6 ms·
I've grown used to being corrected, to the point that it's a pleasant surprise to be told I might be right. What I notice more and more, is the "you're wrong"
by ggm 3y ago
I've grown used to being corrected, to the point that it's a pleasant surprise to be told I might be right.
What I notice more and more, is the "you're wrong" is used to buttress opinion masquerading as fact. If you preface "I think that.." to asserts it doesn't stop the "you're wrong" but it at least puts the discussion into the realms of conjecture about things, including facts, rather than simple asserts of facts which are often not as factual as they seem.
I also notice that argument by analogy is being over-used. Because you want to compare your large single CPU to a multi CPU doesn't mean it actually is a Bull compared to a herd of chickens. Or that cat-herding is actually much harder than it looks: you need the right kind of cream. Wait.. that analogy might not work here..
- XorNot 3y ago"best-practice" is a specific, over-used term in the tech industry. People instinctively give opinions and say "well best-practice is..." to fortify it against being criticized, and then lean heavily on the fact that if you actually ask them to support that notion then they imply or accuse the questioner of being hostile. "It's best practice" should invite the question of "according to who, in which publications? What are the circumstances of the practice, are they similar to our circumstances?"
- aspenmayer 3y ago> A weasel word, or anonymous authority, is a word and phrase aimed at creating an impression that something specific and meaningful has been said when in fact only a vague, ambiguous, or irrelevant claim has been communicated. The terms may be considered informal. Examples include the phrases "some people say", "it is thought", and "researchers believe". Using weasel words may allow one to later deny any specific meaning if the statement is challenged, because the statement was never specific in the first place. Weasel words can be a form of tergiversation and may be used in advertising, (popular) science, opinion pieces and political statements to mislead or disguise a biased view or unsubstantiated claim. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weasel_word https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weasel_word Edit: Verb tergiversate (third-person singular simple present tergiversates, present participle tergiversating, simple past and past participle tergiversated) (intransitive) To evade, to equivocate using subterfuge; to obfuscate in a deliberate manner. (intransitive) To change sides or affiliation; to apostatize. (intransitive, rare) To flee by turning one's back. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tergiversate https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tergiversate
- nonrandomstring 3y agoThere's a spectrum isn't there, between weasel words that are avoidant and non-attribution which is done out of respect or kindness. News is full of passive prose; "A source claimed yesterday", because anonymous sources need protection. A barrister might say in court; "It has been said that...", not to invite libel or misidentify a witness. Or a teacher might say "It's been brought to our attention that some children..." not to embarrass a kid in front of everyone.
- aspenmayer 3y agoThese are good points. Here are some links I found relating to legitimate points you have raised: Why does The New York Times use anonymous sources? https://www.nytimes.com/article/why-new-york-times-anonymous-sources.html https://www.nytimes.com/article/why-new-york-times-anonymous... A Look at Journalists' Use of Anonymous Sources https://www.voanews.com/amp/journalists-use-anonymous-sources/3738986.html https://www.voanews.com/amp/journalists-use-anonymous-source... Society of Professional Journalists Ethics Committee Position Papers: Anonymous Sources https://www.spj.org/ethics-papers-anonymity.asp https://www.spj.org/ethics-papers-anonymity.asp Everything-but-the-kitchen-sink: a guide to confidential sources https://ethics.journalism.wisc.edu/2018/12/07/the-everything-but-the-kitchen-sink-guide-to-confidential-sources/ https://ethics.journalism.wisc.edu/2018/12/07/the-everything... https://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Wikinews:Avoid_weasel_words https://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Wikinews:Avoid_weasel_words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Avoid_peacock_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Avoid_peacock_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Words_to_watch#Puffery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Word... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery
- pixl97 3y agoI mean, not writing your own encryption library is best practice.
- Eisenstein 3y agoIf someone asks you 'why?' can you tell them? If not, you are using it as a weasel word. If so, then you are using it as shorthand for 'I could explain it but I don't think I need to right now'.
- ruszki 3y agoOr literally that’s the only information what you really have. I haven’t met a single person except universities who knew more about this topic (ie they’re rare). Even the library/interface which is used is not well understood usually, even on the surface level.
- briHass 3y agoIt's not clear, even, to what depth this 'best practice' applies. Writing your own crypto primitives is probably a bad idea, but what about combining them? AEAD approaches demonstrate there can be nuance even with battle-tested primitives and how they're combined or used in practice. Oh, but what about key derivation or protecting the keys in general? What good is that library's encrypt method if the DIY key secrecy/rotation/exchange is sloppy?
- bongodongobob 3y agoNah. Best practice usually means "assume a spherical cow". The idea is to point in the right direction because there are no one size fits all solutions for anything. It's a starting point that isn't stupid and is backed by the blood of poor bastards from the past.
- RaftPeople 3y agoBut frequently, in technology, the term "best practice" is used where it's not really settled whether it's a good practice 80% percent of the time or only 20% percent of the time. If you look at the history of industry trends over the last X decades, most of which were replaced by the next trend due to the pain that was eventually discovered, you will find many people claiming the new trend was "best practice" typically mid-way through the hype cycle and before the actual trade-offs become well known.
- simonkagedal 3y agoSame goes for “anti-pattern”.
- paulpauper 3y agoI have grown accustomed to being wrong a lot as well, especially online, but it would be nice being right more often too. It's like "Am I really that far off the mark? Maybe I am. Downvotes coming." I like to think my opinions are not that bad. Yet when it comes to investing in other aspects in life ,where money is at stake or making income, I have been right more often than not. So I guess I right where it matters most, and wrong about the less important things. Or maybe I am wrong about those things because I don't invest as much mental energy into having the perfect or correct opinion compared to things where there is money at stake.
- digbybk 3y ago> I like to think my opinions are not that bad. I find this sentence kind of funny. If you thought your opinions were bad wouldn’t you change them?
- ihaveajob 3y agoI suppose they meant that their opinions are not that controversial or against the norm. I've encountered this when I talk online about car safety, speeding, and generally about safe streets. There's a particular type of car lovers who are always waiting to swamp any dissenting opinion with downvotes, effectively drowning the discussion. I think my opinions are not that bad but for that crowd, it would make you reconsider your priors; if they're so offended by what I said, am I wrong?
- rfrey 3y agoOf course "I think my opinions are correct" is a tautology. But what people mean when they say things like "I think I have good opinions" is that they think they were reasonably careful and thoughtful in forming their opinions... that they don't hold opinions just because they read a comment on an internet forum, for example. IMO.
- efitz 3y agoThe problem with opinions is not that they are good or bad, it’s how difficult they are to change. Other people who are unwilling to change “bad” opinions in the face of contradictory evidence is easily observed. If you find yourself never changing your own opinions, then you probably have a problem.
- haswell 3y ago> I also notice that argument by analogy is being over-used This one seems especially pernicious, not because of extremely over-wrought comparisons, but because sometimes the analogy fits really well on the surface. But beyond the structural fit, it does not really help prove anything. Too often I'll encounter an analogy wielded as if it proves the underlying point, when the reality is that it breaks down quickly if you dive into the details. Analogies can be great to help establish new mental models, or to try out an idea with terminology that people already understand, but can be quite misleading. Better used for learning than trying to prove things.
- ben_w 3y agoAnalogies are like a box of chocolates: overused clichés, but we hand them out and gobble them down with delight.
- efitz 3y agoAnalogies are decorative writings, not arguments.
- Jensson 3y agoThey can be arguments, for example if you want to show that the other person has inconsistent views due to feelings or bias an analogy between the two inconsistent scenarios can make that clearer. I've changed my mind thanks to analogies many times.
- haswell 3y agoTo split hairs a bit, analogies can support arguments, but are not considered a conclusive form of evidence/argumentation in and of themselves in formal logic. While the analogy may have been instrumental in helping change your mind, it likely did so by helping you understand the actual underlying argument.
- 3y ago
- roenxi 3y agoOn the topic of opinion masquerading as fact - if you check the dynamics there it quickly gets quite interesting. Political arguments are unusual if they involve an expert. On the big ones (economics, medical, military and technical policy) it is relatively rare to see an expert and doubly rare to find one who isn't pushing some sort of agenda. There tends to be a tiny pool of people doing a speaking circuit that turn up again and again and they're there for a reason. If you run the numbers on (informed people informing the discourse about a topic) / (people who know about topic) the numbers are a bit grim too. And a big driver of that seems to be that either the debate isn't about facts so nobody cares, or frequently that the experts don't have a well advertised an opinion on an important subject. It really turns up in economics where finding facts is a challenge. The biggest economic miracle of our time is China's industrial policy and it isn't particularly obvious what the facts about that are. I'm sure that there are economists who are devoting their lives to figuring out what happened in China because it is an interesting and important topic. But where the facts are being surfaced is not obvious and it isn't going to make its way through the broader public discourse. TLDR; finding any facts in any public discussion is actually a bit of a challenge. It tends to be opinion all the way down until the trail goes cold.
- balderdash 3y agoI generally agree with you, but at the same time don’t think it’s always nefarious. At least personally, I’d say I definitely am more opinionated (have more of staked out positions) in areas I know something about / spent time thinking through - I’d imagine the same is true for many “experts” - it doesn’t mean they are “right” but based on their underlying conceptual frameworks[1], most of the time they’ve come to a conclusion and are going to push that. [1] I find most policy debates I get into with friends have nothing to do with the policy at hand but rather more core political/philosophical questions underlying their thinking (e.g. do the ends justify the means or are they more individualist va collectivist)
- pitaj 3y ago> The biggest economic miracle of our time is China's industrial policy and it isn't particularly obvious what the facts about that are. I'm not sure exactly what you're referring to, but I think it's pretty well understood that the growth of China is thanks to the market reforms in the 70s and 80s.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wombatpm 3y agoMy inner jerk likes to assert Hitchin’s razor: what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence
- heresie-dabord 3y agoThat's Hitchens, of course. Here's a set of philosophical razors. [1] There are social contexts where clarity of statement and lucidity of thought *are not* among the tools/objectives of an encounter/interaction. But in debate or education or in any other case where clear words and ideas are indeed among the tools/objectives, avoiding them or undermining them is being a different kind of jerk. [1] _ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_razor
- taneq 3y ago> you need the right kind of cream. Ina a similar vein, when people talk about managing creative technical types as ‘herding cats’ I respond that this is a management style issue: You don’t herd cats, you give them something to chase.
- The_Colonel 3y agoArguing by analogy is indeed problematic. You can often find rough analogy which supports the argument, but also a different analogy which disproves it. Additionally, I think arguing by analogy is a sign that you lack real / structural arguments, real understanding.
- ruszki 3y agoIf you can find analogies for both supporting and disproving something, then the reasons are not what’s stated. Isn’t it good to show that?
- edmundsauto 3y agoI believe analogies should be used to communicate clearly, not advance an argument. In a good faith discussion, everyone needs to understand other perspectives - analogies are a lossy/impressionistic tool that can help people understand your argument.