4 ms·
Vietnam to collect biometrics – even DNA – for new ID cards
- frank_bb 3y ago[dead]
- hnbad 3y agoAnd state capitalists will keep defending Vietnam as "communist" because the universities offer courses in "Dialectical Materialism and Ho Chi Minh Thought", I'm sure, just as when they denounced LGBT rights protests as an American "color revolution". It's not your DNA anymore, it's The People's DNA now. Once again goes to show that if you try to use a state to build communism all you get is a state, which is all the more likely to slide into authoritarianism because it gets to claim it's all for the common good. If you actually want to build communism, you need to start bottom up with material conditions first. This is why anarchists keep talking about prefiguration.
- neontomo 3y agoI've never been convinced that communism wasn't about power, like with capitalism, it's just different people holding the sticks.
- hnbad 3y agoThat's why I prefer the label "anarchism" even if the desired end state of anarchism fits Marx's definition of communism as a "state-less, class-less" society. To paraphrase Bakunin: I don't care if the stick I am beaten with is called The People's Stick, I want there to be no stick at all. Vanguardism by trying to utilize the existing systems of oppression to bring about communism fails the instance it succeeds in taking over those systems because the interests of rulers are not those of those ruled over. Aspirationally communist states like the Soviet Union or Mao's China merely succeeded in abolishing the capitalist class by replacing it with the bureaucracy. But under communism there must not only be no capitalist class but also no working class because the perpetuation of a working class means there is still a class system and the oppression that comes with it. Anarchist practice means creating federated, horizontal structures and dismantling oppressive hierarchies (i.e. the systems that enable people to exert power over others). You can still have individual bad actors but the damage a bad actor can do in a horizontal structure is negligible compared to what they can do in a hierarchy, especially one that rewards bad behavior (cf. people complaining that sociopaths make the best business people). So at worst, yes, you will have other people holding the sticks but the sticks will be much smaller and thus easier to overcome if used against you.
- int_19h 3y agoSome amount of hierarchy is unfortunately necessary if we want to tackle larger issues that necessarily require coordination (like, say, global warming - you can't mitigate it if any commune can just "opt out" because e.g. they personally aren't affected in a negative way). I think the important thing is to always treat hierarchy as a cost. So whenever things need to be organized, you look at that cost versus the benefits to see whether it is justifiable at all; but even if it is, you still try to minimize the cost to achieve the requisite outcome. Broadly speaking, in the context of governance in general, it means loose confederations with power mostly flowing "bottom up", but with mechanisms in place that still do allow to tackle those aforementioned emergencies like AGW that require top-down enforced coordination.
- hnbad 3y agoI think you mean violence, not hierarchy. Engels made a similar mixup when he wrote a screed against anarchists based on a misunderstanding of "authority" to mean any form of violence. Anarchy describes organization and cooperation within a group. There can be groups that have different interests and those differences in interests can lead to disagreements that can be resolved in different ways. That doesn't change. Even in prehistorical gift economies there is evidence for various forms of diplomacy to arrange agreements with other groups: migration, gifts, demonstrations of power, ceremonial fights or, as a last resort, war. It's worth pointing out that this is no different today. States can make all the laws they want but if they want other states to do what they say, they need to find a different way to do so. And more often than not, this fails unless both sides can find a mutually beneficial agreement.
- int_19h 3y agoI meant both. To get back to my example, groups operating completely independently would not be able to solve AGW. To solve it, you need a single coordinated plan across different groups, and people and organizations who will see it through. At that point, you have a hierarchy. Further, some groups will refuse to participate for selfish reasons, and thus it may be necessary to compel them to participate in said hierarchy. But there are different ways to arrange those things. The problem with most hierarchies today is that they're sold as something innately good, not as necessary evil to solve a particular problem. If you're building a hierarchy with the latter perspective in mind, you add plenty of checks and balances to make sure that it does not entrench and take over other issues.
- shadowgovt 3y agoCorrect, and it even seems self-evident from the phrase "dictatorship of the proletariat" that many communist theorists adopted as descriptive of their theory.
- the_af 3y agoIt's worth noting that in communist theory (which you mentioned), the dictatorship of the proletariat is an intermediate step before communism is fully achieved, it's not the end goal. In practice I'm not sure the proletariat ever held this power (as a class; individuals may have).
- tcmart14 3y agoAnd in communist thoughts, capitalism is sometimes referred to as "the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie." I've always taken it to mean where power relies and not in the modern sense of what we call a dictatorship.
- int_19h 3y agoIt can be interpreted more or less literally, depending. Thing is, while Marx is the originator of that term and concept, the source from which most people are aware of it is actually Lenin/Bolsheviks and their offshoots (Mao etc), and they were very much on the literalist side of that interpretation. But they had to be to do what they wanted - a society run by workers - because they managed to take power in Russia, a country, where 80% of the population were peasants who did not, as a rule, support Bolsheviks (the de facto Russian peasant party was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_Revolutionary_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_Revolutionary_Party). Consequently, when you look at early USSR, it had gems like these in its 1924 Constitution: "ARTICLE 9. The Congress of Soviets of the USSR is composed of representatives of the urban Soviets and of the Soviets of the urban type, on the basis of one deputy per 25,000 electors, and of representatives of the Congresses of Soviets of the rural districts on the basis of one deputy per 125,000 inhabitants." That is, rural (peasant) votes were explicitly diluted ~1:5 wrt urban (worker) votes in the Soviet council system. Needless to say, this has very little to do with democracy, but it is a good example of taking "dictatorship of the proletariat" literally.
- Jiro 3y ago"Under capitalism, man oppresses man. But under socialism, it's the other way around."
- somenameforme 3y agoI don't understand how communism can work, even in theory, without authoritarianism. If a state guarantees minimum standards, then many people would be motivated to pursue their own interests. In a communist society, who wants to be a janitor? In a capitalist society that role is filled in a very brutal fashion - clean the toilets, go find another job, or go homeless. That's nothing to be proud of, but if the choice is between that pseudo-freedom and the very real non-freedom of the government dictating you are hereby deemed a toilet cleaner, I'd much rather go for the former. I'd also add that I only mention janitor as something more relatable. There are a tremendous number of less well known jobs where people essentially have to sacrifice their health to provide the niceties we all take for granted. For instance if you've ever been in a town with a paper mill, it smells horrible 24/7 and its effects on everybody's health are even worse. How/why would anybody ever work/live in such places in a communist system, unless forced to?
- ttymck 3y agoIt sounds like you've described two systems where folks are forced to work at a paper mill.
- NhanH 3y agoCommunism assumes that no one has to clean the toilet, but the toilet would still be cleaned. It’s the abundance of resources premise. You can’t have communism in a scarcity world. The common example being taught to kids are oxygen: think of how everyone can consume as much as they need, and there are enough for everyone. How the toilet actually get clean is left as the exercise for the reader.
- hnbad 3y agoIt's tiring to hear people critique communists using the same tired arguments I hear from Christians critiquing atheism. "If there is no God, why wouldn't you rape and murder everyone" and "If there is no police, why would you clean the toilet" have the same answer. Yes, if you have a toilet and think cleaning toilets is yucky but you value having a clean toilet, you'll have to ask someone to clean it for you and they'll likely not want this to be a one-sided relationship unless you're literally phyiscally or mentally disabled to the point people want to take care of you because you can't do so yourself. That does not require capitalism. Heck, you could even have money without having capitalism. The question is what money can buy. Under feudalism for example - not that feudalism is preferable to capitalism unless you think you'd get to be the king (and arguably not even then) - all the money in the world wouldn't have turned a peasant into a king because the lord would have just had his guards confiscate the money, kill the peasant and flay their corpse as a warning against not knowing your place in the hierarchy. Saying "if I don't pay people to clean the toilet, it'll just be dirty forever" not only betrays your own suspect attitudes to hygiene but also a complete detachment from how 99% of human interactions operate, namely based on a shared interest of not wanting to be taken advantage of and helping when you can. Some people genuinely like cleaning toilets. Some people don't mind cleaning their own toilets. Some people would really rather not have to clean their own toilets and are willing to do other things for other people. Some people are filthy slobs and would rather have a dirty toilet than clean it themselves or help others. And yes, the obvious answer to "what about jobs that will literally kill you" is: then why should anyone want to do those jobs? If the jobs are vital to the survival of the group, those sound like some pretty damn prestiguous jobs that would lead to whoever does it being held in very high regard and treated as a saint. If the jobs are largely useless to the group, they simply won't be done unless we can find a way to do it that won't kill you. The difference is that under exploitative systems we either literally force people to do so at gunpoint or we treat the workers as disposable drones and only compensate them (or invest in their safety and care) as little as we can get away with. But I understand that all of this might sound like fanciful prose if you can only ever envision systems working if they rely on exploiting some 90% of the population even though they're only held together by those 90%'s misplaced compassion.
- xkbarkar 3y agoWhen privacy is criminalized, only criminals will have privacy. Cant be bothered to search for who said that to give credit. Phrase still stands
- bertman 3y agohttps://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Phil_Zimmermann https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Phil_Zimmermann Creator of PGP
- cratermoon 3y agoIt's interesting how in the US people rail against government moves like this in Vietnam while giving a pass to private companies doing the same thing. Ostensibly, it's OK because the companies don't have the law to enforce participation, but practically speaking there are lots of ways to coerce people into giving up their privacy by making the consequences of not giving it up such that they are effectively excluded from economic life. Of course these companies do sell the data, and they sell it to governments, so the end result is the same. The extra step allows the middleman to turn a profit, so in western neoliberal economics it's not only permissible, it's laudable.
- shadowgovt 3y agoWhen privacy is the price of a hamburger, those who hold their privacy dear will cook for themselves.
- vkou 3y agoWhen privacy is the price of participation in society, those who hold their privacy dear will live in a tent under a bridge or as an off-the-grid hermit in the woods. Employment, credit, medical care, access to shelter, transportation, utilities are all hard-gated behind 'voluntarily' giving up your personal information to firms that will either sell, or share, or leak it. (I just got a notification that Delta Dental is very sorry it lost mine, I guess I should add dental care to that list.) In the US the political zeitgeist is to rail against any kind of government overreach, while closing both eyes and plugging both ears to overreach or abuse done by anyone who has a profit motive.
- karaterobot 3y ago> Local media reported at the time of the amendments that changes were made to reflect trends in digital society management. I had not heard of this term, and I don't find much of substance regarding digital society management on the web. But it does seem to exist as a cluster of concepts at the union of academic, Orwellian, and marketing vocabularies. Sometimes you see a phrase and feel dread that you'll have to live in a world where it's just an ordinary thing people say. I remember when "Department of Homeland Security" felt dystopian. Now it feels like an ordinary, well-worn phrase that I intellectually know must be dystopian, but the nerve endings that used to tingle are now burned out. Here's to the continual process of redefining normal.
- dudefeliciano 3y agothis talk was pretty interesting and scary at ccc https://media.ccc.de/v/37c3-12004-please_identify_yourself https://media.ccc.de/v/37c3-12004-please_identify_yourself
- nonrandomstring 3y agoPrivacy was only one of the issues mentioned in that talk alongside exclusion/lockout, racism, compulsion or choice. The subtext seemed to be that the Indian project was reckless, violated multiple rights, and revealed multiple problems, whereas the European version observed UDHR and ECHR definitions of "right to privacy" and much more. In summary the Euro ID schedule is much more cautious. Resilience is a real problem in my view. When these systems go tits-up - and they will go spectacularly tits-up as biosciences and AI advance - the lack of alternatives like RFID cards, papers, trusted notaries etc will have a colossal impact. The danger is not the idea of legibility for digital governance (we already have that) but the blind, gushing enthusiasm to build one centralised system around singular technologies.
- BlueTemplar 3y agoYeah. > Vietnam’s future identity cards will incorporate the functions of health insurance cards, social insurance books, driver's licenses, birth certificates, and marriage certificates, as defined by the amendment. The project of digital file-sharing across administrations, all being tied to a single social security number, became a scandal and was made illegal for a reason !
- caymanjim 3y agoGiven the number of people who voluntarily submit DNA to ancestry and other analysis sites, it really doesn't have much practical impact if governments collect it. Even without yours, they have enough of your relatives' to identify you. I have the same knee-jerk reaction as everyone else to government encroaching on privacy, but in the end we've all long since voluntarily given up any semblance of privacy. We're all carrying tracking devices and filling our homes with microphones and our families have given away our DNA for us. Privacy doesn't exist.
- temp0826 3y agoI expect someday that the entire population's full genomes will be recorded (by some government entity or otherwise) and public. It's sadly only a matter of time.
- teeray 3y ago> Even without yours, they have enough of your relatives' to identify you This is what makes me mildly irritated about “consent to collect DNA samples.” DNA is not just you, unlike other biometrics, like fingerprints—it’s your relatives too. This makes it hypothetically possible, for example, for some insurer to genetically determine you have a preexisting condition without ever consenting to give your DNA. Of course this will never get unwound because of the enormous boon to law enforcement these mega gene databases have been.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 3y ago"I also care, but actually I don't" wow
- hervem 3y agoExcept that Viet. gov. isn't really good at putting directive.. During Covid, Vietnam had ~20 official applications to track vaccination and half of them could give travel/move certificate. And to not stop, every city & district did manage differently "inventory" from application, google form, excel over Dropbox to hand managed paper. To finish, I don't even imaging how it could end; IT security speaking.
- dadjoker 3y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- bookofjoe 3y ago>Newborn DNA Banking [in the U.S.; 2010] https://www.aclu.org/documents/newborn-dna-banking https://www.aclu.org/documents/newborn-dna-banking
- latchkey 3y agoThey say in the article that it is no small feat, but in Vietnam, there is a lot of government. Even the most rural communities (where people literally have no running water or barely and electricity), they have local party officials overseeing things. If they want to get this done, it'll get done.
- alephnerd 3y ago> where people literally have no running water or barely and electricity It's changed rapidly in the past few years. I've been to rural Gia Lai (a friend of mine is from there), and the amount of basic infrastructure being implemented is astounding. They are trying to use digital infra similar to what Aadhar was used for in India. It also makes sense to lock it biometrically given that the Cambodia and Laos borders are extremely porous, and it's fairly common for smugglers or migrants to try and bribe someone for VN ID cards. Digital infra is the fastest and most efficient way to disburse welfare without worrying about corruption or shrinkage. If that means being reducing civil liberties, so be it. You can't eat PGP or use it to send your kid to high school. > local party officials overseeing things They're useless (at least in Gia Lai). They messed up my friend's name on their passport and barely get anything done. It's MPS that's taking over this, and they're competent (and scary for obvious reasons)
- latchkey 3y agoI spent 2 years on a motorbike going all over VN/Cambodia/Laos... you go outside of the cities and it is village after village of people with very little infrastructure. Gia Lai isn't that rural. I drove AH17 and QL14c. I'm thinking more in the North. Ha Giang, Cao Bang, even out to Sapa. ALL of the borders are porous. I literally drove over the northern border into China at some random point, and there was nobody there. It is super easy to go back and forth. I also drove a lot of the trade routes along the border cut into the forests. ID cards aren't going to stop anything. You are definitely correct about competency. No argument there.
- alephnerd 3y ago> I'm thinking more in the North. Ha Giang, Cao Bang, even out to Sapa Ah, the only parts of Vietnam poorer than Gia Lai. Fair enough. > Gia Lai isn't that rural On QL14c and AH17 it isn't, but in between those two highways it definetly is (think dirt roads, wooden shanties like you'd see in neighboring Mondulkiri/Ratanakiri). > ID cards aren't going to stop anything. If you are distributing social assistant payments, you need identification. If you leave identification to local PD (who are paid too little to care about being competent), it's not that difficult to bribe them to either add or remove you from a registry, or create multiple ghost identities in order to siphon social assistance payments (probably at the behest of the local party official). The only true form of identification that is tamper-proof is biometric. > ALL of the borders are porous Agreed, but Laos and Cambodia are significantly more impoverished than Vietnam, especially the portions of Cambodia and Laos neighboring VN. It's hard for someone there to migrate to Thailand like how Cambodians in Siem Reap or Laotians around Vientiane do.
- tamiral 3y agolots of countries share data and also require you to get finger printed, iris scanned, photo taken etc which is already a lot of biometrics.. not sure for this DNA thing looks a little excessive...