6 ms·
Tesla Cybertruck may have a rust problem
- Symbiote 3y agoPosts on the source (forum) linked in the article suggest this is dust from railway tracks that lands on the cars and rusts. It needs to be carefully removed, but is common on new cars transported by rail.
- pompino 3y agoYou can also passivate, powdercoat, etc. Not that you should need to do this after dropping that kinda cash on a car (refuse to call it a truck :P)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- somat 3y agoIt really is a terrible truck. And on that subject I was thinking on pickup truck beds today. None of them are really very good. A good bed would be made out of solid steel and be full of tie down points. That is, the way work trucks are made. As is stands they are made of car body steel and have almost no tie down points, and never one where you need it. As a postscript I have been watching the edison motors channel(they are developing an electric semi truck). and my first thought was "there is no way these guys are going to be able to make it in the industry, They make way too much sense" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=an6e2Lh9u58 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=an6e2Lh9u58
- kube-system 3y ago> A good bed would be made out of solid steel and be full of tie down points. That is, the way work trucks are made. There's a lot of different truck beds with different styles and materials for different purposes. Sheet metal truck beds are the most popular work truck bed by volume, but there are very serious industrial users that choose aluminum. e.g. https://cmtruckbeds.com/truck-beds/ https://cmtruckbeds.com/truck-beds/
- orwin 3y agoDisagree on the 'made of solid steel', my father is a woodworker/painter/decorator, aluminum is enough, he doesn't move gravel or stone. Fully gree with full of tie down points. Even in car trunks, you need more tie down points. Let me insure my stuff won't fly if I take a sharp turn, please!
- m463 3y ago> tie down points I've always thought the same thing. Maybe none of the CEOs ever take home groceries in their car. Or haul a motorcycle, bicycle or plates of food over to a potluck. Why don't trucks and cars have modular storage? multi-use storage? Why do we have to quickly drive home from the grocery store to put stuff in the fridge or freezer? We should have a cooler in the back of the vehicle for groceries so it doesn't become a race, and groceries don't have to be the last stop. and milk jugs, eggs, bread. Car manufacturers provide enough storage so that all of them end up thrown about the trunk on the drive home. Why not reconfigurable storage that holds them in place? They're too busy figuring out how to add some subscription entertainment system. Or optimize away physical controls into the touchscreen. Actually, why can't we have some sort of storage that lifts your groceries out of the car and wheels them into your kitchen?
- D13Fd 3y agoThe answer to all of your questions is that trucks are marketed largely to people who don't need trucks and will only subject them to light use. If the truck bed were solid steel it would cost more and wouldn't sell that much better. If there were more tie downs it wouldn't look as sleek and fewer people would buy it. Those are the people who don't use tie downs (or the bed, really) anyway. That high-end entertainment system is what sells trucks to that kind of customer.
- JohnBooty 3y agoSerious question: won't any "real" pickup truck user put a plastic truck bed liner in the truck bed anyway? I mean if you're hauling heavy stuff around it's going to quickly beat a bare metal or painted metal surface to crap anyway right?
- JohnBooty 3y agoI've always thought the same thing. Maybe none of the CEOs ever take home groceries in their car. Or haul a motorcycle, bicycle or plates of food over to a potluck. From the outside, seems like two huge factors. One it's because there's so much time crunch pressure on vehicle development. It costs megabucks and they can't just extend the development cycle on a new vehicle for months to allow for "dogfooding" (which may involve hauling literal dog food from the grocery store) Two it's because feedback cycles on vehicles are long enough to be effectively useless. For example, everybody hates the removal of physical controls from car interiors, but it doesn't hurt new car sales (because it's not obvious how crappy the controls are until you've spent some real time in the vehicle) so manufacturers don't really have an effective feedback loop guiding their decisions. So cars often have just the dumbest possible usability failures.
- throwup238 3y agoFinally, concrete evidence that the rewrite it in Rust fad has gone way too far! It’s about time we put object oriented oxidation to rest.
- yobert 3y agoSeems like if they went with a different language, the truck would Go better.
- FredPret 3y agoShould have gone for good old Steel Bank CL
- ripvanwinkle 3y agoTesla ought to have C'en this at the start
- spindle 3y agoWhoa! Steel Bank CL actually is named after the metal (slightly indirectly - it's a reference to the fact that Carnegie Mellon University was founded partly on steel money).
- 1propionyl 3y agoSteel and finance: Carnegie -> Steel Mellon -> Bank
- signaru 3y agoI just want a truck that can deliver cargo and packages in crates.
- Reason077 3y agoThis “rust” is cosmetic tarnishing, not structural corrosion. Over time I imagine it will develop into a beautiful patina. Every CyberTruck will look unique. If you really want to keep it looking shiny and pristine, you can always get a clear protective wrap.
- booi 3y agolol what. Without a clear coat or some protective coating, all metal will corrode over time and 100x faster near the ocean. Even marine-grade 316 stainless steel. Steel patina is basically just corrosion.
- kube-system 3y agoNot that it is the case here (it almost certainly isn't), but not all corrosion is 'bad'. Some steels are designed to form a protective layer of corrosion and then stop corroding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weathering_steel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weathering_steel If Tesla really wanted to stick to the cyberpunk theme, they should have chosen COR-TEN :)
- dzhiurgis 3y agoMarine stainless generally doesn't corrode if it remains dry. Otherwise boats would be near impossible.
- lokar 3y agoI live a mile from the Pacific Ocean and have a bunch of 10+ year old 316 around the outside. It’s starting to rust.
- abledon 3y agothe Cybertrucks near Starbase are gonna look wild after a year or so of the sea-salt air eating away at them
- XorNot 3y agoOr they could've clear-coated it from the start, because the vehicle wasn't advertised as "will develop a patina" it was advertised as "stainless steel that's why we're not painting it".
- Ctyra 3y agoWhy capital 'R' in rust here? I thought somehow they were using Rust in their software, and ran into some problems with it.
- Reason077 3y agoExactly right. And Tesla engineers known as May and Havé are believed to be responsible for the bugs.
- rconti 3y agoIt's almost as if there's a pattern to which letters in the headline are capitalized...
- ftorres16 3y agoTitle case can be confusing sometimes. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_case https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Title_case
- jodrellblank 3y agoAs seen in one of the answers on "What is the worst gotcha in C# or .NET?" at https://stackoverflow.com/a/2542285 https://stackoverflow.com/a/2542285 (among many other interesting answers over 3 pages)
- Bud 3y ago[dead]
- madaxe_again 3y agoI don’t understand why people want their truck to look pristine. Mine is all of seven years old, and is more dents and scratches than it is intact bodywork - because it’s a truck, and it gets used for truck stuff. If you don’t use it for truck stuff, and want a shiny object, for god’s sake, don’t buy a truck.
- jaarse 3y agoI think there is a very good chance that exactly zero Cybertrucks are used as actual work trucks.
- hindsightbias 3y agoThe majority of trucks sold are status symbols. I’ve never seen a muddy Raptor.
- JohnBooty 3y agoI'm not exactly defending it but a lot of people buy trucks because they occasionally "legitimately" need one. I remember my parents used to buy station wagons. 51 weeks out of the year, we did not need a station wagon. But one week out of the year... we did need it, for family vacations.
- JohnBooty 3y agoCar rust is a little bit more than a cosmetic issue. Eventually it destroys things.
- jaarse 3y agoYou have to admire the marketing when they can convince their fans that not clear coating a vehicle is a feature not a bug. It wouldn’t even look different or cost all that much. The only downside is you would be able to leave it parked outside. What will Tesla think of next?
- tivert 3y ago> You have to admire the marketing when they can convince their fans that not clear coating a vehicle is a feature not a bug. It's not rust, it's an attractive patina!
- phone8675309 3y agoYou're washing it wrong
- moepstar 3y agoMeta: What is it with Tesla that each little thing is being blown epically out of proportion by news outlets, press, TV, etc.? I mean, i get it - bad news are good news, bring clicks etc. But with Tesla? - Cybertruck? Rust, tyre problems - "recalls" which are OTA software updates - waste disposal in CA - ... Elon is of course no saint, a controversial figure - in fact, i think he's pretty much a clown and at this point in time, he's doing Tesla a disservice by still being "in charge". But that's not the point with the recent (?) reporting, i feel this seems to be bigger and across much of the media i observe - as if every troll factory in the world has a contract to bash on Tesla... Recently, it's gotten so bad, i had to use RSS-Bridge with the filter plugin to filter each headline that contains "Tesla" - right now only sparing HN from this treatment - not sure if i'm keeping that up for much longer :(
- ShamelessC 3y agoSeems obvious to me. Tesla has an absurd valuation. Their CEO is the richest person alive (or was at one point) and has a cult-like status amongst many online fans. This person has historically used his loudspeaker to lie, pump, dump, you name it. Finally, Tesla as a company is premised on subverting an existing industry with very established players - it’s entertaining news when that doesn’t go according to plan. Probably similar reasons why the press jumped all over every Apple mistake when Jobs was around.
- jjguy 3y agoAll this, but there is also some negative PR getting funded, presumably by the incumbent car manufacturers threatened by Tesla. Remember that NYT article came out in 2018 that painted such a terrible picture of Elon (1)? A year later it showed up on my Facebook feed as a paid advertisement. Who pays to promote a year-old news article?
- yifanl 3y agoI wonder if they actually want Tesla to succeed (or at least partially). Because if its true that an auto manufacturer can achieve those valuations, then they can too.
- serial_dev 3y agoHuh, interesting. It would be hilarious* if these cars really had a serious rust problem, and all the hipsters with their 60-100k cars will explain how rust is completely normal on a 3 years old car. Or that it is "cosmetic tarnishing". * hilarious in the abstract, if it happened to you and you take a financial hit, I'm sorry As one reddit comment mentioned, if people start wrapping this car, but the "wrapping" company is not doing a perfect job, moisture and dirt under the wrap can wreck the car without owners noticing it for a long time. However, I'm not sure if the issue is really widespread, I'd imagine we had more photos if it were. I guess we will see.
- qwerpy 3y agoI haven't decided if I'm going to wrap my Cybertruck, lean into the Mad Max rust aesthetic, or lovingly wipe it clean every week like my neighbor and his pristine Shelby. Most likely, option 3 until I get bored, followed by option 2 until the wife gets embarrassed, then option 1. Ah yes, I'm well aware of the financial hit. I'm buying a new car after all!
- Terr_ 3y ago> Or that it is "cosmetic tarnishing". I'll give it a pass if it turns out it was made with weathering steel. :p https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weathering_steel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weathering_steel
- D13Fd 3y agoThat would be an incredible mess. If it's not pre-weathered, weathering steel leaves rust stains everywhere during the weathering process. You would have thousands of people suing Tesla for the damage to their driveways and garages. I don't think it's weathering steel :-)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Volundr 3y ago> cosmetic tarnishing We call that patina.
- lucidpare 3y ago[dead]
- r0ckarong 3y agoDisrupting the "cars that can stay outside" industry from the ground up.
- i_am_a_peasant 3y agoInitially I expected it was about software running on the cybertruck, was disappointed, and amused.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoWhat on earth is this article > If things like rain, car washes, bugs, and pine tar need to be cleaned off immediately and regularly, road salt, rocks, and debris from off-roading will surely wreak havoc on the truck’s body. Clean off car washes? Has no one driven Cybertruck in salt or off-road yet? > stainless steel body doesn’t have a clear coat, so there’s nothing to protect the body from dents, dings, scratches, Clear coat protects from dents and dings? How is this article written worse than a bot.
- iamthemonster 3y agoIn industry we don't use bare uncoated stainless steel in marine environments at elevated operating temperatures due to chloride stress corrosion cracking risk. I do wonder what metallurgists think of this bare 301 stainless steel from a CSCC point of view.
- Danielben 3y ago[flagged]