4 ms·
NASA's New Horizons Discovered a Large Surprise in the Kuiper Belt
- pfdietz 3y agoI'm still cheerleading for discovery of a Mars to Earth mass planet out there, with an exospheric temperature low enough it could retain helium. If it existed it could be the best place in the solar system to mine the fusion fuel helium-3.
- malfist 3y agoGas giants hold onto their gases, not because they're cold, but because they're massive. I doubt you could get a planet to form with liquid or solid helium on the surface. Building a planet generates a great deal of heat and pressure. And we'd know if there was another gas giant in the kuiper belt. I couldn't find estimates on how much mass is in the oort cloud, but probably not enough to form a orbit with enough mass to make a gas giant. Edit: Just found the wikipedia section on the mass of the oort cloud. Roughly estimated at 5 earth masses. Neptune, which isn't quite massive enough to be a gaseous planet, is 17 earth masses. Saturn, our smaller gas giant is 95 earth masses
- wredue 3y agoAll planets and moons hang on to their gasses through gravity. I would think our understanding of solar system formations and solar winds makes the likelihood of lots of helium being in the outer system being quite high. The temperature is not related to holding on to the helium, but to its density for higher efficiency farming.
- pfdietz 3y agoThe temperature at the exobase does have an effect on retention of helium. If it's high enough (relative to the escape energy of the planet) the high energy tail of the thermal distribution will leak atoms into space.
- BurningFrog 3y agoI thought you can just shovel He-3 from the ground on the Moon?
- pfdietz 3y agoAt about 10ppb concentration in the regolith. Without really serious heat recycling the energy cost of extracting it would be higher than the fusion energy it would yield.
- bilsbie 3y agoCould you skim it off a gas giant? If part of a gravity assist there would be no gravity well penalty.
- pfdietz 3y agoThat would be (from Uranus) the next best idea (or perhaps scooping suborbitally lobbed 3He tanks in a rugged cone-shaped collector), but I think launching it to space in the normal way from a hypothetical smaller planet would be better, if such a planet existed.
- criddell 3y agoThis is the surprise: > Data from the New Horizons probe as it sails serenely through the Kuiper Belt hints at unexpected levels of particles where dust ought to be thinning out, suggesting the donut-shaped field extends significantly farther from the Sun than previous estimates suggest.
- russfink 3y agoDoes that dust explain some gravitational anomalies?
- netcraft 3y agoim no astrophysicist, but if you mean the anomolies that lead us to believe that there may be a planet 9, I dont think so. This dust would be assumed to be spread around evenly, and the anomalies that make us think there is another planet would have to be clustered together in an orbit.
- ravedave5 3y agoI'm surprised to see a clickbait headline like this on HN. Thanks for posting that info.
- mikece 3y ago"It's the most recent in a growing body of evidence that our understanding of the outer Solar System is lacking..." Isn't this -- finding out that what we didn't know is far greater than we realized -- typical in any field of science or even profession? When I was 5 years into my programming career I had the cocky feeling of knowing everything. 20 years later I feel more like I know nothing because every day I'm discovering more about my profession that I never even knew existed (thank you, HN!).
- rtkwe 3y agoWe tend towards finding smaller and smaller details that we didn't understand as a field matures unless it gets upended by large new discoveries. Classical mechanics for example, we can safely say we've got that pretty much locked down and know what it's good for and where we need to apply other methodologies. Also we have to zoom out from the individual view when thinking about collective knowledge in an entire field. Each individual person has a vast amount they can continue to learn of course but fields as a whole can tend towards more complete knowledge of a particular topic.
- tzs 3y ago> Classical mechanics for example, we can safely say we've got that pretty much locked down and know what it's good for and where we need to apply other methodologies Yet even classical mechanics holds some surprising mysteries, such as how bicycles self-stabilize [1]. [1] https://www.aip.org/history-programs/niels-bohr-library/ex-libris-universum/balancing-bicycles https://www.aip.org/history-programs/niels-bohr-library/ex-l...
- rtkwe 3y agoI'm not sure how closely that applies. We didn't, but mostly because people hadn't really studied it and hadn't worked through the mechanics. As soon as we really started looking AFAIK the solution came pretty quickly; it's a combination of 3 things that all make the bike steer towards where it leans: gyroscopic precession, head angle and CoM of the front steering section. All 3 of those things can be tuned to be larger or smaller and that affects the velocity required to achieve stability. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZAc5t2lkvo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZAc5t2lkvo
- jmclnx 3y agoI hope it lasts also. I am wondering if these particles will continue on to the ort cloud ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oort_cloud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oort_cloud
- Log_out_ 3y agoPropably a remnant of the birthplace of our sun? Basically a slice of the nebula that spawned the system dragged along for the longest ride ever?
- abhijat 3y agoThere is a paper linked on the article which says potential causes for the dust distribution are Kuiper belt object collisions and radiation pressure (I'm assuming from the sun?) pushing dust outward > New data (Figure 3) at larger heliocentric distances show that the SDC-reported dust f l uxes, out to 55 au, remained higher than current models expected. Each of the three physical phenomena: optical properties and radiation pressure (Arnold et al. 2019); compositional variation between silicates and ice (Grigorieva et al. 2007); and a further reaching than currently identif i ed distribution of dust-producing bodies in the solar system (Fraser et al. 2023), may contribute to the data/model deviation.
- zzanz 3y agoHere is an official NASA article on the discovery: https://www.nasa.gov/missions/new-horizons/nasas-new-horizons-detects-dusty-hints-of-extended-kuiper-belt/ https://www.nasa.gov/missions/new-horizons/nasas-new-horizon... It probably has a better title too, considering the more clickbaity title above.