21 ms·
Nuclear SMR welding breakthrough
- boxed 3y agoSeems like this tech could be very relevant to SpaceX too...
- V__ 3y agoI'm really rooting for SMRs, but are there realistic projections on what the energy production costs will be?
- camel_gopher 3y agoLatest on NuScale was 189/MW ($0.189/kW). More expensive than solar but here in CA 20 cents a kilowatt would be welcome
- bryanlarsen 3y ago77% of the cost of a kWh in California are fixed costs. So if production cost 19 cents, then your cost would be 19 cents + 77% of your current price + a few more cents for the profit on the production costs. IOW, it would increase your electricity bills.
- Twirrim 3y agoWhile also getting you more reliable and consistent power generation than anything you'd get from Solar or Wind.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe unreliability of the California grid is almost entirely due to transmission, not generation. And nuclear is not a reliability panacea. Nuclear only has a 90% uptime, whereas the goal for power delivery is 99.99%.
- exe34 3y ago> The unreliability of the California grid is almost entirely due to transmission, not generation. I think describing night time as a problem of transmission is technically correct, but probably not the issue here.
- imtringued 3y agoSince when does the wind stop blowing at night? You can play dishonest games and win dishonest responses.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoNot arguing the earlier points or saying this is relevant - but - here in Kansas, kinda known for it's wind, it usually dies down around sunset. We do get wind at night sometimes but we get a lot more during the day.
- pfdietz 3y agoFor ERCOT in Texas, it's the other way around: wind generation tends to be higher at night. https://www.ercot.com/gridmktinfo/dashboards https://www.ercot.com/gridmktinfo/dashboards
- 3y ago
- cwmma 3y agoI think one of the issues is just that for thermal power plants in general, there are big economies of scale, one big boiler/turbine/etc is better then multiple small ones)
- pfdietz 3y agoMuch more than from the Canigou Sun Bear project in SW Colorado ($1.5B for 971 MWp, including I think 2 hours of batteries, 1979 GWh/year (23% capacity factor), 35 year life for the PV).
- earthnail 3y agoThe one thing I still wonder is whether SMRs could create a security nightmare. Every nuclear power plant is a fantastic target for terrorists. Transports of nuclear waste are a fantastic target, too. I read once that the UK has many nuclear waste trains driving all the time, most of them empty, just to make it hard to guess which one to hit. (I assume other western countries have the same system). That kind of security doesn’t scale well. How do you protect infrastructure with many SMRs?
- BlueTemplar 3y agoI am more concerned about when/if we have millions of small nuclear reactors around, some of them will end up abandoned/lost. Then many years later, they will start to leak (think rain getting in).
- samus 3y agoUnlikely, that would imply a major breakdown of civilization. They are all connected to power lines, else they would not have been installed in the first place.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoWell yes, major breakdowns of civilization have happened before and will happen again. There's one going on right now on the Ukraine/Russia border !
- samus 3y agoAnd we saw what happens when nuclear installations are caught behind frontlines. In such situations, installations composed of SMRs would have advantages. For example, artillery blowing one up would be quite gnarly still, but less so than if that happened to a much larger monolithic plant!
- gambiting 3y agoI mean during cold war many RTGs were deployed in remote regions of the world and subsequently lost. We even know of some cases where random people came across them and opened them up(unknowingly killing themselves in the process).
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoWhy does it take 12 months to weld these things in the first place? The article doesn't say anything about that, and I can't intuit why it would take that long in the first place.
- BryanLegend 3y agoMight have be a foot thick wedge that was filled one bead weld at a time.
- 3D30497420 3y agoThat's my issue with articles like this. It sounds pretty great, but it provides barely any context. The quote at the end is a quote from the company's project lead, which sounds like it was taken from a company press release. So, yay? Edit: The quote actually was taken from a news release. See: https://www.sheffieldforgemasters.com/news-and-insights/news/02/sheffield-forgemasters-makes-global-leap-in-nuclear-welding-technology/ https://www.sheffieldforgemasters.com/news-and-insights/news...
- practicemaths 3y agoI'm not a welding engineer. I imagine half of it is checking the welds are to code and certifying it.
- djaychela 3y agoMy (albeit short and 30+ years ago) experience in the nuclear industry as an apprentice would lead me to believe that it's about quality control and inspection as well as it probably being a long-winded task if the pressure vessel is 8 inches thick. I'd think it would need to be entirely welded at that depth, with each weld pass being X-ray inspected. Everything I did when briefly working in a reactor (3 months of my 4 years) took a LOT of time because of safety checks and routine.
- magicalhippo 3y agoSounds like my buddy who's a programmer for our social services. He said they spend about one day per week coding and the rest doing code reviews.
- CamperBob2 3y agoTalk about ambiguous headlines. I thought this was going to be about using nuclear energy for welding.
- opwieurposiu 3y agoThere are more details and a video of the welder here: https://camvaceng.com/electron-beam/ebflow/ https://camvaceng.com/electron-beam/ebflow/ It has a mini-vacuum chamber on the welding head so you can e-beam weld large workpieces without needing a large vacuum chamber.
- senectus1 3y agothats some pretty cool engineering
- m3kw9 3y agoCan someone help visualize what is being welded?
- waldothedog 3y agoSomeone else might have more detail, but I believe these are “basically” massive metal tubes that are created by building up welds, one on top of the other, to achieve extremely high integrity structures for containing nuclear fission.
- mikece 3y agoOne of the benefits often cited (and it is again in this article) is that SMRs allow for electrical generation to be located extremely close to where it will be consumed, avoiding line losses on the transmission grid. How significant are the line losses for a plant that is 100 miles from where the electricity is being consumed?
- ahmedfromtunis 3y agoI did a paper on this back at engineering school around 10 years ago. I forgot most of the details, but iirc the losses can be up to 33% in certain conditions (mostly cold weather).
- mikece 3y agoWorse in cold weather? I thought conductors get more efficient the colder they get (or is cold relative to humans insignificant to high voltage lines)?
- ahmedfromtunis 3y agoI forgot the details but I remember it's something about humidity in the air. I recall however that I read about a blue halo forming around some cables in snowy nights as electricity charges the air surrounding said cables. This phenomenon was a huge source of losses in transport cables.
- tnorgaard 3y agoViking Link, the 765 km HVDC (VSC-based) link rated at 1400 MW between England and Denmark has a rated loss at 3.7% [0]. [0] https://www.viking-link.com/auction-faqs https://www.viking-link.com/auction-faqs
- LorenPechtel 3y agoCan't address it overall but some while back I did some calculation on shipping power around the world from wherever the sun was shining. I took the real-world numbers for the biggest transmission lines--and found the only question being how many nines on the loss percentage. You are fighting two separate forces. Some of the energy is lost to heat in the wires, this is minimized by making the voltage as high as possible--but the higher the voltage the more corona loss there will be.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoSecurity against malevolent actors? Having reactors everywhere seems like an invitation for disaster... edit: i am pro clean power and i believe nuclear waste can be stored safely; I just don't want to put town's at risk via under secured nuclear facilities.
- XzAeRosho 3y agoOne could argue that large reactor plants make for easier targets since the surface area of attack vectors is much larger.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoOne might also argue that 1000 units versus 1 (guessing) would be harder to keep track of.
- topspin 3y agoThere are rarely 1 conventional reactors on a site, although there are a few examples to the contrary. The largest sites have 6-8 reactors. Typically there are 2-4, which facilitates load management during outages. The good news from the security prospective is that SMRs will likely be similarly concentrated, just with greater numbers of reactors. They are highly unlikely to be sprinkled about willy nilly, despite the thinking of some. Siting is a major problem with all power generation and particularly with nuclear: getting a site approved is a major accomplishment involving no end of costly wheeling and dealing over many years. Although there are use cases, often championed as killer applications for SMR, such as very remote, undeveloped locations, I expect that for every 1 such isolated reactor actually deployed, 100 will be lined up in rows and columns at major reactor sites.
- sgt101 3y agoA big consideration is grid structure, it's very expensive to create power distribution from generators into the infrastructure. There already exists grid infrastructure at old reactor sites, so I think it's very likely that they would be ideal candidates for SMR deployment.
- temp0826 3y ago>> potentially taking high-cost welding processes out of the equation I wonder what kind of cost they're talking if a high-powered electron gun and vacuum chamber are cheaper
- ActionHank 3y ago12 months of labour I'm assuming
- ajcp 3y agoThe vacuum chamber *is* part of the electron gun; it's essentially on the end of the "barrel" to create a vacuum just at the spot of the weld.
- peter_d_sherman 3y ago>"Using conventional techniques, this can take over a year, but Sheffield Forgemasters have reduced this to under a day using what is called Local Electron-Beam Welding (LEBW) to complete four thick, nuclear-grade welds. LEBW is a revolutionary method to weld two pieces of metal together using a high-energy density fusion process centered on a high-powered electron gun operating in a local vacuum. This melts and fuses components to one another and allows for an efficiency of 95%, deep penetration, and a high depth-to-width ratio." Never heard about this before... let's learn more about it!: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron-beam_welding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron-beam_welding Apparently you first need a vaccuum chamber to prevent energy dissipation... that sounds about right... But then we find this interesting quote: >"Magnetic lenses can shape the beam into a narrow cone and focus to a small diameter. This allows for a high power density on the surface to be welded." Now that's super-cool! (Or, well, super-hot -- as the case may be! :-) ) Then there's this: >"The beam can then be redirected to meet the needs of applications beyond welding such as surface hardening, annealing, exact beam positioning, imaging, and engraving. Resolution of 0.1 mm can be achieved." Now that is truly useful! It seems like this would be an excellent technology for creating future space stations, spaceships and other deep-space vehicles, of one form or another... Anyway, great article!
- LorenPechtel 3y agoAnd it sounds like something that would be practical to use in space. Normally you either burn fuel (and lifting said fuel is very pricey!) or you use an electric arc--but your arc won't work in vacuum.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoThe Soviet Union and USA have used electron beam and laser welding in space [1]. 1. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002259/downloads/20200002259.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20200002259/downloads/20...
- codersfocus 3y agoHow high powered? This sounds like a CRT display.
- lchengify 3y agoIf you're interested in a visual of how different welds interact with the metal, I watched this video on SpaceX's Starship welding that was helpful [1]. Something I try to remember is that most non-organic materials gain their properties from a precise lattice structure. This often doesn't come across when looking straight at the chemistry equations. Welding both disrupts and rebuilds this lattice structure, which is why it requires so much skill to do at volume. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CP8Hbr2jL_c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CP8Hbr2jL_c
- demaga 3y agoI jumped to 3:16 and was very confused for a moment.
- barryrandall 3y ago1 reactor per day would double the number of reactors in the world in less than 18 months. Can we generate enough people qualified to run them without compromising safety?
- EasyMark 3y agothat was welding together just one part of a reactor, it would involve a lot more than that one part. You'd have to get all the various steps done in parallel and all stages less than 24 hours to get a "1 a day" pipeline going. I think that is wishful thinking by anyone's standards.
- samus 3y agoThat's one large bottleneck resolved, perhaps one of the most limiting. But it doesn't mean they will actually crank up the assembly line that far to then sit on a large inventory, which would create its own issues.
- radu_floricica 3y agoThey're pretty small for a commercial reactor. But on the other hand nobody stops us from building them in parallel. The point is that they break existing rules: we'll stop counting reactors, for one thing, because numbers will mean a different thing. And also, more importantly, we need a lot less qualified operators to run them safely.
- ergocoder 3y agoRollsroyce stock has been on the run. Love this news. I hope this 10x the stock.
- jdietrich 3y agoAs a side note, the company mentioned here (Sheffield Forgemasters) has some incredibly weird history involving a big pipe and Saddam Hussein. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supergun_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supergun_affair
- Etheryte 3y agoIt's always chilling to read a Wikipedia article that essentially ends in saying that the problem was solved by assassinating the head honcho.
- RecycledEle 3y agoThis welding process will have massive impact on military armor, if it did not come from the military.
- pfdietz 3y agoOne thing to note is you won't be able to have a welder just standing there operating this, as it will produce energetic photons from bremsstrahlung, some of which will scatter back out of the metal. There will be little or no induced radioactivity, but the radiation environment during operation will be significant. Low pressure nuclear systems (like molten salt systems) will not need nearly as thick walls or deep welds, but they have their own problems.