6 ms·
A city doesn't have space restrictions. It has transportation restrictions. If you manage to make people travel around faster, you increase the housing supply
by marcosdumay 3y ago
A city doesn't have space restrictions. It has transportation restrictions.
If you manage to make people travel around faster, you increase the housing supply by a much higher amount than you can by converting local land into housing.
So, everybody would be better by increasing the reach and area for train tracks, even if you convert a reasonable amount of nearby area into parks, if also, while you are at it, you provide some way for local transit to integrate with the long-distance one.
The dichotomy on the article is just plainly wrong. Transportation enables you to improve on both, and without transportation you will have neither.
- ghaff 3y agoGeography also matters of course. And many many companies are not actually located in a city. Better commuter rail/light rail is desirable. On the other hand, a commute is still a commute. I'm actually quite convenient to a commuter rail station that ties into the city's subway quite well. But I pretty much hate commuting into the city on the few days I have to do it because it still takes a big chunk out of my day.
- kiba 3y agoBetter commuter rail/light rail is desirable. On the other hand, a commute is still a commute. I'm actually quite convenient to a commuter rail station that ties into the city's subway quite well. But I pretty much hate commuting into the city on the few days I have to do it because it still takes a big chunk out of my day. If the speed isn't actually fast, then transportation needs to be improved.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm about 45 miles outside of the city. Once you have 15 stops or so I'm not sure how much you can improve things?
- kiba 3y agoI'm about 45 miles outside of the city. Once you have 15 stops or so I'm not sure how much you can improve things? Express train line, which means fewer stops or no stops at all between destination. There's probably various inefficiencies such as infrequent service and slowdown of the train due to track issue. For me, it's the issue of the train not being local to where I live, and infrequency of service, which means I could be waiting up to 20 minutes for the train to arrive in some cases. Stops are not as unbearable for me which felt like a minute or shorter for each stop.
- ghaff 3y agoMy train line eliminated semi-express service during the pandemic and it's still very clearly much below pre-pandemic ridership. The transit service did make improvements a number of years back but it's still clearly operating well below economic breakeven. (Which may be OK.) The station is fairly convenient to me to go in for morning rush hour. It's unusable for an evening event. The train is basically empty if I even take it at the tail-end of rush hour. And trains are understandably infrequenty scheduled outside of rush.
- presentation 3y agoTransit demand has a chicken and egg problem, in that demand will increase if the service quality is high but in a place like yours the service quality is low so demand remains low. I don’t think this improvement can happen without a clear vision and integrated plan for achieving it, initial low metrics be damned.
- ghaff 3y agoIt's hard to make commuter rail work outside of commuting hours beyond a few locations like Manhattan that are so painful and expensive to drive in and park. I'd have trouble justifying subsidizing every off-hour rider with a $100 bill given there are trains; it just will probably take you 2 or 3x the time relative to driving if you want to head home after a play or a dinner.
- wskinner 3y agoWhat about people who don’t want to live near train tracks? Or people who currently live on land that would be seized if train tracks were to be built? Not everyone wants to live in a city.
- CalRobert 3y agoI don't want to live near cars yet it is virtually illegal for me to get that short of becoming a hermit in the mountains. What about me?
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe polled preferences of Americans look something like 60-40 in favor of single family homes. The actual land distribution in metropolitan areas looks more like 95-5. To some degree, building more train tracks and allowing dense housing relieves pressure on the remaining areas.
- Tagbert 3y agoor people don't tell the whole truth in polls?
- bobthepanda 3y agowe have no way of figuring that out. The land is not legally permissive to get to a true market-oriented distribution of housing.
- wskinner 3y agoSure we do. We can investigate the living preferences of people with the means to choose between multiple options.
- kiba 3y agoWhat about people who don’t want to live near train tracks? Or people who currently live on land that would be seized if train tracks were to be built? Not everyone wants to live in a city. You see those gigantic parking lots and 4 way stroads? Many of the parking lots are empty for much of the day, and stroads are dangerous and inefficient. For that matter, freeways and interstate highways are valuable resources we could repurpose for train tracks. We have grossly inefficient transportation corridor that could easily be made more efficient. Now, there will still be need to demolish homes and businesses for public benefit, but reducing traffic and making good use of land more efficiently means less homes will needed to be demolished.