7 ms·
ADHD linked to evolutionary success in ancient humans
- kayodelycaon 3y agoI highly doubt ADHD is a survival mechanism. It comes with a vast degree of side-effects like emotional control, sensory issues, ability to focus, and memory recall. It's like saying severe anxiety is linked to evolutionary success because anxious people pay more attention to the things around them.
- grimgrin 3y agoNot exactly in disagreement with this concept: > In the 21st century we may have pathologized ADHD as a negative disorder, but that could be just because these characteristics simply don’t easily suit the world we have constructed. In a different context, it is possible that someone with ADHD could be a saviour to a tribe by restlessly exploring new pastures.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoI mean... This study used a pretty direct test: "Around 450 people participated in the experiment, and all were simultaneously screened for ADHD symptoms. Unsurprisingly, the researchers found those with higher ADHD scores moved on to new bushes sooner than others but more importantly, those with ADHD also tended to collect higher volumes of berries overall."
- hanniabu 3y agoThis actually makes perfect sense
- falcolas 3y agoI have a problem with their test for ADHD - two things. One, it's a 6 question test. Pretty limited. Two, the test diagnosed half of the participants as having the equivalent of clinical diagnosis of ADHD, when the global diagnosis rate is closer to 5%. Huge red flag. They used a black box AI tool to diagnose folks. IMO, this was a bad choice for a study.
- myth_drannon 3y agoIt's a genetic mutation per article. So it's possibly a beneficial mutation in evolutionary terms despite side effects because it persisted. Similar to sickle cell disease (which is also a genetic mutation) in people of African descent which protects from malaria.
- bowsamic 3y ago> It's like saying severe anxiety is linked to evolutionary success because anxious people pay more attention to the things around them. And? That could be true...
- brodouevencode 3y agobut hardly conclusive
- scott_w 3y agoIf only someone was doing research on neurodiverse behavioural traits. Maybe try to identify people displaying those traits and put them into simulations of conditions that we think prehistoric humans lived in.
- bowsamic 3y agoSure but the OP made it sound ridiculous on the face of it, but it sounds like a reasonable suggestion to me
- notfed 3y agoPoe's law is strong here. Anxiety obviously evolved as an adaptive trait.
- hirvi74 3y agoAll mammals can exhibit it. I do not think anxiety is a disorder, but rather a natural response. It's literally our "fight or flight" mechanism. I think the disorder part comes from the fact that such mechanisms are being hit constantly for so many people that it causes disorder in one's life. There is no rest for the system, and it's constantly under some sort of strain. Yes, anxiety might save us from a saber-tooth tiger, but I do not think situations like that were an all-day-every-day kind of occurrence like the things that cause anxiety in today's time.
- shric 3y agoADHD doesn't need to be free of negatives as long as it improves survival and reproductive chances. The inability to focus and lack of memory recall, for example, may either not matter or just be negligible compared to other factors. While ADHD does lead to focus problems, people with ADHD are usually just as good at focusing as anyone else when their life depends on it.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago> repoructive Scooby?
- shric 3y agoFixed. For those not familiar with the slang, "Scooby" is apparently a response to say one doesn't understand what you're talking about and could use a clue. However, even a Google search on the typo of "repoructive" was able to reveal what I meant with zero context.
- notfed 3y agoI thought they were referring to Scooby Doo, a cartoon dog who has a speech impediment.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoYes, exactly this.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoReally? I mean it as in "Scooby Doo". When I read it, it sounded like his voice in my head.
- pjdesno 3y agoUnless circumstances never change, there's always value to a population in having a spectrum for any trait. It's also likely that the specific characteristics that best position individuals for success as modern white collar workers were optimal for 99% of the evolutionary timeline of human existence. If mild to moderate ADHD offers an advantage in a high mortality setting, the loss of individuals with more extreme symptoms isn't going to make much of a difference in selection pressure. (sickle cell anemia is an extreme example of this)
- AdamN 3y agoThere are many conditions that confer a narrow fitness advantage and have significant disadvantages too: sickle cell anemia (malaria resistance), diabetes (cold tolerance) are two I can think of off the top of my head. Here's an interesting book on the topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival_of_the_Sickest_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival_of_the_Sickest_(book)
- imbnwa 3y agoTBF evolution doesn't give a hoot about side effects. It is not an intelligence. Moreover, human communities provide massive shielding for diverse traits by being near top of the food chain (when we're in armed groups).
- InSteady 3y agoFurthermore, each individual human has not been optimized for solo survival, we have (generally speaking) been optimized for group survival in which mix of behavioral traits/strategies is beneficial to the group. Individuals with traits that would be suboptimal if they were out there on their own can sometimes provide a great deal of value to the group under the right circumstances. Even if little Jane ADHD taxes resources more than other group members on the average year, perhaps her unique behavioral traits open the possibility of saving the entire group from starvation during an atypical hunting/foraging year.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imbnwa 3y agoSomewhere in here is a basis for a critique of the pervasiveness of invidiualism in America
- kstrauser 3y agoADHD isn’t the inability to focus. It’s the inability to focus on something that’s not interesting. In an environment where one isn’t obligated to sit at a desk and memorize things for 8 hours straight, that may not be as much of an issue. Amazingly, anxiety also decreases greatly when one’s not worried about being unable to care about whatever boring thing is being inflicted upon them this month. I’m glad I had such things inflicted on me in interest of making me a more well rounded human. But left to my own devices, young me would have escaped to a library every single day and memorized every book on the subjects I liked. If we lived in a placetime where that were a viable option, ADHD vs Education wouldn’t have been such a problem for me.
- hirvi74 3y agoADHD is an attention regulation disorder not an attention capacity disorder. As much as ADHD is: > 'It’s the inability to focus on something that’s not interesting' ADHD is also the inability to stop focusing on something that’s interesting.
- ksenzee 3y agoEver hear someone describe their anxiety as “always being on the lookout for a saber-toothed tiger attack”? I have very little difficulty imagining environments where anxiety is linked to evolutionary success.
- notfed 3y agoThat anxiety sounds warranted, but why are attractive members of the opposite sex saber-toothed tigers?
- hirvi74 3y agoBecause the term "cougar" has a different meaning.
- francisofascii 3y agoGreat question. Maybe because the stakes are high in either case.
- ccleve 3y agoThe study they performed is utter garbage. They saw the result they wanted to see. They produced a unique game where players were given eight minutes to collect as many berries as possible by hovering a mouse pointer over a bush. Each time they foraged from the same bush a player’s harvest would slightly decline but if they moved to a new bush they would suffer a time penalty. So what would most players do? Stick to the same reliable berry-supplying bush? Or risk wasting time by trying another bush to see if it had more fruit? Explore or exploit? Around 450 people participated in the experiment, and all were simultaneously screened for ADHD symptoms. Unsurprisingly, the researchers found those with higher ADHD scores moved on to new bushes sooner than others but more importantly, those with ADHD also tended to collect higher volumes of berries overall. Writing in the newly published study, Barack and colleagues noted that participants without ADHD characteristics tended to over-harvest single patches. Looking at what would be an optimal harvest strategy for the game it was discovered that players with high ADHD scores were more successful overall. The outcome of this game is 100% dependent on the parameters: the decline in the harvest from a given bush, and the time penalty. If you change the parameters to favor persistence, then guess what, persistence wins.
- instagraham 3y ago> The outcome of this game is 100% dependent on the parameters: the decline in the harvest from a given bush, and the time penalty. If you change the parameters to favor persistence, then guess what, persistence wins. I think that's by design. In situations where exploratory behaviours pay off, ADHD-like behaviours prove beneficial. In settler roles, they do not. The study's hypothesis is to hint that explorer-types could tend to push evolution forward, and that ADHDers could tend to being explorer-types. I don't think there's any contention that ADHD is necessarily advantageous today - at least not from this study. It would be too complicated to make such a point.
- hirvi74 3y agoI believe there is some merit to this, or at least similar, hypothesis(es). Based on population percentages, the disorder seems, to me, to be far too common to be some kind of genetic fluke. We are talking about something that affects ~1/20 - ~1/10 adults. I mean, one is more like to have ADHD than blue eyes, or green eyes, or red hair, etc.. As someone with ADHD, it surely can cause disorder, and believe me, it can cause plenty of it. However, I wouldn't say that it's without its upsides at times either. In my personal experience, I find that my ADHD has been somewhat more advantageous when in a group setting than individual setting. I feel like I can bring a different angle of creativity to things that neuro-typicals cannot, but perhaps that is just my wishful thinking.
- anon115 3y agoyou got foreground thinking and then you got pertinent thinking.
- humbleferret 3y agoA couple of key points that stood out to me: 1. ADHD traits could have been beneficial for exploring new food sources in ancient times. 2. While ADHD is often seen as a disorder today, it might be better suited to different environments. Intriguing stuff about ADHD traits maybe being helpful in some situations! Makes me rethink how I view ADHD, and chimes with my own experience of folks with ADHD doing really well in certain tasks compared to others. A good reminder to consider different perspectives. I also learnt that the DRD4/7R gene was linked to ADHD AND risk-taking behaviour.
- EthanHeilman 3y agoADHD has helped me find success in the modern world by making me fail at things I don't find interesting. This forced me to work on what I find interesting. This is risky. I can't experimentally verify it, but on the balance I believe I am better off with ADHD than without it. It has also caused me problems because even being slightly outside the norm has high costs in a mechanized economy that values interchangeable parts/people over novelty.
- kstrauser 3y agoYou probably want someone with ADHD to be on guard duty at night: “I’m bored, this is boring, I should go poke Joe with a stick until he wakes up, I’m OMG A TWIG SNAPPED LET’S GO”.
- hirvi74 3y agoI've always been great at finding items that people lose, 'I Spy' games, stealth games, hunting, etc.. Not sure if there is any merit to it, but I find that because I do not typically fixate on one particular thing, I can easily distracted by anything/everything, thus I can spot differences rather rapidly. I consider it like a breadth-first search vs. a depth-first search.
- AceyMan 3y agoThis. I've determined that the societal benefit of ADHD is best demonstrated in the hunter role during humans' hunter-gatherer era. Long runs or hikes to get to the locale / day (or days) long stints of observant concentration resulting in longer than 24H wake/sleep cycles / intense sprints to chase down prey —— all well-suited for the ADHD constitution. I've thought about it from every angle and it sure adds up to me.
- JohnMakin 3y agoThe seemingly poor quality of this "study" aside, the whole "ADHD is ackshually a superpower" movement over the last few years is really frustrating for me, especially hearing it from people who "suffer" from it. There's a broad spectrum of symptoms with varying severities for sure, but for me, I can definitely point to it as the number one thing that has adversely affected the quality and trajectory of my life, and I'd do pretty much anything to be rid of it. It's very hard to explain to people who do not deal with it, even the people that are like "oh actually it makes me super special and productive in X scenario." Cool. Good for you. For many people it's completely debilitating. I'm one of the luckier ones that fell into a career that suits my natural tendencies, and have trained myself to overcome disadvantages, but go visit an ADHD support group sometime online. It's truly heartbreaking to hear the stories.
- swozey 3y agoIt's absolutely ridiculous to me how much people coming into hn/reddit and going "wow I read these symptoms, I think I must be adhd!" blew up around 2020. For those of us who have been ADHD our entire lives and have been acutely aware of every single thing that ADHD has affected IN our lives. Like losing relationships, partnerships, making people think we don't care about them, disinterest, spiraling into depression because we can't keep things orderly for more than a week, having to write down literally everything lest we immediately forget the next question we need to ask, getting panic attack level anxiety frustrated when we can't find something we've lost 10000 times like our keys but we KNOW we put in the same exact spot because we trained ourselves to do it, getting put down and told we were incredibly smart but didn't apply in school.. I have never, ever, once since I was probably 7-8 wondered if I did or didn't have ADHD. Nor has anyone in my entire life. And it absolutely obvious to me, as someone who has ADHD, who also has ADHD. It's absolutely a spectrum but we can 100% hear ourselves caged inside of someone elses heads. And now, 2024, with 80% of HN now thinking they need stims because at 42 after having 3 kids running around they find it hard to focus, so now I can't get my prescriptions because they're out of stock and I pretty much can't function on weekends now because I have to limit my intake to save extra pills in case I can't get it next month and I have to get tested more frequently because now it's even FURTHER on everyones radar as a narcotic. And I'm aware that some people just literally have no idea what some mental thing is. I have 40+ yo friends who don't know that some feeling they felt 3 days ago was panic attack level anxiety. Well, it's time to learn about your feelings and how to identify and work with them, big boys! Delay fun https://imgur.com/a/BVQkKOV https://imgur.com/a/BVQkKOV ! Edit: I'm not gatekeeping diagnosis at all, get one if you need one and it helps. I'm just explaining what the situation is like from this perspective. It's incredibly troubling to see an illness you have blow up in popularity because there are so many things that can come with that, like the gov cutting it off for us completely, us running out of medication, etc. Although, this is ADHD. If this was cancer and it started growing exponentially i'm sure they'd do more medication creation and research, instead we're treated like coke addicts. edit2: And I should mention, just because I was dx'd as a kid doesn't mean anything in that huge list at the top was evident to me that it was caused by ADHD and not anything else in my life. It took decades of going through the same cycles and loops and seeing the ways my adhd would cause things to be different from others and cause issues. A lot of people think "Wow if I'd gotten dx'd at 8 instead of 38 my life would be amazing." Unfortunately not. I didn't really figure out the interpersonal relationship issues were hugely ADHD until my 30s. ADHD when I was a kid was a "he's super hyper and can't focus" and was supposed to go aaway by "adulthood." No psychiatrist has ever given me a good understanding of ADHD that took all my own research. Turns out it's a lifelong thing. Psychiatrists in the past were awful.
- nye2k 3y agoThe explore/exploit tradeoff immediately seems like a natural connection to some synaptic pruning and forking research that has been popping up around neurodiverse brain patterns. Is the individual following a typical known neural path to find the berries because they have already learned it to be successful? Or are they instead connecting new neural pathways along the way and following atypical unanswered thought threads in an attempt to find a new and better option... for some motivated reason? Seems more useful to study over a longer term, across many similar tasks.
- megamix 3y agoI'm always fascinated by ADHD and have you guys read Procrustean Bed (Taleb, 2010) where he silently hints at this with the following quote: "For instance, few realize that we are changing the brains of schoolchildren through medication in order to make them adjust to the curriculum, rather than the reverse."
- dirtybirdnj 3y agocannot upvote this hard enough. group think is so appealing to the herd that they will throw out reality to stay comfortable themselves. who cares what the means are as long as there is no discomfort for ourselves.
- hirvi74 3y agoTrust me, I would have benefited from changes like this. However, while such changes would be a great start, I think it would be cruel to adjust curriculum to a person with ADHD, then throw them into a society that does not adjust to them. If anything, the current system is at least consistent i.e., the same shit system in curriculum prepared me for the same shit system the world runs on.
- notfed 3y agoAs an ADHDer I don't think any curriculum would have worked for me. It's not a simple matter of "let's just teach ADHD kids the ADHD way". Medication has allowed me to absorb a massive amount of important knowledge that I would have otherwise ignored.
- jmacklin308 3y agoI have it. I wish I didn't. Having it is like being in a batting cage, but the ball launcher is hurling baseballs at 5-50Mph at 200rpm. The smallest noise can throw me off an essay I'm writing or report I'm making, unless It's something I just adore like making video games. It might have been helpful back in ye olden times, but It sucks having it in today's work environment. Boring desk jobs where you sit down and work 8-5 don't utilize it at all. At the end of the day go home wanting to do projects and to work on my future ambitions, but I'm just tired and end up not being able to finish them.
- wustep 3y agoDirect link to paper: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2022.2584 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2022.258...