5 ms·
Hackers got nearly 7M people's data from 23andMe
- comfort014 3y ago[dead]
- tonetegeatinst 3y agoI'm into cyber security as a hobby....and one thing has always confused me regarding these breaches. Lots of these things are sold on the dark web and they might release snippet samples to get a buyer but my understanding is that unlike the old days of hacking....they normally don't release the entire stolen content unless they really believe in totally free data, or they have some massive gripe with the company. Normally only those who paid get access and iirc the guy who got into the 23&me company wanted like a shitload of money for the entire dataset which was massive. I heard the entire data was somewhere between 20 and 50 terabytes but I could have wread an estimate.
- yieldcrv 3y agoso whats confusing? you can trade Fullz on the darkweb or you can gun for the whole dataset wholesale is cheaper than retail the hacking economy distributes risk the same way corporations do, the person making the hack isnt the person using the hack, isnt the person selling the hacked data, isnt the person using the hacked data
- hwbunny 3y agoHow could they exfiltrate that much data without being noticed?
- surfingdino 3y agoCentralised storage of sensitive data has to go away. We need something better.
- free_bip 3y agoWhat would you suggest? Storing data on the blockchain where costs per GB are tens of orders of magnitude higher?
- surfingdino 3y agoNo, storing multiple copies on _encrypted_ data with private keys in possession of the owners of data, not companies processing / storing it. That way you could leave those files on an HTTP server and it would be safe. The driver for centralised storage of DNA and other data is the business model based on resale of the data in raw or processed form.
- scarby2 3y agoUntil the customer loses the key, which is essentially what happened here...
- buffington 3y agoIf the customer loses the key to the encrypted data, then it's useless to everyone, including bad actors. This is not what happened here. 23&Me exercised poor security. I deal with financial data for my job, (like, transactional data, for most Americans), and I would consider that less sensitive than DNA data. We lock that transactional data up so tight it'd make your head spin. If it's data about an individual, in the wrong hands, it can do harm. If you're in the business of people's data, you cannot be stupid about protecting that data. 23&Me is (was) very much in the business of people's data, and could afford and attract the best talent to ensure the data was encrypted and protected. They're reaping what they sowed.
- tzs 3y agoThey didn't require 2FA. That's the only arguably poor security I see. Is there something beyond that they should have done?
- nothercastle 3y agoWhy does it matter they were going to sell it off to whoever wanted it anyway. Not like they were keeping it private
- fliggertiggy 3y agoThis. The 'customers' were always the product. Thanks to your naive aunt Janice they've probably got your DNA too.
- hobbitstan 3y ago[dead]
- tqi 3y agoWhere is the wall to wall 24x7 coverage of this? I guess if it's not a company that is competing for eyeballs and clicks then it's not a big deal...
- tzs 3y agoIt was already extensively covered when it was new. It probably died down because when you strip the sensationalism from the stories it comes down to this. 1. Bad guys took leaked emails and passwords that were leaked from other sites and tried them on 23andMe. 2. 14000 of those people in those leaks from other sites had 23andMe accounts and used the same email and password at 23andMe. 3. That gave the bad guys access to everything on those accounts. 4. 23andMe has an opt in feature that shows you all your relatives on 23andMe who have also opted in. "Relative" means people out to 4th cousins. Mine has 1500, although I suspect that the average is more like 700. 5. The majority of 23andMe users opt in to relative sharing. This is not surprising since finding relatives is one of the major reasons people use DNA testing services. 6. If you are on 23andMe and opted into relative sharing, and any one of your relatives who also opted in is one of the 14000 from #2, then the bad guys can see your name, geographical area, and DNA relationship to your relative from #2 on that person's relatives list. 7. That turns out to be about 7 million people.
- tiahura 3y agoAre there any reports of anyone actually harmed by this, or is it all tiresome righteous indignation?
- kmoser 3y agoHow would you correlate this breach with actual harm? If somebody, say, hacks into one of your other accounts, or opens credit in your name, it's not always obvious where they got your info.
- buffington 3y agoOr if a neo-Nazi firebombs your house, your cousin's house, your parents' house, and some guy who you didn't know was your uncle since he was given up for adoption, but was also Jewish. How do you correlate that to a data breach? That's why this data breach is so dangerous. It helps fill in nearly every stepping stone for bad actors, all the way to the baddest of them, to cause harm or exploit someone.
- buffington 3y agoAre you saying you'd be ok a company leaking not just your sequenced DNA (and the avalanche of things that says about you), but who you're related to, by DNA?
- elevatedastalt 3y agoThe company did not leak it. People reuse passwords. "Hackers" just tried passwords from earlier dumps and accessed profiles of people who reused the same password with 23&Me
- tiahura 3y agoAs soon as a cousin or two does it the cat’s kind of out of the bag, isn’t it? Isn’t that what all of these “I did my DNA and you’re my dad!” and “Ancestry.com cold crime DNA break” stories prove?
- kmoser 3y agoWait, people give their real name and DOB when registering with 23andMe? Not blaming the victim, just pointing out that if a company doesn't need to know your real name, why give it to them?
- rsaxvc 3y agoOne might ask the same of us who use our initials on hacker news.
- steve_adams_86 3y agoIt's crucial to include your birth year to confuse the hackers (numbers in names are really confusing, they will give up in no time)
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoYou DNA leaked, change your DNA ASAP.
- namaria 3y agoFor a full DNA reset, just click the two halves of the demon core together
- waste_monk 3y agoSome assembly required, you will need a screwdriver.
- cardboardmetal 3y agoThe tricky thing in the case of DNA is, if your relatives were to do a 23andMe, then they inevitably also give away large parts of your DNA. They tracked down the Golden State Killer merely by matching the DNA of a relative. It's a dilemma between one's right to privacy and another one's autonomy.