4 ms·
> In the US they'd risk either being killed by a driver, or stopped by an overzealous neighbor or police officer. It may depends on where in the US you're talk
by JohnFen 3y ago
> In the US they'd risk either being killed by a driver, or stopped by an overzealous neighbor or police officer.
It may depends on where in the US you're talking about, but in my area none of this is actually true. Although lots of people believe it is.
- MBlume 3y agoSounds nice. I've personally spoken on the phone with a police officer who told me he'd involve CPS if he saw my daughter walking (two blocks!) to school again.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- koolba 3y agoHow old is your daughter and what happened when you told him to mind his own business and called his bluff?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> what happened when you told him to mind his own business and called his bluff? It's not a bluff. From what I've read, fighting CPS is expensive. (Though I would raise the issue with the police chief.)
- deprecative 3y agoYou want to antagonize an untouchable murder junkie? In what universe is that a good idea?
- koolba 3y ago“Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.” I also disagree with framing all police as “murder junkies”.
- asoneth 3y agoI agree that we need to push back, but that can also be done politically. Antagonizing a local police officer is a terrible idea unless you are wealthy and/or well-connected. Most are kind, but not all are, and antagonizing the wrong one can make your life hell. (I also agree that the vast majority of police are not "murder junkies". But it's also not surprising that a handful of folks like that do join an organization that nearly always manages to protect their members from repercussions when they use lethal force.)
- alistairSH 3y agoThey might not personally be "murder junkies" but through the "thin blue line", they almost all enable that behavior from their peers.
- jkestner 3y agoOne of the nice things about Texas is that it has a law against that. Tell your reps to get something similar passed. https://letgrow.org/texas-becomes-third-state-to-enshrine-reasonable-childhood-independence-into-law/ https://letgrow.org/texas-becomes-third-state-to-enshrine-re... I'm reminded of how Georgia will pay foster parents of homeless kids more than it'd cost to simply put a roof over those kids' families heads. https://www.propublica.org/article/georgia-housing-assistance-foster-care https://www.propublica.org/article/georgia-housing-assistanc...
- gnicholas 3y agoYeah, in CA you aren't allowed to leave a kid under 6 in a car if "there are conditions that can pose a risk to the child’s health and safety, even if accompanied by another child who is not yet 13. What does it mean for conditions to "pose a risk"? Obviously high heat, but it's not clear what else could qualify. I don't ever leave my kids (one that is under 6 and one that is well over 6, but not yet 13) alone in a car, since I don't want police or nosy passersby injecting themselves in a perfectly benign situation.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoI don't think any of the parent posters were talking about leaving kids in a car. That is certainly a dangerous thing to do.
- gnicholas 3y agoWhy is it "certainly dangerous" to leave a 5 year old and a 10 year old in a car, while I go into a store to pick something up?
- ClimaxGravely 3y agoNot the person you asked but if I had to guess it might be similar to how people react to leaving a dog in a car. That is to say it's a heat issue.
- Symbiote 3y agoUnlike dogs, children can open doors and windows, and can shout for help if they think it essential.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoIn many cars, power windows can't be operated when the car is off with the key removed.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoOverzealous neighbors in the US will have someone's house sold out from under them when the grass is too high and they don't pay the fines to the HOA for mowing it. The idea that they'll be ok with children wandering around unsupervised is preposterous on its face. The cops might not care either way, but only until the busybodies start nagging. Especially the sort of busybodies that live in the places where any sane parent might consider letting their kids wander. Kids would probably go unmolested by aging Karens in the bad parts of Baltimore or Gary IN, but then they have other problems. I agree with you that the risk of being killed by a car is somewhat low though.
- thfuran 3y agoThe US is a country with hundreds of millions of people in tens of thousands of municipalities in dozens of states. The idea that because outliers exist, they describe the typical experience everywhere in the nation is preposterous on its face.
- rootusrootus 3y agoOne place I'd have hoped would be able to understand such a simple concept is HN. Especially with all the Europeans who frequent this site. 330 million people with about the same land area as Europe. Yet people simultaneously think there can be a pretty big difference between, say, UK and Poland, but think that every newsworthy event that happens anywhere in the US is representative of all of the US. It would be hilarious if it were not sad.
- em-bee 3y agouhm, not quite. it's all relative. regions in europe for centuries have been separated by national borders and still are separated by languages. as a result, each region in europe is homogeneous, but different from other regions in ways that doesn't compare to the differences in the US. pretty much the only thing that is really the same every country in europe is mcdonalds and cocacola. yes, there are plenty of differences in the US too, but they are limited to much smaller regions. it is more likely to say that pittsburgh and los angeles are different than the east coast vs the west coast. i have lived in both regions, as i have lived and traveled in many regions of europe. the most stark differences in the US are local, when you compare say an amish town with another town nearby. or chinatown which exists many cities. but for almost any regional uniqueness in the US you can find multiple locations all over the US that share that uniqueness. which is not the case in europe. the problem is that we tend to overstate our differences. i have lived in europe, the US, and new zealand, and i thought they were all very different from each other, until i traveled to asia and africa, and realized that in comparison all western countries really are pretty much the same. in the end we all have much more in common than we realize.
- smo29 3y agoMy friend and I were stopped by an officer and asked to show identification. We were just walking down the street, age 12. This is in the midwest. Dismiss complaints about police at your own peril.
- kasey_junk 3y agoI find these stories of kids not walking (or biking) outside wild! Hundreds of kids in my neighborhood walk, bike, or public transit to school everyday with no issues. I do worry about car on pedestrian crashes but the city has crossing guards and traffic calming for just this. Where are these places that you can’t be outside as a child?
- tmnvix 3y agoI'm not from the US, but just zoomed into a random spot in what I assume is a typical shopping district in suburban Atlanta[1]. Can't imagine many young kids safely walking or biking around there. Compare a local shopping district near me[2]. Plenty of young kids walking and biking to school here alone and in groups. [1] https://www.google.co.nz/maps/@33.8644514,-84.5949946,3a,75y,208.84h,83.56t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sb6exrZvStNdA02l0oLrOGA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu https://www.google.co.nz/maps/@33.8644514,-84.5949946,3a,75y... [2] https://www.google.co.nz/maps/@-41.2953813,174.7673872,3a,75y,275.79h,83.27t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sy_bR5zv82iygZBcR-9-QcA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu https://www.google.co.nz/maps/@-41.2953813,174.7673872,3a,75... edit: Might add that close to those shops in [2] there is a large botanic garden with play area and stream, one small and one very large reserve with native bush and an abundance of mountain bike tracks, a playing field, the central city area with cafes, many theatres, galleries, a library, and all sorts of other things that a child can make use of without supervision. All of this is within 5 minutes walk of those shops. Within 10 minutes walk there is the waterfront and a very safe swimming beach.
- kasey_junk 3y agoBut there are no schools or houses there? I’m not arguing that there are places that are pedestrian unfriendly in the US or even that there are more places per capita like that in the US. I’m just saying it would be weird for homes and schools to be placed in those locales, and even weirder for governmental officials to take action against kids walking in appropriate locales. Here is the shopping district nearest me: https://maps.app.goo.gl/SUZCyUHuGbCAwcYT7?g_st=ic https://maps.app.goo.gl/SUZCyUHuGbCAwcYT7?g_st=ic And here is a place that is inappropriate for pedestrians near you https://maps.app.goo.gl/aLdDyWdbFq6vUG6X9?g_st=ic https://maps.app.goo.gl/aLdDyWdbFq6vUG6X9?g_st=ic Within 5 minutes of my area are at least 5 parks/play lots, a beach and a library. Theaters, cafes and galleries are on that street. Within 1 mile of that location is a 550 acre public park with all manner of facilities and less than 2 miles away is a 370 acre park. Thats not mentioning the museums and university facilities near here. None of that is to flex it’s just to say a random sampling is not an appropriate retort. The US can obviously be less car centric but to imply that it’s impossible or strange for kids to be outside on there own in the US is a wild assertion and anyone making it needs to provide extraordinary proof.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI live a couple blocks from a middle school and a high school. The streets and sidewalks are full of kids walking or biking, alone or in groups, at school start/end times. There are crossing guards at the intersections they use. This isn't a poor neighborhood but it's not terribly wealthy, either. Frankly, if you visit some other country for a couple weeks, you don't get any more than the most superficial idea of what life is like there.
- bcrosby95 3y agoI wonder if there's an urban/suburban/rural or political divide when it comes to this. I live in a suburb in California and have never ran into this problem. But we're also unincorporated and don't have cops with nothing better to do than harass some kid walking to school alone. We're also surrounded by people whose kids are now in their 20s-30s. They don't see our kids running around as a nuisance - they're relatively new empty nesters and the kids seem to evoke nostalgia as they discuss the different things their kids did around the neighborhood when they were young.
- Talanes 3y agoI grew up in rural California in the one town in the county that was incorporated; the kind of place where every cop in town shows up if anything happens at all. I biked and rollerbladed to school alongside literal highways and never was approached about it once.
- asoneth 3y ago> in my area none of this is actually true That's wonderful you live in place where children are can roam freely without being injured or killed by drivers. But this is a real threat in most of the US. Being killed in a motor vehicle crash is the second highest cause of death among children and adolescents. (It was the highest until 2020 when firearm-related injuries overtook them.[1]) For every 100,000 people the Netherlands has 3.8 annual traffic deaths, the US has 12.9, and Libera (the worst I could find[2]) has 35.9. That means when it comes to traffic deaths the US is 3.4x more deadly than the Netherlands and Liberia is 2.8x more deadly than the US. I bike with my kids and let them walk to school and we talk about how to manage these risks. But being near roads in the US is less safe than most other developed countries by a statistically significant margin. [1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2201761 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2201761 [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...
- tzs 3y agoMost of that in the US is children who were riding in a car that crashes. The number of children who are killed by cars as pedestrians or bicyclists is much lower. In 2021 for example it was 176 pedestrian children and 38 bicyclist children [1]. [1] https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/813456 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/...
- asoneth 3y agoThat's an interesting point I need to think about. I do wonder how the deaths would compare to the number of trips taken, because children in the US take significantly fewer trips by bike than children in the Netherlands. Given that pedestrian deaths were at a 40 year high[1] in the US last year, I wonder if the relatively smaller number of children killed is simply a reflection of the low number of children walking. I can say though that the few times I've ridden on the road with my children were the most stressful of my life, I have never done it since, and it made me completely understand why I no longer see any other children or parents doing it. [1] https://www.vox.com/23784549/pedestrian-deaths-traffic-safety-fatalities-governors-association https://www.vox.com/23784549/pedestrian-deaths-traffic-safet...