4 ms·
> It only results in a decrease in per-unit average house prices It never does. Upzoning does NOT reduce per-unit prices, but it certainly increases everyone's
by cyberax 3y ago
> It only results in a decrease in per-unit average house prices
It never does. Upzoning does NOT reduce per-unit prices, but it certainly increases everyone's misery.
- CydeWeys 3y agoAh yes, real estate prices are famously low in the most upzoned parts of the country (Manhattan). If you can build a 100 floor skyscraper on a piece of land, that land is insanely valuable!
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe land is valuable because it is the only land zoned that way. You can’t build a building that tall in Flushing NY. If you could build 100 floor skyscrapers in the entire metropolitan area, this advantage goes away.
- cyberax 3y agoBrooklyn's population density is only half of that in Manhattan, and there's plenty of new construction there. Guess what it does to prices?
- theluketaylor 3y agoYou're reading the demand/supply situation backwards. Even with all the construction in Brooklyn, supply is failing to meet demand, therefore prices are going up. We've failed to meet supply in urban spaces for several generations now and have a massive deficit to pay off before adding any supply can actually drive prices down; we're barely adding enough units to affect the rate of increase of prices.
- cyberax 3y ago> You're reading the demand/supply situation backwards. No. I'm reading it exactly right. Density _causes_ higher prices. It makes it easier to create jobs near dense locations, which in turn makes it more attractive for people to move in. This in turn increases housing costs.
- HPsquared 3y agoIt's a chicken and egg problem. But remember an egg by itself wouldn't survive, and a single chicken in isolation can't produce a viable egg.
- theluketaylor 3y agoThat's all only a problem when supply of housing is constricted, which it has been for generations in all urban spaces. Otherwise it's just wealth generation. It's also a problem when economic activity is limited to a handful of key urban spaces, but that isn't true. There are plenty of places to go make a good living. There just isn't anywhere to live. There should be plenty of different levels of density for people to choose to live in as everyone has different preferences. What's not sustainable in any way is exclusive single family zoning. If, as so many backers of exclusionary zoning claim, people only want to live in SFH, why would we need a law to force that to be the only built form? Surely every single unit built of any other type would fail to find a resident.
- bobthepanda 3y agoFun fact: during the Bloomberg administration, more land was actually downzoned and upzoned. https://www.politico.com/states/new-york/city-hall/story/2014/02/the-quiet-massive-rezoning-of-new-york-078398 https://www.politico.com/states/new-york/city-hall/story/201... This had the effect of driving all the developers into fewer land parcels, hiking up prices. New York has not substantially deviated from this zoning model since then.
- apsurd 3y agoI learned this in 6th grade. You need bedrock to build skyscrapers. Laws of physics and all...
- CydeWeys 3y agoThat knowledge is severely out of date, then. You don't need bedrock to build skyscrapers, and indeed the tallest skyscraper in the world, the Burj Khalifa, is built on top of sand with no connection to bedrock whatsoever. You just need to pour immense amounts of concrete to serve as a foundation.
- apsurd 3y agoWhich is cost prohibitive and doesn't make sense for any other entity other than "let's light money on fire + enslave people to flex so the cool kids like us" UAE. it's not a good look. hope my comment doesn't flag me in unforeseen ways 20 years from now. To be clear, I'm saying effectively yep need bedrock otherwise it makes zero actual sense. (I do take you point, and lesson learned on my part)
- CydeWeys 3y agoIt's not cost prohibitive, it's a technique that is widely used in US cities too. The cost of building the foundation is still small relative to the cost of acquiring the land and building the rest of the building.
- kasey_junk 3y agoDo you have a single data point to back up your assertion? Because the places I’ve seen that have embraced upzoning seem to be counter your assertion https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2024/01/04/minneapolis-land-use-reforms-offer-a-blueprint-for-housing-affordability https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/...
- cyberax 3y agoSF has not built anything, but rents decreased much more than in MN: https://www.sfchronicle.com/realestate/article/sf-rent-prices-18534829.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/realestate/article/sf-rent-price... Rents right now are an unreliable indicator because they are heavily affected by the downtown blights that are spreading in many cities. Sale prices are much more reliable, and Minneapolis prices (as expected) grew: https://www.redfin.com/city/10943/MN/Minneapolis/housing-market https://www.redfin.com/city/10943/MN/Minneapolis/housing-mar...
- theluketaylor 3y agoZoning alone can only affect prices when there is an arbitrage opportunity to build something in location A that isn't possible in nearby location B. When entire cities upzone across the board like Minneapolis there is no arbitrage opportunity, so prices are not going up specifically because the zoning was changed. Prices are increasing because there is a chronic shortage of places to lives near economic opportunity and high demand to live somewhere you can make a living.
- cyberax 3y ago> Prices are increasing because there is a chronic shortage of places to lives near economic opportunity and high demand to live somewhere you can make a living. Yes. And the solution is not to drive people into dense slums, but to make sure that jobs are available outside of city cores. It will require concerted action, probably something like cap-and-trade for dense office space.
- ozzydave 3y agoI live on a street in Berkeley that was not red-lined, so it has single family homes and fourplexes. It’s great, we love it. You can choose to be miserable but it’s got nothing to do with whether your neighbors can afford a home.