4 ms·
Mysterious 280M-year-old fossil is mostly just black paint
- Xeyz0r 3y agoPls, explain. Is like everything fake? Didn't quite get that or skeleton is a real thing?
- leothetechguy 3y agoskeleton is real, but too damaged to be recognizable, and the outline, previously thought to be carbonized skin or flesh, is fake, which means there's no way to properly identify it now.
- slimebot80 3y agoIs it a deliberate forgery, or a really old rock painting?
- masklinn 3y agoAccording to TFA quoting one of the authors, it was likely a preparation (beautification) and / or preservation attempt which went very wrong. > Application of paints, consolidates and lacquers on fossil bones was the norm, because that was the only way to protect the specimens from further deterioration. It was also sometimes to embellish specimens by making them sleek and shiny. Unfortunately, in the case of Tridentinosaurus, the mechanical preparation did most of the damage and then the application of a black paint created the illusion of a lizard-like animal impression on the surface of the rock. That’s not hard to believe if you watch restoration / preservation channels, like Baumgartner. Although obviously there’s no way to tell what whoever did it was thinking at such a remove.
- im3w1l 3y ago> Although obviously there’s no way to tell what whoever did it was thinking at such a remove. Well there are some hints. Hint 1: The specimen wasn't officially described scientifically until 1959. Hence it seems neither the person who found it, nor the geologist he turned it over to seemed to want to cause sensation with a fake find. Hint 2: Giorgio Dal Piaz died in 1962. This means that he was alive (age 87) to protest when it was described scientificially and did cause sensation, but chose not to (though it's possible he was frail and demented I suppose). Hint 3: The person that found the fossil was a museum employee, this makes carelessness less likely, but could go either way for deliberate fraud I suppose.
- saalweachter 3y agoIt could just be the fossil equivalent of the Salvator Mundi restoration.
- mysterydip 3y agoHow did we know how old it was? I assume based on where it was in the stratum?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verisimi 3y agoSomeone recently applied paint AND it was thought the fossil was 280m years old. It does rather carry a pall over the idea we can accurately date anything, doesn't it?
- blueflow 3y agoYou date fossils from the strata they are found in.
- miniwark 3y agoBut you also (partially) date strata from the fossils who are found in them...
- lawlessone 3y ago>But you also (partially) date strata from the fossils who are found in them... And carbon dating. And decay of uranium into lead. They usually have multiple techniques that can be used together.
- kadoban 3y agoNit just because it's interesting (to me at least): carbon dating is never useful on things this old. The halflife of carbon-14 is so short that by about 50k years you're pushing it to about its limit. But yeah there's all kinds of decay chains and geology techniques used to date these things. It's a really cool mix of logical deduction and chemistry and cleverness.
- dredmorbius 3y agoBuilding on this, the general concept is radiometric dating, which can rely on any of numerous decay chains, with half-lives ranging from decades to 100s of billions of years. Specific decay chains are effective clocks for differing lengths of time. Radiocarbon dating is often used on recent human or organic artefacts or remains, within the past 50,000 years or so as noted. It was uranium-lead decay which first demonstratively showed that the Earth was not "young", whether the few thousand years of theological textual analysis or the 30--300 million years that various geological estimates had suggested, but at least 1 billion years old, established by Ernest Rutherford in the early 20th centuries. The present value of 4.54 +/- 0.05 billion years was arrived at by the 1950s, based on the ratios of lead to uranium within zircon crystals, the latter of which cannot form in the presence of lead, and hence, any lead present necessarily being the result of radioactive decay. The measurement process also demonstrated the extent to which modern industrial activity was creating pervasive lead contamination virtually everywhere, largely the result of leaded gasoline, one of Thomas Midgley's lethal legacies. More generally, geochronology is based on numerous methods of which radiometric dating is but one, though a quite powerful one. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiometric_dating https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiometric_dating> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_Earth> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geochronology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geochronology>
- omega3 3y agoI find this article frustrating to read. Here are the important bits: > Conclusion: T. antiquus is a forgery [...] > Part of the fossil, at least, appears to be genuine—the long bones of the hind limbs [...]
- omgJustTest 3y agoSummary: black carbon paint + organic binder was used to paint the fossil, as it was used in preparation of many early 1900 finds. Fossil is partially real, with large amount of paint. Scientists for decades put up weird theories about new species to explain it. Science is hard, assumptions are easy, people have large imaginations &, most importantly, science rewards novel theories. Everything in the science record improves by people asking simple questions, its the day-in-day-out drudgery plus sheer luck that gets real discoveries.
- lawlessone 3y agoCould this be entirely accidental then? one scientist or another person painting it, perhaps a bit haphazardly. Later or someone else someone else interprets this as soft tissue and the mistake just compound.
- simpaticoder 3y ago>people have large imaginations There's a guy on youtube[0] that's convinced that every rock he sees is a fossil. His videos are a strange combination of absurd, disturbing, and relaxing. 0- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQnCueSlWLY&t=0s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQnCueSlWLY&t=0s
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 3y agoIf the preparation was poor quality but done in good faith, couldn't it be that the shape is actually somewhat accurate even though no fossil material remains?
- dmix 3y agoOnly the hind limbs are real, so no
- Aurornis 3y agoThe key part about why this was possible: > How could scientists have presumed the dark outline was carbonized soft tissue for so many decades? "This fossil was discovered in 1931 and back then fossils were treated very differently than today," said Rossi. "Application of paints, consolidates and lacquers on fossil bones was the norm, because that was the only way to protect the specimens from further deterioration. It was also sometimes to embellish specimens by making them sleek and shiny. Unfortunately, in the case of Tridentinosaurus, the mechanical preparation did most of the damage and then the application of a black paint created the illusion of a lizard-like animal impression on the surface of the rock.“ Combine that with the fact that part of the fossil is real (hind legs) and the extreme hesitancy to touch the sample due to its rarity explains how it got so far. I’m sure this story will be a favorite of anti-evolution zealots for decades to come. They love stories like this where scientists were wrong about something (ignoring the fact that they corrected the record publicly) because it helps them convince people that science can’t be trusted.
- wredue 3y agoThey also tend to dismiss off hand the exact same science that is used to find the frauds. So when science find the frauds, the methods are good. When science originally classifies, the methods are bad. Unless, of course, we are talking about, yet another, ark discovery. Then the methods are simultaneously good and bad for a single instance. One think you will notice after some time here is that scientific articles that show facts counter to their narrative get flagged quite quickly, and anti-science propaganda meant to fuel distrust tends to have a very weird upvote to comment ratio on HN these days. The mods blame the sheer mass of these bot networks vs the amount of mods, but the mods also simultaneously and seemingly intentionally limit accounts that make attempts to dispel the obvious disinformation being pushed through this platform.
- _a_a_a_ 3y ago> anti-science propaganda meant to fuel distrust tends to have a very weird upvote to comment ratio on HN these days I've not noticed that, have you any examples?
- 3y ago
- psunavy03 3y agoThis reads like one of the fake headlines that used to scroll across the bottom of the screen while playing SimCity.