5 ms·
Implants and other technologies that decode neural activity
- lenerdenator 3y agoI feel like this is one of those things where a genius develops this technology and acts like it'll bring major insights into how people operate and then they just find out it's nothing but "I'm hungry/thirsty/horny/tired" 90% of the time.
- aatd86 3y agoYou must not have intrusive thoughts... :D Perhaps that some people have telepathic powers and that will be discovered. Besides that, all the usual inscrutable ailments that people may suffer from, adhd, sz, bpd, tourette etc...
- bbor 3y agoYeah but this is mind reading. Idk if “most people are boring” is the right reaction to such a pressing and absolutely terrifying threat to our personal safety and autonomy, in the long term. I hate god for making LLMs work…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iamacyborg 3y agoIt’ll be interesting to see if and how this tech ends up being used to prove/disprove free will.
- LoganDark 3y ago"Free will" doesn't seem to have a generally accepted concrete definition to be proven or disproven in the first place. Besides, as someone with ADHD I know that even if I have free will, other parts of my brain work against me anyway, so I don't actually have total control over my actions.
- iamacyborg 3y agoI think it’s generally understood to mean that you can consciously decide to do a specific thing. The “anti” free will side is generally understood to mean that the brain chooses to do something and then you experience it as a decision after the fact. That’s my understanding of it at the very least and I tend to lean towards the “It thinks therefore I am” side of things.
- mistercow 3y agoAll definitions (that I’ve ever heard) do this thing, though, where they just instantly add more concepts that either don’t have precise definitions, or whose definitions instantly render free will trivially existent or nonexistent, depending on what you go with. What do “you”, “consciously” and “decide” mean? And in particular, how is “you” distinct from “the brain”?
- iamacyborg 3y agoIt probably helps if you look at some of the existing experimental work that’s been done in the field, starting with the infamous Libet paper. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6640273/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6640273/
- mistercow 3y agoI’m aware of that research, but my point is that whether you consider that to have any bearing on free will depends largely on where you draw those other boundaries.
- idiotsecant 3y agoThis doesn't fundamentally answer what the post you're responding to is asking. What do you mean by 'you'? When we use that word we often presuppose that such a thing exists. I suspect that if you dig deep enough 'you' will be something like a fancy version of a mixture of experts 'blind sight' system.
- 3y ago
- akomtu 3y agoRegimes like North Korea will implant it into soldiers and prisoners so it gives an electric shock every time those show signs of "wrong" neural activity. False positives is a plus. Other similar regimes will follow.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoElon will absolutely use this to "permaban" someone from meatspace if Neuralink ever takes off.
- astroboiiii 3y agoLil kidney pains if you go to the library when you were supposed to go elsewhere :(
- bbor 3y agoI think it’ll do even more: show why that’s impossible. We already know that thoughts are electric patterns, so the thought that the manipulation of those patterns could change the inputs or outputs of your conscious mind shouldn’t be a surprise.
- downboots 3y agoAn unpolished thought: Consider the case of a computer simulation of a worm [0] If your simulation predicts the worm behavior up to some tolerance, you then laugh at it's supposed free will There's some outside conditions that can't be controlled (the simulator is also a subset of the same universe) and may deterministically affect the worm behavior To fully account for these factors and their corresponding deterministic chains, the simulation must grow more and more complex if you want more precision Maybe free will could be thought instead of as a determinism ratio taking into account compute limits I suspect a logical contradiction could arise presuming a subset of the universe being able to simulate the whole universe If the simulation has to be limited, some "wiggle room" of free will must be granted to the worm [0] https://openworm.org/ https://openworm.org/
- a-dub 3y agomy pet theory: consciousness, free will, the soul, the spice, whatever you want to call it is a sum of the evolutionary process which produces a living being plus the noise that its substrate and environment excite it with. i believe that the true fuel that drives complex behaviors in neurological systems is noise, and what appears to be free will is simply noise that we can never completely measure, understand or replay. i suspect neurological systems are deterministic only in context of a completely deterministic environment/universe which for our purposes simply doesn't exist. so maybe the field of artificial intelligence, with its completely deterministic and replayable ttl worlds may produce some interesting results around the notion of free will, but i suspect that unless we can replay and then mutate the physical world deterministically, we'll never know if the study of neurological systems can. if you excite a machine with noise, and it creates a memory while producing a complex behavior, is it any less alive than a living biological system that is excited by the noise in its environment? my $.02, definitely keep the change!
- bbor 3y agoIf anyone wants to get into this field, I did a bunch of research recently and the Gtech Unicorn is by far the best option for entry level devs AFAICT. Now we just need to wait until someone starts selling fNIRS+EEG+ultrasound lightweight headsets with built-in LLM processing functions for noise removal and spatial mapping. From there it’s a hop skip and a jump to mind control, sadly. Calling it now, within 5 years American police will start experimenting with EEG helmets for detecting impairment. EDIT: also implants are rediculously unnecessary and dangerous. And that’s just for sensing - please please please never let a Silicon Valley company modulate your brain. That’s sci fi lesson #1, above “don’t do clones” and “time travel is bad”
- vsnf 3y agoIt's the year 2062 and Neuralink has finally perfected mind-reading implants. Dictatorial regimes across the globe are forcibly implanting children with the technology, their every thought sent to the Bureau of Ethics and Education. In accordance with new laws, adults also must submit to an implant, lest they face severe penalties of jail time. Citizens with unsanctioned thoughts are apprehended and re-educated. Those unhappy with the state of affairs no longer have any opportunity to gather like minded others or sympathetic supporters, as the Bureau is alerted to their unharmonious thoughts, and they are intercepted before any collective action can be taken. The regime is stable, the citizenry completely suppressed, the dictators free to continue their atrocities as they see fit, unopposed, forever.
- bilekas 3y agoTo be honest as grim as this is, judging by how little resistance there currently is to adopt new technologies and services regardless of privacy concerns, the majority of people most likely won't be forced at all..
- xetplan 3y agoI think it is much worse than this. I think of my 12 year old niece. She doesn't have a concept of privacy the way I have a concept of privacy. It would never occur to me to film someone in public without their consent for privacy reasons. For younger people, it would never occur to them why you wouldn't film potentially good online content. The idea we are going back to the past seems delusional at best.
- astroboiiii 3y ago*2021 depending on who you ask
- hoseja 3y agoJust to be clear, what is your stance on moderating hate speech on social platforms?
- te_chris 3y ago
- freilanzer 3y agoFrom the moment I understood the weakness of my flesh, it disgusted me. I craved the strength and certainty of steel. I aspired to the purity of the Blessed Machine. Your kind cling to your flesh, as though it will not decay and fail you. One day the crude biomass you call the temple will wither, and you will beg my kind to save you. But I am already saved, for the Machine is immortal… Even in death I serve the Omnissiah.
- iamacyborg 3y agoAh, a fellow power washing fan.