5 ms·
First satellite imagery of the Feb-13, 2024 landslide at Çöpler Mine in Turkey
- londons_explore 3y agoWho would have thought that if you pile soil up in a tall pile as high and steep as you can, right next to a huge pit, then occasionally it might fall back into the pit... A 5 year old on the beach could tell you that...
- walthamstow 3y agoA 5 year old in a Welsh primary school could tell you even more https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aberfan_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aberfan_disaster
- Loughla 3y ago109 kids died in that. Holy shit. And the senior officials got off with a slap on the wrist. That reads like a complete failure of the government. Why did the right people not hang for that?
- defrost 3y agoThe people on the right at that time (UK 1966) didn't hang as they were of an effectively protected capitalist caste with no regulation to hold them to account. If you scroll down the wiki link you can see that the changes to the Mines and Quarries Act ultimately lead to things such as the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act (1974) which provided some teeth with which to bite the owners that cut corners, paid off inspectors, etc. Swings and roundabouts though, a little while later came the Miners' Strike of 1984-1985 which was easily one of the most bitter industrial disputes Britain has ever seen. a turning point in British history. Miners left their pits to fight the attempt of the Thatcher government to close the collieries, break the miners’ union and the labour movement in general, and open the way to a free market economy in which deregulated financial capitalism would be set free by the Big Bang of 1986. The full force of the police, the courts and the media were mobilised to defeat the miners, culminating with the battle of Orgreave on 18 June 1984. Thousands of miners were arrested, fined, imprisoned or sacked, some never to work again. https://www.history.ox.ac.uk/miners-strike-1984-5-oral-history https://www.history.ox.ac.uk/miners-strike-1984-5-oral-histo... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/aug/27/40-years-miners-strike-long-shadow-uk-politics-pit-closures https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/aug/27/40-yea... All part of the delicate balance between those many hordes wanting good wages and working conditions and those few that want all the profits.
- londons_explore 3y agoIn retrospect, it was a battle that didn't matter. There were no profits to be had on either side - mining is best done mostly by machines, and will always be undercut by places with cheap labour and lax environmental regulations. The UK would never be able to compete. And besides, by the 80's it was already becoming clear that coal wasn't the future.
- defrost 3y agoYou seem unfamiliar with mining. The UK and the US aren't really big players, the single largest market for mining stocks is the Toronto TSX by a long shot - many loosely commonwealth trans national companies (Australia, Canada, South Africa, etc) with Russian, Chinese, Brazilian partners, etc. Machines play a big part - Western Australia mines almost a billion tonner of iron ore alone per annum with a tiny population, but cheap labour and lax environmental regs don't play nearly as great a part as you might think. Long term stability on 20 to 50 year time scales is pretty desirable on projects with forward capital investments of 300+ million dollars, high skill levels and good wages improve success rates, the larger mining companies have been trending more and more toward being accountable with respect to populations affected and post operation rennovation .. although that's a shift from don't care and never so .. <shrug> From a political "how society works" PoV the mining strikes and Thatcher push backs weren't about the coal either .. it was a reflection on how the new neoliberal 80s Tories intended to deal with those not aligned with their vision. There were other directions to turn labour forces of the 80s toward, but the vision as such for that time was propert development pyramids, fintech, and all that jazz. Better to be a barrow boy in The City than a gay dancing coal miner.
- mikhailfranco 3y agoSo offer the mine to the miners, if they each put up GBP nx100k capital. See if they really want the risk of loss/mortgage/debt in return for a job. Perhaps they know something beneficial that management doesn't? Workers can be capitalists if they know the business and want to take a risk. Get the responses, end of story. Yet it led to a huge (literal) battle? It was all political: an attack on the gov by the communist miners' union, backed by the Labour Party. It was never about economics, which were obviously terminal. Everybody knew that, on both sides.
- red_admiral 3y agoThe government outsourced managing Aberfan and most other mines to a National Coal Board. The tribunal who investigated the disaster was very critical of said board, but it wasn't the done thing in those days to go after senior officials. Indeed, the disaster was one of the main inputs that led to the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, the act under which senior officials nowadays can be (and sometimes are) prosecuted for negligence leading to deaths.
- BurningFrog 3y agoThe Crown, Season 3 Episode 3, tells this story.
- RealityVoid 3y agoI find comments like this not very helpful. I mean, sure tall things fall, but you have presumably competent people working with these things, people that understand risks and do this all their life. Certainly people that know more than you and me. Somehow, they failed on this, and there's lessons to learn here, but smug "hurr-durr, don't stack things tall" is not it.
- selcuka 3y ago> you have presumably competent people working with these things, people that understand risks and do this all their life. I don't know if you are Turkish, but unfortunately this statement is not a given in Turkey, mostly because of corruption, nepotism, and a general lack of respect for knowledge and experience. I personally know some of the people who built this mine.
- gus_massa 3y agoI'm not sure about Turkey, but everywhere it's common to fire the guy that is worried about security and doesn't want to cut corners. Even if they are competent, some people must choose eating or safety.
- buremba 3y agoWhen you consider the costs of "doing it the right way", the reasoning becomes much more complex no matter how competent people are. In addition to all the corruption, we also culturally tend to be more risk-tolerant when it comes to safety IMO.
- bboygravity 3y agoJust world fallacy
- ImPostingOnHN 3y ago> "hurr-durr, don't stack things tall" This is a rude and uncharitable (bordering on disingenuous) paraphrase of the post you're replying to. The fact that you tossed in an extraneous "hurr-durr" of your own seems to indicate that you feel particularly incapable of responding to what was actually said.
- yowayb 3y agoOther than rage comments of political and corporate incompetence, is there a sounder explanation of inadequate preparation and response in Türkiye? The vast majority of Turks I meet/see don’t seem to care about fully understanding their problems and putting in appropriate work. But I don’t understand why this is.
- not_a_dane 3y agoWelcome to Turkiye, that's why we shouldn't build our nuclear reactor by ourselves.
- yowayb 3y agoOh dear. I forgot about that.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago> But I don’t understand why this is. So the more general question is where group differences originate, and you would like to discuss this on HN. I‘ll go grab the popcorn.
- vkka 3y agoMost probably due to corruption. People have been actively protesting this mine for at least a couple of years now [1], including politicians [2]. [1] https://www.veryansintv.com/veryansin-tv-aylarca-haykirdi-iktidar-olu-taklidi-yapti-maden-faciasi-nasil-adim-adim-geldi/ https://www.veryansintv.com/veryansin-tv-aylarca-haykirdi-ik... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6jJjDjylPg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6jJjDjylPg
- BurningFrog 3y agoA simple first order explanation is that Turkey is still a fairly poor country.
- tokai 3y ago17th rank on GDP. Sure its worse per capita, but Turkey is not poor compared to actual poor countries.
- mrb 3y agoHere is the best video of the landslide I could find: https://youtu.be/SUD0hQjueI0 https://youtu.be/SUD0hQjueI0
- KaiserPro 3y agoThe stark thing is just how liquid the flow is. Then how fast it is. Utterly terrifying.
- jeffbee 3y agoWho invented this method of framing a vertical or square video, and why did they think it was useful?
- dylan604 3y agoBecause millennials (and later) think the vertical aspect ratio is so cool and refuse to flip the phone to record video. The vast majority of video is landscape oriented, so the default players all have that aspect. People seem to very against black mattes to fit differing aspect ratio content than the frame, so some creative type came up with this. Why is this difficult to understand?
- stetrain 3y ago> The vast majority of video is landscape oriented, so the default players all have that aspect. I'm not so sure, by hours created and viewed in recent years that may no longer be true with TikTok / Reels / Stories / Shorts.
- dylan604 3y agoOkay, for the pedantics, broadcast news is a landscape format. So if someone provides content that was recorded in portrait, something must be done to it. The black bars from matting the content is still despised, primarily by the same crowd that is shooting portrait video.
- dwighttk 3y agoThe shadows in the old and new image are really throwing me off. The new image looks like the pit is to the left and the old image looks like the left side is a huge pile.
- dwighttk 3y agoOh okay I’m getting it now… it is always a pile but the slide was off the back of the pile. It just looked so much like a pit when I saw it at first that I couldn’t get that thought out of my mind.
- dendrite9 3y agoThere also appears to be a significant shift between the images where the after image is up and to the right of the before image. But it might also be a distortion issue that isn't even across the image. The optical illusion, plus the changes in the mine due to mining make the comparison difficult.
- bcraven 3y agoThis is a well-known phenomenon in topographic maps. Here are some examples: https://ramblemaps.com/why-does-sunlight-come-from-north https://ramblemaps.com/why-does-sunlight-come-from-north
- soared 3y agoInteresting link, thanks!
- Towaway69 3y agoHow many people died? Didn't hear a thing about this. I guess they are still looking for survivors.
- mrtksn 3y agoOfficially, 9 people are missing.
- Aeolun 3y agoOne of the posts here says they were working on the surface though. That does not strike me as survivable. I find it hard to imagine anything remains to be found.
- Towaway69 3y agoApparently the nine in question were working underground, there is probably no realistic chance of survival if massive amounts of earth are covering the entrances. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68287504 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68287504
- rightbyte 3y agoI guess working underground is your only chance of survival if in such a landslide?
- Towaway69 3y agoJust getting out might be an issue... Eventually oxygen will also become problematic. Electricity and lighting might also have gone. My feelings go out to the nine missing people.
- rightbyte 3y agoThose Chilean miners were down there for quite some time. But ye the outlook is not good. I guess there is a fundamental difference in how these mines collapsed. Unless any pocket would have some "earth radio", undamaged telephone line or something I don't see how the rescuers even would begin knowing where to look.
- perihelions 3y agoWhat is a "leach heap" in an open-pit gold mine? Is it cyanide waste? - "Gold cyanidation (also known as the cyanide process or the MacArthur–Forrest process) is a hydrometallurgical technique for extracting gold from low-grade ore by converting the gold to a water-soluble coordination complex. It is the most commonly used leaching process for gold extraction.[1] [...] Production of reagents for mineral processing to recover gold represents more than 70% of cyanide consumption globally." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_cyanidation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_cyanidation [late edit]: The Hurriyet news article linked in the OP confirms this, - "Energy and Natural Resources Minister Alparslan Bayraktar stated that even if the miners are reached, the entire soil mass will still be removed from the area, addressing concerns about possible environmental damage due to the cyanide-tainted waste soil used in the gold extraction process." https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/35-mln-cubic-meters-of-soil-to-be-removed-from-erzincan-mine-landslide-190840 https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/35-mln-cubic-meters-of-soi... [edit 2]: A Turkish-language source cited in Wikipedia suggests there's a risk of this waste contaminating the Euphrates river. This mine does appear to be located right next to that river, and uphill of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Çöpler_mine_disaster#Aftermath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Çöpler_mine_disaster#Aftermath https://www.google.com/maps/place/39%C2%B025'33.6%22N+38%C2%B031'19.2%22E/@39.4324826,38.5117931,14z/data=!4m4!3m3!8m2!3d39.426!4d38.522!5m1!1e4?hl=en&entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/place/39%C2%B025'33.6%22N+38%C2%... [edit 3]: Here's a long-form Turkish journalism (published in English) discussing this question: https://www.duvarenglish.com/experts-warn-of-severe-cyanide-exposure-to-euphrates-as-mine-located-in-water-basin-news-63852 https://www.duvarenglish.com/experts-warn-of-severe-cyanide-... ("Experts warn of severe cyanide exposure to Euphrates as mine located in water basin")
- Loughla 3y agoThe part about how social media was weirdly critical of the picture, with one poster stating that flat wasn't a landslide is fascinating. Why are some people just knee-jerk 'insert thing here' deniers? What is that?
- BurningFrog 3y agoOn balance, it's probably a great feature of humanity that we always have some contrarians around.
- someplaceguy 3y agoWell, then I disagree.
- kibwen 3y ago> The ultimate cost of this landslide is likely to be many multiples of the money saved on mining operations through inadequate construction and/or operation of the leach heap. Ah, but who are the people who profited from cutting corners, and who are the people who will bear the cost of the cleanup? If these are not the exact same set of people, then it was a net profit to collapse this mine and kill these men. The profiteering will continue apace, because the system incentivizes it. The article does mention that some people were arrested, but that seems to be for direct negligence, not systematic negligence. If the highest-ranking person who sees consequences from this is merely a single VP, then it sounds like the rest of the executive parasites might be in the clear.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Ah, but who are the people who profited from cutting corners, and who are the people who will bear the cost of the cleanup? If these are not the exact same set of people, then it was a net profit to collapse this mine and kill these men. The profiteering will continue apace, because the system incentivizes it. It’s a mine. The cost of the cleanup refers to what it will cost to remove the collapsed dirt and get back to the layers at which they were mining. So to answer your question: The cost is borne by the mine operators if they want to resume mining. > The article does mention that some people were arrested, but that seems to be for direct negligence, not systematic negligence. If the highest-ranking person who sees consequences from this is merely a single VP, then it sounds like the rest of the executive parasites might be in the clear. Kind of wild that a country throws people into jail before an investigation can even be performed, yet people are out for blood and demanding that, what, the entire company leadership is thrown in jail? Everyone who might possibly be involved? There are countries where governments will use their power to throw large numbers of people in jail to seek revenge for problems, but they aren’t the workers’ paradise you imagine. They’re just terribly oppressive regimes. It’s also unlikely that these situations would only result in executives going to jail, because the people on the front lines (who are not entirely free from involvement in decision making) tend to get blamed too. Reactionary jailing feeds people’s revenge fantasies, but it’s actually a really terrible and scary way to have to live for everyone. There are a lot of extremely cynical assumptions in this comment.
- soared 3y agoNear info with video and images: https://eos.org/thelandslideblog/copler-mine-2 https://eos.org/thelandslideblog/copler-mine-2
- user90131313 3y agoFor all the HN folks, they had a very big arsenic pool near and it was used for gold mining. It will probably affect life around there because of very close river called Firat river.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoThe Firat is known in the West as the Euphrates.