graduates are stupid because of lack of meritocracy in the admissions process, they will be poor donors (because they're poor post-graduation).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ajay-p 3y agoThat.. did not last long. In my opinion it was a disastrous thing to even attempt. There is really no way to judge a random person's ability to learn, or even address the act of learning, without a standardized test. The ACT and SAT will always need work as culture changes, but throwing it out in search of restorative justice is extremely unwise.
- asoneth 3y ago> throwing it out in search of restorative justice is extremely unwise. I see this claim a lot, but it seems partially true at best. As per the article and conversations with friends in admissions departments, the testing requirement at many elite schools was suspended due to the coronavirus pandemic. However, the debate over how tests impact disadvantaged students may be why "many schools continued their test-optional policies even as the public health crisis eased" as per the article, so you're partially right that it probably played a role in why some schools have dragged their feet. (Contrast to schools like MIT which also dropped their testing requirement during the pandemic but reinstated it more quickly afterwards.)
- bombcar 3y agoI think what was more prevalent was a "unequal outcomes can be explained away by this standardized test" and then we got a chance to experiment with it and learn new data.
- asoneth 3y agoAgreed that an across-the-board change to admissions policies like this is an opportunity to test the thesis, although the pandemic had many other confounding impacts that may be hard to isolate. Still, I don't know anyone who works in higher ed admissions who wants to get rid of standardized testing for "restorative justice" reasons. Rigorous schools need to be able to ensure they don't admit students who have no hope of graduating and competitive schools need to winnow down the number of applications to a number that they can actually review. My impression is that the objections to standardized testing typically come from groups outside universities like the NEA, FairTest, teachers unions, parents, activists, etc.
- hirvi74 3y agoI have no real qualms with this under one wishful condition. My condition is that I think if schools are going to start selecting for this type of individual again, it would be quite beneficial to start heavily screening children for learning disabilities and other disorders that can impact educational attainment. I had an undiagnosed learning disability, and had I known at the time, I could have received proper accommodations and treatments that I believe would have greatly improved my abilities to better perform on standardized tests and academics in general. However, screening children for such disabilities was not common in the public education system of the South East, US during my time. Based on my academic achievements, GPA, etc. the standardized test I took (ACT) was by no means an accurate reflection of my abilities. In fact, the ACT actively harmed my educational opportunities. While these tests may help children with poorer socioeconomic status, I think the tests currently discriminate against neurodivergent people, and are probably significantly worse for neurodivergent people with poorer socioeconomic backgrounds.
- EchoChamberMan 3y agoUnfortunately, screening requires spending time and money, and both are things businesses/schools would rather not do.
- jjmarr 3y agoIn Ontario, Canada we don't have standardized tests to get into university. Grade inflation is the worst it's ever been. We don't even have GPAs because it's too coarse a distinction. Virtually all serious competitors to top schools graduate with a 97-99% average in their top 6 grade 12 courses. Many graduate with 100%. Even then most students with 98s get rejected from schools like Waterloo in Computer Science. If taken at face-value, that means students can't make any mistakes in their last year of high school. That's across two semesters worth of tests in several subjects. Imagine if failing a test worth 10% of a course was enough to prevent you from going to a good university because it dropped your average across 6 courses from a 98% to a 97%. (10%/6 = 1.67%) Some teachers will give easy tests that are difficult to not get 100% on. Other teachers will make up the numbers entirely. Regardless you still have to spend time and money on extracurriculars since the 98% is a bare minimum. This means student activities and clubs aren't for socializing. They have been co-opted as a mechanism to create 10-person executive bodies so students can show they had leadership roles when applying to uni. A club that actually meets for its stated purpose imposes too much of a time commitment since competitive students need multiple leadership roles on their application. The University of Waterloo has an entire series of math competitions as a sneaky way to administer standardized testing to potential CS or math students. This gives them a competitive advantage over other schools. Waterloo also has a comprehensive dataset of "adjustment factors" to weigh your average differently depending on your high school. This has been in place for a decade. Schools like the University of Toronto force you to apply to computer science after your first year. They admit everyone but only a small amount of students get to continue into high-demand programs such as CS (this is called POSt). This incentivizes you to sabotage your classmates to look better, especially when many classes' grades are curved. Why would you attend a study group and help your competitors? This creates a high-pressure and negative environment. e.g. Three people killed themselves in the same computer science building at U of T in the two years before the pandemic. https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/students-criticize-u-of-t-after-third-death-at-same-building-in-under-two-years/article_66993ec6-cb38-57c7-84b1-9b4808c01138.html https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/students-criticize-u-of-t-a... Our top universities select for undergraduates that are skillful at creating fake leadership roles for themselves and sabotaging others to look better by comparison. At least standardized tests require you to study.
- 3y ago
- weweersdfsd 3y agoStandardized nationwide tests, or entry exams that are the same for everyone are the only fair and equal ways of choosing who is admitted to study and who isn't. Anything else leads to corruption and discrimination. Helping those who are disadvantaged to achieve better educational outcomes should happen already way earlier, starting from their childhood. Proper teacher training, social services and extra funding for schools in poorer areas (regardless of race/ethnicity of population) is a good way to do that. That's basically how Nordic welfare states work, and the results are pretty good in terms of social mobility.
- ksec 3y ago"You can always count on Americans to do the right thing - after they've tried everything else." - Winston Churchill I know a lot of people will take this negatively, I actually think this is a very good compliment to the American culture.