18 ms·
Amazon Sued over Prime Video Ads: Class-Action Suit Alleges Deception
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y ago“But last month, Amazon changed the deal. To stream movies and TV shows without ads, Amazon customers must now pay an additional $2.99 per month… This is not fair, because these subscribers already paid for the ad-free version; these subscribers should not have to pay an additional $2.99/month for something that they already paid for.” Seems like a pretty solid case where they altered the deal in the midst of a one year Prime contract. I look forward to the eventual $.32 settlement I receive.
- johnnyo 3y agoThe article mentions the ads are expected to bring in $3 billion annually. Even if the lawsuit is successful, I suspect it will cost Amazon much less than what they are projecting to make.
- diggan 3y ago> Even if the lawsuit is successful, I suspect it will cost Amazon much less than what they are projecting to make. What's the point then? It appears only lawyers stand to gain from this, as usual. As soon as fines and legal infractions are viewed merely as the 'cost of doing business', enforcing regulations becomes futile. At that point, might as well transition to a 'free for all' market rather than maintain a faux judicial system.
- voakbasda 3y agoThe point is that fines and legal infractions are the cost of doing business. The government consistently fails to enforce laws in a meaningful way. We are indeed in the midst of a free for all, where "all" here refers to established interests wholly capable of buying legislation and courts.
- alwaysrunning 3y ago> What's the point then? It appears only lawyers stand to gain from this, as usual. "lawyers stand to gain from this"
- Retric 3y agoThe point is it heavily discourages this kind of mid subscription bait and switch. Not living in a world where bait and switch / illegal business practices are 10x as common is the benefit of class action lawsuits not the occasional random check for $1.37 or worse a coupon etc. Long term they could have rolled out adds as people resubscribe and there’s no lawsuit, and next time they may consider doing so.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoUsers are also harmed by watching the ads. It would be reasonable to calculate the value of each viewed ad as part of the compensation that is sought by a class-action.
- glitchc 3y agoIt's hard to show legally that users are harmed by watching ads, tort law requires a clear path to harm. If some users purport some benefit, that would negate the harm claims.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWouldn't one clearcut argument be that many people are willing to pay money specifically to not see ads?
- robertlagrant 3y agoI'm willing to pay money to buy a nice car. That doesn't mean a less nice car would harm me.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf you paid money for a nice car and got a less nice car, you suffered financial harm.
- dylan604 3y agoIf less nice car doesn't have some of the same safety features like side impact air bags but are then in a t-bone collision where you are injured because the air bags were not there, then yes.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIf the nicer car doesn't have air bags then that might harm me more. This is orthoganal.
- dangus 3y agoThis is exactly what I was going to say. Prime is sold as an annual purchase, and they didn’t structure the deal so that it would kick the ads in when your current term expires.
- init2null 3y agoBest case is that they'll be forced to let us cancel with a partial refund. This is a worthy lawsuit for that reason.
- mikestew 3y ago"Forced"? You can already cancel Prime, and get a pro-rated refund.
- silisili 3y agoI cannot believe they didn't roll this out as some feature flag based on account signup/renew date, and instead just told all paid members they're now being downgraded(remember, it's not just ads, it's lower quality).
- eitally 3y agoNo matter what people think about the products Google has built, they absolutely did handled the subscription, grandfathering and later deprecation of Google Play Music to Youtube Music, and Youtube -> Youtube Red -> Youtube Premium. A subscriber may have lost features, but they definitely did not get upcharged as part of a transition, and only later did Google start raising rates -- separate from forced functional subscription changes.
- neogodless 3y agoYeah - Google Stadia was actually kind of nice deal for the people that jumped in early.
- silisili 3y agoAbsolutely. I'm still mad about going from Play Music to Youtube Music, but I didn't feel cheated. I was also a Stadia subscriber, and while they probably legally didn't have to, they refunded every single penny I spent on games and hardware.
- ajdude 3y agoIt's not just Google either, every single pay subscription service I've ever had only altered the price for me on my renewal date (and I've often had year-long or higher subscriptions). Amazon seems to be an outlier.
- maximus-decimus 3y ago> it's not just ads, it's lower quality I didn't know that. I watched an old movie the other day (Whisper 2007). It looked like complete shit and found that strange.
- jmward01 3y agoSomewhere in the prime TOS we have agreed to this and likely much worse. I paused my subscription, not that that will mean anything to them. This lawsuit was inevitable and will change absolutely nothing no matter the outcome. The meaningful change we need is actual consumer advocacy and invalidating predatory TOS clauses. It isn't possible to live in the modern world without accepting the ridiculous and predatory TOS attached to everything and that isn't right.
- vidanay 3y agoThe lawsuits and settlement budgets were all figured in to their anticipated costs to make this change.
- seesaw 3y agoI canceled in protest. If enough people cancel, that would send a message that people won’t support ads. But I am probably an outlier.
- michaelbarton 3y agoAnecdata, but I and several of my friends have too. It’s a trivial amount of money ($3) but it just really rubbed me up the wrong way and that’s what led to me cancelling.
- danaris 3y agoIt's already been established (at least in some jurisdictions...? unclear on the details, I'm afraid) that terms in agreements like a TOS that are too far beyond the pale can, at least, be ruled unconscionable.
- apwell23 3y ago> I look forward to the eventual $.32 settlement I receive. Do you know why amount is always ridiculously low. Are these lawsuits primarly for the lawyers to make a buck, I dont see how anyone else would be motivated otherwise.
- nickff 3y agoThey have a low chance of success in court, and are a relatively expensive proposition for the plaintiff lawyers pursuing them. As such, the lawyers are happy to take a generous (to them) settlement before the case gets too far. On the opposite side, it helps the company avoid expensive discoveries, low-probability but possibly very expensive judgements, and gets rid of the need to keep investors informed about nuisance suits.
- Janlopp 3y ago[dead]
- Turing_Machine 3y agoThat's certainly the usual case, but not always. I recall one Facebook class action check I got that was in the $250 range.
- kmeisthax 3y agoThe way a class action lawsuit works is this: You, Big Business Co, do something that injures a bunch of people for a small amount. A lawyer files a lawsuit on behalf of a purported class - i.e. "Everyone Bezos Hurt vs. Amazon". There's a whole thing about class certification and other things I don't have time to get into, but let's say the judge agrees that this is a class whose harms can be adjudicated together. At some point, if you actually have a claim, Amazon wants to pay money for it to go away. This is an accepted part of the legal system, because US courts are adversarial courts[0]. The judge is just the referee. That means that if the plaintiff and defendant agree to take their business elsewhere, the judge can't get involved and continue to prosecute a dead case[1]. First problem: lawyers don't work for free. In fact, pretty much all of them are in massive amounts of student debt until their 40s and 50s, because their ability to command insane amounts of money for their services is priced into the cost of their education. Normally, a lawyer either gets paid by their client, or the client agrees to the lawyer taking a percentage cut of the damage award if one were to exist. Problem is, there's no client yet - we're suing on behalf of an abstract group of people that may or may not want to be involved in the case. Second problem: we don't know who's a member of the class, or even how many people are a member of it. Settlement agreements typically involve cash payments of a fixed amount. You have to divvy that fixed amount up to an unknown number of people. So as a result every class action settlement works like this: first, the lawyer gets a cut of the settlement, then the class splits it up however many ways. People have to respond to a settlement offer in order to be included in the class. If more people sign up than we have money for, however, then the class members are diluted. Amazon's liability does not increase just because they harmed more people than they thought. This is, effectively, a weird kind of double protection racket, in which the person shaking Amazon down for money is also taking money from Amazon to shake them down for less so the mob (us) doesn't get as much. All of it is enabled by fairly understandable and straightforward rules being chained together to arrive at a terrible result. [0] The opposite of this is inquisitorial courts. Inquisitorial as in NOBODY EXPECTS THE SPANISH INQUISITION! [1] There are certain situations in which a judge can object to a settlement that is unfair to the class, but they can't outright demand the case be brought to trial.
- crazygringo 3y agoExcept that, from all reports online (including someone in these comments), Amazon will cancel your annual Prime subscription and refund all remaining time without any problem. They don't seem to be holding anyone to the contract. (And of course plenty of people subscribe monthly rather than annually as well.) So I'm not sure there's any case here at all? Since even with annual subscriptions, it seems you can cancel at any time and get a prorated refund. The fact is, online subscription services change their benefits/features all the time. And companies seem to handle it two ways: grandfather existing customers for the rest of their subscription period, or offer prorated refunds for people who want to cancel. And while the former is definitely going to make customers happier, I think they're both acceptable from a legal standpoint? So I'm not sure this lawsuit has any chance of succeeding at all.
- Retric 3y agoSimply canceling mid contract isn’t a perfect remedy. Consider, should they get to keep the interest on the money they are handing back to you? Obviously not. Contracts are enforceable because society is much worse off if they aren’t. Imagine if your bank could arbitrarily cancel a car loan and ask for the outstanding balance back at any time simple because they felt like it.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoEnjoy the pennies on your interest.
- Retric 3y ago6 months on 139$ /2 @ 6% is $2.09 not just a few cents. Multiply that by everyone with an annual prime membership and your talking 1/2 billion dollars or so.
- crazygringo 3y agoIt's only being multiplied by the number of people who are canceling because of this. If that's 0.1% of 200 million subscribers who cancel, that's about $400K in supposed interest. Not half a billion. A rounding error for Amazon. But interest just doesn't generally factor into small consumer "returns". If you buy shoes online and then return them 25 days later because they don't match the photos exactly, you don't get interest on that either. At these amounts, it's not worth worrying about.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoAssuming a settlment is reached, it would probably require Amazon to stop their practice of charging additional fees in exchange for not harassing customers with ads. That latest internet meme from Cory Doctorow labels this particular form of bait-and-switch as "enshittification". Perhaps the plaintiffs get only a dainty payout as a result of a settlement, but their lawyers will make some decent coin, and that provides the motivation to work to prove Amazon is breaking the law. How much ad revenue does Amazon make per Prime customer on average. Is it more or less than $2.99/month. We might find out the answer to questions like these during discovery. IIRC, in past litigation we learned that Google makes about $5.50/month per user from ads. What is the alternative. Plaintiffs could finance their own lawsuits against Amazon. Perhaps they could recover more than $.32. But how much would they have to spend on legal fees and costs to reach a settlement. Chances are, Mr. Napoleon and the other plaintiffs are not paying anything. People who do not appreciate being harassed by ads by Amazon can engage lawyers to work for them "for free" to stop Amazon from further harassment. Plus, those people might get a check for $.32. What's the alternative. Keep getting harassed by Amazon and complain on HN expecting something will change. That sounds even less effective and more ridiculous than class action lawsuits and $.32 settlement checks.
- Justsignedup 3y agoThis is why companies do this nonsense. The cost is so low, that its just the cost of doing business. They need an additive punitive damage getting everyone $100. In any case, sensationalist headlines aside, some lawyer is gonna make a lot of money. And I'm guessing the case will be settled so we can't just go to small claims court and sue them for 3k each.
- drtz 3y agoHere's where I'd normally complain about how our economic system requires prices to increase while product quality degrades to ensure ever-increasing profits for shareholders. Instead, I'll complain about commercials: why can't we just have something that's truly paid and ad-free? Do we actually value our time less than advertisers do?
- johnnyo 3y agoBecause it’s more profitable to have something that is paid for AND has ads. Same thing happened with cable TV when it first came out, it was advertised as ad free. Then it filled up with ads, and the streaming services came along promising no ads. Now the circle is repeating itself. Here is the NYTimes in 1981 on the topic https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-invaded-by-commercials.html https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-inv...
- TehCorwiz 3y agoGreed is cyclical.
- drtz 3y agoThanks for sharing that NYT article. > ...critics say that the use of sponsorship could make cable programmers more vulnerable to censorship or control by advertisers, particularly in light of recent efforts by organizations such as the Moral Majority and its offshoot, the Coalition for Better Television. 40+ years later I think it's pretty clear this was an accurate prediction. > A much-cited - and widely disputed - study by the Benton & Bowles advertising agency found that the public would accept advertising if it meant a reduction or a holding-of-the-line on subscription fees... This is great until a year later when YoY revenue growth is flat and prices are increased anyway.
- apwell23 3y ago> Because it’s more profitable to have something that is paid for AND has ads. how does it work for HBO then.
- thinkingkong 3y agoIt doesnt take much of an imagination to understand that amazon knew of the probability of a lawsuit, understands the probability of its success, and did the math on upside. With 3B on the line they can afford the lawyers, the appeals, the penalties, etc.
- wrs 3y agoWhat burns my cookies is that you pay the extra $3 for “ad-free” service and then Freevee still has ads. I thought Freevee was the way they sneaked in an ad-based service by just branding it differently. Are they going to add another $3 for “ad-free Freevee”?
- kennethrc 3y ago... sigh ... Considering the shows I've liked on FV, one can hope :|
- brewdad 3y agoThe ads have always been Freevee's business model. So they might offer an ad-free option at some point but that seems highly unlikely.
- wrs 3y agoSure, but my point is they’ve just turned Prime into an ad-based business model, so what’s the point of Freevee now? Just merge the two and let me turn off all the ads.
- srameshc 3y agoWill that even bother Amazon ? I am sure all the big ones have learned how to settle these Suits.
- Johnny555 3y agoI'd rather have them be forced to let me cancel Prime Video and discount my Prime membership by $8.99/month. If they are going to make Prime Video unusable to me by injecting ads, then I don't want to pay for it at all, but I do still want the other Prime benefits.
- maxwell 3y agoSeems like whole premise of Prime, and most Apple products for that matter, is to capitalize on the failure to enforce product tying that's illegal under both Sherman and Clayton.
- blagie 3y ago... I thought the original premise of Prime was to take goods and services which, under basic economic theory, are more efficient centrally-funded by taxes, and provide those via a private entity. Especially things with zero marginal cost, like movies, music, and TV, should not be sold per-unit, but should be available to everyone and funded by taxes. Prime looked like a private equivalent to that. If we all pay $3.5B per month (350M people times $10/month), that's enough to give us all the college textbooks, movies, software, and music we might want to use, as well as paying for a lot of transportation infrastructure for rapid shipping. It seemed like a good model while Amazon was doing that. Now it looks more like what you said. Prime looks a lot more antitrusty in the model it's evolving to. I cancelled Prime about six months back, and Amazon is just obnoxious. There are ads on content I paid for. I can't check out without five annoying alerts. All those Prime deals look a lot less like deals and more like ways to bump up pricing for people who don't opt in. All in all, once I cancelled Amazon, it basically imploded on me, and now I only use it if there are seriously no other options. That also pushes me away from any vendors who standardized on Amazon for logistics. All of a sudden, I realized non-Prime members just won't buy from you if you use Amazon for logistics. It didn't used to be like that. Pre-Prime Amazon worked fine.
- chung8123 3y agoPrime never had video to begin with so I doubt they would discount it for you.
- liendolucas 3y agoSo this is the cherry on top. After paying for a subscription you also have to pay to not get ads? That's lame. People should start boycotting Amazon right now.
- turtlesdown11 3y agoRemember, AMZN is all about "customer delight"
- al_borland 3y agoIt’s become more about customer plight.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoI was delighted (as a former Amazon Prime customer) with not only how easy it was to cancel my membership... but that they refunded the entire year [I only had four months left]. Good riddance.
- crazygringo 3y agoGenuine legal question here: can this suit succeed as long as Amazon allows anyone to cancel their Prime membership with a refund of all remaining time? You can subscribe to Prime monthly or yearly. Anecdotally, everywhere I've checked on forums, everyone who's contacted customer service to cancel their annual Prime membership has gotten a prorated refund (or even full refund in some cases). And I'm assuming that's probably their actual internal policy, specifically to avoid a lawsuit. So if this is the case, is there any basis for this suit to succeed? It seems like it's wrong if Amazon changes the terms mid-subscription -- but it doesn't seem necessarily wrong for ongoing subscriptions if you can get out of it at any time.
- notatoad 3y ago>And I'm assuming that's probably their actual internal policy, specifically to avoid a lawsuit. it might be to avoid a lawsuit, but it's probably not to avoid this specific lawsuit. when i cancelled my prime, i didn't have to give any reason why, i never told anybody it was because i was mad about getting ads on prime video. but i still got the pro-rated refund for the 6mo remaining in the subscription.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] more discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39350257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39350257
- oraphalous 3y agoI would dismiss such lawsuits and their plaintiffs as strange and persnickety if it weren't for... Here in Australia, where the ads haven't been introduced yet, I got a notification from Amazon prompting to change to a yearly subscription because of the money I'd save. They've never prompted me thusly before. I don't care about the extra dollars for ad free. It's just like raising the price of a service - which happens all the time. And what's more, it certainly WOULD benefit me to switch to yearly, which I never got around to doing. But it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Amazon is trying to lock people into year long contracts right before they change the terms. The deliberateness of THAT intent, the willingness to just so blatantly pinch from the pocket of the unwary - even if it's only a few bucks. That PISSES ME OFF. Now I love capitalism - the right to own the sweat off your brow that stokes the competitive fires! It's the air we breathe. But these hyper-capitalist a-holes that would steal a cent if you just blink for a second... Goddamn. What makes these people? That drop of sweat, that they didn't earn, joins the billions of others in a torrent of wealth being syphoned of the regular folk on a daily basis. And the world is growing parched. So I salute the persnickety and fastidious Sir Wilbert Napoleon and everything he represent. I hope he wins.
- adamjc 3y agoThis, Netflix account-sharing blocking, and the ever increasing amount of streaming platforms (that mean an overall reduced catalogue per platform) leads me to believe we will see a resurgence in piracy. Yo, Ho, Ho :)
- ijhuygft776 3y ago"Went back" to piracy years ago... I actually pirated movies even when they were available on my Netflix subscription. I unsubscribed from Netflix when they started their descent into Netflix-only content.
- skeaker 3y agoWe already are: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39254807 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39254807
- int_19h 3y agoThe system is so blatantly rigged, why would you respect the "intellectual property" rights of people who are fleecing you? At this point I'm just ripping everything worth watching using tools like StreamFab, and encouraging everyone to do the same. Given how cheap local NAS storage is these days, you can easily have all your favorite videos and shows in one place. For bonus points, Plex has much better UI than Amazon.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Watching Ads on Amazon Prime Video Is a Deal Breaker for Some https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39178546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39178546
- zerocrates 3y agoI wonder what made Amazon go with this course of action. Plenty of the other providers have done basically the same thing: the previous price now includes ads and you have to pay more to stay ad-free... but they've all done it by raising prices and introducing a lower with-ads tier. To me it feels worse to have your service downgraded with the option to pay more to get it back than it does to have your price increased with the option to drop to a worse tier. That's sort of irrational, as the price increase is basically "opting you in" to pay more, but also just reflects how much ads suck. In terms of Amazon's choice, my best guess is that it's a reaction to an effect I've seen other providers describe: the ads are so lucrative they actually earn more on the lower-tier customers.
- rc-1140 3y agoThe most important question, in my opinion, is will this class-action suit actually result in any meaningful change or will Bezos/Amazon scrape up some cash to make this "little lawsuit problem" go away?
- malermeister 3y agoGet a seedbox for like 10 bucks a month, throw on Jellyfin, Radarr and Sonarr and never worry about this BS ever again. I used to pay for Netflix and Prime. It keeps getting more fragmented, more expensive and more shittified. Like Gabe Newell said, piracy is a service problem. I'm willing to pay a reasonable monthly fee for a good service. Unfortunately the only ones providing that are pirates.
- hasbot 3y agoMore info for those (like me) that didn't know what a seedbox is: https://www.reddit.com/r/seedboxes/wiki/index/what_is_a_seedbox https://www.reddit.com/r/seedboxes/wiki/index/what_is_a_seed...
- notyourwork 3y agoI’d love for a real economic discussion on what a fair price is. I agree with your point but not sure there is a price point consumers would tolerate and business could maintain a profitable business model with. That’s the fundamental issue we have right now.
- rdudek 3y agoWhat's worse is they locked Dolby Atmos and HDR behind the paid tier, something that used to be available normally. The Enshitification of Amazon continues.
- spandrew 3y agoI cancelled my Amazon Prime after this email. $2.99 isn't a lot, but I was already on the fence given all of their good shows were heading to the dumpster fire that is the + premium channels; Paramount+ AMC+ channels, etc. So far I haven't missed it. I watch more YouTube than any of these services anymore.
- sakopov 3y agoI guess next quarter is going to be a blowout. Amazon is pulling all kinds of levers in the name of profitability. AWS is now charging for [public IPV4 usage](https://www.infoq.com/news/2024/02/aws-ipv4-charges/ https://www.infoq.com/news/2024/02/aws-ipv4-charges/) which will bring $1B in revenue.
- xtracto 3y agoI found it amusing that just yesterday the Federal Comission for Competition (COFECE) in Mexico, gave a ruling to Amazon and one of its competitors Mercadolibre that they have to "unbundle" their video/streaming offerings from their "Prime" or "Plus" payment subscription, because they are distorting the market [1]. I just hope that they can follow up the ruling and don't succumb to Corporate pressure or corruption. [1] https://businessinsider.mx/cofece-exige-amazon-mercado-libre-cobrar-por-separado-servicios-de-streaming/ https://businessinsider.mx/cofece-exige-amazon-mercado-libre...