3 ms·
Definitely seems more feasible than a lot of crazy energy ideas! E.g. I think this makes more sense than the air versions because you don't have problems launch
by IshKebab 3y ago
Definitely seems more feasible than a lot of crazy energy ideas! E.g. I think this makes more sense than the air versions because you don't have problems launching/landing or when the wind stops.
Probably the biggest issues I could imagine are maintenance and wildlife. They might be minor issues though. Also in most of the world (maybe not the Faroe Islands) this has to compete with solar & batteries which are getting cheaper and cheaper. If this is more than £5-10m then I think solar and batteries would be a much better option in most of the world.
- Someone 3y ago> Probably the biggest issues I could imagine are maintenance and wildlife. They might be minor issues though. Might, yes, but I think it’s unlikely all problems will be minor. Salt water isn’t kind to metal, no matter how well painted. Also, I expect barnacles will start growing on it. If you’re a filter feeder, this may be even better than sitting on the sea bed or on a whale. Question will be how much that effects their $/MWh calculation. The only real way to find out is to try, I guess.
- usrusr 3y agoThe good news is that we do have a bit of experience with metal machines that operate in sea water for decades. We (as in humanity, I don't) know exactly what to expect. You'd want to have a permanent service operation scaled exactly to how much overhauling capacity you need to put the tide kites in a round robin maintenance loop.
- hoseja 3y agoAnd yet, every other tidal powerplant has been rendered hopelessly useless by barnacles.
- usrusr 3y agoHave they? And how many of them can be ordered to surface under tide power, for easy maintenance access and towing into a maintenance dock without involving expensive divers? I presume the tether on this would be built long enough for controlled surfacing, a longer tether means larger deadzone between inbound and outbound tide, but there won't be much energy in the flow close to the turning point anyways.
- Sammi 3y agoWe are perfectly capable of removing barnacles from ship hulls. What makes these kite hulls different? These are just fancy boats you know.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoMaybe we don't even care if barnacles grow on it since it's kind of a water catcher anyway. Or if not this design, maybe one could be designed to either not care or even benefit from barnacles. Remove the whole problem of fighting it.
- Tarq0n 3y agoI wonder to what extent its output correlates with that of wind energy in the same region. Having a reasonably independent set of generating technologies might help with the intermittent generation of sun-based renewables.
- Super_Jambo 3y agoI guess power output will basically be the derivative of this tidal height chart: https://www.tide-forecast.com/locations/Gamlagatt-Faroe-Islands/tides/latest https://www.tide-forecast.com/locations/Gamlagatt-Faroe-Isla... The steeper the slope the higher the power output. I think the real question on tidal generation is how costly is maintenance. The sea is just a very unforgiving environment. Salt water and marine life fouling everything are difficult engineering problems that just add more expense than I can imagine wind turbines having. If they can make tidal work I guess we'll end up in a world where most of their profit comes from keeping the grid alive when it's a calm and there's no sun. I guess this may mean these technologies aren't going to really take off until we stop using hydrocarbons to make up the shortfalls...
- justsomehnguy 3y ago> maybe not the Faroe Islands Capital and largest city: Tórshavn, 62°00′N 06°47′W
- leoedin 3y agoThe huge difference between solar and tidal energy is the predictability. Tides can be predicted in advance - you always know exactly when and how much electricity you'll get. That's really valuable in a world of increasingly volatile electricity supply. Solar will probably be far cheaper per installed MW (although capacity factor will be much lower), but batteries are still a long way from being cost effective. The cheapest batteries right now cost $100/kWh or $100k/MWh. Battery costs are still falling, but the curve is levelling off. That price means that time-shifting 1 MWh of energy a day for 10 years would add $27 per MWh to the cost of electricity (ignoring ongoing maintenance costs, and assuming a 1MWh battery can do 4k cycles). The company behind this is forecasting $50/MWh of generation. Solar on its own right now sits at $30/MWh, although presumably that's for places with relatively high capacity factors. The limitations are obvious - this is very geographically constrained. I suspect there will be a small place for this type of technology in the renewable mix - especially in remote and northern places. Then again, offshore wind is already sitting at below $50/MWh and doesn't have the same geographic constraints - so maybe it's a better bet.