10 ms·
Why diets backfire: A year after weight loss, the desire to eat grows (2018)
- petesergeant 3y agoAll hail our Lord and Saviour, the GLP-1 Agonist drug. I’ve lost the weight I put on 20 years ago many, many times, and spent my every waking moment hungry. Now, I take a pill every morning, and eat like a regular human.
- kls0e 3y agoi lol‘d
- vundercind 3y agoIt’s that or “fix our culture”. Thank god these drugs came along, really, because we were never gonna accomplish that.
- _cenw 3y agoWhat's the cultural fix for having broken satiety signaling?
- rqtwteye 3y agoNot celebrating overeating. Not having highly processed food that’s designed to make people eat too much. Not pouring tons of sugar or salt into everything. Serving normal portions in restaurants Not feeding kids candy bars that are four times as big than what I had as a kid. Learning cooking. Not exactly rocket science.
- _cenw 3y agoThat wouldn't fix the problem for someone who already has it?
- rqtwteye 3y agoA lot of eating is habit. You can change those.
- petesergeant 3y agoWhat does that do to fix the broken satiety mechanism in the human body that the article describes?
- quickthrower2 3y agoLong term fix for all people, rather than a pill for one person. In addition you have to eat a lot of unprocessed food to get fat, where here I define unprocessed food is something you killed or foraged for (or mass produced equivalent), and not refined in any way. A strawberry for instance. Eat 1000 calories of rump vs. a small Pizza for example, which would make you want to eat more?
- doc_gunthrop 3y agoThe broken satiety mechanism is a result of hormone imbalance caused by a poor nutritional diet. Highly processed foods, an overabundance of sugar, artificial sweeteners, salt, and refined vegetable/seed oils, a carb-heavy diet, deficiency of essential micronutrients, and so on causes deleterious effects on the human body. People need to eat less junk and eat more natural whole foods.
- vundercind 3y agoNo, that [edit: culture, that is] seems to be what keeps other cultures thinner than ours. People from them move here and tend to promptly start getting fatter, so on a population level greater individual willpower doesn’t seem to be the answer. So the way to reverse the ever worsening obesity trend in the US (and elsewhere, though we’re leading the charge) was “fix culture”. That’s very hard (it’s not even entirely clear exactly which bits would have to change) and basically nobody (who had a prayer of making a dent in the problem) was seriously trying. But now we have the “sell everyone drugs” option which is actually gonna work, relatively easily and quickly compared with the sole plausible alternative. We lucked out.
- _cenw 3y agoYou also seem to have misunderstood the question. We have millions that have the problem already, for whom it was never going away with "simply eating better". This is resetting obese people to the baseline, not preventing obesity in the first place. We still have that problem, and that does require a culture (or rather regulatory) fix.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoGP's point is that fixing culture is approximately impossible. Culture evolves, but we have little direct control over it. But fixing something that is merely biology, now that is possible, because it takes science, engineering, and then you eventually get a direct solution that scales.
- babblefrog 3y agoIf only we knew exactly what in the culture we need to fix. There are a lot of theories. Something in our environment has broken the homeostasis which worked for the last million years.
- px43 3y agoMaybe we could punish the bad actors who spent decades lobbying so they could sell more and more addictive food products to our population, or maybe at least we could stop subsidizing them so much? The incentives are so fucked. Now we have basically the entire healthcare industry and the entire pharmaceutical industry relying on the food industry to keep us loaded with addictive garbage that wrecks our health. There is to much money to be made in the US by keeping people unhealthy which is probably the main reason we're not getting universal healthcare any time soon. Countries with better healthcare actually have an incentive to keep their population healthy. In the US, it's the exact opposite. IMO food companies should be allowed to sell addictive garbage to people who want it, but they should also be on the hook for paying for treatments. Then maybe we'll start seeing treatments that actually cure rather than address symptoms short term. The same should really be true for every industry that sells addictive crap.
- prepend 3y agoBeing poor and active. I think the whole “high sugar/calorie food is prevalent and cheap” is a symptom of relatively wealthy counties that have leisure time. I feel like if bad food wasn’t so cheap and we worked 7 days a week, that would “fix” our culture. But since the cat’s out of the bag, I don’t see us going back to constant work. We seem to like leisure time and sugar is really cheap. Even in “poor” countries, diabetes is creeping up because we’re getting the processed foods from Europe and the US.
- petesergeant 3y agoThe article says that once you’ve been fat once, you experience hunger more strongly for years afterwards, even if you lose weight. What exactly are you proposing we fix here?
- throwanem 3y agoWe could start by talking about things that come in bags and boxes, and that consist of little beyond sugar, salt, and fat in as little matrix as necessary to support the addictive effect. The dark pattern of food. Honestly, that first kidney stone was a godsend, however unpleasant; having to be extremely intentional about salt got me off all that junk except for old times' sake, and set me up to discover how pleasant things can taste when you can actually taste them. That one change also made more of a difference in my ability to lose and keep off weight than did quitting a 20-year, pack-a-day smoking habit. Quitting smoking added about ten pounds. Having to get serious about eating well took off fifty. This stuff is a problem. We won't fix that problem at a societal level, of course, because that's no longer something this society can achieve. But we could.
- glp1guide 3y agoThis is awesome -- I've heard it described as "food noise", and luckily I've never had to struggle with it, but hearing the anecdata is super amazing. They don't work for every single person, but there's no way GLP1s won't legitimately change the world. They already are. How did you get into GLP1 RAs and where did you initially search for information about them? Was it a recommendation from your doctor?
- petesergeant 3y agoHa, I was going to start an info site just like yours, did the keyword research and registered some domain names, but other projects took precedence. Like almost everyone else, I heard about them through the media, and then booked in to see an endocrinologist. Various subreddits have been great, with a particular shout out to the Mounjaro one
- glp1guide 3y ago> Ha, I was going to start an info site just like yours, did the keyword research and registered some domain names, but other projects took precedence. I'd love to hear about what you were going to do! If you want to chat I'd love to -- reach out to victor@<the domain> or admin@<the domain>. > Like almost everyone else, I heard about them through the media, and then booked in to see an endocrinologist. Various subreddits have been great, with a particular shout out to the Mounjaro one Yeah, there's a ton of great information on the subreddits -- I've found some to be more about encouragement, and then others to be more about fact finding (which I'm spending a lot of time doing now -- working on a research roundup for January 2024).
- petesergeant 3y agoOh, also, if you want to experience food noise, spend a day eating only fibre. It’s the kind of hungry where your tummy isn’t rumbling. Alternatively, nicotine withdrawal is a fine substitute experience.
- darkteflon 3y agoIs this Rybelsus, do you mind if I ask?
- petesergeant 3y agoYes, although I did the initial loss with Mounjaro
- abhaynayar 3y agoOne of the best ways to maintain I've experienced is to just keep track of your weight every single day. And trying to do it while knowing daily fluctuations don't matter much, but that if over time you've gained a few kgs, you need to figure out what happened wrong and how to fix it. I had a daily habit metric to "eat well" but that was much more complex and mentally taxing, so I simplified it to "track your weight" which is just a minute of concrete simple investment every morning. Of course, weight isn't the only thing that matters, but if mostly you're eating healthy and quantity is the only issue then it's a useful metric to track.
- petesergeant 3y agoI can tell you how heavy I was on almost every day since 2009. Hasn’t helped.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think it was proposed as a strategy to keep the weight off, not loose it.
- throwanem 3y agoIt's both. You get to thinking about whether that extra slice you want but don't need is worth changing the trend, and it starts giving you the habit of 'nah'. Granted, this works well for me both because I know how often I can indulge myself and get away with it, and because I'm fairly vain about how I look. No idea if results are likely to be the same for someone not sharing both traits, but I've shed and kept off close to 20% of the 281lb I topped out at during the pandemic, which at least corroborates that this can support both reduction and maintenance.
- bruce511 3y agoI suspect one strategy won't work for everyone, but it certainly works for me as a motivator. Or to put it another way, when I weigh regularly my weight trends down, when I don't it trends up. Of course it goes without saying that standing on the scale has no direct impact on my weight. What I eat, and how much of it I eat, is the crucial factor. (I exercise 4 days a week as part of my regular schedule.) When it comes to "what" it will vary for everyone. For me it's limiting sugar (not eliminating, just being aware, and keeping that down when I can) and also limiting carbs like bread, pasta, rice, potatoes. Again I've not gone for elimination, but just greatly reduced that good group. I eat very little restaurant good, and practically zero fast food, so that likely also plays a part. The important thing is to change slowly to something thats a new norm that's sustainable in the long run. It's not a diet in the sense that im not going hungry. It's just replacing one food with another so that I get more of grid and less of that. I love bread, potatoes, and chocolate. So I get those every few days. Just perhaps in more moderation than before, and not with every meal. I'm losing about a pound every 2 weeks which seems nicely balanced.
- aurareturn 3y agoI don't know if my experience is worth anything here. But I lost a ton of weight doing cardio and going on a vegan diet. It was hard to put the weight off for long though. I also lost a lot of muscles and became "skinny fat". At some point, I hit a plateau and just couldn’t lose more fat despite a 500-1000 daily calorie deficit. It was unsustainable and probably unhealthy. I did some research and switched to weight lifting and eating 20-30% of my calories in protein. Also, I increased my calorie intake to break even. The weight is staying off and I feel healthier and stronger. Edit: I did go off my vegan diet when I switched my exercise strategy from cardio to weight lifting. I don’t have any diet restrictions. But I generally eat healthy food because the high protein diet generally makes me only eat whole foods such as chicken, vegetables, grains.
- RossBencina 3y agoSimilar. Current evidence-based recommendation for daily protein intake is 1.6g protein per kg of target body weight. Not that any of that will solve the issue raised in the article: persistent up-regulated hunger signal sensitivity and down-regulated satiety signal sensitivity.
- latency-guy2 3y ago> Current evidence-based recommendation for daily protein intake is 1.6g protein per kg of target body weight That measure is for when you are specifically looking to build muscle I believe, which might be a bit orthogonal to direction you want to go (if for weight loss). It is also, IMO, a lot of protein to consume a day. I personally have never done that level of protein intake, ever, but I know a few who have, its an insane (to me) amount of protein powder, chicken, and broccoli (or alternatives) you have to consume, every day. If the goal was sustainability, it's definitely not possible for average people.
- zhdc1 3y ago> It is also, IMO, a lot of protein to consume a day. I personally have never done that level of protein intake, ever, but I know a few who have, its an insane (to me) amount of protein powder, chicken, and broccoli (or alternatives) you have to consume, every day. If the goal was sustainability, it's definitely not possible for average people. Yeah, I don't get it either. If you exercise regularly and you're going on a cut, 1.6kg is a good target to maintain muscle mass. That said, in order for you to reach this point, you already have to be very good at regulating your food intake. Otherwise, .9g per kg is a much more realistic target for the 90%+ of people who are simply trying to be fit.
- RossBencina 3y ago[2018]
- ggm 3y agoDoing it solo may be harder. I suspect there's a mutual CBT effect of buddying up to maintain a healthy diet stance. Certainly my partner and I manage "maybe not another serving" policing better between us than on our own. Which doesn't alter that the underlying satiety signals aren't good, it's just that a conscious override option has some reinforcement.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI found my best diet is to do weights at the gym, stop looking at the scales and eat real food every day (but junk is OK too). Have I lost weight? No idea. Don’t care. Yoyoing and being hungry all the time isn’t worth it. I have belly fat though! As I probably should (?)
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI was able to keep weight off long term with the Dr. Fuhrman diet - really unpleasant diet because you stay away from processed foods, which takes extra shopping and cooking efforts. The positive side was that it made me feel much younger, more energy, better sleep, all around good except for the effort.
- bruce511 3y agoI'm not familiar with the diet but I think this is an excellent highlight of why weight loss is not a one-method-suits-all approach. Personally I dislike processed foods, and I love cooking from scratch. It's the time my brain is switched off and I'm literally creating something delicious. I cook for 5 adults, 4 times a week, and it takes about 30 mins to an hour. I'm not saying you should like it, we're all different, but it's handy I enjoy it because it definitely helps with weight management.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoI’ve never been significantly overweight fortunately, but over the pandemic I got about 20 lbs too pudgy, which proved frustratingly hard to lose. What finally worked was combining the Apple Watch (Fitbit is fine too) and a calorie counting app that track calories. The app (Yazio, there are others) took into account caloric expenditures beyond basic metabolic needs. That is, if one walks a mile as tracked by the Apple Watch, that’s an extra ~ 100 calories to eat. Armed with these tools, I set a modest goal of 3-4lbs fat loss per month in Yazio. It worked. An unexpected positive outcome from this experience, is that I developed a much better intuitive sense of the caloric and nutritional value of foods and what activity levels I needed to maintain to stay at my desired weight. I recommend to give this approach a try. Edit to add: These apps make an educated guess as to one’s basic metabolic daily expenditure. For reasons that aren’t clear, this estimate can vary as much as ~25% between persons. Therefore you may have to tweak the daily calorie goal. Second, weigh yourself every day. The weight loss goal of ~ 1lb/week is less than the daily variance in body weight due to hydration levels and so forth, so you will need to use a three or four day rolling average to keep track of your progress.
- leidenfrost 3y agoTo me, what worked best is, yes, tracking calories, but also finding the foods that manager the hunger in the best way possible while also being as low calorie as possible. Proteins and vegetables for the main servings, and green apples, oranges or tangerines for when I crave something sweet afterwards. Beware of juices. Some of them have as mush sugar as a coke.
- mbowcut2 3y agoI’m similar. Never been very over weight but I’ve put on 20ish lbs in the last few years. My wife and I started tracking calories and exercising a month ago and it has been so beneficial. I lost about ten lbs, but even better than losing the weight has been building a better intuition of what foods are calorie rich, higher in protein, etc.
- overvale 3y agoSame. The best part is the education. I now am certain what my portion sizes should be, how much of each meal should be protein, how many calories are likely in the food I'm ordering at the lunch counter, etc. That information, and keeping it in mind the same way you might keep your budget in mind has made a big difference.
- professorTuring 3y agoWhat worked for me: - quit sugar - quit processed foods - avoid fried food - little fat (even the healthy ones) - no nuts/seeds - lifting weights - little cardio I have completely changed my life in one year. It has been a very tough path, mostly socially, going out and not having a beer, burger… social pressure… but when you believe in eating healthy everything goes smooth. Also measure the results, once you get 12-15% of body fat, you may be gaining muscle weight. The goal should be changing your lifestyle to one that is healthy and sustainable.
- beacon294 3y agoThat sounds great, but I haven't found it to be sustainable. I also avoid fried foods, sugar, processed foods. I only eat meat twice a week. I count every gram of saturated fat I eat, and keep it under 10 grams per day. I eat nuts every day, for breakfast and/or afternoon snack -- I find the unsaturated fats and proteins prevent hunger. I also drink protein shakes (1-2 per day).
- nilsbunger 3y agoHas it helped you lose weight or keep it off?
- beacon294 3y agoMy cholesterol dropped from 250 to 200, and I do expect it to fall further as I shave off more rough edges from my diet. What "shaving the rough edges off" looks like is making a slightly healthier choice on my 2 meat meals per week, e.g. single patty burger, skip the cheese, or have a 4 oz steak. Drinking only half the mango lassi, or skipping the milkshake. I also dropped from 215 to 205 lbs. 200-205 lbs is my healthy weight, with 11-13% body fat.
- professorTuring 3y agoHave you thought why isn’t sustainable for you? The main problem I faced was giving in “just this time”. Fat and sugar are addictive and when you fall, it makes it easier to fall again. About healthy food, I had overweight and I mostly ate “healthy food”. I needed to go to a nutritionist and ask him why. This is what O was eating a year and a half ago: Breakfast: two bread slices with avocado. Meal: mostly salads with lettuce, tomato, tuna, avocado, carrots, salt, vinegar and extra virgin olive oil. (I really wanted to lose weight). Dinner: chicken, sushi, eggs… normally I would add a handful of seeds/nuts. This is what my nutriotionist told me: you have been eating quite healthy, the problem are the fats: too many healthy fats (extra virgin oil, avocado, nuts… nuts have a lot of fats). Only add protein shakes when you are trying to gain muscle and you are not able to add normal proteins. I started on protein shakes once I was slim and not able to eat that much food to gain muscle. A year later I am fully conscious of what I eat. I can have eventually a burger, but I am fully aware that it is really unhealthy. My proteins today are mainly chicken and salmon, carbs: quinoa, rice, lentils… and almost no fat (I’m trying to get my fat % to 12… it’s quite difficult) Also read all packaged ingredients you will find nasty surprises in form of fats and sugar in diet / “high protein” meals. Also no juices!
- hackerfooze 3y agoWhat worked for me: plenty of sugar and starch, cut out all fat, low salt. 45 and feeling great, haven’t struggled with weight in nearly a decade.
- rpearl 3y agoI'm having a hard time imagining eating like this. Can you describe a meal you might eat?
- anthomtb 3y agoAny time an article like this comes up, all I have to say (as a one time fat boy) is: How bad do you want it? Do you want six pack abs? Do you want cake? Pick one, unless you are REALLY lucky. And if you clicked that link, you probably aren't. You could also risk whatever a Tijuana pharmacy has on offer but that's another can of worms. It's harsh, but if you want a certain body, you won't be able to consume whatever you want. Alternately, you can consume whatever you want and accept the body you have. No judgement here, so long as you are happy with yourself.
- chii 3y ago> It's harsh, but if you want a certain body, you won't be able to consume whatever you want. and that's why the pharmaceutical companies are forever looking for a drug which makes you lose weight, but also allows you to eat anything (while remaining safe and side-effect free).
- adrian_b 3y ago> while remaining safe and side-effect free Unfortunately it is not clear whether this goal is more realistic than searching for the philosopher's stone or for the elixir of life.
- adrian_b 3y agoWhat you say is only partially true. One can still consume whatever is desired, but in much smaller quantities than desired. For instance, I have been obese for many years. Then I have succeeded to lose (after several failed attempts) more than one third of my initial body weight. After that, I have changed completely my eating habits, otherwise I would have reverted immediately to my old weight. Now I have been controlling my weight accurately for more than a decade. I am still eating cakes, but only cakes that I cook myself from known ingredients, and only twice per week (Sunday and Wednesday) and in a quantity that keeps the daily intake of sugar for those days no greater than 40 to 50 grams. With these exceptions, I do not eat any kind of food with added sugar, so now if I happen to taste some of the industrially-produced sweet food that I liked before, it feels much too sweet, while some vegetables with low sugar content, like onions or red bell peppers, feel quite sweet. However many months have been needed until overcoming the addiction to sugar.
- jupp0r 3y agoWhat works for me: counting calories. I use the MacroFactor iOS app. Set a modest deficit goal and stick to it on average. It's ok to splurge sometimes.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoCronometer.com is my go-to since it's free and it breaks down micronutrients into little progress bars. I also like that it's a website as well as a phone app so I can enter/modify my foods from the laptop.
- sn9 3y agoMacrofactor has that as well, but it also calculates your TDEE based on your weight and intake and tells you how to adjust to accomplish your goals.
- Aurornis 3y agoThis is old research (2018) that has been blown completely out of proportion by news media. It's one of several small studies that gets circulated from time to time as if it disproves that weight loss is possible or something, but it doesn't. Look at the actual study details: > Thirty-five (22 females) adults with severe obesity (body mass index: 42.5 ± 5.0 kg/m2) underwent a 2-yr WL program focusing on diet and exercise. They only looked at 22 women with severe obesity on a rapid and aggressive weight loss program. Drawing conclusions from this tiny group and their abnormally aggressive program isn’t relevant to the average person trying to regulate their weight or steadily move toward a healthier weight target over many years.
- MattGaiser 3y agoIs there any research on long term weight loss that argues a meaningful amount of weight loss is reasonably possible? https://www.vox.com/2016/5/10/11649210/biggest-loser-weight-loss https://www.vox.com/2016/5/10/11649210/biggest-loser-weight-... Vox has an article on it supposedly working, but the results are not what anyone who is overweight would call successful. > The results at year eight are heartening. Eight years later and 50.3 percent of the intensive lifestyle intervention group and 35.7 percent of the usual care group were maintaining losses of ≥5 percent, while 26.9 percent of the intensive group and 17.2 percent of the usual care group were maintaining losses of ≥10 percent. In layman’s terms, half lost nothing. Half of the losers lost so little that they wouldn’t notice. 1/4 lost 10%. Basically nobody who was obese reached a normal weight.
- lazyasciiart 3y agoYou don’t have to reach a normal weight to make a significant difference to your health and risk of death. Maintaining a 10% weight loss is absolutely noticeable in health measures. https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/moderate-weight-loss-improves-heart-health/ https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/moderate-weight-loss-improve...
- makeitdouble 3y ago> Individuals in the study were instructed to eat either low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets— about 1,200 to 1,500 calories per day for women and 1,500 to 1,800 for men. If they're splitting groups, why didn't they bother having a control group with no diet change and only the study follow-up ? I couldn't see any link to the actual study, was there more details ?
- optymizer 3y agoI'd like to share my experience. I've lost 50lbs twice in the past decade and I'm currently losing them again. Hopefully the third time is a charm. What's different now is that I've done a lot of self-reflection. I now realize I have an eating disorder driven by a dopamine response to tasty foods, but unlike other people, my inner thoughts are similar to addicts, I presume, where my brain is deciding to binge the food that triggered that reward until I get stomach pains, which then nullifies the dopamine reward, so only then I stop eating. I've also learned the signal I get when I've had enough to eat and learned to not ignore it. I've also realized that I stress eat, and particularly when I'm feeling down, probably to try to get temporary feelings of happiness as self-medication. Losing weight is fairly straightforward once you get the hang of it, but keeping it off is less so. That's the most difficult aspect to manage about my life: to try to avoid excessive stress and general periods of unhappiness, so that I don't start using food as a source of dopamine, but since a lot of stressors are external, I feel like they're outside of my control, so my general strategy as of late has been to replace the source of dopamine to not be food related. For example, exercising not only helps with losing weight, but it also curbs my appetite so I can fast during lunch without exercising much will power. More vigorous exercise induces runner's high, so it benefits both the efforts of losing the weight and the attempt to switch sources of feeling good. Lastly getting satisfaction from shipping code is a productive replacement for the satisfaction I get from eating foods. That one is more tough to implement because eating provides immediate gratification, while shipping projects is a long endeavor usually. To counter that, I set bite-sized (ha) coding/learning goals for myself that I can complete fairly fast. That keeps my mood up for a bit. Hopefully my experience will encourage others to reflect on their own reasons for gaining weight and try to address the root cause, not just the side-effect of increased weight.
- las_balas_tres 3y agoMy relationship with food seems to mirror yours. You have some good advice on how to deal with it.
- verticalscaler 3y ago> exercising not only helps with losing weight Running and exercising are not efficient ways to lose weight despite what the fitness and wellness industries would have you believe. And ironically the more overweight you are the less efficient it is. Great way to fuck up your joints or waste countless hours sifting through bro science and researching equipment you don't need. It is great for keeping the weight off and enjoying life once you hit a certain point but should not be a chore as will power is finite and precious and at first you're spending it all on eating clean and walking and that is guaranteed to be enough over a long enough period. Push too hard and you'll stall. just be patient and extremely consistent instead. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hacker's_Diet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hacker's_Diet If you can go for a walk for 1-2 hours a day, just simply walk your way out of the problem. And if you "can't afford" to walk for 1 hour every day your life is already in shambles and you're not in a position to make other changes before you sort this out. Eat clean. Walk. Be consistent. Be patient as it will take more than a year, the time delayed reward is the very crux of the matter. And don't stress, laugh more! Laughter is the best medicine buddy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g5AixBKy7b4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g5AixBKy7b4 Highly recommend watching Its Always Sunny in Philadelphia for Macs trajectory. The actor went from skinny to obese and back for a joke. Very best of luck.
- Noumenon72 3y agoThe fact that gaining weight is a one-way door in this way makes it more important for young people than things like starting a 401k. It's so much easier to proactively improve your diet and exercise when you still have your natural thinness than after all your hormones want you to be larger. You know the fat monster is coming for you within ten years if you do not, and it will never really let you go.
- tomhoward 3y agoTo the extent that this phenomenon is true for a significant number of people, it aligns with a concept that I came across several years ago and have been living by ever since with good success: our decisions are driven mostly from our subconscious mind. When seen this way, there are good reasons why a person may be beholden to subconscious patterns that cause them to return to an above-average weight (and thus continue to produce hunger hormones even though they've eaten enough fuel for the body to function well): it can be dangerous to be in good shape - it can attract unwanted attention, attack, or expectations of capabilities that would make people see you as a threat. If a person has had some kind of trauma in the past relating to physical attack, gaining weight can be a way to become invisible, a non-threat, or better protected in the case of an attack. (FWIW this might explain cases where there are severe side-effects after taking drugs like Ozempic: the drug may be effective at blocking the hunger hormones of whatever it does, but if the subconscious pattern is still congruent with maintaining the higher weight level, it will fight back in other ways. The subconscious mind always wins, in my experience.) That said, another factor can just be issues with the microbiome and digestive absorption: there are several conditions that can mean that even though a person has consumed enough food, the nutritional content is not absorbed into the body, due to the presence or colonies of organisms (bacteria, parasites, fungus) that consume the nutrients first), and/or digestive inflammation conditions that mean the nutrients just aren't absorbed, but the fat from the food is still stored. So, more food is desired in order to try to gain sustenance, even though it seems enough has already been consumed (though, issues relating to digestion can also originate in the subconscious mind, as the research behind YC company Mindset Health demonstrates – https://www.mindsethealth.com/research-outcomes https://www.mindsethealth.com/research-outcomes) Health is hard.
- Fluorescence 3y ago> gaining weight can be a way to become invisible, a non-threat I have become a little sceptical about this one because of how frequently I now see it claimed. While there might be real cases, it has become part of the therapy patter around weight-loss. It has become a "realisation" that rationalises someone's eating. It wasn't out of control, it wasn't about desire but an unconscious plan! It paints them as the noble victim and gives them a path to becoming more confident and slimmer. It might even be a helpful mindset but I don't think it's the true mechanism which is more about attempting mood-repair and getting trapped in a food-addiction cycle. I have only ever seen how weight-gain becomes a pain that feeds the need for mood-repair rather than anyone reaching an unconscious victory of becoming invisible. I see the converse happen - when over-weight we feel painfully conspicuous, to an almost paranoid extent. I think it becomes more convincing when women lose weight and get unwanted attention. When the conceived fix is to start eating, is that a rational reaction or the inner food-addict concocting excuses for an XXL pizza? I know when I break an addiction that inner-addict comes up with some hella bullshit. Invisibility might be part of the spectrum of our mental state in weight-gain but I'm seeing this as a primary explanation spike way beyond what I believe is credible for an "unconscious plan" theory. Female obesity is greater than Male obesity but I expect that is due to the greater hormonal and child-birth challenges than this theory.
- maxglute 3y agoIt's hard settling for lower caloric consumption to maintain lower body weight without large life style changes (duh). For the last 10 years I settled for eating what my body desired + lifing heavy and being 30 BMI at 15% bodyfat instead of previous 35%. Now aging is starting to catch up to me, blood pressure and heart burn increasing at same legally obese BMI. Currently skipping a couple meals, do a little fasting to get around to 25 BMI, but really just waiting of better diet drugs.
- tetrisgm 3y agoUsed to be 300lbs. Going down to 200 took 18 months of eating 400 calories as many days as I could endure, and fill myself with water. It's a thankless process. You fight years of muscle memory that tells you that you should treat yourself. Your brain is telling you about all your cravings and how hungry you are. You could be happy and full right now. Worse, when you eat, it'll take 30 mins for you to feel full. It's all stacked against you. Eventually you reach your goal. What now? Can you treat yourself? Loosen up? Chill? The moment you do it's a slippery slope. It's hard to maintain lost weight because your entire body is a machine that you have trained to want this, and happiness and success looks like learning to let go. The determination and drive to fix it is very difficult. I can understand how the craving gets appealing with time as things have settled.
- smabie 3y agoFortunately now weight loss is basically solved due to ozempic and friends. Suspect a very large % of the population will be on these things indefinitely
- perlgeek 3y agohttps://www.drugs.com/ozempic.html https://www.drugs.com/ozempic.html says > after 30 weeks, patients on Ozempic 0.5mg had lost 2.6 kg more than the placebo group, and patients on Ozempic 1mg lost 3.5 kg more than the placebo group. That doesn't seem all that much weight loss to me, and it sounds far from being "basically solved". Also, financing the drug seems to be an unsolved problem, except for the rich.
- gscott 3y agoI am on Mounjaro 10 mg for the past 3 months. I have lost 20 pounds. So far so good, looking to loose more but I seem to have plateaued right now I have not lost any additional weight in the last month... would like to get to 170 which would be another 30 pounds. Luckily my wife works for a hospital and has excellent insurance which covers it. Most people have to pay equivalent to an expensive car payment for it.
- 3y ago
- cbracketdash 3y agoThis is pure garbage. Making an effort to live a better life does not always follow a linear trend. There will be times when some make progress and then revert. But it's entirely about your mindset and intense self-reflection. If one lives in a completely pleasure-inducing life, sure, eating every food under the sun seems better. Yet, a self-reflective person would realize the reasoning behind losing the weight in the first place and why they should continue to stay in that state. It's a paradigm shift in the mind that must happen to maintain the loss in weight. Not the reverse.
- Angostura 3y agoDismisses a scientific study as “pure garbage” goes on post a commentary that fails to address any of its findings.
- coldtea 3y agoYeah, basing the answer on what the "self-reflective person" does is begging the question at best and self-congratulatory at worst. "Wanna lose weight? Just think and act like a person who loses weight"
- hippich 3y agoSomewhat tangent - I've lost about 20% on semaglutide. What I discovered, since I lost quite a lot of muscles as well, my lower back pain, related to crack in one vertebrae, got really bad. Once I reached my weight goal (just a hair above "normal" weight, coincidentally where I plateaued), I started weights lifting, starting at very low numbers, and keeping semaglutide at about half dosage. It seems to help so far. Just something to consider for someone who need to lose a lot of weight and who has some underlying condition. It is still worth it in my opinion, just not as painless as one could think.
- glp1guide 3y agoSo a bit late but this is definitely a thing, but as far as I know, with any kind of rapid weight loss, the loss of muscle "lean mass" can be an issue. Did your doctor warn you by any chance about the cracked vertebrae and the interplay with losing weight/muscle? I'm assuming not but that is definitely not the kind of pre-existing condition that someone might notice (though I'd hope a doctor could notice/forsee that) Starting to pair lifting weights with the treatment seems to be what everyone is suggesting is figuring out now, much like you did[0]. Along with that, probably some remodeling of eating habits is required (instead of just eating less). [0]: https://glp1.guide/content/can-glp1-drugs-replace-diet-and-exercise-ozempic-mounjaro-wegovy https://glp1.guide/content/can-glp1-drugs-replace-diet-and-e...
- borroka 3y agoNo one has a perfect, comprehensive explanation for why so many people today are overweight and obese. I believe, and I am far from being the only one, there is a cultural component and a caloric component. Real life is not black and white, and it is more accurate to see the evolution of norms and diet as a shift in statistical distributions. The caloric component is easy to explain. Today, it is very easy to overeat without realizing it from the point of view of hunger. A Frappuccino, or whatever they call it, can provide 1k kcal, with no impact on satiety. On the contrary, because of the combination of sugar and fat, one may feel hungrier than before when swallowing that Mocacchino. For my grandparents, who were born before World War II, it was much more difficult to take in calories. Even if they wanted to, it was hard to overeat (for a historical overview on the availability of calories, you can read the book "Escape from Hunger and Premature Death" by Fogel). The cultural component may seem more difficult to explain, but I think we can easily see how cultural relativism has strengthened in the last 3 or 4 decades. "Am I fat? Who cares, whatever. Haha." "Do I go out in pj for a "grocery run"? Who cares, as long as I'm comfortable." And this is particularly evident in the United States. If you go to some of the more European parts of South America, Europe or some Asian countries, you see far fewer obese and overweight people. They could certainly gain weight from the standpoint of caloric availability, but they tend not to. Because certain cultural and religious norms are still strong, and people who gain weight are frowned upon. Although I am concerned, from a cultural point of view, about the rotundity of the current pope. Times are changing. Third, there is an issue of self-esteem. The man or woman of the current times see themselves as unworthy, as spectators of the real life lived by other people. When they go from pants size 32 to 34 to 38 to 42, they are not shocked, they are not horrified, they are not concerned for themselves, for their families, for their ancestors, but they take it with the word that best characterizes the philosophy of our times, "Whatever." Judging was bad, but is not judging better? The atomization of the modern human being, lonely, mistreated at work, by partners--whether true or false, and also thinking that a bit of all of us are victims and victimizers--who realizes that he or she will be forgotten the first weekend after they die, leads to having little incentive to dress "properly," to be (reasonably) athletic, strong or fit, to be virtuous. One takes more pride in the new car one has bought than in the body one has built, living "on the rebound" the lives of celebrities who ignore our existence. But all our lives are important, especially to ourselves, and this is the first realization we should have when we start losing weight, or when we decide it is time to put the fork down.
- 2dvisio 3y agoRemind me of interesting research we did as a postdoc. Weight loss (and also maintenance) are generally better when clustering different strategies: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30096203/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30096203/
- spectrum1234 3y agoFasting should help keep the weight down. It takes your liver 2 weeks to adjust. This has helped me to stay less hungry.