4 ms·
I offer as an alternative: IP is property, and it's taxed at the value you declare that it's worth. However, if you swear to the IRS that it's worth $500/yr,
by kstrauser 3y ago
I offer as an alternative:
IP is property, and it's taxed at the value you declare that it's worth.
However, if you swear to the IRS that it's worth $500/yr, then you can't claim in court that a violation of it is costing you $10,000,000/yr in losses. That would be perjury.
Your patent is worth $10,000,000? Awesome! I bet your local school district will love to hear how much you'll be paying in taxes on it.
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoBut property usually isn't taxed. Trading is. If you license a patent to someone else for $500/year, you'd pay tax on that $500. But if it's actually worth more, of course you wouldn't charge such a low fee.
- kstrauser 3y agoTo my knowledge, all US states have property tax.
- eitland 3y agoThat's the point up thread. It isn't now, but we could make it so.
- thelastgallon 3y agoProperty is almost always taxed. In Texas, property taxes on homes are 2.5 - 3% of value, most people pay between 8K - 30K every year. And this keeps going up! Over a 30 year mortgage, I'm sure most people pay more on property taxes than on their home. Approximately 50% of property taxes go to school districts, the rest for other municipal services. Some states also tax car as property. What is not taxed is Intellectual Property. Because it is almost completely owned by the super rich. And, of course, these billionaires need all the help they can get. How about we change this? We can think of wiping out property taxes for homeowners (making homes affordable) and fund education from patent taxes. After all, the super rich are deriving these patents from the education system, its only fair they pay their fair share.
- EnigmaFlare 3y agoReal property is an exception but we're talking about other kinds of property. I don't know of any other kind that's commonly taxed.
- IanCal 3y agoSomething I've wondered about - you specify a value and pay a tax accordingly. Anyone is then able to buy it from you for that price. Have some short term part for free, then fees scale over time.
- eitland 3y agoA slightly different version was in use in Denmark: a ship declared the value of their cargo for toll purposes. They decided the price, but the catch was the customs could buy the cargo at that price.
- jstarfish 3y agoThat is fiendishly clever.
- balderdash 3y agoIt sounds nice in principal but I think it’s not so easy in practice, if I asked you what’s your car worth you probably say something along the lines of well it would cost x to replace it, or I paid y for it, or I could sell it for z on eBay (all three different prices) but if you then said that well whatever price you say someone can buy your car for and you’re stuck with without a car while you go figure out replacing is actually a price is not any of those prices, and is probably higher than the actual value, and may even be higher than the cost to replace it - you might say that’s the idea but ultimately it feels creepy to make people pay a tax to avoid the risk of an asset they rely on not to be taken away at an inconvenient time…
- IanCal 3y agoThe value to me would be the replacement plus hassle value. There's clearly values I'd easily accept, you offer me a hundred grand for my car and you can take it whenever you want. Now for regular items like a car this would be hard. How do I value it and how do I not get caught out when second hand sales spike and I don't follow the markets? But we're not talking about everyone's car. We're talking about asking the state to forbid others to make or build certain things (yes I know it's more detailed but you get the meaning).
- ardel95 3y agoThat would effectively kill software patents. Which is a fine outcome.
- thelastgallon 3y agoThis is better than what I proposed.
- margalabargala 3y agoSomething like this genuinely does hurt very small businesses or inventors who invent something actually valuable but don't have time to quickly scale up. What I like for IP laws is as follows: When you create a protected work, you pay a very small fee. Say, $1 for copyright, maybe $500 for a patent. Each year thereafter, if you wish to maintain your IP protection, you must pay double what was paid the previous year. Otherwise the property reverts to the public domain. This ensures a period of protection if it's genuinely needed, but ensures that everything will eventually enter the public domain, especially in the case where no one is making any economic use of the material.
- hamandcheese 3y agoPatent protection already is not indefinite. It seems much simpler and more fair to shorten the protection period.
- margalabargala 3y agoEven if we halve the patent protection period, that is still ten years during which a patent troll can scoop up a BS patent and then simply send threat letters and rake in money, while chilling any actual advancement. Currently, there's an incentive to disallow progress. If someone does not want to make use of their own patent, they are currently incentivized to sit on it and keep the ability to create that thing out of the hands of anyone else, "just in case". If we shorten the period as you suggest, to half (for example), then that freezes that progress for a decade. If an incentive is created to put inventions into the public domain if one is not using them, then that is better for everyone. And by doubling the fee each year, it becomes financially infeasible for even large companies to keep things out of the public domain forever. A fee of $500 that doubles annually would, at the 20 year mark that is the current patent lifespan, cost a half a billion dollars to renew for that year.
- beefield 3y agoI offer one more alternative. Double the tax every year, and once the ip holder decides not to pay the tax, IP is released to public domain. No compnay has money to keep IP indefinitely in such a scheme.
- KittenInABox 3y agoI would suggest only for corporations above a certain size. I would appreciate if some old music composer somewhere gets to continue being old and stuff without worrying about this sort of thing.
- polishTar 3y agoA lot of patent trolls are very small companies though
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoIt would have to be managed by tracking the number of active patents. You get 100 active patents tax free. Over that, and you have to pay an annual fee. This allows for independent inventors to operate as the system intended while clamping down on NPEs.
- DylanDmitri 3y agoMusic compositions get covered by copyright. Patents are another section of law.
- nextaccountic 3y agoMusic is coveredby copyright , an entirely different law
- akoboldfrying 3y agoWhat do you think will happen if IP becomes impossible to afford, as it surely will under such a policy? Do you think companies that value IP will bother investing further in R&D, let alone even stay in your country? Congratulations on the massive net loss in taxable income in your country. EDIT: Removed some mean words.
- brookst 3y agoDoesn’t work. Lots of people don’t know what their IP is worth, and it can change with market and tech trends. And the damages aren’t based on the harm to the IP owner, but on the benefit to the infringer. I could have a patent that I think is worthless, but in 10 years I discover that a multinational flat out stole the IP after an NDA meeting. What is the value that I should have declared?