5 ms·
United Just Grounded Fleet of Planes Because Its No Smoking Signs Don't Turn Off
- cranberryturkey 3y agoDid the airline industry adopt agile or something?
- quantified 3y ago... and the last ashtrays disappeared a few years back. I wonder if our space tourism rockets will have no smoking signs in the cabins.
- d_silin 3y agoI flew transatlantic in 2024 on a brand new A350 and it still had an ashtray in the bathroom door. I think it is going to be a while until they remove those.
- HWR_14 3y agoIsn't that because some customers want the ashtrays, and it's cheaper to just add them to everything.
- Liquix 3y agoIt's hard to believe that "some" private customers have more sway over the plane manufacturing market than international airlines (the majority of which have banned smoking).
- HWR_14 3y agoIt's not a matter of sway. If 1 purchaser wants an ashtray, it's cheaper to add it to every plane than anything else. And, assuming that one purchaser cares enough to not buy your plane, it seems worth it to make a hundreds of millions of dollar sale. Of the airlines refused to buy planes with ashtrays, as opposed to not caring, that would be a different thing
- kube-system 3y agoAirplanes are not made in anywhere near the kind of volumes where the economies of scale would preclude profitably changing one interior part. Airbus and Boeing both make significant customizations for each airline. Some have entirely custom seating configurations. An ash tray is nothing. The reason they're on the plane is safety requirements.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kube-system 3y agoThe signs and the ashtray are a belt and suspenders approach to mitigate a situation where a lit cigarettes starts a cabin fire. Humans don't follow signs with 100% reliability, so the ash tray is a backup. They're on the plane for safety reasons, and required by law, even where smoking is also prohibited by law.
- siva7 3y agoThey never will. It's for safety reasons on those who won't comply so they don't burn down the plane accidentally.
- ensignavenger 3y agoHow many noncompliance incidents are there per year for no smoking ( like the crew finds the ash/buts in the tray or other evidence)? Is it tracked? Never is a very, very long time. Smoking may not be a thing in a few more decades.
- analog31 3y agoJust the mass of gum in those ashtrays probably cost several gallons of fuel per flight.
- function_seven 3y agoI doubt the mass of gum in an airplane ashtray would add even a single extra gallon to the fuel burn. The least efficient plane[0] burns 1 gallon per passenger every 64 miles. A 3,000 mile flight will burn 47 gallons of fuel per passenger. A stick of gum can be up to 7 grams[1]. Let's assume it's even heavier once chewed, and is a nice, round 10 grams. If we assume the mean passenger weighs only 50kg (or, 5,000 pieces of gum), then each piece of gum is responsible for 9.4 milligallons of fuel for that trip. Or 1.2 fl-oz. Now if we consider that there is gum all over the plane, maybe a soda-can's worth of jet fuel is burned up ferrying it all around. But that's with optimistic passenger weights, pessimistic gum masses, a gas-guzzler of a jet, and probably a calculation error I've made converting between all the different units above. :) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Airlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Airli...: > On the other side, the least efficient was British Airways at 27 pax-km/L (3.7 L/100 km [64 mpg‑US] per passenger), using fuel-inefficient Boeing 747-400s with a low density of 0.75 seat/m2 due to a high 25% premium seating, in spite of a high 82% load factor. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chewing_gum#Product_varieties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chewing_gum#Product_varieties > Chewing gum can come in a variety of formats ranging from 1.4 to 6.9 grams per piece, and products can be differentiated by the consumers' intent to form bubbles or the sugar/sugarless dichotomy.
- jojobas 3y agoAshtrays are still required in toilets and perhaps somewhere else, since it's very preferable that idiot smokers don't dump their butts into paper-filled rubbish bins before getting arrested.
- LeoPanthera 3y ago> ... and the last ashtrays disappeared a few years back. No they didn't. Aircraft are still legally required to have ashtrays, at the very least, in the bathrooms.
- fbdab103 3y agoI find this very amusing. Apparently airlines started banning smoking in the 1980s, but an industry ban was enacted in 2000. Maybe this will be the decade they decide to pull the ashtray requirement.
- askvictor 3y agoThe ashtrays are there in case someone is smoking contrary to the regulations. If they put the still-smouldering cigarette in the bin, it can cause a fire (particularly in the toilet, where most of the bin contents will be paper towel). It's sensible to keep the ashtray requirement.
- quantified 3y ago! I must locate it when I fly next.
- mondobe 3y ago"No vaping", more likely.
- jmward01 3y agoThis is why it takes over a decade to build and certify a new aircraft
- pinkgolem 3y agoTo many ancient rules that are no longer relevant? At least in this example...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LeoPanthera 3y agoHoly misleading headline, Batman. It's not United's entire fleet, as the headline implies. It's just their (relatively small) collection of Airbus A321neo planes. The signs are not faulty. They're deliberately hardwired on, as they are in United's Boeing planes. "The airline’s Boeing 737, 757, 767, and 777 aircraft already have no smoking signs “hardwired to stay illuminated at all times” according to the filing. United just forgot to ask for the same regulatory waiver for the A321neo as for these aircraft. This is a new plane type for the airline. They have 5 currently in service."
- noqc 3y agoPerhaps this is a no green M&Ms situation.
- askvictor 3y agoBrown. Details matter.
- TillE 3y agoIt's not a malfunction.
- dehrmann 3y agoThis is more of how could a regulator that hasn't cleaned up regulations that have been out of date for two decades be expected to keep a close eye on Boeing.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThis proves the plane manufacturer didn't read or understand the full 100% of the regulations, what other regulations did they not read or understand? It seems like a valuable test to check if there are more difficult to errors lurking elsewhere.
- readthenotes1 3y agoIs it possible that regulations elsewhere are sane and the whole "just get a waiver" approach used by all the Boeing models is the answer for the US as well?
- Dylan16807 3y agoIf the plane had been miswired, I could see it. Forgetting to ask for a waiver, nah I don't see it.
- pinkgolem 3y agoFor everyone being to lazy to read the article: 1model affected, it is build to spec of the airline, functions like most other models airline just missed requesting an exception from an ancient, no longer relevant rule the FAA should change(smoking signs need to be able to be turned of by the crew)
- Reason077 3y agoMany smokers live in hope that one day these nanny-state smoking restrictions will finally be repealed, and we’ll be able to once again light up a nice relaxing cigarette onboard airplanes. So it’s important that flight crew can still operate the signs, for when that day comes. Smoking on the airplane! It was a golden age of travel.
- pinkgolem 3y agoHow I do not miss those days with smoke being everywhere
- pests 3y agoI used to go to a bar dart league in my area, Metro Detroit, that still let people smoke even just a year or two ago last time I was there. Not sure if this is 100% true or they were just bullshitting, but they explained Michigan's smoking laws were intended to protect employees who were required to be around it all the time. They claimed that if you had a privately owned establishment with no employees you could allow it. Didn't really care to fact check them at the time but always pondered on this.
- sidewndr46 3y agohow would a bar function without employees?
- pests 3y agoThe owner(s) run the place themselves. This place in particular was only open 3 or 4 days a week and basically 5pm - close, sometimes just for the dart league. Single old guy who probably didn't need the income. They had good burgers though.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWouldn't that mean that a co-op would also be exempt from these kind of laws? That seems unlikely to be true.
- pbj1968 3y agoI still remember smoking on airplanes. Towards the end, they used to sequester them and close a curtain as though that protected us. Weird times of the tyranny of the minority. It did make for easy times to get a table during the “first available” twilight period of going to restaurants. One of my elders remarked, “nobody is actually smoking in this section.” Shh! Habitual smokers were never over 50% in America - look it up. And 2 out of 3 of them died from causes unrelated to smoking. So it goes.
- bruce511 3y ago>> And 2 out of 3 of them died from causes unrelated to smoking. I mean, OK, 2 thirds didn't die from smoking. But 1 third DID. So basically you're saying that since smoking only killed one-in-three, it somehow wasn't the big deal people made it out to be? And that's -before- we discuss the non-fatal health issues of the other 2 thirds? Or the health issues of non-smokers exposed to second hand smoke. I remember the 80's. Smoke everywhere, all the time. On planes, trains, busses - in restaurants, pubs, offices. I do not miss that. 1 in 3 died. Troops landing on D-Day had better odds of survival.
- readthenotes1 3y agoBut let's bring this back to me: The stench was nearly unbearable at times.
- AmericanChopper 3y ago> Habitual smokers were never over 50% in America - look it up. Stats on this really only go back to 1965, when pretty close to half of US adults smoked. But that’s 15 years after the link between cancer and smoking was established, it’s after doctors had gone from endorsing smoking to testifying against it, and after the ban on advertising smokings “health benefits”. I’d be very surprised if less than half of US adults smoked in the early 50s and prior. The only thing I imagine could confound that would be the fact that women were quite a bit less likely to smoke than men were, but even in the earliest statistics available about 1/3 of them did.
- olliej 3y ago
- philip1209 3y agoI know that certain lights within planes are used by captains to signal information to crews. For instance, I believe it's common to use "Fasten seatbelt light on/off twice" to signal reaching 10,000 feet in altitude. Does anybody know if the no-smoking sign is used for any sort of signaling? (I doubt it because it doesn't make a noise, like the seatbelt signal. But, it might!)
- medler 3y agoApparently not, since many aircraft have them hardwired to always be on
- philip1209 3y agoThe procedures are specific to the company and their equipment, so it's possible - especially in American fleets.
- guender 3y ago[dead]
- p1mrx 3y agoIt is somewhat confusing to tweet about UA with Ukraine flags in your name.
- fotbr 3y agoThey're looking at it wrong. The signs are operable by the flight crew. Given: Aircraft power is on, signs are on. Aircraft power is off, signs are off. Aircraft power is operable by the flight crew. Therefore: Signs are operable by the flight crew. In addition to the aircraft main power system(s), there's almost certainly a circuit-breaker that would turn the signs off. It might turn other things off as well, and circuit-breakers are not generally designed to be used regularly as switches, but there's a circuit breaker in reach of the crew that would turn those signs off.