6 ms·
There shouldn't be ccTLDs. Governments should exist as individual planes within a single top-level namespace. They're crowding the commons and taking useful su
by echelon 3y ago
There shouldn't be ccTLDs.
Governments should exist as individual planes within a single top-level namespace. They're crowding the commons and taking useful suffixes.
But I'm also of the opinion these TLD namespaces shouldn't be bought and controlled by the highest bidders, nor domains by at volume squatters.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoI’m more scared of TLD owners either changing ownership of domaine and/or price gouging than either of those things - if your TLD decides to 10x the cost of your domain, or sell the domain to your competitor, what are you gonna do?
- closewith 3y agoOr just host an annual action, which would be the fairest way to determine the value of the domain. Still, TLD registries know that if they make domains unattractive enough, some other identifier will come along.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoAnnual auction favours whoever has more money, which is fairly anti competitive too. ‘Other identifiers’ only happen at scale. 1000x the cost of fortune 500’s, or a single tld.
- PeterisP 3y agoKind of the whole point is that we don't want domain registrars to be able to extract "the value of the domain", quite the opposite, we could want to auction for the lowest bids for running the technical infrastructure to some appropriate standard, so that as much as possible of "the value of the domain" stays with people actually running services, not goes to someone as unearned rent of a namespace monopoly.
- closewith 3y agoWell, the names obviously have value. Why would that value naturally rest with whoever registered it first? That's just another unearned monopoly.
- PeterisP 3y agoBecause a big part of that value comes only after - and only because - whoever registered the name invested into that brand, sometimes by continued business and reputation, sometimes by marketing. For example, the name ycombinator.com has some value on its own, but I think you won't contest that the vast majority of the current value of that name arose only because a popular community was ran on this domain name for decades, and if hackernews was instead run on scombinator.com or whatever, then the value of ycombinator.com would be just a fraction of what it currently is.
- Macha 3y agoIt would only be fair if we assumed all people had an exact equal amount of resources and therefore if person A outbids person B, it's because it means more to person A than person B, rather than say person A having 100x the resources of person B. We also don't force auction land off every year, because the costs (both financial and social) of that churn and insecurity are way worse than the gains from the resources being allocated for maximum economic value.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoMake an .onion mirror and educate the masses. There should be a way to abuse the tor network as a dns into the clear web.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoAh yes, grandma you should learn how to use tor so you can visit my e-commerce site through an obscure url that’s meaningless to you just be sure not to get scammed.
- maxcoder4 3y agoTor browser is not harder to use then Firefox or Chrome. And people don't type urls, they click on links.
- CRConrad 3y agoI think I'm "people", and I type URLs.
- throwawayqqq11 3y agoTor has solved the centralized name service problem. Once it gets adopted up by browsers, your grandma only has to bookmark weird names.
- h0p3 3y agoUnironically, I agree to the first claim, and I think i2p merits even higher consideration. Worthy attempts to resolve Zooko's triangle are going to require us to have trust in some stack, and it's hard to decentralize that appropriately. Namecoin may be one of the few examples of a b-word worth considering here. Ultimately, however, if the workers are to own the means of productions, there is no substitute for using and owning keys (and if that means people have to rely upon those they know and trust to assist them in this, then so be it). I don't predict that convention will arise in general, but I do prescribe it.
- silisili 3y agoDisagree. ccTLDs at least let you know you're dealing with the country in question - revenue.gov.uk is more trustworthy than revenue.gov.buzz or some other rando gTLD. People should generally just stop buying ccTLD domains for personal use. .ly, .ai, tv isn't as necessary or cool as they think it is.
- benjojo12 3y agoAmusingly, the project/company that the person you're replying to is using .AI domain (see their HN bio), so clearly their opinions about how ccTLDs shouldn't exist can't be that strong
- echelon 3y agoIt shouldn't be a ccTLD. Look at these arbitrary .ai ccTLD rules [1], as originally posted by p4bl0: > The terms and conditions of .ai domain names include things such as "not asking for investors" (without an Anguilla license to be a bank, broker, public company, ICO, exchange, or gambling site) and "not violating copyrights", both of which are… complicated for a lot of AI-related startups that chose to use a .ai domain. That's arbitrary and horrible. Thoughts shouldn't be so encumbered. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39367730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39367730
- seszett 3y agoThese don't seem arbitrary but totally in line with what a ccTLD means. Domains with the .ai TLD must obviously respect Anguilla law, just like the use .gov is restricted by the US government.
- krab 3y agoThey mean .ai should exist but it shouldn't be managed by a foreign country. ;-)
- tsimionescu 3y agoI think they believe that .ai should exist as a TLD, but not as a ccTLD. They'd basically like the Anguilles to not be in control of this TLD. Using it despite that is not inconsistent. Not that I agree with them, by the way. ccTLDs have to exist, countries have an obvious write to host their own TLDs without having to rely on others.
- SahAssar 3y ago> Governments should exist as individual planes within a single top-level namespace. Isn't that exactly how it works? The top level namespace is ".", every goverment controls a namespace under that. Or do you mean that we should have .se.gov, .uk.gov and no government control over non-.gov domains?
- JoshTriplett 3y ago> Or do you mean that we should have .se.gov, .uk.gov and no government control over non-.gov domains? Yes, that would be a substantial improvement.
- quickthrower2 3y agouk.gob us.gob etc. though. Why should we use the English word for government?
- SahAssar 3y agoBecause for most international standards we based it either on french or english. Recently (the last half century or so) it's been a lot more english, which is nice since it's the most widely spoken language.
- midasuni 3y agoOP is a classic imperial citizen with no concept of the world outside his empire
- samatman 3y agoIs http the correct abbreviation for your language's translation of hypertext transport protocol?
- lifthrasiir 3y ago> Governments should exist as individual planes within a single top-level namespace. Do you want something like `foo.us.com` (instead of `foo.com.us`)? That doesn't sound like a meaningful difference, and can be worse than the status quo especially given that different governments would want a different set of second-level domains anyway.
- nativeit 3y agoNot really relevant, but "us.com" is a weird type of sub-top-level domain now, I think some other "cc.com" domains have popped up as well.
- quectophoton 3y agoI have mixed feelings on this. On one hand, as an outsider it seems like every country needs to bow down their heads to the North American ICANN to ask for permission to have their own TLD listed in their root servers (even if those servers are already located in the country that's asking for permissions). But on the other hand, even if every country actually owned their root DNS servers and were completely independent from each other on this regard, everyone already expects the internet to work a certain way. So keeping things like they are now is the more pragmatic way to go. It would be doable in an alternate universe, e.g. every domain is local except those who have a specific TLD for international stuff. Similar to how country calling codes work; all numbers are national unless you use "+something" or "00something". So companies would have "home advantage" with their domain names because users from their own country wouldn't need the international TLD. (Yes, there's issues and things to think about if things were done that way, and I can certainly make this message longer, but everyone everywhere is already used to how things work now so there's not much point.) There's a similar "issue" with IP addresses (which are controlled by North American IANA (which is controlled by North American ICANN)), but in that case it's easier to solve because they are more invisible, not something the common person deals with daily.
- p4bl0 3y agoThat's clearly a very bad idea. Maybe .gov was supposed to be that initially? The USA have it for themselves alone. Thankfully other countries have their ccTLD and can reserve a subdomain for their government official websites, like .gouv.fr in France, because they can't have .fr.gov (which would look strange anyway, since "gov" is a shorthand for the english word). And this is not the only instance. Initially, the .edu was for all education institutions, but at some point it was unilaterally decided that only higher education institutions in the USA should be authorized to use such domains, which is a shame. For institutions still using it outside the US because they registered it before this decision, a single mishaps like missing the renewal deadline and they won't ever be able to get their domain back. And .edu can only be renewed in the last two weeks before expiration (thankfully now it is possible to pay for three years at once rather than a single one but that's recent). So, the history of US-centric management of the internet strongly suggest that it's a good idea that countries have and can control their own TLD. Even if a few people feel like their vanity domain name should use what happens to be a ccTLD.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 3y ago> Maybe .gov was supposed to be that initially? The USA have it for themselves alone. .gov dates to 1984, back when the internet was the ARPA-Internet. At the time the whole thing was a US military network that some research institutions were permitted to connect to. .edu was never intended to be used for every school in the world, just the institutions collaborating on US government research. https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc920 https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc920 If you think about the history of the internet from today's international perspective, it sounds strange, because it never was that from the beginning. It always was a US military computer network that grew way beyond the initial intent. It wasn't until 2016 that the US government decided to hand over control to the international community.
- p4bl0 3y ago> .edu was never intended to be used for every school in the world There was a time when .edu domains were attributed upon simple requests as long as you were an education related institution, from wherever in the world. It only later became paid, and then restricted to US institutions in 2001 (that is 16 years after the creation of the .edu TLD, contrary to what you say). I know this because I inherited the management of such a domain for a French university directly from the person who created it back then and who told me the whole history of how they got hold of this domain name. I insist on saying "institutions" and not "schools" because it's what I can see. Examples still in use in France includes polytechnique.edu [1] but also snes.edu, which is the website of the main workers union for middle and high school teachers in France (SNES-FSU). Also, note that nothing in its text seems to limit the scope of the RFC 920, the one you linked, to the US. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89cole_polytechnique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89cole_polytechnique
- midasuni 3y agoHow’s the connectivity in Anguilla?
- zokier 3y agoThere shouldn't be any gTLDs. Registrations for legacy TLDs should have closed when ccTLDs were introduced. There is no other generally accepted division of world except countries with their sovereignity. All entities with presence on internet are generally subject to some country. The handful of other entities (UN etc) can be handled as special cases.