9 ms·
Indian government moves to ban ProtonMail after bomb threat
- yankaf 3y agogandu guys, the ban done via ISP is being done via the dns, though you might not receive some emails, but still can access it, just change your dns
- thih9 3y agoI guess they will receive their next threat from a gmail account?
- vinni2 3y agowhich is easier to trace presumably?
- thih9 3y agoI suppose not by much if you create a new one or use somebody else’s data. I’m sure the proton one wasn’t also someone’s main email account.
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoBut Google will usually provide logs/IP addresses (not content) to police without a warrant, which can be used to start tracking down the culprit. It isn't clear from the report if the Police got a warrant or even made a request to ProtonMail.
- spacecadet 3y agoMost do not just sign in to a compromised account and send and email from their laptop... It usually involves some level of obscurity. Im sure if they want to find out bad enough they will- but I would be surprised if this was sent by someone just sitting there.
- chollida1 3y ago> But Google will usually provide logs/IP addresses (not content) to police without a warrant, which can be used to start tracking down the culprit. Not in Canada. Google has been very clear they don't give anything to law enforcement without a warrant. Where are you getting your information from? Because its very scary if true.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ijhuygft776 3y agoyou used to be able to create a protonmail account using Tor.... so I guess it might be easier
- protonmail 3y agoYou still can.
- nottorp 3y agoYou're not thinking big enough. Next email should come from the Indian government's email. Considering how tech aware they are, I'm sure there are hundreds of thousands of indian gov email acounts with passwords like 1234...
- davchana 3y agoWhat if it comes by postal mail i.e. India Post?
- alex_smart 3y agoWhat if it comes by a pigeon? Oh no!
- nottorp 3y agoErm. They are arresting pigeons already: https://apnews.com/article/india-chinese-spy-pigeon-f3543790447d4b43d347294e21874bf1 https://apnews.com/article/india-chinese-spy-pigeon-f3543790...
- tempodox 3y agoThis would make things interesting, since they'd have to ban governmental use of email then.
- rockyj 3y agoBan everything you cannot control / understand! That is the classic Indian bureaucracy reaction. For example, They also banned tinted windows in cars after an assualt happened in a car. Then, there was a time where they banned something or the other on a daily basis. Even right now there is Section 144 imposed in multiple cities - which means a "ban" on "unlawful assembly" of 5 or more people. 5 or more people in multiple cities which have a population of millions! Now, how do they enforce / check these "assemblies of people" depends on the people you ask. I have already spoken too much.
- jwr 3y agoIt's not specifically Indian. Canada just banned Flipper Zero devices because the little radios can replay car key fob signals and older cars are susceptible to replay attacks. Stupidity is everywhere.
- cedws 3y agoUK government has tried to ban encryption time and time again. This is what happens when you have old/incompetent career politicians in power instead of deep thinkers like scientists and engineers.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> deep thinkers like scientists and engineers That doesn't work, either, because they tend to be rather dismissive of human concerns, and, at its heart, government is all about humans. I don't have a solution, but I don't think that declaring that only one-or-another "class" of humans is fit to govern, is it.
- jvanderbot 3y agoThat's a stereotype and probably not true. Many deep thinkers are humanists. It's probably more likely around the hyper rational types, but my boss is the most empathetic engineer I've ever worked for. This is anecdotal but your comment seems fairly clearly overbroad
- verisimi 3y agoBureaucrats will write rules. No need to follow them. Why can a jumped up idiot determine what's right or wrong?
- mrtksn 3y agoSo they want to block the service? Why not simply block incoming mail from ProtonMail?
- recroad 3y agoIndia for all intents and purposes is now an ethno-national state with no press freedom, severe persecution of minorities, and human rights violations aplenty. I grew up in India when it was a relatively secular state. For example, when the Babri Masjid (mosque) was destroyed by Hindus in the early 90s, the national magazine, India Today and major newspapers led with the headline, "India's Shame" and acknowledge how bad that was for Indian secularism. Less than a month ago the same mosque was now converted into a Hindu temple and the press and government led the cheerleading. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/1/22/why-is-indias-ram-temple-in-ayodhya-controversial https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/1/22/why-is-indias-ram-t...
- risinaf661 3y ago[dead]
- 1sembiyan 3y ago1. No press freedom: what explains the presence and popularity of the wire, scroll, news minute, the quint, etc? Traditional print media that’s critical of the current party in power includes The Hindu, Telegraph etc. That there’s no press freedom is false. 2. Ethno-nationalist state: what ethnicity are we talking about here? BJP loses often in elections locally, and majority of their opponents are Hindus. What India has always been is illiberal. You are weakening your point by exaggerating the current conditions. Moreover this prosed ban is because we have an overzealous bureaucracy that doesn’t understand technology and does not care to. It’s got nothing to do with what India has become.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoAs a data point, the previous government that grandparent speaks of also has been involved in actual suspension of democracy, abolition of press rights, and jailing of opposition leaders[1]. Indian administrations have always have had an authoritarian bent regardless of who has been in power. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emergency_(India) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emergency_(India)
- derpitron 3y ago
- alephnerd 3y ago"On February 8, a bomb threat was sent to 13 schools in Chennai, a city in the state of Tamil Nadu in southern India. The threat turned out to be a hoax, and the Tamil Nadu police found that the email was sent via a ProtonMail account. Unable to trace the IP address of the sender and failing to get assistance from Interpol, the Tamil Nadu police put in a request to India's Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology to block access to ProtonMail within the country"
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoWait until they hear about the inability for US authorities to trace swatting phone calls and robocalls and scam texts. Ban the phone system!
- alephnerd 3y agoIn the US, local PDs can and have litigated telcos over swatting [0]. Every state has a Anti-Swatting Litigation Task Force within their AG now to take Telcos to court over swatting incidents. On the other hand, India doesn't have a judicial agreement with Switzerland over data sharing for criminal investigations [1] (while the US does [2]), and Protonmail only honors Swiss litigation [3] This should change with the new India-Switzerland FTA though. [0] - https://portal.ct.gov/AG/Press-Releases/2022-Press-Releases/AG-Tong-Announces-Nationwide-Anti-Robocall-Litigation-Task-Force https://portal.ct.gov/AG/Press-Releases/2022-Press-Releases/... [1] - https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess.pdf https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess.... [2] - https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%80%93NOTICE https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%... [3] - https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement
- testhn2ac 3y ago[flagged]
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agohttps://www.onmanorama.com/content/mm/en/kerala/top-news/2023/12/02/kollam-child-abduction-tom-and-jerry-cartoon-helped-police-identify-suspects.html https://www.onmanorama.com/content/mm/en/kerala/top-news/202... so apparently a child was abducted and one thing led to another and the child was recovered so the child revealed how he was shown tom and jerry cartoon. the police then went on a fishing trip and literally cross referenced which user in a particular area watched tom and jerry on youtube at a particular time/date to find the cuprits. if this wont get your antenna up, i dont think anything else will proton thing is normal compared to this
- rockyj 3y agoFunnily enough, it reminds me of this - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnk8Bwk3r_M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnk8Bwk3r_M (from the 17:00 mark)
- astura 3y agoThis seems like normal police work?
- EasyMark 3y agoI think that they're point at the police state monitoring everything you watch on tv or accessing it.
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoNormal police work meaning you can willy nilly go and canvass internet browsing history of thousands of citizens ? What stops them from taking political vendetta ?
- mfrw 3y agoIf this is the current condition, what alternatives are there that you may suggest apart from; `Don't use it!`
- 2Gkashmiri 3y ago
- sampli 3y agoHopefully they use gmail next
- i67vw3 3y agoWtf!! I am user of Protonmail and its other services (from India). The protonmail ID is actually my main Email-Id and is used everywhere, even on government sites. Hope https://internetfreedom.in/ https://internetfreedom.in/ steps in or some other organization.
- qart 3y agoYep. Same here. I'll get locked out of my bank account too.
- miroljub 3y agoWhen registering your next mail, make sure to register a domain first, and use it as your online identity.
- behringer 3y agoI wouldn't trust someone else to host my email ID. Get yourself your own domain at porkbun.com, make sure it's a .com or at least a very reliable TLD that won't be going anywhere, and then setup proton to point to it. You are no longer locked into any one provider :) You can always transfer your domain and you can always transfer your email host.
- dutchCourage 3y agoDo your due diligence when choosing a registrar. I recall a blog post where an attacker got access to the blogger's domain through a social engineering attack on the registrar, and subsequently got access to their emails. I'm curious if anyone knows the article I'm mentioning and how to prevent such an attack. I couldn't find the article back.
- _heimdall 3y agoThere's a pretty egregious misunderstanding of how email works in both the article and the proposed ban. Protonmail can only end-to-end encrypt email when the receiver is also using Protonmail. The email spec has no support for a universal encryption method, one of the reasons we'd be better off not using email at all today. They also don't explain how the inability to track the sender's IP is specific to Protonmail. Unless I missed a key feature, Protonmail doesn't do anything to hide or obscure the sender's IP.
- alephnerd 3y ago> inability to track the sender's IP is specific to Protonmail The issue is India doesn't have a judicial agreement with Switzerland over data sharing (which includes User IP Addresses) for criminal investigations [0] while the US does [1], and Protonmail only honors Swiss litigation [2] This should change with the new India-Switzerland FTA though. [0] - https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess.pdf https://carnegieendowment.org/files/ParsheeraJha_DataAccess.... [1] - https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%80%93NOTICE https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/framework-article/1%E2%... [2] - https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement https://proton.me/legal/law-enforcement
- _heimdall 3y agoIndia is target Protonmail rather than all companies in countries that India doesn't have an agreement with though, right? My point was just that singling out Protonmail doesn't make sense and misses the point on how email works.
- alephnerd 3y agoThink of laws like Blacklists/Deny Lists. A platform is default allowed until it denies to comply with Law Enforcement Requests. When that happens, a platform can by denied/blacklisted. This is why Protonmail is blocked in India and not Gmail or Yahoo. If Proton AG decided to ignore US Law Enforcement requests, it would get shut down the same way. This exact thing happened to Lavabit in 2013.
- szundi 3y agoBest ad
- acatton 3y ago> ProtonMail is the best choice if you want an end-to-end encrypted email platform Is this native advertisement? There are many other choices, some of them being as good if not better. A few of them are small mom-and-pop businesses which didn't take on investment, and won't enshittify ( https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/enshittification https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/enshittification ) * https://www.privacytools.io/privacy-email https://www.privacytools.io/privacy-email * https://github.com/pluja/awesome-privacy?tab=readme-ov-file#mail-services https://github.com/pluja/awesome-privacy?tab=readme-ov-file#...
- upofadown 3y agoThis all seems a bit confused. This has nothing to do with encryption. ProtonMail cooperates with law enforcement to track down users, but they do need a proper legal process. They won't just release user information on a simple request. They do have the ability to capture IP addresses. ProtonMail is accessible over Tor, but they don't allow registration/verification over Tor.
- heikrana 3y ago> ProtonMail is accessible over Tor, but they don't allow registration/verification over Tor. They do now.
- protonmail 3y agoHi! It is in fact possible to signup via our onion website or using Tor browser.
- upofadown 3y agoBut do you have to provide any information during such a signup that could be used to identify you in response to a valid legal warrant of some type? The "verification".
- protonmail 3y agoThis depends on the exit node, so if you are experiencing this, we recommend trying another one. If it persists, contact us here so we can take a closer look: https://proton.me/support/contact https://proton.me/support/contact
- upofadown 3y agoExperiencing what? To phrase my question differently: can someone show up on a Tor connection and make a new account without giving Proton any indication of who they are? So that in the case they abuse the account somehow, the only thing that Proton can do is just cancel the account?
- hansonpeter 3y ago[dead]
- dommer 3y agoWhat an ad for ProtonMail - Governments cannot track you.
- honeybadger1 3y ago"The Indian government uses a bomb threat as an excuse to take away more of your freedom"
- ijhuygft776 3y agoWhy don't they ban phones too?
- miohtama 3y agoChina is already there, leading the pack. If you are Uighur ethnicity you need to use a special government issued “phone” or force installed app. They really use it as a tracking device. https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/05/01/interview-chinas-big-brother-app https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/05/01/interview-chinas-big-bro...
- nimish 3y agoThey severely restricted the buying of SIM cards after the Mumbai terror attacks on the flimsy basis that the terrorists used cell phones to coordinate them . In practice it means that it's a massive pain to get a local number when visiting family. VOIP intra-country is also illegal, but it's not clear if that's regulatory capture or for similar "national security" grounds.
- ijhuygft776 3y ago> it's not clear if that's regulatory capture or for similar "national security" grounds The reason given doesn't matter that much... they give whatever reason they think most people will approve.
- supertrope 3y agoSatellite phones are banned.
- SmokeyHamster 3y agoWould the ban work the other way too? As a PM user, would I stop receiving a ton of spam from Indian addresses?
- testhn2ac 3y agoMove to Google if the PM spam filter is so bad
- canistel 3y agoWhat do you expect? They banned VLC for months, for some silly reason. https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/vlc-player-has-been-unbanned-in-india-months-after-silly-ban-download-now-available-2297121-2022-11-14 https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/vlc-player-h...
- testhn2ac 3y ago> Unable to trace the IP address of the sender and failing to get assistance from Interpol, the Tamil Nadu police put in a request to India's Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology to block access to ProtonMail within the country, according to Hindustan Times. That request was granted today, with the government authority issuing an order to block the service in the region. This is at the request of a state police of Tamilnadu. This particular state in India is ruled by a Party that's against Modi and his party. Question here, why can't Protonmail cooperate with the police investigating bombing threat against schools ?
- lukan 3y agoBecause swiss and india have no jucidial agreement on sharing data, but working on it.
- Gys 3y agoJust ban terrorism. Problem solved.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shinryuu 3y agoIf you’re making a bomb threat through normal mail. Are they going to ban the post as well?
- seatac76 3y agoBureaucracy does its thing. Interesting how governments just do not understand technology.
- rldjbpin 3y agoyou have to wonder just how much such rulings help anyone. - practically nobody uses the service in the country (especially when dealing with hundreds of millions connected on the internet), and for some this might have a streissand effect. - those using such services for nefarious reasons would have little to no reason to abide by it. IT law enforcement is already very ineffective as it is, and would only be used as a lever when dealing with cases the administration has special interest in. - this is not really a matter of encryption but about data sharing arrangements with other countries (as correctly pointed out in the comments). funnily enough it is against the law to refuse decryption (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_Technology_Act%2C_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_Technology_Act%2C_...).
- MariaRobb 3y ago[dead]
- albertaaura99 3y ago[dead]