4 ms·
I find myself thinking of dog breeds: Over the last ~150 years, selective breeding has led to an explosion of phenotypes, but there's a limit to how much humans
by Terr_ 3y ago
I find myself thinking of dog breeds: Over the last ~150 years, selective breeding has led to an explosion of phenotypes, but there's a limit to how much humans can take credit--or perhaps blame--for all the results.
Much of what we've done is to evoke particular blends and combinations of a great many individual genes that already existed throughout in the species.
P.S.: IANADogGeneticist so these numbers are totally made-up, but imagine an island population of 1,000 "average dogs" or mutts that look the same. They collectively bear 20 distinct genes that promote Long Noses, and 15 distinct genes that promote Short Noses, and due to what chromosomes they're on, each dog might have a random ~4 from the Long Nose set and ~3 from the Short Nose set. On average you'll keep getting similar looking individuals, until some sinister aliens arrive and begin... The Pug Project, leading to a bunch of poor lapdogs with 8-10 Short Nose genes and 0-1 Long Nose ones.
- ericmcer 3y agoSelective breeding has some huge and obvious morality issues around it, but it is fun to think about possibilities. Hyper intelligent dogs? 10 foot tall humans?
- rollcat 3y agoDid you read "Dune"? Basically the entire plot.
- Vecr 3y agoTo be clear you can't breed mammals like plants, the "back crossing" in Dune does not work on humans.
- dekhn 3y agoDo you mean "can't" as in it's technically impossible, or do you mean "can't" as in it's not ethical? Most of our science seems compatible with the idea that you can back-cross mammals, after all we do that in mice all the time.
- chmod775 3y ago> I find myself thinking of dog breeds: Over the last ~150 years, selective breeding has led to an explosion of phenotypes, but there's a limit to how much humans can take credit--or perhaps blame---for all the results. Dogs as a species wouldn't exist if humans didn't selectively breed a now extinct lineage of wolves, which to me means that humanity is to blame for all of it.
- jibal 3y agoIt's well known that wolves self-domesticated, resulting in the subspecies Canis lupus familiaris.
- chmod775 3y ago> It's well known that wolves self-domesticated It is really not. All we have are two popular hypotheses, which may even be true at the same time. It is clear the self-domestication pathway would not have worked without humans allowing it to happen. This quickly devolves into semantics. It is however not up for debate that humans have been breeding dogs/wolves for millennia. > resulting in the subspecies Canis lupus familiaris. Put the wrong two zoologists in the same room and if you're unlucky they'll bore you all day debating whether domesticated dogs are a distinct taxon. Just say species without specifying and you'll sidestep the issue. If you want to call them Canis lupus familiaris rather than Canis familiaris, then sure! I guess that's why I meant!
- jibal 3y ago"This quickly devolves into semantics." It quickly devolves into you being wrong that humans get all the blame for it. That's the point and the rest is deflection and strawmen like "It is however not up for debate that humans have been breeding dogs/wolves for millennia" -- duh.
- mncharity 3y ago> evoke particular blends and combinations I long ago encountered a suggestion that the great behavioral malleability of historical dog breeding resulted from taking a common ancestral hunting sequence, and tweaking dials on the steps. So for fudged illustration, given a sequence of <chase-it-down, bite-hard-on-neck, shake-until-dead, carry-back, bury-it>, turning the "bite" step down, and the "shake" and "bury" steps way down, gets you a retriever breed. This malleability then misled people about the broader flexibility and efficacy of selective breeding. Like someone going "Look what I did today tweaking a configuration file! ... Programming is so easy!". I thought the paper might make for a fun web interactive (but IIRC had difficulty refinding it).