6 ms·
Forgejo forks its own path forward
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> It will remain possible to upgrade from the latest Gitea version released at the time of the hard fork, but versions past that will not have such a guarantee. I recently did try to upgrade my Gitea instance to Forgejo but it wasn't a success. I've ended with just hard re-import of the repos, of which the hardest part was manually clicking all 'orphaned' repos. Can't say anything (good or bad) yet of this whole situation, but Forgejo has a chance to be a bit better product... while it have the manpower and funds. > the shackles of proprietary tools Ahem.
- drcongo 3y agoI've been planning to set up a local Gitea mirror of my GitHub, given your experience of both, would you recommend Forgejo over Gitea?
- justsomehnguy 3y agoATM there is virtually no difference between them if you are interested in the basics. Mirroring was working fine in Gitea, no reason it would be broken in Forgejo. The whole ordeal reminds me of OwnCloud/NextCloud split: both are fine if you need the basics, OC is on the negative list for paywalling the already existing functionality, NC tries too hard to be Nero Burning ROM of webapps; both are shit nowadays. I didn't like how the takeover of G. went, so when I had the opportunity, I tried to migrate to F. The decision is up to you, though.
- drcongo 3y agoPerfect run down, thank you!
- CaptainFever 3y ago> > the shackles of proprietary tools > Ahem. (Genuine) Can't really understand it. Is it because it sounds like a Communist reference?
- justsomehnguy 3y agoIt's brilliant. Straight: yep, tools. Rhymes great with the intended meaning: corporate fools Can be still used straight: >> A person or group which is used or controlled, usually unwittingly, by another person or group. And finally can be used straight again: >> a foolish or unlikable person
- zx8080 3y agoChange the name please. Most have no good idea how to pronounce it.
- gruez 3y agoForge-joe?
- PedroBatista 3y agoHate to be that guy who "ignores" the huge amount of effort and people's free time just to "bitch" about the name, but... the name is horrible and that has real impact because people can't pronounce it, don't like it and forget about it. So the project will have low adoption and sooner or later will be abandoned. Name is only a factor, but IS a factor. The devs don't owe anything, I'm just asking for a consideration.
- zx8080 3y ago> has real impact because people can't pronounce it, don't like it and forget about it. Forgetto
- aloisdg 3y agoForj-Jo I would say (and so does this guy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4OQMc1rIO4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4OQMc1rIO4)
- dave78 3y agoI checked out Forgejo shortly after they forked to potentially replace a Gitlab instance. At the time at least, what I found was they seemed to be spending most of their efforts bickering over a code of conduct and I think they already managed to have a scandal of sorts where they decided to kick someone out for CoC violations. This was before they had even made any real code changes. It really turned me off; I don't want to be dealing with a project that uses a CoC as a weapon. I don't know if the situation has changed or not, but if that kind of thing worries you, then I suggest looking into it before going all-in on Forgejo.
- CaptainFever 3y agoThis is interesting. I run a Forgejo instance but if the project is really more of an Ayo.js (over-interested in governance and office politics, under-interested in coding), I would consider Gitea or Gitlab instead. Do you have a source? I can't find anything about this online.
- wtfwhateven 3y agothere is no source, they made it up
- lolinder 3y agoBe warned that Gitea has its own problems—the trademarks and domain were transferred to a for-profit entity (Gitea Ltd. [0]) and gitea.com is now being operated by a different for-profit entity (CommitGo, Inc.). Given that Gitea Ltd. was created specifically to make money to fund the development of Gitea, it's concerning that they already felt the need to obfuscate the situation further with another company, with no real explanation for why. I think the Forgejo developers were correct that the transfer of the IP did not bode well for the future of the open source project. As for GitLab, I'm concerned by the fact that the company has become weirdly enterprise-y of late. This might not affect the self-hosted version yet, but I wasn't willing to risk it. I ended up going with Forgejo as the option with the least concerning governance structure. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33372471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33372471
- kstrauser 3y agoI wish it were possible to compare user numbers between the 2. That's not everything, of course, but it does say a bit about the long-term viability. That's crucial when there's talk of a hard fork: am I leaving a project with a million active users for one with 7? Or maybe it's the opposite, and I need to get off the sinking ship while they're still compatible?
- diggan 3y agoNot sure about Gitea, but Forgejo is what is being used for Codeberg (and maintained by the same people, maybe?) whereas the voluntary association behind Codeberg (Codeberg e.V.) has at least 429 members (https://blog.codeberg.org/letter-from-codeberg-looking-into-the-new-year.html https://blog.codeberg.org/letter-from-codeberg-looking-into-...), so I think it's pretty safe to say Forgejo will be maintained for the time being.
- Kwpolska 3y agoHow many of those members are actually capable of maintaining the codebase? How many of them will leave at the first sign of trouble or some petty conflict?
- diggan 3y agoI'm guessing most of them, as the organization is focused around codeberg.org, a git repository hosting service, like GitHub but open source and supported by a non-profit. It'd be pretty weird for non-software developers to join a non-profit association behind a git forge. And if that wasn't enough, joining the association also requires paying an annual fee. If the existing leadership disappeared tomorrow though, how many would actually have enough free time and energy to actually continue running the ship? That I'm not sure about, but the capability is there if there is will.
- Kwpolska 3y agoPolitically-motivated forks by non-developers have happened in the fast. For example, https://github.com/ayojs/ayo https://github.com/ayojs/ayo — a fork of node.js, whose only changes were to README.md and CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md, everything else was just copied from Node.
- ericyd 3y agoThe most fascinating part of this post to me is that even after reading the pronunciation key [1] I still don't feel confident that I'm saying the product name correctly. It makes me reflect on how English-centric the web still is even in 2024, and it makes me wonder if non-native English speakers have similar hang ups with other popular apps/companies. [1] https://forgejo.org/2022-12-15-hello-forgejo/ https://forgejo.org/2022-12-15-hello-forgejo/
- bluish29 3y ago> makes me wonder if non-native English speakers have similar hang ups with other popular apps/companies As a non-native English speaker, I can confirm that you are right. This happens all the time. I used to pronounce "Cache" as "kay-sh" for a decade or so (sometimes I still do)
- miki123211 3y agoWhatsApp is notoriously bad at this, the pronunciation is not very obvious if you don't speak English. I've definitely heard non-English speakers pronouncing it with more of an a sound, like in farm.
- sirl1on 3y agoI think the mispronunciation may stem from the intended pun/wordplay: What's up? -> WhatsApp
- Rexogamer 3y agoside note, but why is the audio example an mp4 of all things? there's no video so surely mp3 or something similar would be better fitting
- ericyd 3y agoThat's hilarious, I didn't even realize it was a clickable link! Well, file formats aside, props to the team for including an audio recording of how to pronounce it.
- 3y ago
- AHTERIX5000 3y agoGitea + Drone has been a great combination. I have a somewhat complex project with CI pipelines running on x86/arm64 Linux and x86 Windows and from time to time considered switching to Forgejo + actions or Forgejo + Woodpecker CI but they don't seem to support Windows runners or offer anything worth the hassle really.
- jamesu 3y agoCurrent woodpecker CI has a windows agent, feels like it has become better rounded as of late.
- fs0c13ty00 3y agoI understand the changes to Gitea pissed the community so much. But at least it appears they are not resorting to a "bait and switch" with the open-source license, and remain committed to retaining the MIT license. Offering a managed service and paid support seems like a reasonable move to me, and would certainly benefit many small and medium organizations. The profit gained from business could also provide funding for contributors and maintainers. I like the approach of taking money from corpos to make FOSS stronger. Hard-forking an already MIT licensed project for just another one is really bad for both side.
- mappu 3y agoMy understanding of the frustration is Codeberg had over-invested in Woodpecker CI and so were blindsided by the appearance of Gitea Actions runner, that was developed by a core contributor, funded by an external party. In my mind, Forgejo's creation is an overreaction to basically this event. It's true that Gitea could have had more openness about such forthcoming development, and I think the new company structure for lunny + techknowlogick will really help them with this and being more professional. Gitea still has all the development resources and the vast bulk of all PRs. They're committed to MIT with no CLA, the lead developers are there, and that really matters. In comparison, Forgejo to this point has dragged its feet to rebase its few (~100) patches onto each new Gitea release. Most of the changes are simply rebranding, plus some new moderation tools for codeberg. Although codeberg don't even run forgejo directly but yet another downstream fork. So I think this hardfork will likely spell the end (or: rebirth) of forgejo. They haven't demonstrated much independent development so far. The worry about keeping some MIT independence is I think a sideshow, the latest Gitea is still MIT and with no CLA. So if forgejo may no longer be drop-in compatible, why would you switch to them? I wish Gitea and Codeberg could be better friends. Gitea has had amazing success this year with adoption by Blender and other large projects.
- jacooper 3y agoIt mainly has to do with Gitea creating a for profit and assigning everything to it without any community consensus.
- crotchfire 3y agoPlease fix the utterly unpronounceable name.