6 ms·
Job posts for workers without degrees are booming, but not the hiring
- tareqak 3y agoWhat about having paid internships / apprenticeships for everyone regardless of whether or not they have started or finished a diploma or degree program?
- DebtDeflation 3y ago>Job posts for workers without degrees are booming, but not the hiring You could remove "without degrees" from the above and it would still be true. Whether the purpose is job market research or filling resume banks, the fake job posting has been elevated to an art form.
- santiagobasulto 3y agoThis is like traditional inheritance based OOP vs Mixin architectures. A degree is traditional inheritance, you ARE something (a doctor, a software dev, etc). Having the skills is like Mixins. You CAN do X, Y, Z. For example, you have the skills to do Data Wrangling with Pandas, you have the skills to perform classification with scikit-learn, etc. I think skill-based approaches are a lot more efficient (just as in OOP :))
- LtWorf 3y agoThe problem is that evaluating a skill takes very long.
- dotancohen 3y agoNo, a degree does not demonstrate that you ARE something - modulo defects and accidents, all humans are composed of the same parts. A degree asserts that you have demonstrated skills and knowledge of a particular subject, most often at the same institution that taught those skills and knowledge. No analogy needed.
- santiagobasulto 3y agoSo, if you find a doctor for example, in their 40s/50s, and you give them an experiment (with all the statistical parameters) and you ask them to test/reject the null hypothesis, you think they'll be able to do so? Degrees say "you ARE X", they, by extension, might INFER that you KNOW the Skills X, Y, Z that are part of the study plan. But that's not granted. Having a degree doesn't mean you have the skills. You might have forgotten, you might have cheated, etc. Thesting for the skill in particular is the only way.
- dotancohen 3y agoNo, I do not think that doctors are particularly good with statistics. Nor do I think that OOP analogies are a good way to describe what a degree is.
- santiagobasulto 3y agoIf doctors aren't good at statistics we're all doomed :) Their job is literally being a statistics human reference.
- hnbad 3y agoDegrees are signals. A degree from a reputable university signals both a group membership in a certain social group (e.g. "Ivy League graduates") as well as a common shared experience. A degree in general also signals some level of social status (i.e. able to afford that university) as well as the rote learning ability, endurance and willingness to put up with arbitrary hurdles and rules to achieve that degree. To an extent it also demonstrates an ability and willingness to subordination and deference to authority. You seem to believe that companies look for the most skilled person to do a given job. They don't, even if they keep saying that. They look for someone willing to put up with as much bullshit and punishment as the company can get away with while creating as much profit for the company (or whichever metric is used instead) as possible without making the company leadership look bad. For higher positions like management they usually look for someone exactly like who they already have but who won't threaten their status within the company. For leadership positions they usually look for someone who won't fraternize with the subordinates and knows how to play politics. In addition to its use as signals, degrees used as a filter are also a base level way to demonstrate due diligence. If you take the guy without a degree, that's a risk and if he's a dud, that was a bad decision. If you take the one with a degree and he turns out to be a dud, that's just bad luck.
- nlstitch 3y agoUhm, same goes for job posts with degrees. There are A LOT of fake job postings right now. Im coming across postings that are open for six hours and people never repond.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y agoi remember when job posts used to be for jobs now they're more like billboards that never get taken down just to fill a space
- sokoloff 3y agoSome (not all) of the strongest employees I’ve worked with had no degrees (often “not completed” rather than “never started”) and my own degree is in Mechanical Engineering, despite only ever having worked with computers. > If there are two candidates — one with a degree, one without, “to many hiring managers, it will feel risky,” he said. But the above quote seems logical for me as well. In an interview situation, I have evidence that the person with a degree can follow rules/policies and track towards a long-term goal with success. Like it or not, that is a signal of something that’s relevant in lots of business/office situations and so, all else equal, I’d expect managers to lean towards the degree-holder.
- pknomad 3y ago> Some (not all) of the strongest employees I’ve worked with had no degrees (often “not completed” rather than “never started”) and my own degree is in Mechanical Engineering, despite only ever having worked with computers. There's an element of self selection. Perhaps you're working at a place where only highly capable employees work and people without college education who work at your place are capable of succeeding without one in the first place? My manager seems to fit the mold you're describing. There are definitely people out there who are brilliant and don't need a college degree to show that. I am a frequent poster at /r/itcareerquestions and a mod for /r/engineeringresumes and my anecdotal observation is that on average, college serves as a decent filter for separating hirable people from the rest. I apologize for my incendiary comment but I see that many people who lack college degree tend to have big character flaws (whether it's from nature or nurture) those flaws would get in the way of their success even if their respective employer didn't look at college education as a measuring stick for hirability.
- ZephyrBlu 3y ago> college serves as a decent filter for separating hirable people from the rest Yes, it's obvious to everyone that a degree is correlated with being hireable because having a degree is also correlated with a lot of favourable attributes like intelligence and conscientiousness. If you want a warm body a degree is a good filter. This is contradictory to strongest/highly capable employees though. For that case, having a degree is an extremely lazy filter. You filter unhireable people, but you also filter extremely hireable people.
- briandear 3y agoShouldn’t literally all jobs be skills-based?
- ghxst 3y agoBeing skilled is only part of being a good employee, I think it's fair to look at a degree as an indication that someone is able to commit to something long term etc but of course I have to assume there's a way for people without degrees to make up for that indication.
- briandear 3y agoMeasuring commitment using a university degree is rather silly. I have two degrees, including an MBA, and I’m just as non-committal as I was before the degrees.
- mrits 3y agoYou'd also have to show it is a commitment to the job and and not a commitment to improving themselves. Common sage advise now is to job hop at the beginning of your career.
- ghaff 3y agoI mean, it's a question of degree (ha!). An MBA (I have one) is pretty straightforward if you have a technical degree from a decent school; read any of the MBA first year books and it's always the math that gets people as was certainly the case when I was a tutor. But, even so, it takes some degree of commitment to plow through a formal education program.
- ghaff 3y agoIt's also an indication--assuming a school of a certain tier--that someone else has already put the effort into vetting a person so you may not even need to. As far as a degree is concerned, I was once given an offer without even interviewing. I asked to come in and talk to people anyway but I didn't need to.
- 3y ago
- bluedino 3y agoI can't get hired at my current gig because I don't have a degree (but they'll let me be a contractor...). The joke is the PhD fellows and principals don't want some Linux hacker that never went to college fixing all their code that doesn't work. Edit: shit/code
- anthk 3y agoFixing shit is not a task of an engineer, but a technician.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoCentering a div for six figures also doesn't make you an engineer.
- Uptrenda 3y agoAt my last job I was hired to fix security issues found in some code being audited. I didn't 'write' or design the code myself. Yet the process was really just the same as regular software engineering. I wrote new code to implement algorithms that were missing, fixed validation logic, improved testing, and wrote some simple scripts to make working with some of the file formats easier. I'd have just been a 'technician' to you but IMO: it involved all the same skills as if I'd have designed it myself. You still need to know what all the code does well enough to have written it and have the skills to improve it. So I'm not sure the distinction really matters here.
- aeonik 3y agoNot gonna lie. This perspective leaves a very bad taste in my mouth. Why do you think engineers don't or shouldn't fix things? Isn't the very idea of designing a system: solving a problem, and isn't problem solving synonymous with "fixing a problem". One can choose to implement various formal and rigorous methods throughout a process, but at the end of the day it's all the same activity.
- msmenardi 3y agoas an ex-technician, I'd have to agree. With the caveat that they should choose how they want to fix your shit.
- MarCylinder 3y agoOne of the only, if not the only, persons at my company without a degree. On the fast track to director, and currently in senior management. I'm not downplaying degrees, but not all fields need one.
- tyingq 3y agoVaries wildly by workplace culture, recruiting filters, etc. It's certainly a barrier for many.
- ghxst 3y agoFrom my personal experience, this rings true but mostly when applying for junior level positions. I've found that both myself and others I know in similar situations have had a lot more success applying for medior to senior level positions (assuming you have the confidence and experience to back it up).
- Rapzid 3y agoMy experience as well; haven't really been asked since getting mid+. Once before getting hired in an interview with the CEO at a startup, but just shrugged it off. Usually this comes up(outside interview but on this instance too) like this: "Oh, where did you go to college?" "I didn't." "Ohh.." Lol. I got hired by that company anyway and it worked out really well for both parties:)
- khokhol 3y ago"Oh, where did you go to college?" "If you didn't read my resume, why are you interviewing me?"
- Rapzid 3y agoI left college college dropout off my resume. Otherwise yeah I think many can sympathize with being hired and having managers not know your history. "Oh you have experience operating SaaS and designing cloud infra? You know how to build packages?!" "Dude, I've been working as an AWS solutions architect and developer for like 8 years and worked as the primary systems engineer at an ISP and VPS provider. Why did you even hire m... I want a raise."
- 23B1 3y agoWhenever I read about the job market, there's always these massive gaps in either the reporting (or my understanding): 1. Job applications disappear into a black hole once submitted. There is no clear understanding as to what happens between clicking SUBMIT and HIRED/REJECTED. 2. There is no understanding of hiring methodologies, or even generally accepted best practices. What are the qualifications of a frontline recruiter? Their chain of command? How are reqs and JDs written, edited, processed, and managed? 3. Generally speaking, how is pay determined? There's no central database of salaries and experiences – which is fine, but then how do we gauge 'who pays better' especially compared to other quantifiable factors like what comes out on a 10K I understand some of this information may be impossible to attain, but I can't think of a topic that more heavily dominates the news cycle but that also seems to be completely built upon a black hole of innuendo, mystery, and guesswork.
- wccrawford 3y agoI tried to get a job without a degree and it wasn't going well, so I went and got one. Then, it still wasn't going well. But I eventually found a company that interviewed me, and it came down to me an 1 other person, and on paper, they looked a lot better than me. They gave me a test (brainbench, IIRC) and I absolutely smoked the other guy on every part of it. So in the end, I didn't need a degree. My next job didn't care at all about my degree, just my 5 years of experience and what I knew how to do.
- highwayman47 3y agomillenials get screwed again
- m0llusk 3y agomillenials killing employment
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- klipklop 3y agoI just see this as a ploy to "de-value" certain jobs. If somebody with a degree applies they will happily hire them over somebody without one. As a bonus (for the company) they will say during salary negotiation something along the lines of "This is an entry level job not requiring a degree, the most we can pay is X."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoIf there's anything suggested by comments on HN posts about hiring, it's that people don't know how to hire, and just make stuff up. I'm reminded of the talk by the ex-Google hiring committee person, who reported that not only did their research show that the interviewers' ratings didn't predict the relative performance of people who were hired, but also that his entire committee rejected all of their own (anonymized) interview review packets. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8RxkpUvxK0?t=8m20s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8RxkpUvxK0?t=8m20s