5 ms·
Use of decimal point is 1.5 centuries older than historians thought
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- KineticLensman 3y agoTFA only mentions two of the mathematicians involved. The full paper being reported [0] makes it clearer that, as ever, there was a much richer nuanced history with many interacting players. It also describes the specific calculations involved. [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0315086024000016?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S031508602...
- blensor 3y agoThey could have said 150 years, but then, where's the point
- kinix 3y agoGlad you got here before me, it put a full stop to me making the same comment
- robertlagrant 3y agoI believe that would cover the same period, yes.
- mapreduce 3y ago> They could have said 150 years, but then, where's the point I know jokes are generally discouraged on this forum but this one is clever and done really well with good taste. Seems appropriate for the kind of crowd we have here. Very well done, sir!
- Terr_ 3y agoSignificant Digits are besides the point.
- caxco93 3y agoI think that is exactly the reason why they went with 1.5
- stareatgoats 3y agoIANAM or historian for that matter, but shouldn't an article like this mention that the use of positional decimal fractions is much older? at least according to the Wikipedia article on decimal separators: "Positional decimal fractions appear for the first time in a book by the Arab mathematician Abu'l-Hasan al-Uqlidisi written in the 10th century.[9] The practice is ultimately derived from the decimal Hindu–Arabic numeral system used in Indian mathematics,[10] and popularized by the Persian mathematician Al-Khwarizmi,[11] when Latin translation of his work on the Indian numerals introduced the decimal positional number system to the Western world. His Compendious Book on Calculation by Completion and Balancing presented the first systematic solution of linear and quadratic equations in Arabic."
- codeflo 3y agoThe idea is a lot older than Al-Khwarizmi: positional base-60 fractions were already used by the Babylonians in *2000 BC*.
- ithkuil 3y agoBabylonians did indeed use positional notation. But they didn't use the "point" to separate integral and fractional parts of a number. Moreover they didn't even write zeros to indicate an order of magnitude! You just had to know the right scale out of context I'm going to write the numbers in base 10 just for simplicity (they used base 60 which has many more divisors and works much nicely): Numbers 20, 200, 2, 0.2 and 0.00002 would be written simply "2" The reciprocal of 2 would be 5 The reciprocal of 5 would be 2 If that doesn't seem to make sense, let's just reassert that a given "spelling" of a number actually represents infinite numbers: a base and a free "scale" parameter. Thus 5 is also 0.5 The reciprocal of 0.5 is indeed 2 and thus it works. It's like a kind of "modular" arithmetic but for scale. I know that it allowed them to consult tables with reciprocal numbers which helped them to actually perform divisions using just multiplication. I don't know what method they used to keep track of the scale. Was it some kind of out of band "context" or just using common sense to guess the magnitude of the result?
- Someone 3y agoI agree. Reading > The invention of the decimal point led to the development of the decimal system I think the writer didn’t grasp the difference between “writing numbers as a sequence of place-valued digits, using a separator between the integer and fractional parts” and using, specifically, a dot as that separator, which (as far as we know now) came much later. The paper (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0315086024000016?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S031508602...) doesn’t make that error. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_separator#Hellenistic–Renaissance_eras https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_separator#Hellenistic–... hints at the point ‘won’ being because of the invention of thypesetting, saying “Later, a "separatrix" (i.e., a short, roughly vertical ink stroke) between the units and tenths position became the norm among Arab mathematicians (e.g. 99ˌ95), while an L-shaped or vertical bar (|) served as the separatrix in England. When this character was typeset, it was convenient to use the existing comma (99,95) or full stop (99.95) instead.”)
- throw0101b 3y agoMore important question: comma or period? :)
- weebull 3y agoI'd like to understand where this difference originates from. It can be very confusing working with Germans (for example).
- throwawayben 3y agoWikipedia has a quite detailed history section: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_separator https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_separator
- ysofunny 3y agothe answer is the same as tabs or spaces
- GrumpySloth 3y agoIt’s not so arbitrary. I’ve grown up in a country which uses commas, but it’s still really confusing even to me, when writing e.g. f(1,2). Is that function applied to 2 arguments or 1? For this reason I always use period as decimal point.
- winety 3y agoI'd say: Spacing matters, f(1,2) is different from f(1, 2). Just use a semicolon to separate the numbers, e.g. f(1,2; 2).
- GrumpySloth 3y agoMaths is typically written fast, so subtle spacing is too weak a signal to distinguish meanings. Where I studied maths, we even crossed our zeds horizontally to make it easier to distinguish from carelessly written 2s. Similarly, even though the country uses commas, the uni uses periods, for the benefit of clarity. Almost noone uses semicolons in function application in writing.
- jmclnx 3y ago>found use of a decimal point by a Venetian merchant 150 years before Interesting a merchant was the one who so far started using it in the 1400s. Since Venice was based upon trade, I wonder if some older use could be found in The Ottoman Empire or one of the Arab or India Empires ?
- zoomablemind 3y agoAnyone tried to translate the example given in the TFA manuscript excerpt image? There are way too many dots in the text.
- fhars 3y agoThe paper is linked in the article, from it: At one point he squares the distance 92 pedes, 9 untia, 0 minuta, 9 secunda. He writes this quantity as “.92909.”, and its square as “.8.6.3.2.0.8.2.2.8.1″
- zoomablemind 3y agoThanks. Well, roughly this is equivalent to 92909**2 = 8632082281 which is correct arithmetically, yet still not a clear application of dec point. Assuming 'pedes' is steps, 'untia', 'minuta', and 'secunda' are some dec divisions of a step, then the result notation has too many points to keep the meaning. Looks like more of a reading/spacing convenience for a whole number with many digits. Not much about decimal point.
- DeathArrow 3y agoIn many countries the decimal point is actually a comma.
- moi2388 3y agoYes but their commas are decimal points so it’s all good
- fuzzfactor 3y agoCan't read the article but which one predates which? I can only imagine there's a reason they're called decimal points.
- IdiranVibe 3y agoWell, they tend to not call them decimal points in those countries/languages either!